Athenaeum Hotel
From
$166
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
$166
/ night
About this property
Take in the views from a garden and make use of amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services.
Amenities
Take in the views from a garden and make use of amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services.
Business amenities
Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, and a safe deposit box at the front desk. This hotel has 2 meeting rooms available for events. Free self parking is available onsite.
Dining
Enjoy a satisfying meal at Heirloom serving guests of Athenaeum Hotel. Quench your thirst with your favorite drink at the bar/lounge.
Rooms
Make yourself at home in one of the 150 air-conditioned guestrooms. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Bathrooms feature shower/tub combinations, hair dryers, and slippers. Conveniences include irons/ironing boards, as well as phones with free local calls.
Location
Located in Mayville, Athenaeum Hotel is just steps from Chautauqua Amphitheater and 3 minutes by foot from Chautauqua Lake. This hotel is 0.4 mi (0.6 km) from Chautauqua Golf Club and 1.1 mi (1.7 km) from Chautauqua Institution.
What's nearby
Chautauqua Amphitheater(0.1 miles)
Chautauqua Lake(0.1 miles)
Hall of Philosophy(0.2 miles)
Miller Bell Tower(0.3 miles)
Chautauqua Institution(0.3 miles)
Chautauqua Golf Club(0.4 miles)
Whitney Bay(2.4 miles)
Lakeside Park(3.2 miles)
Chautauqua Belle Steamboat(3.4 miles)
Chautauqua Lake(4.1 miles)
Chautauqua Bookstore(4.5 miles)
The Lawson Center(6.2 miles)
Ashville Bay(8.9 miles)
Dewittville Bay(9.1 miles)
Lake Shore Center for the Arts(10.7 miles)
The nearest major airport is Jamestown, NY (JHW-Chautauqua County)(15.6 miles)
Parking
Restaurant
Non-Smoking Rooms
Valet Parking
Tennis Courts
ATM / Cash Machine
Location
3 S Lake Dr, Chautauqua, New York, United States of America
Chautauqua Amphitheater (0.1 miles)
Chautauqua Lake (0.1 miles)
Hall of Philosophy (0.2 miles)
Miller Bell Tower (0.3 miles)
Chautauqua Institution (0.3 miles)
Chautauqua Golf Club (0.4 miles)
Room options
1
Premium Room
Room details
1 Queen Bed
Sleeps 4
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Rollaway or Extra Beds (Free)
5
Standard Room
Room details
1 Queen Bed
Sleeps 4
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Rollaway or Extra Beds (Free)
Guest reviews of Athenaeum Hotel
6.9
Pleasant
Based on 260 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Athenaeum Hotel offers a distinctive, historic stay inside the Chautauqua Institution, with grand porches, lake views, and nostalgic charm, where many guests enjoy friendly service and an ambiance that feels like stepping back in time.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Athenaeum Hotel offers a distinctive, historic stay inside the Chautauqua Institution, with grand porches, lake views, and nostalgic charm, where many guests enjoy friendly service and an ambiance that feels like stepping back in time.
Rooms are generally comfortable, though some are small with older features or sloping floors, and a few guests reported noise from weddings. Parking is often off-site with a walk, and valet or shuttle support and guidance can be inconsistent, so arrival logistics may require extra time. Breakfast and on-site dining range from excellent and enjoyable to limited or cold, with availability sometimes affected by events or the off-season. Expect a characterful, scenic stay with welcoming staff, alongside trade-offs in modern convenience.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Expansive porches and common areas set a relaxing scene, and the on-site restaurant/bar hosts events at times. Parking is off-site and can involve a walk; valet or shuttle support is inconsistently available or communicated.
Related guest reviews
6
Judi
Sep 20, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
No valet available when we checked in and the parking lot was 5 blocks away!!!
No valet available when we checked in and the parking lot was 5 blocks away!!!
8
john
Jun 3, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
10
Paula
Apr 23, 2024
·
We had such a lovely stay. Great jazz night and cocktails on veranda!
We had such a lovely stay. Great jazz night and cocktails on veranda!
8
Jared
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
8
William
Oct 5, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We did not get a lake room, but the porch and yard are a great place to relax.
We did not get a lake room, but the porch and yard are a great place to relax.
10
Gwen
Aug 21, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
We enjoyed staying at the historical hotel. I think parking could be better explained and assistance should be available to get you back to your car with all of your bags. We got a ride to the front gate - but ended up walking with all of our bags to our car in the very back parking lot. RIDICULOUS!
