Holly Hill Motel

We stayed at Holly Hill in the middle of the Lighthouse Challenge. We were very pleased with the price, because many places had raised their rates due to the event taking place. We were most impressed that the parking lot was so well-lit when we arrived! We reserved two rooms, #8 and 9, but ended up parking at room #5 because others had taken our spot. Perhaps numbering the parking spaces would be helpful for this, otherwise it’s certainly not the fault of the motel owners. Our rooms were very clean, and the beds were comfortable. However, each room was provided with ONE washcloth and two bath towels. NO hand towels. Our daughter’s bathroom smelled strongly of smoke. Even spraying it didn’t help. There was one plastic cup in each room; no ice bucket. No chair to sit on. The air conditioner worked very well. We didn’t get showers because there was only warm water (no cold in either room!) and we didn’t know if we would be able to control the temperature. We brushed our teeth quickly because the water started out warm and only rose in temperature. We googled the remote in order to figure out how to even turn the tv on. Our daughter did the same in her room. She was finally able to figure it out, and managed to find a couple of channels; ours never went beyond saying “no channels.” To be fair, we could have gone back to the office and asked for help, but we were getting up early anyway. We did get a good night’s sleep, but we wouldn’t recommend this motel.

Holly Hill would not qualify as luxurious accommodations but it covers the basics quite nicely and provides friendly service at a manageable price. It is renovating one section of its rooms, so it is partly a construction zone at the moment but the inconvenience is minor. Its biggest advantage is its location relative to the popular Keansburg Beach area. Take a right out of the hotel and then the first turn to the north and you are on a direct line to the beach and surrounding town..

We stayed for several days. Our room was clean and the price was fair. It was easy to overlook small broken things like the toilet paper holder. We would stay again. We would just bring an iron and hairdryer. They were remodeling the exterior so it will be nice to see the upgrades. If you’re used to really nice hotels with soaps, ample towels, tissue boxes, coffee maker, ironing board, chairs and maybe desk etc…. This place isn’t for you. In comparison it’s pretty bare bones. But if you want a reasonably priced, clean and safe place to lay your head for the night…. This is for you. It looks like a nice family owned business. Depending on who you interact with there may be a struggle to communicate in English.

The property looked like it was in a war zone, half of the motel was surrounded by a construction fence - they have a long way to go to make it a nice place again

Good stay, facility newly renovated, clean

Our first stay here in a few years. Holly Hill has been significantly upgraded since our last stay. Fully renovated. The rooms are still on the small side, but they are now freshly painted, new soundproof windows, large flat screen TV, electronic locks on the door, the fridge/freezer, microwave, furniture, beds and bath have all been replaced and modernized.

The motel is being renovated and is an excellent value. Room is fairly small and there is a lack soap and shampoo in the room. The room could have been cleaned better but it was not terrible

The property is under construction, so it gives an unfair rating to give right now. I am curious to see what it looks like when it is finished.

The entire motel has recently been renovated with excellent lighting, newer floors, and fresh paint. A great value for the money.

The basic facility was ok, well lit parking, new looking facades. The room was clean but there wasn't a chair or table. The towels were thin as were the pillows. Plus there wasn't a single hook or place to hang any clothes. There seemed to be a lot of residents living there. there was one who was outside all the time looking to bum money or cigarettes or... It was close to where I needed to be but i doubt I'll stay again even for the low cost.. I'd have been better off at another motel even if it cost more.

The bed smelled disgusting, and the white sheets had stains .

Clean

The room smelled like cigarettes and the blanket had burn marks on it. The location was convenient, but I’d drive further to get where I was going to avoid staying there again.

Towels were stained.

there was what looked like pubic hair al over the bed and pillows. Everything was stained, including the mattress pad. The floor stained our feet with yellow dirt, they gave us half a roll of toilet paper for three days.

It was very clean, remodeled room.

I usually stay at budget motels when I travel, so I don't have high expectations at all, but this was one of the worst motels I've stayed in. For $166, I expected more. The night before, I stayed at a $65 motel that was better than this one. The floor was filthy. I had to put a towel down to wipe my feet off before getting into bed. Maybe that's why the towels were stained because other guests have to do the same thing? You only get 3 towels, by the way, and the soap is about the size of a vanilla wafer, so bring your own. The wifi didn't work at all in my room #7. The TV didn't work either. So I had nothing to do. A few positives were the bed was OK, the water was warm, and the air conditioning worked. It was a bit odd that they called my house twice to ask if I was coming. I wasn't even that late to check-in. I arrived around 7pm. Communication with the front desk was difficult to say the least. Avoid this place, if possible.

We stayed here for just one night, and honestly, it felt like we had stepped into a scene from a movie. Between the vibe of the place and pulling in late, I half-expected to be on a stakeout looking for a fugitive or maybe hiding out like CIA agents laying low. Of course, it’s a motel, so what you see is what you get. The room was clean, but there was a musty smell and a few fruit flies greeted us when we arrived. On the plus side, the staff member at check-in was very friendly and explained everything clearly. The location was convenient, and for a quick overnight stay, it did exactly what we needed, with a little extra cinematic flair. Overall, it was a positive experience.

