Name: Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Spa & Golf Resort
Address: Tarporley Road, Whitchurch, Shropshire (comté), GB
Price range: 80 $US–146 $US per night
Rating: 7.5

Ce qu'en disent des voyageurs

Au Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Spa & Golf Resort, les clients apprécient le personnel accueillant, les chambres spacieuses et le cadre pittoresque du parcours de golf, tout en notant des parties datées et des problèmes occasionnels d'entretien ou de propreté, notamment dans les salles de bain, ainsi qu'un rapport qualité/prix et un service en salle à manger mitigés.

La piscine et la salle de sport sont appréciées, et les installations de golf sont un point fort, bien que la disponibilité du spa et certains vestiaires soient parfois aléatoires. Plusieurs clients estiment que les prix du petit-déjeuner et du bar sont élevés par rapport à la qualité, et le service du dîner peut être lent. L'emplacement est paisible mais un peu isolé, les taxis nécessitant une réservation préalable et le bruit occasionnel de golfeurs ou de portes claquant tôt le matin. Attendez-vous à des installations correctes et à une vue sur la campagne, mais pas à une expérience systématiquement soignée.

Équipements

Propreté

Chambres

Service

Emplacement

Repas

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Équipements

Les parcours de golf sont un point fort, et la piscine et la salle de sport sont appréciées. L'accès au spa et certains vestiaires peuvent être incohérents ou fatigués, et des bornes de recharge pour véhicules électriques sont disponibles.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

10

Annette

13 mars 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Really nice place, very comfortable bed, felt very safe as single female traveller. Not overly keen on menu and quite expensive. Nice breakfast. Pleasant swim in the morning, only two lanes and people swimming here there and everywhereso difficult to swim in straight line. Changing rooms tired and need updating. Enjoyed my stay though.

10

Natalie

13 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Only stayed for one night but lovely hotel, big spacious room with opening balcony doors. Great pool and spa area, golf course and grounds around the hotel are beautiful

10

Jake

30 juil. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

So far the best Macdonald Hotel I've stayed at. Nice facilities, friendly staff and the golf course makes a great running loop.

8

Nigel

29 mai 2023

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

All in all the stay was good and pleasant, one thing I missed at a place like this was a jacuzzi and one other thing was at the spa, My wife haded to have a refund for her nails

6

Robert

5 juin 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Stayed one night to attend a funeral locally. The room was comfortable enough and breakfast was buffet style but fine. EV drivers should note that the charging provider has been rebranded as Roam and not EVC Plus on the signs. Download their app before you arrive as it’s 3G signal strength in the car park. Plenty of chargers though and more being installed which was great to see.

10

Julian

23 avr. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Lovely, large comfortable room. Good gym, decent equipment. Very nice breakfast. A little shocked at price of large glass of wine £18!!!!

6

Emma

23 juin 2023

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Hotel needs refurbishing, feels a little outdated. Went to book spa and was told no as they were closing as they sent the therapist home early.

8

Colin

15 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Nice overnight stay...comfortable room with comfy large bed. Bar shut at 9pm which was disapointing, Breakfast wasnt the best, but staff were friendly and polite.

10

paige

12 avr. 2025

·

A séjourné 3 nuits

Lovely property, great facilities, staff were lovely. Would highly recommend

8

Scott

24 mars 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Although a little tired and in need of a freshen up, and although there was a slight drain smell from our shower (not enough to complain about) the room was spacious, clean and well furnished. It had a beautiful view over the golf course. The main downside was the mattress which was a little hard and probably a bit worn out. Otherwise it was lovely and the staff were great overall. The gym and pool were also lovely, and complimentary to hotel guests.

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Propreté

Les commentaires sur la propreté sont mitigés : plusieurs clients signalent de la moisissure, du calcaire et des salles de bains ou des chambres mal nettoyées, tandis que d'autres ont trouvé leur logement propre ou impeccable. Des signes d'usure liés à l'entretien sont également mentionnés.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

2

Diane

19 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Room next to noisy boiler room. Dirty room. Dust under bedside tables, 3 pillows for 2 people, one in a dirty cover. Dirty glasses, kettle and water jug. Fridge not working.