We enjoyed staying at the historical hotel. I think parking could be better explained and assistance should be available to get you back to your car with all of your bags. We got a ride to the front gate - but ended up walking with all of our bags to our car in the very back parking lot. RIDICULOUS!
10
DENISE
Jun 22, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We had a nice time. The porch is beautiful and we had an excellent meal at the Heirloom restaurant!
We had a nice time. The porch is beautiful and we had an excellent meal at the Heirloom restaurant!
4
ELIZABETH
Sep 9, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
8
karen
Sep 17, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
We were glad to be in the annex because there was a wedding reception in the main stay. Clean. Only problem was that some of the wedding guests did stay in the annex and were loud in the hallways after midndight.
We were glad to be in the annex because there was a wedding reception in the main stay. Clean. Only problem was that some of the wedding guests did stay in the annex and were loud in the hallways after midndight.
10
Melanie
Jun 6, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
It was wonderful! Only downside was the parking lot was a bit of a walk from the hotel
It was wonderful! Only downside was the parking lot was a bit of a walk from the hotel
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Many guests found rooms and linens clean, but recurring maintenance and cleanliness issues were noted, including peeling paint, mildew, dirty outdoor furniture, and spider webs on the exterior.
Related guest reviews
8
Brandon
Oct 2, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
8
Jared
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
8
Michelle
May 31, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Had a really nice stay at this historic hotel by the lake despite it being quite run down. Had a beautiful view from the balcony of our room but didn't want to sit in any of the furniture. Wicker furniture was in bad shape and the seat cushions were all very dirty. Should be replaced with more durable outdoor furniture that doesn't need cushions and could easily be wiped down.The whole hotel is in need of some tlc. Could be so beautiful but money definitely needs to be spent for restoring both the interior and exterior.
Had a really nice stay at this historic hotel by the lake despite it being quite run down. Had a beautiful view from the balcony of our room but didn't want to sit in any of the furniture. Wicker furniture was in bad shape and the seat cushions were all very dirty. Should be replaced with more durable outdoor furniture that doesn't need cushions and could easily be wiped down.The whole hotel is in need of some tlc. Could be so beautiful but money definitely needs to be spent for restoring both the interior and exterior.
8
Hans
Oct 24, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
8
Halina
May 16, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
this was a beautiful hotel with the wrap around porch, stairs and fountain. it did need a new coat of paint and regardless it was lovely. some of the furniture in the interior was not as attractive as it could have been. stay with a theme! all in all, this was a unique experience and i was happy to stay here.
this was a beautiful hotel with the wrap around porch, stairs and fountain. it did need a new coat of paint and regardless it was lovely. some of the furniture in the interior was not as attractive as it could have been. stay with a theme! all in all, this was a unique experience and i was happy to stay here.
8
Laurie
Sep 6, 2022
·
Stayed 2 nights
We enjoyed our stay!! The staff was nice, rooms were clean. Obviously in a hotel built in 1861 it’s not perfect but has historical charm. Would stay again 😊
We enjoyed our stay!! The staff was nice, rooms were clean. Obviously in a hotel built in 1861 it’s not perfect but has historical charm. Would stay again 😊
10
Michelle
May 22, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Property had lots of character. Exceptionally clean. Nice continental breakfast. Beautiful location. Will stay again.
Property had lots of character. Exceptionally clean. Nice continental breakfast. Beautiful location. Will stay again.
8
Kurt
Oct 20, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Crisp clean sheets and nice breakfast.
Crisp clean sheets and nice breakfast.
8
James
Aug 30, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Historic and neat, but rundown and in need of renovation.
Historic and neat, but rundown and in need of renovation.
8
David
Jun 8, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Rooms are comfortable for many, with high ceilings or lake views in some, but several are small with older furnishings, uneven floors, small TVs, and occasional in-room Wi-Fi limitations. Noise from weddings or events affected some stays.
Related guest reviews
10
ronald
Oct 3, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
8
john
Jun 3, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
8
Brandon
Oct 2, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
8
Jared
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
10
Suzanne
Sep 5, 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
Lovely old hotel with a great view of Chautauqua Lake. The staff was friendly and helpful. Our room was small but more than adequate. We had a great time and found lots to do and places to see.
Lovely old hotel with a great view of Chautauqua Lake. The staff was friendly and helpful. Our room was small but more than adequate. We had a great time and found lots to do and places to see.
