Welcome to Coconut Cay *As Seen on HGTV

James and Nikki are wonderful hosts. Coconut Cay has amazing views and amenities, including a pool and ocean views. The location is close to fun activities, restaurants, the ferry and shops. We would stay with tham again.

Such a cool place to stay. I will list the “negatives” just so you come prepared. Don’t let these stop you from visiting!-Some doors do not lock. -The drive up to the house feels a little sketchy and dangerous (because of parked cars everywhere on the streets- but I think it’s just an old neighborhood. -Be prepared for barking dogs and roosters. -The property could use more rugs as it always felt like we were walking on a sandy, cold (in bedrooms) or slippery floor. -The front bathroom is the only one you can take a shower in as it has great water pressure and stays hot. The other is like a gentle rain shower on a spring day in Florida- with a similar and varying luke warm to cold temperature). -I am not sure if I missed it but there is no A/C in the common areas (only bedrooms) so you have to open windows and the screens have holes so it lets all the mosquitos. -Some windows do not close even in the bedrooms so they get bugs too. -It had a k cup coffee maker but no one on the island (that we could find) sold k cups. -If you are a hot tea drinker there is no electric or stove kettle. -Be prepared to rent or uber/taxi everywhere as most of the activities and restaurants are on the other side of the island. -Finally, it could use a little more personal accessories like shampoo, body wash, and a blow dryer in each bathroom. Other than these minor issues we still had fun and enjoyed our stay!

Family had an amazing time exploring the island. We loved the pool and view. Could have spent our whole vacation in the pool enjoying the view. AC was great and beds were comfortable. Would definitely stay here again.

Enjoyed the view and the pool.

We had an amazing time and loved the pool overlooking the ocean. Pulled in to a wild horse in the backyard! The whole place needs a thorough scrub but we loved everything else about the house and location. Would definitely stay again! And recommend to anyone staying on the island.