The Colonial Inn & Creamery
$268
/ night
Avg. for September
Prices for The Colonial Inn & Creamery
Select dates to see prices and availability
$268
/ night
Avg. for September
Monthly average prices
Nightly prices at The Colonial Inn & Creamery average $65 in December, the cheapest month, and $288 in October, the most expensive, based on the last 12 months.
| Month | Average price |
|---|---|
| January | $118 |
| February | $113 |
| March | $134 |
| April | $113 |
| May | $240 |
| June | $219 |
| July | $213 |
| August | $208 |
| September | $268 |
| October | $288 |
| November | $98 |
| December | $65 |
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
Sep · $268
S
O
N
D
Most expensive: October (~$288)
Cheapest: December (~$65)
About this property
Make use of convenient amenities, which include complimentary wireless internet access and a picnic area.
Amenities
Make use of convenient amenities, which include complimentary wireless internet access and a picnic area.
Business amenities
Free self parking is available onsite.
Rooms
Make yourself at home in one of the 14 air-conditioned rooms featuring microwaves and flat-screen televisions. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms have showers and complimentary toiletries. Conveniences include irons/ironing boards, and housekeeping is provided daily.
Location
When you stay at Colonial Inn & Creamery in Watkins Glen, you'll be in a state park, just steps from Watkins Glen State Park and 8 minutes by foot from Seneca Lake. This motel is 4.5 mi (7.2 km) from Watkins Glen International and 0.2 mi (0.4 km) from The Tasting Room.
What's nearby
Watkins Glen State Park(0.1 miles)
The Tasting Room(0.2 miles)
Seneca Lake(0.4 miles)
Seneca Harbor(0.5 miles)
International Motor Racing Research Center(0.7 miles)
Watkins Glen Beach(0.9 miles)
Schuyler Hospital(2.2 miles)
Castel Grisch Winery(2.3 miles)
Montour Falls Historic District(2.9 miles)
She-Qa-Ga Falls(3 miles)
Montour Falls Memorial Library(3 miles)
Hector Falls(3.5 miles)
Eagle Cliff Falls(3.8 miles)
Lakewood Vineyards(4 miles)
Barnstormer Winery(4.5 miles)
Elmira, NY (ELM-Elmira - Corning Regional)(21.4 miles)
Ithaca, NY (ITH-Tompkins Regional)(30.3 miles)
Parking
Non-Smoking Rooms
Housekeeping
Golf Course (nearby)
Fishing
Hiking
Location
701 North Franklin Sreet., New York, United States of America
Watkins Glen State Park (0.1 miles)
The Tasting Room (0.2 miles)
Seneca Lake (0.4 miles)
Seneca Harbor (0.5 miles)
International Motor Racing Research Center (0.7 miles)
Watkins Glen Beach (0.9 miles)
Room options
4
1 Queen Bed, Inn Style
Room details
1 Queen Bed
Sleeps 2
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
4
1 Full Bed, Inn Style
Room details
1 Full Bed
Sleeps 2
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
1
Standard Double Room
Room details
2 Queen Beds
Sleeps 4
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
4
2 Bedroom Suite, Inn Style
Room details
1 Queen Bed
and 1 Full Bed
Sleeps 4
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
4
1 King Bed, Motel Style
Room details
1 King Bed
Sleeps 2
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
4
2 Full Beds, Motel Style
Room details
2 Full Beds
Sleeps 4
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
1
Standard Single Room, 1 Bedroom
Room details
1 Full Bed
Sleeps 2
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Microwave
Guest reviews of The Colonial Inn & Creamery
7.4
Good
Based on 659 verified reviews
Who stays here?
Business
5%
Couple
49%
Family
21%
Group
12%
Solo
10%
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
At The Colonial Inn & Creamery, travellers consistently praise the walkable, central location near Watkins Glen State Park, while feedback is divided on the dated rooms, maintenance issues, and the contactless model that some find convenient and others frustrating.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
At The Colonial Inn & Creamery, travellers consistently praise the walkable, central location near Watkins Glen State Park, while feedback is divided on the dated rooms, maintenance issues, and the contactless model that some find convenient and others frustrating.
Noise and light from the street affect some front-facing rooms. Guests frequently enjoy the on-site creamery and occasional pizza options. Overall, it serves as a straightforward base with uneven comfort and support.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
On-site creamery and occasional wood-fired pizza are a popular perk mentioned across reviews. Parking is generally easy, though a few guests found spaces limited or tight.
Related guest reviews
8
John
Sep 25, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Super friendly staff. Nice clean room. Easy parking. We were able to leave the car there and walk to the Park despite checking out. ALSO - You can’t beat the free ice cream ❗️
Super friendly staff. Nice clean room. Easy parking. We were able to leave the car there and walk to the Park despite checking out. ALSO - You can’t beat the free ice cream ❗️
2
Gladys
Oct 4, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Parking very limited with tight spaces. Window view, horrible. No TV connection.
Parking very limited with tight spaces. Window view, horrible. No TV connection.
10
William
May 27, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Manager was outstanding and accommodating, personalized service. Great food recommendations- the ice cream at The creamery was fantastic, made in house. Outstanding experience, will definitely call again!! Thank you!!
Manager was outstanding and accommodating, personalized service. Great food recommendations- the ice cream at The creamery was fantastic, made in house. Outstanding experience, will definitely call again!! Thank you!!