8
Jake
May 29, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
It was good but the wedding going on was loud and disruptive as we were looking forward to a more tranquil visit. However it was all good
It was good but the wedding going on was loud and disruptive as we were looking forward to a more tranquil visit. However it was all good
8
Hans
Oct 24, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
6
Sara
Sep 25, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
I was given the noisiest room in the hotel unfortunately.
I was given the noisiest room in the hotel unfortunately.
8
karen
Sep 17, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
We were glad to be in the annex because there was a wedding reception in the main stay. Clean. Only problem was that some of the wedding guests did stay in the annex and were loud in the hallways after midndight.
We were glad to be in the annex because there was a wedding reception in the main stay. Clean. Only problem was that some of the wedding guests did stay in the annex and were loud in the hallways after midndight.
8
David
Jun 8, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Staff are frequently described as friendly, welcoming, and helpful. A few guests experienced disorganized check-in or limited assistance with parking/valet.
Related guest reviews
10
steven
May 26, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
great staff
great staff
8
Brandon
Oct 2, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
The hotel was exceptionally clean, the staff was very friendly and cooperative. The bed was hard and very small, really my only complaint.
8
Jared
Sep 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
The hotel itself is quite lovely. Very old world 1890s era charm and craftsmanship. The room was pleasant and clean, very high ceilings and large windows. The bed was very comfortable. With all that said, the hotel was built before cars. It's very tight and we did not expect to have to park appropriately 1/8th mile away. We are perfectly capable of the walk, and they do offer valet parking and shuttle options. But I feel they should make that known for older folks. Also the bathroom, clean as it was, left me a bit disappointed. Everything worked, but the shower was sad. The staff we dealt with was mostly pleasant and helpful. If you wish to have a view of the lake, you want the East side of the hotel I believe
10
Gwen
Aug 21, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
We enjoyed staying at the historical hotel. I think parking could be better explained and assistance should be available to get you back to your car with all of your bags. We got a ride to the front gate - but ended up walking with all of our bags to our car in the very back parking lot. RIDICULOUS!
We enjoyed staying at the historical hotel. I think parking could be better explained and assistance should be available to get you back to your car with all of your bags. We got a ride to the front gate - but ended up walking with all of our bags to our car in the very back parking lot. RIDICULOUS!
8
Hans
Oct 24, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
10
Nicolette
Sep 20, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
It was like going back in time to a simpler but elegant era in history. Great staff.
It was like going back in time to a simpler but elegant era in history. Great staff.
4
ELIZABETH
Sep 9, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
10
greg
Oct 2, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Very welcoming to our dog. Very friendly staff
Very welcoming to our dog. Very friendly staff
10
Susan
Sep 26, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
We love the charm and beautiful scenery around the hotel. Hotel staff are more than accommodating. We will definitely visit again.
We love the charm and beautiful scenery around the hotel. Hotel staff are more than accommodating. We will definitely visit again.
10
Robert
Oct 13, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
The hotel and staff were wonderful.
The hotel and staff were wonderful.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Located within the Chautauqua Institution, the setting is scenic and walkable with lake views and gardens that guests praise. Off-season stays feel quiet and peaceful.
Related guest reviews
10
Debra
Dec 8, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
This is a unique hotel in the middle of Chautauqua Institution. We had a fantastic room and thoroughly enjoyed the history and surroundings.
This is a unique hotel in the middle of Chautauqua Institution. We had a fantastic room and thoroughly enjoyed the history and surroundings.
10
Ruth
May 18, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Our stay was unique and opened our eyes to an area we've never seen. We enjoy looking at the map and picking places that look different for our overnight stays during road trips that lead us here. Off season for this area made for a great rate. Wonderful time.
Our stay was unique and opened our eyes to an area we've never seen. We enjoy looking at the map and picking places that look different for our overnight stays during road trips that lead us here. Off season for this area made for a great rate. Wonderful time.
10
ronald
Oct 3, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
8
Roel
Oct 16, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
It was a good place for fall colors viewing. Quiet time of the year.
It was a good place for fall colors viewing. Quiet time of the year.
10
Suzanne
Sep 5, 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
Lovely old hotel with a great view of Chautauqua Lake. The staff was friendly and helpful. Our room was small but more than adequate. We had a great time and found lots to do and places to see.
Lovely old hotel with a great view of Chautauqua Lake. The staff was friendly and helpful. Our room was small but more than adequate. We had a great time and found lots to do and places to see.