The shower was so dirty and towels had brown stains on them. We went for a concert nearby and just booked a cheap place to stay. We got 2 pillows that looked so old and flat. No hand towel for after you wash your hands. Just a wash cloth that someone washed their gross body with. There was hair And dirt in the shower. We left this morning without even washing up. The toilet paper holder was ripped off the wall. Next time we go somewhere overnight for a concert well spend the extra money.

The person checking me in was very nice. The sheets were a little dirty. The shower was a little dirty. There were many bugs in the room. The air conditioning unit made a lot of strange noises.

Towels and sheets were stained. TV didn't work.

Wifi in my room did not work. No hot water - lukewarm at best. Dirt on floor upon arrival.

This is the only hotel I've ever stayed in with no closet or coat rack. There was nothing provided to hang up coats/clothes. No suitcase rack. Very high noise level from cooling unit and high traffic highway. Many ants in the sink.

This is a cheap motel- bare-bones and bottom of the barrel, BUT it was clean, and the other folks staying there were not loud. Also, beware that it is right on a main road with motorcycles and ambulances screaming by all night. I wouldn’t want to stay there for a vacation, but it was ok for a night.

Room was clean and bed comfortable, which is primary. But bare bones, not even a chair, which I would have liked. Wifi was not strong enough to get a signal to check my emails. And proprietor did each check-in as though for the first time. Still, very convenient location, and I'll probably use it again.

The rooms were clean and newly renovated, nice new TVs, but could have used a table or chair. The parking lot could use some work, a whole repaving, but for the low cost for the night and proximity to Sandy Hook, it was worth staying there for a few nights. A bit noisy being right on the main road, but didn't hear any noise from other folks staying there, which was a plus. Also close to a lot of stuff in the area.

Our first stay here in a few years. Holly Hill has been significantly upgraded since our last stay. Fully renovated. The rooms are still on the small side, but they are now freshly painted, new soundproof windows, large flat screen TV, electronic locks on the door, the fridge/freezer, microwave, furniture, beds and bath have all been replaced and modernized.

room was very simple, just renovated, note must bring all your own supplies. No rack to hang clothes, no accessories available. should of used some soundproofing in walls. overall nice room.

The basic facility was ok, well lit parking, new looking facades. The room was clean but there wasn't a chair or table. The towels were thin as were the pillows. Plus there wasn't a single hook or place to hang any clothes. There seemed to be a lot of residents living there. there was one who was outside all the time looking to bum money or cigarettes or... It was close to where I needed to be but i doubt I'll stay again even for the low cost.. I'd have been better off at another motel even if it cost more.

Well located for our purposes. Clean, reasonable price, most basics provided. However, Wifi did not work for our part of the building, and no public area or even chairs to go where it did, so I was not able to conduct my minimal business while there. Easy to get a Wifi multiplier for outlying rooms.

My stay there was quite comfortable, room was clean very clean and I felt safe also want to thank the staff for going above and beyond by bringing packages to my room and genuine concern for my welfare! Thank you so much to all the staff!

Property management is was very nice and helpful

Cons first- the staff member that checked me in and out, likely the owner who lived above the stairs was extremely unfriendlt and acted bothered by the fact that i needed to be checked in and out. VERY strange fella. No words like hello, thank you or goodbye were used. He looked at me with eother intimidation or fear and was extremely short with his responses and rude in tone. I literally had no damn requests. The entire place was in very bad shape from the outside, and it looked dangerous, dirty and decrepit. There were many signs arpund on what not to do, similar to what i imagine to be a halfway house. Lastly, the TV did not work, ans neither did the coffee machine. I wanted a coffe in the am and a movie in the evening- but that was not happening. There was shampoo, but no conditioner. Now to the good- the room itself was in fantastic condition, newly renovated, beautiful, confortable and with a great layout. It was clean as if the president could walk in. In fact, i was shocked and i wish to get my house in that order and look! It was 5 star worthy within the door- and with 0 bugs. It was stone tiles and not carpet! Modern and easy to clean. Spacious. However, the service was so atrocious, and with the nin-working appliances (plugged into outlets that worked), it takes away the human touch and bare necessities. I wish this room existed in each of my stays, but i dont wish the bad service upon my enemies.

Room was clean. Everything works. 1 clothes hook on door, no where else to hang clothes. Front desk guy hates his life, and you too. One key only for the room. It was like pulling teeth to get extra coffee, shampoo and a towel.

Front desk check in was rough as the gentleman checking us in did not speak English well. And when we got to the room there were specks of blood on the sheets that were supposedly cleaned. Was double charged by the merchant as well and when I called to ask for clarification the merchant was rude and spoke down to me as if I was stupid and not understanding.