8
Rhonda
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The owners are fantastic! The ice cream was delicious! You can’t beat the location! The facilities were old fashioned, but well cared for. And I feel they compensated for that with a very reasonable price.
The owners are fantastic! The ice cream was delicious! You can’t beat the location! The facilities were old fashioned, but well cared for. And I feel they compensated for that with a very reasonable price.
8
Allison
Jul 13, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Colonial Inn and Creamery is in a nice central location. The room was clean and equipped with small refrigerator, microwave and toiletries. Check-in was contactless with a door code. Ice cream at the creamery was excellent.
Colonial Inn and Creamery is in a nice central location. The room was clean and equipped with small refrigerator, microwave and toiletries. Check-in was contactless with a door code. Ice cream at the creamery was excellent.
10
elissa
Jul 9, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
It was very quiet and they made the process for check in and check out seemless. The ice cream onsite was great. Parking was easy and the instructions they provided were very clear about the whole check in process.
It was very quiet and they made the process for check in and check out seemless. The ice cream onsite was great. Parking was easy and the instructions they provided were very clear about the whole check in process.
10
Deborah
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
200 yr old hotel with lots of character. Ice cream is great 👍
200 yr old hotel with lots of character. Ice cream is great 👍
10
Dan
Sep 29, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
They have an home made ice cream shop on site, delicious treat! Very convenient for walking in town and especially Watkins Glen State park. Older building and rooms, very well maintained and clean.
They have an home made ice cream shop on site, delicious treat! Very convenient for walking in town and especially Watkins Glen State park. Older building and rooms, very well maintained and clean.
10
Susan
May 30, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great staff. Very convienent! Good ice cream on site. Pizza food shack was okay. Also, on site.
Great staff. Very convienent! Good ice cream on site. Pizza food shack was okay. Also, on site.
10
Sher
Jul 7, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The original building was constructed in 1837 so this is an interesting historic building. We selected a traditional inn-style room versus a typical hotel room and were not disappointed. The room was very clean and included a tv,refrigerator, microwave, and air conditioning…all in good working condition. A coffee-bar is located in the guest lobby. A creamery (which offers vegan ice cream for those who should avoid dairy) and out-door pizza and grill are on site. The inn is located 5 minutes walking distance from the main entrance to Watkins Glen State Park. The staff is so very friendly and accommodating, From owner, management, house keeping, and food handlers everyone is your friend. What a nostalgic place to stay in Watkins Glen!
The original building was constructed in 1837 so this is an interesting historic building. We selected a traditional inn-style room versus a typical hotel room and were not disappointed. The room was very clean and included a tv,refrigerator, microwave, and air conditioning…all in good working condition. A coffee-bar is located in the guest lobby. A creamery (which offers vegan ice cream for those who should avoid dairy) and out-door pizza and grill are on site. The inn is located 5 minutes walking distance from the main entrance to Watkins Glen State Park. The staff is so very friendly and accommodating, From owner, management, house keeping, and food handlers everyone is your friend. What a nostalgic place to stay in Watkins Glen!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Cleanliness is inconsistent: some rooms were reported clean, but many noted musty odors, stained or worn carpets, and missed cleaning between stays. Housekeeping during multi-night visits was often absent.
Related guest reviews
10
John
Nov 7, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Simple hotel in a good location. Room was clean and comfy. They sent us a door code so we didn't have to worry about the check in time.
Simple hotel in a good location. Room was clean and comfy. They sent us a door code so we didn't have to worry about the check in time.
2
Jeffrey Allen
Nov 12, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Good location. The room was moldy and musty with lots of cobwebs. Extremely tiny shower. Furnishings were outdated. Not what we expected. We left after one night due to mold and mildew.
Good location. The room was moldy and musty with lots of cobwebs. Extremely tiny shower. Furnishings were outdated. Not what we expected. We left after one night due to mold and mildew.
4
Georgia
Apr 29, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The room I stayed in was clearly not cleaned well, visible dust under the bed and someone’s old socks behind the rolling clothing rack. The bed comforter had dark stains on it and was clearly not clean. The bed was set on two small frames which left a gap in the middle that was unsupported, which would start to collapse when laying in the middle.
The room I stayed in was clearly not cleaned well, visible dust under the bed and someone’s old socks behind the rolling clothing rack. The bed comforter had dark stains on it and was clearly not clean. The bed was set on two small frames which left a gap in the middle that was unsupported, which would start to collapse when laying in the middle.
6
Stamatia
Aug 8, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
The Inn is really adorable but definitely needs some updating. The room had beautiful wallpaper, cable tv, and air conditioning but the carpets were torn in spots and they felt dirty. The bathroom floor was also so sticky, my feet were dirty after walking around barefoot. There is also no outlet in the bathroom and there’s no full length mirrors. It is self check in and there wasn’t any people around, it didn’t feel very welcoming. Our mini fridge in our room froze everything we put in overnight. Having the ice cream parlor and room with games and books was a great touch, very old town charm. Location is prime. Walking distance to Watkins Glen State Park, Lake Seneca pier, and lots of restaurants and shops right on the same road. Free and easy parking.
