The St. Regis New York

The hotel is under construction’ Air conditioning did not work one day.

Until the lobby/dining refurbishments are finished, the hotel has nothing to offer but a long walk through basement hallway. Seriously. The cost of this misery remained astonishingly high. My room, during a period when the hotel was not at full occupancy, was on the third floor facing an alleyway. You shouldn’t have to complain to receive a modicum of respect

We stayed for a couple of days/nights in one of their deluxe suites. The butler service was incredible, very courteous prompt, willing to help in any way. The rooms were very clean, in fact cleaned a couple of times during the day if we needed. They were working on the lobby. Although you needed to go to substitute lobby, all personnel were very nice directly us where to go. We can not wait to have our next trip into NYC & stay at the St. Regis

The remodeling was bothersome

Everything was great a little disappointing Hotels.com did not advise us Lobby, Restaurant and Bar all under construction.

There was a renovation going on… They should have stop booking rooms under these conditions…

This felt like a bait and switch. The hotel was under construction and the entire lobby and restaurant and bar were closed. Felt like a prison. The checkin "upgraded" us from our king to a "bigger" room. What a joke. it wasn't bigger just a room with two full beds that felt like they were mattresses bought on sale at kmart before they went bankrupt. She staff were indifferent. Absolutely not worth a grand a night. Expedia should have told us details of the construction before booking. I would have stayed at the four seasons.

We chose the St.Regis for its famous lobby and bar and classic charm. We were not told until just before our arrival that the lobby was being renovated and off limits and the bar and restaurant were closed. We understand those are being modernized and the beautiful rooms will also be modernized. Exactly what we do not want, so we will not return.

Property was partially under renovation, which caused an issue with lifts. Lastly, I had requested requested the last day of statement which is yet to be received. Regards

The hotel lobby and restaurants are all under construction. We were never notified of this ahead of time. In fact, we were getting emails about booking dinner in the restaurant which was not even open. Our room was not ready at 5:45 pm for check in. Instead of the 2 double bed room, we got a one bed and a roll away bed. Secondly, the hot water facet shut off after 30-45 seconds in the bathroom. There was no hot water in the bathtub. When we tried to place our breakfast order Friday evening for Saturday morning, the staff was rude and did not want to take our order. We thought we would have a wonderful weekend bridal shopping for my daughter. The hotel was a huge disappointment.

This is the best hotel in NYC. The service is impeccable. The rooms are well appointed and beautifully maintained. The in-room dining is fantastic and our butler team were attentive and helpful despite being very busy over the holiday period. Highly recommend if you want to have a unique and luxurious experience.

The hotel is under construction’ Air conditioning did not work one day.

The property is lovely, but the experience suffered. I spent two nights in NYC. Here were the problems: (1) On the first night, a Bose radio went off prior to sunrise. I couldn't turn it off without moving furniture and unplugging it. And then trying to get back to sleep. (2) I was unable to control the thermostat so the room was much warmer than I wanted. I asked the staff to turn it down while I was out and they turned it down to 60 degrees. (3) Finally, when I left, I asked for my car to be pulled around. I gave them the requested 20 minutes notice, but waited 20 additional minutes for the car to come around due to an error at the desk. I know these are first world problems (believe me, I know), but you're paying the St. Regis to eliminate these errors, not to make them. I doubt I'll return.

We have stayed at the st Regis two times prior to this recent stay. Our flight was cancelled to Toronto and the hotel we were staying at couldn’t accommodate us as our room was not available. Anyway, we decided to book the St Regis as we have enjoyed staying there in the past. This time however, the room was not to our standards at all. The shower flooded. Our rooms decor was really worn and dated. Their breakfast was lack luster. The bellmen and doormen were great. The front desk upon check in was not very welcoming. We wouldn’t be staying here again I’m afraid. For the price you pay vs the service you receive doesn’t balance out. The St Regis should be downgraded to a 4 star property rather than a 5.