The motel didn’t have my reservation. The charge was pending on my credit card. He was not willing or he was unable to help me. I called your Customer Service only to be hung up on. I called again and told to call another number. That number was no good. I then went to another hotel then called my credit card company and disputed the bill.

First at check in there is a $25 room cleaning deposit that they didn't tell you about. The room was fine. large, clean. Door did not fit frame properly and at night the light from outside shown right in. I booked a 2 night stay. Half a roll of toilet paper. 2 towels, 1 washcloth and 1 bath mat. Toiletries were smaller then small. 1 tiny bar of soap, 1 packet of body wash and 1 packet of hand lotion. again packets not mini bottles. Then at 2 am the fire alarm goes off. I don't think it was going off in every room as there were maybe 15 people outside. and they had a sign saying no vacancies. No management to tell us anything. I went in and rang their doorbell and told them .They never came out to talk to their guests. 20 MINUTES THE ALARM WAS GOING OFF AND THEY NEVER ONCE SAID ANYTHING TO US. They also never said anything the next AM at checkout. The guy in the next room said "ive been here about 2 months and this happens frequently but it usually only last a couple minutes"

Could barely understand guy at check in, charged me extra $25 they don’t tell you about anywhere else as a “security deposit”. Room smelled, air conditioner was disruptive and sounded broken or on the verge of breaking, every single linen was stained (bedsheets, towels, everything), flies and gnats were abundant in the room. Overall, it’s a you know what hole. For the amount I paid and the fact that I only stayed 2 nights, I’m horrified. Overcharged and very very underimpressed. If you have nowhere better to stay, I’d still suggest sleeping in your car over this place. If you do stay here, never take off your shoes or you might contract something. I want a refund so bad.

I love this place very nice and people at office are really nice and helpful

Room was very clean and well-maintained. Bed was firm. Staff was very informative & pleasant.

Was looking for an inexpensive option to stay for about 8 hours - just to sleep. Arrived at location at 1pm, after an event in nearby town. Half of the motel was gated off and under construction. Other part had broken windows with cardboard in them to block airflow. Looked unsafe. Located between a trailer park and a strip club. Decided to drive the 2 hours home rather than risk it. Do not book!!

New owners/management. They cleaned up really nicely. Rooms are clean, beds comfortable, and the location is very convenient for Sandy hook and other beaches in the area.

Location is great. Adaquate for a motel.

This is a cheap motel- bare-bones and bottom of the barrel, BUT it was clean, and the other folks staying there were not loud. Also, beware that it is right on a main road with motorcycles and ambulances screaming by all night. I wouldn’t want to stay there for a vacation, but it was ok for a night.

Good: newly rebuilt and redecorated room; bed and bedding; TV and channel list; towels, friendly helpful staff (family-owned property). Bad: Poor WiFi, close to highway full of riders of very loud motorbikes. Notes: $25 damage deposit at checkin (refunded); no microwave in room but one in lobby; almost no convenient dining unless you have a car or use delivery. Overall: hard to beat for the price.

Holly Hill would not qualify as luxurious accommodations but it covers the basics quite nicely and provides friendly service at a manageable price. It is renovating one section of its rooms, so it is partly a construction zone at the moment but the inconvenience is minor. Its biggest advantage is its location relative to the popular Keansburg Beach area. Take a right out of the hotel and then the first turn to the north and you are on a direct line to the beach and surrounding town..

We stayed here for just one night, and honestly, it felt like we had stepped into a scene from a movie. Between the vibe of the place and pulling in late, I half-expected to be on a stakeout looking for a fugitive or maybe hiding out like CIA agents laying low. Of course, it’s a motel, so what you see is what you get. The room was clean, but there was a musty smell and a few fruit flies greeted us when we arrived. On the plus side, the staff member at check-in was very friendly and explained everything clearly. The location was convenient, and for a quick overnight stay, it did exactly what we needed, with a little extra cinematic flair. Overall, it was a positive experience.

Room was clean and bed comfortable, which is primary. But bare bones, not even a chair, which I would have liked. Wifi was not strong enough to get a signal to check my emails. And proprietor did each check-in as though for the first time. Still, very convenient location, and I'll probably use it again.

The rooms were clean and newly renovated, nice new TVs, but could have used a table or chair. The parking lot could use some work, a whole repaving, but for the low cost for the night and proximity to Sandy Hook, it was worth staying there for a few nights. A bit noisy being right on the main road, but didn't hear any noise from other folks staying there, which was a plus. Also close to a lot of stuff in the area.

You get what you pay for. I will say, the rooms are updated and clean. The outside of the rooms are very well lit. There are definitely some questionable occupants with even more questionable vehicles making it feel rather unsafe to sleep and leave your car outside. We were legitimately concerned our car would be sitting on cinder blocks in the morning. Not to mention the noise from being on the highway.