The Inn is really adorable but definitely needs some updating. The room had beautiful wallpaper, cable tv, and air conditioning but the carpets were torn in spots and they felt dirty. The bathroom floor was also so sticky, my feet were dirty after walking around barefoot. There is also no outlet in the bathroom and there’s no full length mirrors. It is self check in and there wasn’t any people around, it didn’t feel very welcoming. Our mini fridge in our room froze everything we put in overnight. Having the ice cream parlor and room with games and books was a great touch, very old town charm. Location is prime. Walking distance to Watkins Glen State Park, Lake Seneca pier, and lots of restaurants and shops right on the same road. Free and easy parking.
2
Jim
Oct 3, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Room in much needed repair. Sheetrock cracked and broken tiles in bathroom. Floor would make your feet dirty. Shower handle was broken. My room was switched and the air conditioning was broken in that room. Both rooms smelled very musty. I ended up after one night on what was a wedding anniversary trip with my wife. Watkins glen is a nice town and beautiful place. I would recommend avoiding staying here
Room in much needed repair. Sheetrock cracked and broken tiles in bathroom. Floor would make your feet dirty. Shower handle was broken. My room was switched and the air conditioning was broken in that room. Both rooms smelled very musty. I ended up after one night on what was a wedding anniversary trip with my wife. Watkins glen is a nice town and beautiful place. I would recommend avoiding staying here
2
Jose
Sep 2, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
What they call contactless checkin means there is no staff, no front desk, no way to contact them. They provided several phone numbers that nobody would answer and was not set up to accept messages. We left a day early because we could not sleep on the broken bed again, rugs were filthy and constant black flys flying around, grounds were not kept up, very cramped room, just could not look past so many things not to normal standards…
What they call contactless checkin means there is no staff, no front desk, no way to contact them. They provided several phone numbers that nobody would answer and was not set up to accept messages. We left a day early because we could not sleep on the broken bed again, rugs were filthy and constant black flys flying around, grounds were not kept up, very cramped room, just could not look past so many things not to normal standards…
6
Tammi
Aug 4, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Room number 1, the room was clean but had a moldy, musty smell and since the floor was soft near the door, id assume there was some water damage at some point and that is why it smelled like that. Also a queen bed on top of a full size frame and it causes a dip in the middle of the bed. Other than that everything was fine.
Room number 1, the room was clean but had a moldy, musty smell and since the floor was soft near the door, id assume there was some water damage at some point and that is why it smelled like that. Also a queen bed on top of a full size frame and it causes a dip in the middle of the bed. Other than that everything was fine.
4
tina
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Bed was uncomfortable; floor was filthy; no fan in bathroom; shower stall too smal; no soap dish; only one mirror
Bed was uncomfortable; floor was filthy; no fan in bathroom; shower stall too smal; no soap dish; only one mirror
6
Nelly
Aug 27, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Room was not clean at time of check in, also garbage truck picked up at 3:00 AM making lots of noise and truck lights right next to the room, not a good experience.
Room was not clean at time of check in, also garbage truck picked up at 3:00 AM making lots of noise and truck lights right next to the room, not a good experience.
8
Adele
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff was excellent, Very attentive and helpful. The Inn was very clean and quaint. Would definitely stay there again! Thank you a positive experience for our stay!!!
Staff was excellent, Very attentive and helpful. The Inn was very clean and quaint. Would definitely stay there again! Thank you a positive experience for our stay!!!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Rooms are basic and dated, with comfort varying from very soft beds to small, cramped showers and fluctuating water temperatures; several guests reported TVs or remotes not working and heating/cooling quirks. Street-facing rooms can be noisy with light bleeding through thin curtains.
Related guest reviews
8
Peggy
Aug 2, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We booked a room in the Inn portion of this property. Our room faced the main road, which made it very noisy at night. There is a lot of truck traffic. The Inn also keeps a light on over the front door and it shined brightly through the thin curtains. The room was a decent size, but it lacks reading lights by the bed and there is no place to sit except for on the bed. Our TV did not work, but that was due to the cable company upgrading they system and not finishing all the rooms. The staff was extremely nice and having a free ice cream cone with our stay was a special extra! The Inn and our room were extremely clean and the bed was extra comfortable.
We booked a room in the Inn portion of this property. Our room faced the main road, which made it very noisy at night. There is a lot of truck traffic. The Inn also keeps a light on over the front door and it shined brightly through the thin curtains. The room was a decent size, but it lacks reading lights by the bed and there is no place to sit except for on the bed. Our TV did not work, but that was due to the cable company upgrading they system and not finishing all the rooms. The staff was extremely nice and having a free ice cream cone with our stay was a special extra! The Inn and our room were extremely clean and the bed was extra comfortable.
8
Kristin
Aug 20, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Charming with quirks. If anyone in the inn uses a toilet while you are in the shower, your water will turn scalding hot. This is a great location.
Charming with quirks. If anyone in the inn uses a toilet while you are in the shower, your water will turn scalding hot. This is a great location.
4
George
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We didn’t expect a fantastic hotel for the price, but we were disappointed by a doorknob coming off, a broken cabinet drawer, and their free wifi would not come up for my wife and I. The AC filter was also filthy and we had to clean it before using the AC. The location is right in the middle of town, and check in and check out is super easy, so that was the hotel’s saving grace.
We didn’t expect a fantastic hotel for the price, but we were disappointed by a doorknob coming off, a broken cabinet drawer, and their free wifi would not come up for my wife and I. The AC filter was also filthy and we had to clean it before using the AC. The location is right in the middle of town, and check in and check out is super easy, so that was the hotel’s saving grace.
