Name: Best Western The Hilcroft Hotel West Lothian
Address: East Main Street, Edinburgh (und Umgebung), West Lothian, GB
Price range: 83 $–186 $ per night
Rating: 8.47

Was Gäste sagen

Im Best Western The Hilcroft Hotel West Lothian heben Bewertungen saubere, komfortable Zimmer und ein gutes Preis-Leistungs-Verhältnis hervor, zusammen mit Nachteilen wie veralteten Bereichen, Lärm von Fluren oder der Straße, unregelmäßiger Warmwasserversorgung und Sommerhitze aufgrund begrenzter Fensteröffnung und Belüftung.

Das Personal wird durchweg als freundlich und hilfsbereit beschrieben, obwohl einige Gäste von langsamem Frühstücksservice, einem falsch bearbeiteten Sonderwunsch oder wenig verständnisvollen Reaktionen auf Probleme berichteten. Das hoteleigene Restaurant ist beliebt, während die Qualität, die Portionsgrößen und der Zeitpunkt des Frühstücks von ausgezeichnet bis durchschnittlich oder zu lange gekocht variieren. Die Lage ist für Autofahrer zwischen Edinburgh und Glasgow in der Nähe der Autobahn gut geeignet, aber die öffentlichen Verkehrsmittel nach Edinburgh können lange dauern. Erwarten Sie eine freundliche, preiswerte Basis mit einigen Einschränkungen in Bezug auf Komfort und Frühstück.

Ausstattung

Sauberkeit

Zimmer

Service

Lage

Gastronomie

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Ausstattung

Ausreichend kostenlose Parkplätze und eine hoteleigene Bar/Restaurant werden immer wieder erwähnt und geschätzt. Es gibt keinen Aufzug und keine Möglichkeit zur Gästewäsche, und Teile der Unterkunft werden als veraltet beschrieben.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

6

Re

14. Feb. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Hotel looks tired, most of the staff very chatty and helpful. Shower leaked continuously, hot water was cold in the morning but hot in the evening. Food average, beer was good.

6

Alison

14. Juni 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Chose this location as Expedia listed it as having laundry facilities. Upon arrival learned that there are no laundry facilities which was disappointing

10

Margaret

5. Aug. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

All of the staff was wonderful — the night staff was very helpful, and the day staff was great!!! Thank you Zoey and everyone!!! This is a very nice, clean property, often used for weddings. Book early as this property books out. Driving distance to Edinburgh or Glasgow.

8

Susan

2. Juni 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 8 Nächte

Love the property and location. Travelocity showed laundry facilities available but that turned out to be wrong. The people were very nice and helpful.

8

Wendy J A

12. Aug. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

Adequate. Room good size and repair in bathroom sorted. It was a useful base as we drove to local station with free parking to get into Edinburgh daily. Huge breakfast first morning. Last morning as per menu but significantly smaller. No lift, so heavy cases up a staircase. Bathroom tap water not drinking but supplied bottle water free.

10

ROSEMARY

9. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Hotel easy to find, well located for motorway. Plenty of parking, (free). Friendly reception staff, Room spacious, clean, tea, coffee, bottled water and biscuits provided. The fridge with icebox an added touch. Shower over the bath, quality soaps, shower gel and shampoo provided along with clean quality towels. Large comfortable bed. Only negative was lack of sound proofing between rooms, could hear next door talking and coughing. Would stay again.

6

David

26. Mai 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Unfortunate the rooms do not have window screens as it was very hot that evening and so could not leave window open due to no screen and so many mosquitos etc. Street facing room quite loud late into the night with traffic passing close. Unfortunately the guest across the hall was in and out of the room every 10-15 mins from midnight until near 3am and their door slammed every time. The hotel should do proper maintenance to make sure all room doors close soft. Great service on arrival, easy free parking and decent quality restaurant with fair pricing,.

8

Susan

24. Mai 2024

·

Although some amenities were misstated in Travelocity, the staff and costs were very good. So central in location, made it easy to drive everywhere.