6

PATRICIA

31 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The reason I haven’t given higher rating is the condition and cleanliness of the bathroom. The shower sealant was discoloured with mould in parts and the extractor fan in the ceiling had dust hanging out of it

2

Simon

22 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Would not recommend this hotel, poor staff, poor cleanliness smells of damp

8

philip

19 sept. 2025

·

A séjourné 3 nuits

Property was clean and tidy , breakfast was good and served quickly, and it was in a convenient area for sightseeing

4

Ian

24 août 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

room wasn’t properly cleaned; cups not washed; shower doesn’t drain properly; mould in shower, nice bar and restaurant, good location, nice outlook over the golf course; rose wine with meal not cold

4

Richard

17 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Hotel looked nice from the outside, with golf course on room terrace. I booked the deluxe room, expecting a high standard, however, it was a large room, but the bed was very uncomfortable, there was no A/C, the TV was very old and none of limited satellite channels did not work, the bathroom again again a good size, had mould on the ceiling, silicone sealant was just thrown on around the toilet, no extract system and looked very dated and worn. I ate in the restaurant, food was really nice, £40 for 2 courses and 2 diet cokes. Not the best place to stay.

8

Kit-Yee

26 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Staff at the hotel were great very friendly and the breakfast was good. Room itself very spacious however the bathroom was dirty hair in the bathtub which is off putting

10

Alfred

28 oct. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The room was spotless amd staff were courteous!!!

4

Ryan

9 oct. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Overall the stay was pleasant, mainly for the company we had for a wedding in the area. However, the room hadn't been cleaned, had urine over the toilet and bathroom floor. The night staff attempted to clean it but the bathroom still smelt so ended up cleaning it ourselves. The room itself could of done with a clean, dust and pubic hair was all over. Also, wouldn't advise the breakfast, £24 for a childs portion of average food, the continental section was limited, and didn't seem value for money.

4

David

16 nov. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

For a 4 star hotel we expected a higher standard. When entering the room it was lovely however the bathroom really let us down. There was mold, thick limescale coming out of the taps. It didn't look clean. The restaurant is extremely overpriced considering the amount of money being spent for the room and the spa, £8 for garlic butter i think is disgusting oh also a service change just to top it all off. The Spa is really where we enjoyed ourselves. The staff are extremely lovely and helpful. We only had half a day but it was well worth it.

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Chambres

Les chambres sont généralement spacieuses, avec parfois vue sur le parcours de golf et accès à un patio ou un balcon, mais le décor et les équipements semblent datés par endroits. Le confort et les commodités varient : matelas très mous ou fermes, téléviseurs limités ou défectueux, absence de climatisation ou de ventilateurs, et bruit occasionnel provenant des portes ou des golfeurs matinaux.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

10

Natalie

13 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Only stayed for one night but lovely hotel, big spacious room with opening balcony doors. Great pool and spa area, golf course and grounds around the hotel are beautiful

6

Nick

29 juin 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Terrible television setup in most of the rooms with very limited channel options and in some rooms no EPG option either. For the money I would expect and demand more and better. Also two single beds pushed together isn’t really a king size bed. No very honest.

6

Emma

1 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

We stayed for 2 nights in August 2024 because we had a wedding nearby. The property has a stunning golf course, bed was very comfy and the staff were very friendly and attentive. However, the hotel was too loud for us - the doors of all the rooms slammed shut and it was constant banging from about 6.30am as people started on the golf course. Unfortunately the breakfast was also very poor, and far too expensive for the quality.

4

Richard

17 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Hotel looked nice from the outside, with golf course on room terrace. I booked the deluxe room, expecting a high standard, however, it was a large room, but the bed was very uncomfortable, there was no A/C, the TV was very old and none of limited satellite channels did not work, the bathroom again again a good size, had mould on the ceiling, silicone sealant was just thrown on around the toilet, no extract system and looked very dated and worn. I ate in the restaurant, food was really nice, £40 for 2 courses and 2 diet cokes. Not the best place to stay.

10

Daniel

8 août 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Really good size room, was perfect on the ground floor having patio doors open onto a small bistro set. Really comfortable stay. Attentive staff. Didn't eat here as i was working in the area ling hrs but Cant ask for me.

8

Judith

31 juil. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Everything in the main room was excellent. No fan or air conditioning, hence a bit stuffy at night.

8

Robert

11 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Warm welcome at check in and very efficient. Large comfortable room everything worked . Great staff. . Reasonable food promptly served . Rather noisy at night - mostly single men on golfing weekend so banging doors and boisterous noise after being in the bar!