We stayed for a couple of days/nights in one of their deluxe suites. The butler service was incredible, very courteous prompt, willing to help in any way. The rooms were very clean, in fact cleaned a couple of times during the day if we needed. They were working on the lobby. Although you needed to go to substitute lobby, all personnel were very nice directly us where to go. We can not wait to have our next trip into NYC & stay at the St. Regis

The St Regis is due for a makeover. Its entire decor is dated. Everything there is priced double of what its really worth. If you like to over pay than this is your stay.

Such great expectations for this hotel but sadly did not produce a great experience. The hotel itself is very nice. Not as impressive as some of the others in the same category but very old school and well kept. Unfortunately that’s where it stopped. First of all, no warning of construction going on and my room was terribly loud with air hammer drills and workers yelling for the first three hours. Asked to change rooms but they said construction would be over at 5 and gone for the weekend. Feel sorry for the people who stayed through the week. With the exception of the front desk and the butler, service was horrible. Waited forever to get a table at Astor court, food took forever and the quality of food was horrendous. They should be ashamed. Chicken was room temperature and no aesthetic value to anything. Gigantic clumps of hair in the shower upon arrival which tells me nothing was cleaned. Took 20 mins to get a waiter for morning coffee, brings out my espresso and girlfriends cup then forgets the coffee. We never saw the waiter again. Hostess disappeared so I actually had to get the concierge to get the coffee. Most of this stuff is easy to forget if you’re at the holiday inn but not at this price point. These are the best hotels in the world and everything should be top notch. Stay at the Plaza or the Four Seasons this place was a joke

Property was partially under renovation, which caused an issue with lifts. Lastly, I had requested requested the last day of statement which is yet to be received. Regards

The hotel lobby and restaurants are all under construction. We were never notified of this ahead of time. In fact, we were getting emails about booking dinner in the restaurant which was not even open. Our room was not ready at 5:45 pm for check in. Instead of the 2 double bed room, we got a one bed and a roll away bed. Secondly, the hot water facet shut off after 30-45 seconds in the bathroom. There was no hot water in the bathtub. When we tried to place our breakfast order Friday evening for Saturday morning, the staff was rude and did not want to take our order. We thought we would have a wonderful weekend bridal shopping for my daughter. The hotel was a huge disappointment.

The staff was incredible, the hotel was immaculate, the location was the best.

Incredibly comfortable beds and nice quiet rooms.

This is the best hotel in NYC. The service is impeccable. The rooms are well appointed and beautifully maintained. The in-room dining is fantastic and our butler team were attentive and helpful despite being very busy over the holiday period. Highly recommend if you want to have a unique and luxurious experience.

The property is lovely, but the experience suffered. I spent two nights in NYC. Here were the problems: (1) On the first night, a Bose radio went off prior to sunrise. I couldn't turn it off without moving furniture and unplugging it. And then trying to get back to sleep. (2) I was unable to control the thermostat so the room was much warmer than I wanted. I asked the staff to turn it down while I was out and they turned it down to 60 degrees. (3) Finally, when I left, I asked for my car to be pulled around. I gave them the requested 20 minutes notice, but waited 20 additional minutes for the car to come around due to an error at the desk. I know these are first world problems (believe me, I know), but you're paying the St. Regis to eliminate these errors, not to make them. I doubt I'll return.

Until the lobby/dining refurbishments are finished, the hotel has nothing to offer but a long walk through basement hallway. Seriously. The cost of this misery remained astonishingly high. My room, during a period when the hotel was not at full occupancy, was on the third floor facing an alleyway. You shouldn’t have to complain to receive a modicum of respect

We have stayed at the st Regis two times prior to this recent stay. Our flight was cancelled to Toronto and the hotel we were staying at couldn’t accommodate us as our room was not available. Anyway, we decided to book the St Regis as we have enjoyed staying there in the past. This time however, the room was not to our standards at all. The shower flooded. Our rooms decor was really worn and dated. Their breakfast was lack luster. The bellmen and doormen were great. The front desk upon check in was not very welcoming. We wouldn’t be staying here again I’m afraid. For the price you pay vs the service you receive doesn’t balance out. The St Regis should be downgraded to a 4 star property rather than a 5.

The St Regis is due for a makeover. Its entire decor is dated. Everything there is priced double of what its really worth. If you like to over pay than this is your stay.

Only one window on the room…..