10

Nazir

6. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

The location is conveniently located for public transport. Self parking if you have own car and Bar open. The stuff are wonderful, professional and helpful to cater for residents need. I had two elderly auntie and they kindly relocated them from First floor to ground floor

10

Larissa

10. Aug. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Great place to stay with lots of parking and a nice restaurant attached!

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Sauberkeit

Die Zimmer sind im Allgemeinen sehr sauber und gut gepflegt. Einige Gäste erwähnten Probleme wie einen muffigen Geruch im Badezimmer, staubige oder verschmutzte Stellen und abgenutzte Gegenstände.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

10

Adam

7. Dez. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Friendly staff, clean room and excellent service

8

thomas

11. Dez. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Yes clean

8

Elizabeth

12. Juni 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Great location for getting to Murrayfield. Helpful and friendly staff. Amazingly we didn’t hear the wedding parties in full swing both nights we were there (my heart sank initially when I saw them). Rooms were nice and clean although could’ve done with some extra deep hoovering at the carpet edges next to wall. Would recommend. Particularly the staff. They were great.

6

Heidi

5. Juli 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Reception area ok, room pretty grim. Many signs of wear and tear - shower head riser broken, marks/stains on walls, desk not clean, dusty kettle, blind was dirty and ripped, no chair for desk (man-handle on of the other chairs. No usb points for recharging but you can borrow a grubby usb plug from reception. Just bath towel and hand towel provided, hidden in wardrobe, use hand towel as bathmat. Wouldn't take much to improve. Not asked if my stay was ok so they can have feedback on Expedia.

10

Antonio

1. Juni 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Clean room and bathroom, friendly and helpful staff. Very good breakfast.

10

Liz

22. Juli 2023

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

Pleasant staff, very clean comfortable rooms

4

Danielle

26. Okt. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Room and bathroom were quiet, clean and well presented, although bathroom did have a mild damp smell. Bed was very comfortable and we had a great night sleep despite a wedding being held in the hotel that night. However in the morning neither of us were able to have a hot shower, despite running the shower on and off over an hour (between 7 - 8am). When we spoke to staff on check-out we were essentially told that the further away from the hot water system your room is then you get less hot water when the system is in demand. Very frustrating that this is a known issue and they still insist on putting people in those rooms. Even more frustrating that there was very little apology from the staff about the issue who had a “well that’s just the way it is” attitude about our experience. As someone who frequently stays in Best Western hotels this wasn’t the level of service I have previously experienced from the brand and I will not be staying here again.

10

Christopher

26. Juni 2025

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Overall a very nice hotel, clean friendly and helpful staff.

10

Mary

14. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

We had a late arrival and the reception staff were great and very helpful. They chatted for a few minutes while we checked in which was good as some places they ignore you and dont make conversation. The room was very clean and tidy and the bed was soooo comfortable.

10

V A

3. Sept. 2023

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Great stay, very helful and friendly staff. Excellent breakfast and room extremely clean . Only let down was a rip in the head board of our room. Not a huge issue but didn't look great appearance wise. There was a wedding on during our stay which did not affect us at all with regards to late noise. Would definately recommend and would return.

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Zimmer

Die Betten sind bequem und einige Zimmer sind geräumig oder wurden kürzlich renoviert, aber andere wirken klein oder abgenutzt. Mehrere Bewertungen erwähnen unangenehm warme Zimmer und gelegentliche Probleme mit der Warmwasserversorgung am Morgen.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

6

Christopher

8. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Good hotel and restaurant. Very noisy during the night . Banging doors. Steer clear of room 21

8

Jennifer

11. Okt. 2023

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Couldn’t open windows or change temperature of room,which was too hot for us. Only one towel for two people (only discovered later at night and didn’t want to go down stairs to ask for another)

8

Archie

7. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Check in was good, kind and efficient staff, I was only there for one night. The room was nice, spacious enough, large bed with what I assume to be memory foam mattress, which was a treat, could've done with a plug socket by the bed, otherwise it was okay. Breakfast the next morning was something to be desired, waited 30 minutes to be offered any kind of hot drinks or toast, and the waitress who eventually took my order looked as though she'd rather be elsewhere. I can excuse the fact that there was a large party staying overnight which could've been a factor in the service delay, however some recognition wouldn't have gone amiss. The breakfast itself was average, overcooked fried egg, potato scone which I'm sure had seen better days, and the beans were lukewarm. Would I stay here again? Only out of sheer convenience, for what I paid I expected slightly more.