6
Praveen
Jul 26, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We didn’t like that the house keeping did not come to clean the room and the bed was not at all comfortable (the mattress needs to be replaced). The bathroom was very conjusted.
We didn’t like that the house keeping did not come to clean the room and the bed was not at all comfortable (the mattress needs to be replaced). The bathroom was very conjusted.
6
Bob
Mar 11, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The rooms are very bare bones, which is fine at this price point. The office was very good about sending login information and the check Inwas easy. The room was really hot and turning down the heat didn’t matter. We ended up leaving the windows open in Mid March. The hotel is on the main road and the traffic was really loud. I didn’t think there would be so much traffic but there was was. Finally, when one of the other room flushed their toilet, ours would gurgle really loudly.
The rooms are very bare bones, which is fine at this price point. The office was very good about sending login information and the check Inwas easy. The room was really hot and turning down the heat didn’t matter. We ended up leaving the windows open in Mid March. The hotel is on the main road and the traffic was really loud. I didn’t think there would be so much traffic but there was was. Finally, when one of the other room flushed their toilet, ours would gurgle really loudly.
6
Lynda
Aug 24, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The location is great. TV did not work.
The location is great. TV did not work.
8
DARLENE
Aug 19, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Our room was in front of building so lots of traffic noise. There was also lots of light from street lights that came in through curtains. Could use some blinds. Very limited water pressure on shower.
Our room was in front of building so lots of traffic noise. There was also lots of light from street lights that came in through curtains. Could use some blinds. Very limited water pressure on shower.
4
Marion
Aug 19, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The only positive thing to say is the location. The bed was too soft.
The only positive thing to say is the location. The bed was too soft.
4
Stephen
May 6, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Bed and pillows were the worst. Both way too soft with no support. Cheap bedframe with no headboard so pillows kept slipping down the between the wall. Only one chair in the room. Shower very small and uncomfortable. Everything was clean and room was recently remodeled, they just need to focus more on comfort. We left a day early due to the bed.
Bed and pillows were the worst. Both way too soft with no support. Cheap bedframe with no headboard so pillows kept slipping down the between the wall. Only one chair in the room. Shower very small and uncomfortable. Everything was clean and room was recently remodeled, they just need to focus more on comfort. We left a day early due to the bed.
6
Michael
Dec 14, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Everything was virtual. Room was okay. Heat was difficult to adjust, room way too hot. Broken blind in bathroom. We had front room on street, lots of noise even with my earplugs. Curtains on windows were not adequate to keep light from porch and street out of room. Probably will not stay here again
Everything was virtual. Room was okay. Heat was difficult to adjust, room way too hot. Broken blind in bathroom. We had front room on street, lots of noise even with my earplugs. Curtains on windows were not adequate to keep light from porch and street out of room. Probably will not stay here again
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Service is mixed: some guests found staff friendly and the contactless check-in straightforward, while others struggled to reach anyone for help and experienced delayed or unresolved issues. Responsiveness varies significantly.
Related guest reviews
2
Margaret
Sep 21, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
In our experience the management/staff seem to believe that contactless check-in also means contactless stay. We had no way to communicate that we had multiple problems (toilet, tv, lights) with our room. I was not able to leave a message with the phone number that was provided, email and text didn’t work. Finally, spoke with someone who was rude and condescending. A bad experience overall. But the free ice cream (which was good) at the on-site creamery helped us feel a little bit better. LOL
In our experience the management/staff seem to believe that contactless check-in also means contactless stay. We had no way to communicate that we had multiple problems (toilet, tv, lights) with our room. I was not able to leave a message with the phone number that was provided, email and text didn’t work. Finally, spoke with someone who was rude and condescending. A bad experience overall. But the free ice cream (which was good) at the on-site creamery helped us feel a little bit better. LOL
4
Judy
Oct 29, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The location and the safety was the only thing good about this room. It was part of the main so I felt safe as a solo traveler. But actually checking into the hotel was difficult, had to do everything online and called two people before one of them called me back to let me in so very slow process. I waited in the lobby for quite some time. Then ended up back at my car waiting until someone called me back so I could go in and check in. I could not get the TV on the remote control seem to be dead so I turned it on with a button on the TV but I couldn’t do anything else. So I shut it back up.I called that same number a couple of times to say the room was freezing cold. No one ever called me back. I looked in every closet in every drawer and could not find any extra blankets and could not find any, so I had to sleep in layers of my clothes and my nose was frozen. I only slept a couple hours and could not get warm so I left and went out to my car and warmed up with the seat heaters. I would definitely not come again and I definitely would not recommend.
The location and the safety was the only thing good about this room. It was part of the main so I felt safe as a solo traveler. But actually checking into the hotel was difficult, had to do everything online and called two people before one of them called me back to let me in so very slow process. I waited in the lobby for quite some time. Then ended up back at my car waiting until someone called me back so I could go in and check in. I could not get the TV on the remote control seem to be dead so I turned it on with a button on the TV but I couldn’t do anything else. So I shut it back up.I called that same number a couple of times to say the room was freezing cold. No one ever called me back. I looked in every closet in every drawer and could not find any extra blankets and could not find any, so I had to sleep in layers of my clothes and my nose was frozen. I only slept a couple hours and could not get warm so I left and went out to my car and warmed up with the seat heaters. I would definitely not come again and I definitely would not recommend.