Such great expectations for this hotel but sadly did not produce a great experience. The hotel itself is very nice. Not as impressive as some of the others in the same category but very old school and well kept. Unfortunately that’s where it stopped. First of all, no warning of construction going on and my room was terribly loud with air hammer drills and workers yelling for the first three hours. Asked to change rooms but they said construction would be over at 5 and gone for the weekend. Feel sorry for the people who stayed through the week. With the exception of the front desk and the butler, service was horrible. Waited forever to get a table at Astor court, food took forever and the quality of food was horrendous. They should be ashamed. Chicken was room temperature and no aesthetic value to anything. Gigantic clumps of hair in the shower upon arrival which tells me nothing was cleaned. Took 20 mins to get a waiter for morning coffee, brings out my espresso and girlfriends cup then forgets the coffee. We never saw the waiter again. Hostess disappeared so I actually had to get the concierge to get the coffee. Most of this stuff is easy to forget if you’re at the holiday inn but not at this price point. These are the best hotels in the world and everything should be top notch. Stay at the Plaza or the Four Seasons this place was a joke

Loved the care and comfort as well as the quiet , calm ,gracious atmosphere !

This is the most luxurious hotel I have ever seen. It was designed by John Jacob Astor who unfortunately was lost in the Titanic disaster. But thankfully his beautiful hotel keeps his legacy alive. The architecture is absolutely jaw dropping. You will feel like you went back in time because the decor and amenities look like they are brand new even though they are intricately ornate Edwardian designs. This hotel looks like it's from a fairy tale both inside and out.Astor thought of everything. Every little detail in this place is impeccable. The staff is extremely friendly and thoughtful and their service is excellent. They carry your luggage and walk you to the building with an umbrella if it's raining. They carry your luggage up to your room. The concierge desk helps you with whatever you need. It was my mother and my birthday and they were so thoughtful and hooked us up at another restaurant for her birthday dinner. They gave us a personalized birthday card and treats. They gave us a tour of the basement which has historical artifacts and photos or autographs of many famous celebrities who came to stay to perform at the venue in a previous decade. If you are a fan of luxury, history or VIP treatment this is the place for you. If you want to experience luxury

Great service. Beautiful house car took us to the show. Butler was fantastic. 5 star experience!

This is the best hotel in NYC. The service is impeccable. The rooms are well appointed and beautifully maintained. The in-room dining is fantastic and our butler team were attentive and helpful despite being very busy over the holiday period. Highly recommend if you want to have a unique and luxurious experience.

Terrible experience. Front desk staff were atrocious

Beautiful property and absolutely my favorite hotel in the city. Wonderful location right off of 5th Ave. Amazing service, pleasant staff, and very helpful and patient concierge. Love staying at this property its always a perfect trip to the city.

Beautiful hotel from the gilded age. Outstanding service. Beautiful and delicious breakfast.

Service in the hotel was terrible , butler service and room service was very bad

Check in person was an absolute pleasure to deal with. The butler on the floor was very responsive.

The Hotel reception team was very un profesional to say the least. We reserved a suite for 3 adults and a child and told that there are no rollaway beds and we “have to manage” . Checkin was 2!hours late. We kept recieving call to the room in the mornings regarding room service that were not ours. And other comments It just felt NOT st regis but a Motel 6.

Butler service was terrible. Emailed twice with a request and no response. Called to ask for distilled water for cpap machine and was told to walk to a store to buy some. Very disappointed.

This is the most luxurious hotel I have ever seen. It was designed by John Jacob Astor who unfortunately was lost in the Titanic disaster. But thankfully his beautiful hotel keeps his legacy alive. The architecture is absolutely jaw dropping. You will feel like you went back in time because the decor and amenities look like they are brand new even though they are intricately ornate Edwardian designs. This hotel looks like it's from a fairy tale both inside and out.Astor thought of everything. Every little detail in this place is impeccable. The staff is extremely friendly and thoughtful and their service is excellent. They carry your luggage and walk you to the building with an umbrella if it's raining. They carry your luggage up to your room. The concierge desk helps you with whatever you need. It was my mother and my birthday and they were so thoughtful and hooked us up at another restaurant for her birthday dinner. They gave us a personalized birthday card and treats. They gave us a tour of the basement which has historical artifacts and photos or autographs of many famous celebrities who came to stay to perform at the venue in a previous decade. If you are a fan of luxury, history or VIP treatment this is the place for you. If you want to experience luxury

Great hotel in beautiful location

Beautiful property and absolutely my favorite hotel in the city. Wonderful location right off of 5th Ave. Amazing service, pleasant staff, and very helpful and patient concierge. Love staying at this property its always a perfect trip to the city.