8

sharon

18. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Set at the end of the village, Breakfast was average, room was spacious and bed was large and comfy.

8

Joan

25. Aug. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für 6 Nächte

The staff are friendly and welcoming. The rooms were very clean. However, in August, our rooms were extremely hot- no air circulation. The window only opens a few inches on the top. The plastic desk fan doesn’t help. The food at the restaurant was very good.

10

Adam

24. Feb. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Great hotel for a short stop, staff very friendly and helpful, only complaint is my to didn’t have any channels

10

ROSEMARY

9. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Hotel easy to find, well located for motorway. Plenty of parking, (free). Friendly reception staff, Room spacious, clean, tea, coffee, bottled water and biscuits provided. The fridge with icebox an added touch. Shower over the bath, quality soaps, shower gel and shampoo provided along with clean quality towels. Large comfortable bed. Only negative was lack of sound proofing between rooms, could hear next door talking and coughing. Would stay again.

6

David

26. Mai 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Unfortunate the rooms do not have window screens as it was very hot that evening and so could not leave window open due to no screen and so many mosquitos etc. Street facing room quite loud late into the night with traffic passing close. Unfortunately the guest across the hall was in and out of the room every 10-15 mins from midnight until near 3am and their door slammed every time. The hotel should do proper maintenance to make sure all room doors close soft. Great service on arrival, easy free parking and decent quality restaurant with fair pricing,.

4

Danielle

26. Okt. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Room and bathroom were quiet, clean and well presented, although bathroom did have a mild damp smell. Bed was very comfortable and we had a great night sleep despite a wedding being held in the hotel that night. However in the morning neither of us were able to have a hot shower, despite running the shower on and off over an hour (between 7 - 8am). When we spoke to staff on check-out we were essentially told that the further away from the hot water system your room is then you get less hot water when the system is in demand. Very frustrating that this is a known issue and they still insist on putting people in those rooms. Even more frustrating that there was very little apology from the staff about the issue who had a “well that’s just the way it is” attitude about our experience. As someone who frequently stays in Best Western hotels this wasn’t the level of service I have previously experienced from the brand and I will not be staying here again.

8

Helen

20. Juli 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Very good but uncomfortable bed

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Service

Der Service wird durchweg als freundlich, hilfsbereit und zuvorkommend gelobt. Gelegentliche Versäumnisse sind langsamer Frühstücksservice, ein falsch bestellter Kuchen und wenig verständnisvolle Reaktionen auf Probleme.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

8

Archie

7. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Check in was good, kind and efficient staff, I was only there for one night. The room was nice, spacious enough, large bed with what I assume to be memory foam mattress, which was a treat, could've done with a plug socket by the bed, otherwise it was okay. Breakfast the next morning was something to be desired, waited 30 minutes to be offered any kind of hot drinks or toast, and the waitress who eventually took my order looked as though she'd rather be elsewhere. I can excuse the fact that there was a large party staying overnight which could've been a factor in the service delay, however some recognition wouldn't have gone amiss. The breakfast itself was average, overcooked fried egg, potato scone which I'm sure had seen better days, and the beans were lukewarm. Would I stay here again? Only out of sheer convenience, for what I paid I expected slightly more.

10

Prantika

9. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

Very friendly and helpful staff.

10

Mark

16. März 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Chris on reception was very helpful. Food was nice too

10

Lesley

1. Okt. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Lovely stay here, staff were fabulous highly recommended

10

Claire

18. Aug. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Great service overall

10

John

19. Apr. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Absolutely stellar service from the team here. Friendly, courteous and couldn't do enough to help. Hotel is comfortable and clean and has everything you need. Staff are the stars here though.