10
Cipriano
Jul 13, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The owner and the lady at reception were more than accommodating exceptionally nice
The owner and the lady at reception were more than accommodating exceptionally nice
4
George
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We didn’t expect a fantastic hotel for the price, but we were disappointed by a doorknob coming off, a broken cabinet drawer, and their free wifi would not come up for my wife and I. The AC filter was also filthy and we had to clean it before using the AC. The location is right in the middle of town, and check in and check out is super easy, so that was the hotel’s saving grace.
We didn’t expect a fantastic hotel for the price, but we were disappointed by a doorknob coming off, a broken cabinet drawer, and their free wifi would not come up for my wife and I. The AC filter was also filthy and we had to clean it before using the AC. The location is right in the middle of town, and check in and check out is super easy, so that was the hotel’s saving grace.
10
Asako
Aug 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We didn’t see any stuff when we arrived at around 7pm as it was contactless check-in. It was clear instruction we received in advance. The room was super clean and kind of a big room. After check-out, we stopped by ice cream store and got free ice cream as hotel guests (free single scoop ice cream for hotel guest)!! Also, location is amazing. We went to Watkins Glen Gorge walk from the hotel which was only a few minutes away. (Park parking is $10/vehicle). Only one thing I wanted to have in the room was a hair dryer. Other than that, it was perfect location and amazing hotel!
We didn’t see any stuff when we arrived at around 7pm as it was contactless check-in. It was clear instruction we received in advance. The room was super clean and kind of a big room. After check-out, we stopped by ice cream store and got free ice cream as hotel guests (free single scoop ice cream for hotel guest)!! Also, location is amazing. We went to Watkins Glen Gorge walk from the hotel which was only a few minutes away. (Park parking is $10/vehicle). Only one thing I wanted to have in the room was a hair dryer. Other than that, it was perfect location and amazing hotel!
6
Tammy
Jun 6, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
I wouldn't do it again. Loved the location and space in the rooms. However, the check-in process was not the best. Instructions said we would get a code on arrival, we did not. Thankfully Mario and Charlene were there to assist. The room we booked was not ready/available so they did provide an alternative and that was extremely helpful. My room's toilet did not flush correctly and I did report. It's so convenient to Watkins Glenn Park and downtown. Perhaps our stay experience was due the culmination of a very large event weekend? Not sure, but we are unlikely to try again.
I wouldn't do it again. Loved the location and space in the rooms. However, the check-in process was not the best. Instructions said we would get a code on arrival, we did not. Thankfully Mario and Charlene were there to assist. The room we booked was not ready/available so they did provide an alternative and that was extremely helpful. My room's toilet did not flush correctly and I did report. It's so convenient to Watkins Glenn Park and downtown. Perhaps our stay experience was due the culmination of a very large event weekend? Not sure, but we are unlikely to try again.
2
Abhijit Tanaji
Jun 7, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The check-in process was smooth and straightforward, which we appreciated. The property has a cozy feel, and we understand it's a family-run business, which often means limited on-site staffing. However, several aspects of our stay were disappointing. The room was not properly cleaned upon arrival, and there was no housekeeping service during our 3-day stay. We requested cleaning and trash removal after day two, but no one came. As the temperature dropped in the evenings, we discovered that the central heating had been turned off. Despite requesting a space heater, none was provided, which made the nights uncomfortable. Another major concern was the lack of support—there was no staff on-site, the provided phone numbers were unreachable, and there was no reception desk to assist with even basic needs. While we appreciate the charm and intention behind a family-run property, some basic services and a reliable way to reach someone for help would make a significant difference. We hope these issues can be addressed, as it has the potential to be a much more pleasant stay in the future.
The check-in process was smooth and straightforward, which we appreciated. The property has a cozy feel, and we understand it's a family-run business, which often means limited on-site staffing. However, several aspects of our stay were disappointing. The room was not properly cleaned upon arrival, and there was no housekeeping service during our 3-day stay. We requested cleaning and trash removal after day two, but no one came. As the temperature dropped in the evenings, we discovered that the central heating had been turned off. Despite requesting a space heater, none was provided, which made the nights uncomfortable. Another major concern was the lack of support—there was no staff on-site, the provided phone numbers were unreachable, and there was no reception desk to assist with even basic needs. While we appreciate the charm and intention behind a family-run property, some basic services and a reliable way to reach someone for help would make a significant difference. We hope these issues can be addressed, as it has the potential to be a much more pleasant stay in the future.
10
Clarence
Feb 3, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Really liked the contactless check in and the codes for each individual door, that was nice. Even though we didn’t follow it correctly the first time the staff were so incredibly patient and helpful!! Would definitely come back!
Really liked the contactless check in and the codes for each individual door, that was nice. Even though we didn’t follow it correctly the first time the staff were so incredibly patient and helpful!! Would definitely come back!
2
Angelo
Jun 1, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
No towels in our room. Check in procedures are bizarre. No one answers the phone.
No towels in our room. Check in procedures are bizarre. No one answers the phone.
8
Adele
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff was excellent, Very attentive and helpful. The Inn was very clean and quaint. Would definitely stay there again! Thank you a positive experience for our stay!!!