Location &

Wonderful property in the heart of the City!

The staff was incredible, the hotel was immaculate, the location was the best.

This is the best hotel in NYC. The service is impeccable. The rooms are well appointed and beautifully maintained. The in-room dining is fantastic and our butler team were attentive and helpful despite being very busy over the holiday period. Highly recommend if you want to have a unique and luxurious experience.

No restaurant a 3 star hotel

Beautiful hotel from the gilded age. Outstanding service. Beautiful and delicious breakfast.

Everything was great a little disappointing Hotels.com did not advise us Lobby, Restaurant and Bar all under construction.

Each staff member that helped us was wonderful. The only areas of improvement for the room were that there were no slippers and the televisions were very poor quality. The hotel I would give 5 stars. The room service food I would sadly have to give 2 stars. The food was AWFUL. Risotto was watery mush with no seasoning. Ordered an avocado tofu scramble which was beautifully presented but tasted like nothing, They do not seem to use salt or any other seasonings when cooking. Ordered a mixed selection of ice cream and it all just tasted BAD. Great hotel absolutely stay here but don't order food. We were being lazy and did not take advantage of the countless great restaurants in the city.

Service in the hotel was terrible , butler service and room service was very bad

This felt like a bait and switch. The hotel was under construction and the entire lobby and restaurant and bar were closed. Felt like a prison. The checkin "upgraded" us from our king to a "bigger" room. What a joke. it wasn't bigger just a room with two full beds that felt like they were mattresses bought on sale at kmart before they went bankrupt. She staff were indifferent. Absolutely not worth a grand a night. Expedia should have told us details of the construction before booking. I would have stayed at the four seasons.

We chose the St.Regis for its famous lobby and bar and classic charm. We were not told until just before our arrival that the lobby was being renovated and off limits and the bar and restaurant were closed. We understand those are being modernized and the beautiful rooms will also be modernized. Exactly what we do not want, so we will not return.

Such great expectations for this hotel but sadly did not produce a great experience. The hotel itself is very nice. Not as impressive as some of the others in the same category but very old school and well kept. Unfortunately that’s where it stopped. First of all, no warning of construction going on and my room was terribly loud with air hammer drills and workers yelling for the first three hours. Asked to change rooms but they said construction would be over at 5 and gone for the weekend. Feel sorry for the people who stayed through the week. With the exception of the front desk and the butler, service was horrible. Waited forever to get a table at Astor court, food took forever and the quality of food was horrendous. They should be ashamed. Chicken was room temperature and no aesthetic value to anything. Gigantic clumps of hair in the shower upon arrival which tells me nothing was cleaned. Took 20 mins to get a waiter for morning coffee, brings out my espresso and girlfriends cup then forgets the coffee. We never saw the waiter again. Hostess disappeared so I actually had to get the concierge to get the coffee. Most of this stuff is easy to forget if you’re at the holiday inn but not at this price point. These are the best hotels in the world and everything should be top notch. Stay at the Plaza or the Four Seasons this place was a joke

The hotel lobby and restaurants are all under construction. We were never notified of this ahead of time. In fact, we were getting emails about booking dinner in the restaurant which was not even open. Our room was not ready at 5:45 pm for check in. Instead of the 2 double bed room, we got a one bed and a roll away bed. Secondly, the hot water facet shut off after 30-45 seconds in the bathroom. There was no hot water in the bathtub. When we tried to place our breakfast order Friday evening for Saturday morning, the staff was rude and did not want to take our order. We thought we would have a wonderful weekend bridal shopping for my daughter. The hotel was a huge disappointment.