10

Emmanuel

23. Nov. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Great staff

10

Mary

14. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

We had a late arrival and the reception staff were great and very helpful. They chatted for a few minutes while we checked in which was good as some places they ignore you and dont make conversation. The room was very clean and tidy and the bed was soooo comfortable.

10

Sharon

11. Mai 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Staff in all areas of hotel were friendly, helpful and knowledgeable.

6

Shibin

23. Okt. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Ordered a birthday cake in advance. Reminded about the cake during check in and requested to prepare the chocolate cake ready by midnight, and they promised that it is ready. At midnight when asked , they said it is "missing ". However they arranged a small lemon sponge cake ( from tesco ) after waiting for 2 hrs.

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Lage

Günstige Basis für Autofahrer zwischen Edinburgh und Glasgow und in der Nähe der Autobahn, mit einer im Allgemeinen ruhigen Umgebung. Die öffentlichen Verkehrsmittel nach Edinburgh können lange dauern.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

8

Robert

3. Okt. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Good stop over hotel

10

Nell

10. Apr. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

We used this hotel as a base while visiting family. Close to a few big attractions like Falkirk wheel , kelpies , Bo’ness Steam Railway , Linlithgow palace and lock , and of coarse the bridges over the river Forth I would like to recommend this hotel and it’s lovely staff to anyone who might be considering staying here

10

Paul

3. Nov. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Stopped on the way too and from Edinburgh Airport over a 2 week period. Two different rooms both excellent. Very clean. Hreat breakfast and friendly staff. Ideal for staying near Edinburgh with Airport about 20 minutes away and park and ride/tram station. I travel for work and plan to keep using this gem.

10

Angela

31. Mai 2023

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Lovely hotel within half an hour of Edinburgh airport. Plenty of free parking too. Rooms were clean and comfortable. Highly recommend if you need to be near the airport without paying ridiculous airport hotel prices

10

Jacob

20. Mai 2025

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

The staff were extremely accommodating and friendly. I plan on staying here when I come back to Scotland. It is central to both Edinburgh and Glasgow which is awesome and not too busy.

8

Wendy J A

12. Aug. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

Adequate. Room good size and repair in bathroom sorted. It was a useful base as we drove to local station with free parking to get into Edinburgh daily. Huge breakfast first morning. Last morning as per menu but significantly smaller. No lift, so heavy cases up a staircase. Bathroom tap water not drinking but supplied bottle water free.

10

ROSEMARY

9. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Hotel easy to find, well located for motorway. Plenty of parking, (free). Friendly reception staff, Room spacious, clean, tea, coffee, bottled water and biscuits provided. The fridge with icebox an added touch. Shower over the bath, quality soaps, shower gel and shampoo provided along with clean quality towels. Large comfortable bed. Only negative was lack of sound proofing between rooms, could hear next door talking and coughing. Would stay again.

10

Liliana

15. Aug. 2023

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

When i booked I didn't realize it was out of Edinburgh, kinda long bus trip but as soon as we arrived we loved the place. The staff was amazing in accommodating us early, although busy with a wedding. The room was very clean and the food was amazing. Highly recommended!

10

shane

9. Sept. 2023

·

Aufenthalt für 3 Nächte

Nice and quiet area to base our Edinburgh explorations. The front desk staff were exceptional with hints for our further travels around Scotland

8

Susan

24. Mai 2024

·

Although some amenities were misstated in Travelocity, the staff and costs were very good. So central in location, made it easy to drive everywhere.

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Gastronomie

Restaurantmahlzeiten werden häufig als sehr gut und preiswert bewertet. Das Frühstück reicht von ausgezeichnet bis durchschnittlich oder zu lange gekocht, wobei die Portionsgrößen und die Konsistenz des Services variieren.

Ähnliche Gästebewertungen

6

Maria

21. Mai 2023

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

The room was clean and tidy, however, there was no kettle and tea bags for tea.. The breakfast was not the usual buffet but arather limited choice (photo), one had to order the hot breakfast from the menu. One would think it would make it individually for each customer reducing food waste, however, they forgot to bring my bacon and brought too many mushrooms even I'd asked for just a bit of mushrooms When I asked for the cheese/meet platter, they brought a plate of grated cheddar cheese and a few slices of processed ham, which was rather disappointing as compared to other Best Western hotels we stayed at.