10

David

10 juin 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The hotel is very good but make sure you get a room close to the lobby as the TV does not work when you are at the end of the building

10

Yvette

18 août 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Lovely hotel overlooking golf course. Unfortunately our room was right by the first hole and the golfers were out bright and early on the sunday morning and not at all respectful that people were in in bed... we paid £172 for the one night and didnt even get a lazy sunday morning lie in 🤔

8

Scott

24 mars 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Although a little tired and in need of a freshen up, and although there was a slight drain smell from our shower (not enough to complain about) the room was spacious, clean and well furnished. It had a beautiful view over the golf course. The main downside was the mattress which was a little hard and probably a bit worn out. Otherwise it was lovely and the staff were great overall. The gym and pool were also lovely, and complimentary to hotel guests.

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Service

Le personnel est largement salué pour son amabilité, son attention et sa volonté d'en faire plus, avec plusieurs exemples d'aide proactive. Des problèmes occasionnels incluent un service de petit-déjeuner lent ou sous-effectif, un enregistrement non surveillé ou sujet aux erreurs, et des erreurs d'attribution de chambres.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

10

Alice

17 sept. 2025

·

A séjourné 4 nuits

Lovely hotel with lovely service.

4

David

12 déc. 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Hill Valley never fails to disappoint!! Hotels.com refused to refund my money after I entered an incorrect date by error. This is totally IMMORAL. The hotel was virtually empty. My room was COLD on arrival. The TV did not work (wrong remote control left with TV!). No instructions on how to use the Nespresso machine. Chairs in bar restaurant were grubby. My meal was incorrectly described on the menu; some of the food was hot. Some was cold. And served on a cold plate! No condiments on the table. Sound system playing piped music was totally distorted. Needs replacing. Little things mean a lot in a 4* hotel. Hill Valley needs a major shake up and spruce up. It's a shame they have the virtual monopoly on hotel accommodation in the Whitchurch area. Premier Inn would be a better choice.

10

Peter

15 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

An absolutely wonderful stay, nothing was too much trouble for all the staff. The location is stunning, easy to locate, parking a few metres from reception, ideal for couples or larger parties of golfers.

8

Fraser

9 août 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Turns out that it’s REALLY hard to persuade a taxi to come out to this location unless pre-booked. Staff were super helpful and did eventually get me fixed up, but perhaps on check in you could check if a taxi might be required and advise guests to pre book.

10

Amanda

2 avr. 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Staff were very helpful. Receptionist let us swap rooms when allocated room was right next to lift & I was worried I wouldn’t sleep because of noise. One of the housekeeping staff ran my partner to the wedding venue we had been at the day before when he was unable to get a taxi

4

Emma

4 févr. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

We enjoyed our stay in the McDonald hill valley hotel. Bathroom needed redecorating. On arrival, we checked in, as we entered our room we actually walked in on someone in bed who was not at all happy understandably. Neither were we. Somehow we’d been allocated a room that had already been allocated to someone else. Very embarrassing situation. Staff were apologetic and we were offered an upgraded room. Other than that no other problems. The bed was very comfortable.

8

Robert

11 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Warm welcome at check in and very efficient. Large comfortable room everything worked . Great staff. . Reasonable food promptly served . Rather noisy at night - mostly single men on golfing weekend so banging doors and boisterous noise after being in the bar!

10

Alex

26 sept. 2025

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Great place and staff 👍

10

Jonathan

24 nov. 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The staff at this hotel were exceptional. After trying to get a taxi without success and having an injured leg, the front desk staff arranged for one of the other members of the team to drive us to the train station. They went above and beyond and it was really appreciated.

8

Phillip

28 août 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

I booked 10 rooms for family and friends the night before our daughter’s wedding. We arrived and checked in and was given our room key, unfortunately when we arrived at our room it was still occupied. Fortunately nobody was in the room so we returned back to reception and was assigned another room. Had a lovely stay and would not hesitate on staying again. Staff and food was great.

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Emplacement

Situé dans un cadre pittoresque et calme, à côté du parcours de golf, avec un parking facile sur place. L'endroit est un peu isolé, les taxis étant difficiles à trouver sans réservation préalable et une marche de 20 minutes jusqu'à Whitchurch.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

8

Rachel

8 août 2023

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Staff were wonderful and welcoming. Willing to fix any problems that arose such as the key card stopping working the second day. Nice rooms, lovely views and nice and quiet location.