Staff was excellent, Very attentive and helpful. The Inn was very clean and quaint. Would definitely stay there again! Thank you a positive experience for our stay!!!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Excellent central location a short walk to Watkins Glen State Park, restaurants, shops, and the lake. Street-facing rooms may experience significant traffic noise and bright exterior lighting at night.
Related guest reviews
8
Peggy
Aug 2, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We booked a room in the Inn portion of this property. Our room faced the main road, which made it very noisy at night. There is a lot of truck traffic. The Inn also keeps a light on over the front door and it shined brightly through the thin curtains. The room was a decent size, but it lacks reading lights by the bed and there is no place to sit except for on the bed. Our TV did not work, but that was due to the cable company upgrading they system and not finishing all the rooms. The staff was extremely nice and having a free ice cream cone with our stay was a special extra! The Inn and our room were extremely clean and the bed was extra comfortable.
We booked a room in the Inn portion of this property. Our room faced the main road, which made it very noisy at night. There is a lot of truck traffic. The Inn also keeps a light on over the front door and it shined brightly through the thin curtains. The room was a decent size, but it lacks reading lights by the bed and there is no place to sit except for on the bed. Our TV did not work, but that was due to the cable company upgrading they system and not finishing all the rooms. The staff was extremely nice and having a free ice cream cone with our stay was a special extra! The Inn and our room were extremely clean and the bed was extra comfortable.
8
Antonio
Jul 1, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel was very convenient for our visit to Watkins Glen, only 5 minute walk with variety of restaurants nearby.
The hotel was very convenient for our visit to Watkins Glen, only 5 minute walk with variety of restaurants nearby.
10
Leonard
Apr 17, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Loved the rocking chairs out front and the location in the middle of town within easy walking distance of the entire town.
Loved the rocking chairs out front and the location in the middle of town within easy walking distance of the entire town.
10
Natalie
Aug 14, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great location, close to everything by foot.
Great location, close to everything by foot.
6
Jamey
Apr 18, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This property is in a great location - walkable to the state park and to the lake and town.
This property is in a great location - walkable to the state park and to the lake and town.
8
Lindsey
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great location. Will stay here again.
Great location. Will stay here again.
8
Jae
Sep 14, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Especially easy to access to Watkins Glen State Park and Seneca Lake.
Especially easy to access to Watkins Glen State Park and Seneca Lake.
8
Gregory
May 30, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
The room was very clean,nice bed and furniture and conveniently located in town so we walked to the state park and later in the evening to a local restraunt within a few minutes.and there is a public acess area to seneca lake within a 5min.drive.And a few briew words with the staff and she was very friendly.
The room was very clean,nice bed and furniture and conveniently located in town so we walked to the state park and later in the evening to a local restraunt within a few minutes.and there is a public acess area to seneca lake within a 5min.drive.And a few briew words with the staff and she was very friendly.
4
Eric
Oct 11, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
The noise from the Main Street was horrific. Even with blankets over windows and ac running to mitigate noise, there was barely sleep. Only after 3 am when truck traffic and locals were asleep did it quiet so the kids could sleep. My family didn’t stay the second night and found other accommodations. Due to paid in full ahead of Time, attempting a refund for 2nd night but it may be lost. It was worth finding other accommodations and spend more than to remain. The inn keeper made a special remark that it’s a 7 day warning to cancel the second night - how was I suppose to know 7 days ahead of time at a place I’ve never stayed… that it would be the worst night sleep at a lodging I’d ever had to cancel the second night. Very little empathy, especially for the kids. The inn was nice otherwise and enjoyed the building and history. But I’d not be returning. I do hope this posting is kept up for others to read, and I’m sure others had a better experience. But not for the other two folks I spoke to in the hallway the next morning. Wish it was better - was excited about the place.
The noise from the Main Street was horrific. Even with blankets over windows and ac running to mitigate noise, there was barely sleep. Only after 3 am when truck traffic and locals were asleep did it quiet so the kids could sleep. My family didn’t stay the second night and found other accommodations. Due to paid in full ahead of Time, attempting a refund for 2nd night but it may be lost. It was worth finding other accommodations and spend more than to remain. The inn keeper made a special remark that it’s a 7 day warning to cancel the second night - how was I suppose to know 7 days ahead of time at a place I’ve never stayed… that it would be the worst night sleep at a lodging I’d ever had to cancel the second night. Very little empathy, especially for the kids. The inn was nice otherwise and enjoyed the building and history. But I’d not be returning. I do hope this posting is kept up for others to read, and I’m sure others had a better experience. But not for the other two folks I spoke to in the hallway the next morning. Wish it was better - was excited about the place.
8
Chad
Aug 11, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great location. Walking distance to all of downtown Watkins Glen. Clean and comfortable Inn.
Great location. Walking distance to all of downtown Watkins Glen. Clean and comfortable Inn.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
The on-site creamery is frequently praised (often with a free scoop for guests) and the pizza is well-liked, though a few had negative experiences. Coffee and pastry offerings were limited or inconsistent in availability.
Related guest reviews
10
Ranjini
Aug 11, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff serving icecream on Aug 4 around 7:30 pm was rude. Deliberately kept ignoring us when I asked him till what time they were open. I asked him 3 times for him to respond. He was not busy but just kept ignoring like h dint hear us.
Staff serving icecream on Aug 4 around 7:30 pm was rude. Deliberately kept ignoring us when I asked him till what time they were open. I asked him 3 times for him to respond. He was not busy but just kept ignoring like h dint hear us.