10

Vivian

13. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Very nice comfortable rooms. Breakfast overcooked.

8

David

19. Juli 2023

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Very comfortable hotel, the rooms are nice and clean. The staff are all friendly and helpful. The food was good value

8

Archie

7. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Check in was good, kind and efficient staff, I was only there for one night. The room was nice, spacious enough, large bed with what I assume to be memory foam mattress, which was a treat, could've done with a plug socket by the bed, otherwise it was okay. Breakfast the next morning was something to be desired, waited 30 minutes to be offered any kind of hot drinks or toast, and the waitress who eventually took my order looked as though she'd rather be elsewhere. I can excuse the fact that there was a large party staying overnight which could've been a factor in the service delay, however some recognition wouldn't have gone amiss. The breakfast itself was average, overcooked fried egg, potato scone which I'm sure had seen better days, and the beans were lukewarm. Would I stay here again? Only out of sheer convenience, for what I paid I expected slightly more.

10

Kenneth

19. Juli 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Staff were friendly, lovely room that looked as it was recently renovated. Great breakfast with plenty of choice. Would recommend for price bracket.

8

Joan

25. Aug. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für 6 Nächte

The staff are friendly and welcoming. The rooms were very clean. However, in August, our rooms were extremely hot- no air circulation. The window only opens a few inches on the top. The plastic desk fan doesn’t help. The food at the restaurant was very good.

8

Denise

26. Okt. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Hotel reception very nice rest of the hotel dated, food in resturant was very nice

8

Claire

3. Sept. 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Beds were comfortable, food very nice, staff were very helpful indeed

10

Antonio

1. Juni 2025

·

Aufenthalt für eine Nacht

Clean room and bathroom, friendly and helpful staff. Very good breakfast.

10

Robert

10. Sept. 2024

·

Aufenthalt für 2 Nächte

Helpful staff good resturaunt

War das hilfreich?

KI-Zusammenfassung aktueller Gästebewertungen

Monat	Durchschnittspreis
Januar	75 $
Februar	82 $
März	93 $
April	98 $
Mai	122 $
Juni	147 $
Juli	145 $
August	178 $
September	126 $
Oktober	99 $
November	98 $
Dezember	93 $

So.	Mo.	Di.	Mi.	Do.	Fr.	Sa.
				1	2	3
4	5	6	7	8	9	10
11	12	13	14	15	16	17
18	19	20	21 $173	22 $112	23 $140	24 $186
25 $84	26 $139	27 $151	28 $134	29 $105	30 $147	31 $123

So.	Mo.	Di.	Mi.	Do.	Fr.	Sa.
1 $86	2 $102	3 $134	4 $120	5 $94	6 $89	7 $128
8 $83	9 $100	10 $140	11 $116	12 $94	13 $120	14 $159
15 $85	16 $107	17 $136	18 $109	19 $96	20 $98	21 $122
22 $86	23 $102	24 $137	25 $118	26 $100	27 $102	28 $126
29 $86	30 $96

Best Western The Hilcroft Hotel West Lothian

Preise für Best Western The Hilcroft Hotel West Lothian

Monatliche Durchschnittspreise

Über diese Unterkunft

Lage

Zimmeroptionen

Standardzimmer, 1 Doppelbett, Nichtraucher

Familienzimmer, 1 Doppelbett, Nichtraucher

Familienzimmer, 2 Einzelbetten, Nichtraucher

Superior-Zimmer, 1 King-Bett, Nichtraucher

Standardzimmer, 1 Doppelbett, barrierefrei, Nichtraucher

Standardzimmer, 2 Einzelbetten, Nichtraucher

Gästebewertungen zu Best Western The Hilcroft Hotel West Lothian

Wer übernachtet hier?

Was Gäste sagen

Es wurden noch keine Bewertungen geschrieben

Richtlinien der Unterkunft

Hinweise zum Check-in

Gut zu wissen

Optionale Extras

Preise für kommende Reisedaten