10

Peter

15 mai 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

An absolutely wonderful stay, nothing was too much trouble for all the staff. The location is stunning, easy to locate, parking a few metres from reception, ideal for couples or larger parties of golfers.

8

Marie

9 nov. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The hotel grounds are beautiful.

8

Fraser

9 août 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Turns out that it’s REALLY hard to persuade a taxi to come out to this location unless pre-booked. Staff were super helpful and did eventually get me fixed up, but perhaps on check in you could check if a taxi might be required and advise guests to pre book.

10

Steve

31 mars 2023

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

The room was big, modern and spacious. Facilities we’re good Whitchurch is a 20 minute brisk walk. If you need a taxi to come back in the evening, pre-book or you might also striggle to reach any of the nine taxi companies in the area. Breakfast was great as were the pool and gym. I can also recommend the Black Bear in town for its foods and craft ales.

8

philip

19 sept. 2025

·

A séjourné 3 nuits

Property was clean and tidy , breakfast was good and served quickly, and it was in a convenient area for sightseeing

6

Robert

5 juin 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Stayed one night to attend a funeral locally. The room was comfortable enough and breakfast was buffet style but fine. EV drivers should note that the charging provider has been rebranded as Roam and not EVC Plus on the signs. Download their app before you arrive as it’s 3G signal strength in the car park. Plenty of chargers though and more being installed which was great to see.

10

Neil

13 mai 2023

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Good stay, some maintenance issues and needs some upgrading, staff and location excellent

8

Joanne

25 juin 2023

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Staff were great. The hotel was let down by a group of men shouting obscenities around a table in the bar. They had no consideration for other guests. They clearly had very limited vocabulary. This went on for an hour, so if you have children, I would rethink the stay. Other than that it was a very nice hotel. Lovely location

6

ruth

15 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Needs updating, grounds were beautiful but difficult to get to as there are no cabs available from train station

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Repas

La qualité et le rapport qualité/prix de la restauration sont incohérents : beaucoup trouvent le petit-déjeuner limité ou trop cher et les boissons coûteuses, tandis que certains repas sont agréables. Le service peut être lent ou désorganisé aux heures de pointe.

Avis de voyageur à ce sujet

4

David

12 déc. 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Hill Valley never fails to disappoint!! Hotels.com refused to refund my money after I entered an incorrect date by error. This is totally IMMORAL. The hotel was virtually empty. My room was COLD on arrival. The TV did not work (wrong remote control left with TV!). No instructions on how to use the Nespresso machine. Chairs in bar restaurant were grubby. My meal was incorrectly described on the menu; some of the food was hot. Some was cold. And served on a cold plate! No condiments on the table. Sound system playing piped music was totally distorted. Needs replacing. Little things mean a lot in a 4* hotel. Hill Valley needs a major shake up and spruce up. It's a shame they have the virtual monopoly on hotel accommodation in the Whitchurch area. Premier Inn would be a better choice.

10

Paul

29 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Lovely staff, Breakfast a bit overwhelmed on the Staurday morning, paid £18.00 for a continental Breakfast and there was hardly anything left on the tables, no bread, hardly any cold cuts. Could only have some Granola!!!. For £16.00 at the lounge bar a cafetier with coffee and two breakfast baps with egg sausages and bacon. More value for money than £24.00 for a cooked breakfast or £18.00 for a continental. All this was offset by the great service and lovely staff.

10

Julian

23 avr. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Lovely, large comfortable room. Good gym, decent equipment. Very nice breakfast. A little shocked at price of large glass of wine £18!!!!

8

Ray

1 août 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Food and service is a let down. Couldnt eat in the conservatory because they said they havnt cleared the empty tables even though more staff than customers. Food came out different to menu. A glass of wine is more expensive than a main course.

6

Emma

1 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

We stayed for 2 nights in August 2024 because we had a wedding nearby. The property has a stunning golf course, bed was very comfy and the staff were very friendly and attentive. However, the hotel was too loud for us - the doors of all the rooms slammed shut and it was constant banging from about 6.30am as people started on the golf course. Unfortunately the breakfast was also very poor, and far too expensive for the quality.