6
Ellie
May 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
This is a cheap 2 star motel at most. Bed is comfortable and clean but that’s it. No staff here most of the time. Even the coffee machine didn’t work in the morning and no one here to help.
This is a cheap 2 star motel at most. Bed is comfortable and clean but that’s it. No staff here most of the time. Even the coffee machine didn’t work in the morning and no one here to help.
10
Charles
Jul 23, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Superb location. Quiet, homey and cool despite the hot weather. Two minute walk to Watkins Glen State Park. Great ice cream and pizza. Highly recommended.
Superb location. Quiet, homey and cool despite the hot weather. Two minute walk to Watkins Glen State Park. Great ice cream and pizza. Highly recommended.
8
Jessica
Jun 5, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Overall the place is cute. The bed was actually very comfortable. There was no regular coffee out when we went down to get some and the pastries were the same from the night before. The bathroom does not have a door which I was not a fan of but we managed. The bathroom also needs hand towels and washclothes. I would stay again but hope they will put out fresh regular coffee for the morning. You have to text the inn as the front desk is not regualry manned and they never answered with several requests for a slightly later checkout. Even a no would have been better than no answer. Oh well. Id still stay again because the location is ideal and the bed was clean and comfy.
Overall the place is cute. The bed was actually very comfortable. There was no regular coffee out when we went down to get some and the pastries were the same from the night before. The bathroom does not have a door which I was not a fan of but we managed. The bathroom also needs hand towels and washclothes. I would stay again but hope they will put out fresh regular coffee for the morning. You have to text the inn as the front desk is not regualry manned and they never answered with several requests for a slightly later checkout. Even a no would have been better than no answer. Oh well. Id still stay again because the location is ideal and the bed was clean and comfy.
8
Rhonda
Sep 18, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The owners are fantastic! The ice cream was delicious! You can’t beat the location! The facilities were old fashioned, but well cared for. And I feel they compensated for that with a very reasonable price.
The owners are fantastic! The ice cream was delicious! You can’t beat the location! The facilities were old fashioned, but well cared for. And I feel they compensated for that with a very reasonable price.
10
christine
Sep 2, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Peaceful & friendly
Peaceful & friendly
8
maria
Aug 27, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
They give you ice-cream but it taste like ice and the cones are old. The cleanliness of room was very good.
They give you ice-cream but it taste like ice and the cones are old. The cleanliness of room was very good.
10
Dan
Sep 29, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
They have an home made ice cream shop on site, delicious treat! Very convenient for walking in town and especially Watkins Glen State park. Older building and rooms, very well maintained and clean.
They have an home made ice cream shop on site, delicious treat! Very convenient for walking in town and especially Watkins Glen State park. Older building and rooms, very well maintained and clean.
10
Susan
May 30, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great staff. Very convienent! Good ice cream on site. Pizza food shack was okay. Also, on site.
Great staff. Very convienent! Good ice cream on site. Pizza food shack was okay. Also, on site.
10
Sher
Jul 7, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The original building was constructed in 1837 so this is an interesting historic building. We selected a traditional inn-style room versus a typical hotel room and were not disappointed. The room was very clean and included a tv,refrigerator, microwave, and air conditioning…all in good working condition. A coffee-bar is located in the guest lobby. A creamery (which offers vegan ice cream for those who should avoid dairy) and out-door pizza and grill are on site. The inn is located 5 minutes walking distance from the main entrance to Watkins Glen State Park. The staff is so very friendly and accommodating, From owner, management, house keeping, and food handlers everyone is your friend. What a nostalgic place to stay in Watkins Glen!
The original building was constructed in 1837 so this is an interesting historic building. We selected a traditional inn-style room versus a typical hotel room and were not disappointed. The room was very clean and included a tv,refrigerator, microwave, and air conditioning…all in good working condition. A coffee-bar is located in the guest lobby. A creamery (which offers vegan ice cream for those who should avoid dairy) and out-door pizza and grill are on site. The inn is located 5 minutes walking distance from the main entrance to Watkins Glen State Park. The staff is so very friendly and accommodating, From owner, management, house keeping, and food handlers everyone is your friend. What a nostalgic place to stay in Watkins Glen!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
8
Colin
5 days ago
·
Stayed 1 night
Self check in site, advise to check in prior to arrival to obtain the room key code number. Touch pad on the door. Room was basic but clean, shower good, plenty clean towels & toiletries provided.
Self check in site, advise to check in prior to arrival to obtain the room key code number. Touch pad on the door. Room was basic but clean, shower good, plenty clean towels & toiletries provided.
10
Jonathan
last week
·
Stayed 2 nights
Room was nice and clean. Bed was very soft. Parking lot got flooded and it was a challenge to find a place. Great location. Would stay there again.
Room was nice and clean. Bed was very soft. Parking lot got flooded and it was a challenge to find a place. Great location. Would stay there again.
6
Angela
2 weeks ago
·
Stayed 2 nights
The room was clean, but there were multiple insects in the room. Everything worked but there were holes in the wall and no decor. The self serve check in did not work but when we called the number we were able to check in. Location was convenient. The ice cream was yummy.
The room was clean, but there were multiple insects in the room. Everything worked but there were holes in the wall and no decor. The self serve check in did not work but when we called the number we were able to check in. Location was convenient. The ice cream was yummy.