8

Ciara

11 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Overall an okay stay. Car park a tad confusing but depends on which way you enter the hotel grounds. Be careful of old golfers driving at you in their golf buggies in the car park! I was hoping to go for a relaxing swim but it felt more like a busy leisure centre and people doing serious training - not relaxing at all. My room was a deluxe room, however no water or added extras. Bathroom was extremely dated and shower was covered in limescale and mold on the walls. Not to mention some of the complimentary Elemis bottles were empty - I had a “shampoo” one attached to the wall by the sink instead of hand wash? Heater was rubbish. I went for dinner in the restaurant and was told to go around 8:15 as there were two big parties in. I was completely neglected and forgotten about by the staff despite them walking past multiple times. After 20 minutes had gone I had to shout over for them to take my order. Felt sorry for the teenage staff running the place. The food itself was very good. I was woken up 12:45am by guests coming back to their rooms and shouting in the hallway. I was again woken up at 7am by people slamming their doors when leaving - actually woke me up in shock it was that loud. Breakfast times were earlier than expected so acidentally missed it despite paying for it. I think a finish time of 10/10:30 is more acceptable. All in all, was ok but plenty of room for improvement. Was very overwhelming with the amount of golfers and members using the leisure facilities.

8

James

22 août 2024

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

Great for a business trip, good quailty food and nice rooms. Shame the dinner serivce was extremely slow. Highlight being countryside location

6

Mark

3 sept. 2024

·

A séjourné 2 nuits

Comfortable rooms, though some areas a little dated now. Quality toiletries. Breakfast if on a room only basis is overpriced at £24.00. We popped down to Sainsbury’s cafe instead - 3 minute drive away.

6

Andrew Charles

8 juin 2025

·

A séjourné 4 nuits

A little run down. Breakfast buffet poor and definitely not worth the money.

4

David

16 nov. 2025

·

A séjourné 1 nuit

For a 4 star hotel we expected a higher standard. When entering the room it was lovely however the bathroom really let us down. There was mold, thick limescale coming out of the taps. It didn't look clean. The restaurant is extremely overpriced considering the amount of money being spent for the room and the spa, £8 for garlic butter i think is disgusting oh also a service change just to top it all off. The Spa is really where we enjoyed ourselves. The staff are extremely lovely and helpful. We only had half a day but it was well worth it.

Ces informations vous ont-elles été utiles ?

Résumé généré par l'IA basé sur les avis récents des voyageurs

Mois	Prix moyen
janvier	89 $US
février	90 $US
mars	89 $US
avril	105 $US
mai	127 $US
juin	121 $US
juillet	117 $US
août	135 $US
septembre	126 $US
octobre	104 $US
novembre	92 $US
décembre	90 $US

di	lu	ma	me	je	ve	sa
1 $85	2 $95	3 $102	4 $103	5 $87	6 $112	7 $141
8 $92	9 $95	10 $104	11 $104	12 $89	13 $114	14 $141
15 $87	16 $96	17 $104	18 $106	19 $81	20 $101	21 $125
22 $88	23 $84	24 $92	25 $101	26 $80	27 $106	28 $125
29 $87	30 $84

Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Spa & Golf Resort

Prix pour Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Spa & Golf Resort

Prix moyens mensuels

À propos de cet établissement

Emplacement

Options de chambre

Chambre Standard, 1 lit double (Standard Double)

Chambre Deluxe, 1 très grand lit (Super Deluxe King)

Chambre, 1 lit double, accessible aux personnes à mobilité réduite (Standard Accessible Double)

Chambre Standard, 1 très grand lit (Standard Golf View)

Chambre Supérieure, 1 très grand lit (Deluxe King)

Chambre Standard, 1 très grand lit (Standard King)

Chambre Standard, 2 lits une place (Standard Twin)

Avis des voyageurs sur Macdonald Hill Valley Hotel, Spa & Golf Resort

Qui séjourne ici ?

Ce qu'en disent des voyageurs

Politiques de l’établissement

Instructions d’arrivée

Bon à savoir

Suppléments facultatifs

Prix pour les dates à venir

di	lu	ma	me	je	ve	sa
				1	2	3
4	5	6	7	8	9	10
11	12	13	14	15	16	17
18	19	20 $140	21 $133	22 $109	23 $108	24 $146
25 $87	26 $93	27 $102	28 $102	29 $87	30 $112	31 $138