6
Adam
3 weeks ago
·
Stayed 1 night
Good location. Terrible bed which made getting a good night's sleep difficult.
Good location. Terrible bed which made getting a good night's sleep difficult.
10
Gina
4 weeks ago
·
Stayed 2 nights
My family and I stayed for a long weekend and it really enjoyed the colonial Inn! We had stayed in Watkins Glen before and I think our future stays will be back at the colonial Inn. The room was a tidy, but the AC unit filter hadn’t been cleaned I think ever. Once we cleaned that things were great. Very easy to check in and out. The location is great for walking everywhere.
My family and I stayed for a long weekend and it really enjoyed the colonial Inn! We had stayed in Watkins Glen before and I think our future stays will be back at the colonial Inn. The room was a tidy, but the AC unit filter hadn’t been cleaned I think ever. Once we cleaned that things were great. Very easy to check in and out. The location is great for walking everywhere.
FAQs about The Colonial Inn & Creamery
Is parking available at the property?
Free self parking is available onsite, and it is limited. Parking is on-site and not covered. No reservation is required.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in time is from 16:00 to 21:00, and check-out time is at 11:00. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request, but additional charges may apply.
What is the location of the property in relation to key landmarks?
The property is located in a state park, just steps from Watkins Glen State Park and 8 minutes by foot from Seneca Lake. It is 4.5 miles from Watkins Glen International and 0.2 miles from The Tasting Room.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are allowed at the property, but specific age policies for staying free are not mentioned.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Prices for upcoming dates
September 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
October 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cheaper
Pricier
Average nightly price across deals, with taxes & fees.
Prices in USD for 2 guests, updated daily.
- 2026-09-18: NO DATA
- 2026-09-19: NO DATA
- 2026-09-20: 150.85719105377197USD
- 2026-09-21: 139.59524392242432USD
- 2026-09-22: 139.59229254989623USD
- 2026-09-23: 138.6330264160156USD
- 2026-09-24: 144.14187271194456USD
- 2026-09-25: NO DATA
- 2026-09-26: NO DATA
- 2026-09-27: 147.14301571502685USD
- 2026-09-28: 139.62382056503296USD
- 2026-09-29: 141.13875920791625USD
- 2026-09-30: 137.30808785324095USD
- 2026-10-01: 95.60505390701293USD
- 2026-10-02: NO DATA
- 2026-10-03: NO DATA
- 2026-10-04: 93.14031629257201USD
- 2026-10-05: 108.25957595138549USD
- 2026-10-06: 108.8321247062683USD
- 2026-10-07: 99.30663555526732USD
- 2026-10-08: NO DATA
- 2026-10-09: NO DATA
- 2026-10-10: NO DATA
- 2026-10-11: 95.56217580642699USD
- 2026-10-12: 101.76261538772582USD
- 2026-10-13: 94.51887875442505USD
- 2026-10-14: 95.60505390701293USD
- 2026-10-15: 94.55460174713134USD
- 2026-10-16: NO DATA
- 2026-10-17: 175.36048416900633USD
- 2026-10-18: 91.91572439575195USD
- 2026-10-19: 96.43883854064941USD
- 2026-10-20: 97.67021771850585USD
- 2026-10-21: 96.84985000686645USD
- 2026-10-22: 95.60505390701293USD
- 2026-10-23: 125.86080853958129USD
- 2026-10-24: 124.48165054855346USD
- 2026-10-25: 94.55460174713134USD
- 2026-10-26: 97.71309581909179USD
- 2026-10-27: 91.7199441795349USD
- 2026-10-28: 96.66979000930786USD
- 2026-10-29: 90.47984225082396USD
- 2026-10-30: 126.79573679733275USD
- 2026-10-31: 124.51023594894409USD
- 2026-11-01: 106.38822185516356USD
- 2026-11-02: 162.71922140655516USD
- 2026-11-03: 171.90187842407227USD
- 2026-11-04: 173.80983129119872USD
- 2026-11-05: 171.9304638244629USD
- 2026-11-06: 173.80983129119872USD
- 2026-11-07: 175.71063780822752USD
- 2026-11-08: 174.80790315704346USD
- 2026-11-09: 171.9304638244629USD
- 2026-11-10: 175.71063780822752USD
- 2026-11-11: 171.90187842407227USD
- 2026-11-12: 173.7812458908081USD
- 2026-11-13: 173.80983129119872USD
- 2026-11-14: 171.9304638244629USD
- 2026-11-15: 175.767703515625USD
- 2026-11-16: 176.5038301223755USD
- 2026-11-17: 175.13178345031736USD
- 2026-11-18: 171.9304638244629USD
There is no front desk at this property. Guests can access their accommodation through a private entrance. A virtual front desk provides assistance to guests. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 21 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Cashless transactions are available
- Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, a security system, and a first aid kit
- Cashless payment methods are available for all transactions.
- Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.
Popular amenities
Parking
Non-Smoking Rooms
Housekeeping
Golf Course (nearby)
Fishing
Hiking
Activities
Golf Course (nearby)
Fishing
Hiking
Outdoor Fireplace
Outdoor Furniture
Services
Housekeeping
Designated Smoking Area
Internet
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
Parking
Free Parking
Parking (Limited)
Parking Onsite
General
Non-Smoking Rooms
Picnic Area/Tables
Family Room