8
William
Oct 5, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We did not get a lake room, but the porch and yard are a great place to relax.
We did not get a lake room, but the porch and yard are a great place to relax.
10
Beth
May 26, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Beautiful historic hotel and town. It's like going back in time 150 years. The whole little town is very well kept. The staff at the hotel is wonderfull.Already planning to come back.
Beautiful historic hotel and town. It's like going back in time 150 years. The whole little town is very well kept. The staff at the hotel is wonderfull.Already planning to come back.
10
Michelle
May 22, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Property had lots of character. Exceptionally clean. Nice continental breakfast. Beautiful location. Will stay again.
Property had lots of character. Exceptionally clean. Nice continental breakfast. Beautiful location. Will stay again.
10
Jeffrey
Oct 25, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Wonderful, well maintained building on the Chautauqua Institute property. It felt like you were going back to an earlier time.
Wonderful, well maintained building on the Chautauqua Institute property. It felt like you were going back to an earlier time.
8
David
Jun 8, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
This is an old Hotel, built 1881, and its’ floors are a bit creaky and uneven. But that adds to the charm. Amazing porches with fantastic views of Lake Chautauqua. Bed was comfortable and room was clean.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Breakfast and dining feedback is mixed: some praise excellent, well-stocked options and enjoyable drinks, while others report cold food, items running out, or closures due to weddings or off-season.
Related guest reviews
10
ronald
Oct 3, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
We enjoyed stepping back in time to admire the unique building style of the 1880's. The room was a little smaller than most hotels, except New York City, but was very comfortable. It was a very pleasant experience staying at the Athenaeum Hotel and very relaxing. Also, the "Continental Breakfast" was way beyond the norm...excellent. There were plenty of choices and stocked very well. This was indeed an unexpected bonus. Lastly, walking around the hotel and Chatauqua Institution was very enjoyable.
8
john
Jun 3, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
the hotel & surrounding area very unique. Didnt like that the room was so small & no refrigerator the continental breakfast was not great. the restaurant as closed only bar food and only 1 restaurant in the area
10
Paula
Apr 23, 2024
·
We had such a lovely stay. Great jazz night and cocktails on veranda!
We had such a lovely stay. Great jazz night and cocktails on veranda!
8
Valeria
Sep 25, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Beautiful place, clean and wonderful. Breakfast should be more curated in my opinion.
Beautiful place, clean and wonderful. Breakfast should be more curated in my opinion.
10
Bernard
Oct 4, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great breakfast... fog in the morning prevented a lake view...
Great breakfast... fog in the morning prevented a lake view...
6
Diane
Jun 21, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Food was never hot.Breakfast and Dinner was cold.A lot of noise during the night.
Food was never hot.Breakfast and Dinner was cold.A lot of noise during the night.
10
DENISE
Jun 22, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We had a nice time. The porch is beautiful and we had an excellent meal at the Heirloom restaurant!
We had a nice time. The porch is beautiful and we had an excellent meal at the Heirloom restaurant!
8
Hans
Oct 24, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
The front desk staff were quite friendly and helpful. The bar and food service staff were also personable and helpful. We chose this hotel because my wife stayed here as a child years ago. We were told by others around town that the Athenaeum was last refurbished in 1984. The lobby was refreshed more recently. As other reviewers have stated, if you want to stay at a historic hotel, you'll appreciate the Atheneum, but if you want a pristine room, updated technologies and services, and a diverse menus I'd recommend staying elsewhere. The common spaces at this hotel were in better condition than our room, which had a sloping floor, chipping paint, a stained armchair, and mildew growing on the ceiling in the bathroom. The bed seemed to be memory foam style and a tad soft, but we slept decently. The in-room TV was quite small and did not carry true HD TV. The Wifi was password secured which is so important but very rate in hotels. We had solid connection in the lobby, but it was good to marginal in our room. There was an excessive quantity of spiders and webs on the exterior of the hotel. Not sure why they don't treat for them and remove webs.
4
ELIZABETH
Sep 9, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
Check-in was disorganized, the hotel was short staffed, they ran out of food, there was nowhere to sit in the lobby, and the continental breakfast was nothing special considering the price,
8
Kurt
Oct 20, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Crisp clean sheets and nice breakfast.
Crisp clean sheets and nice breakfast.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Ina
4 weeks ago
·
Stayed 2 nights
Best night sleep in a long time. Quaint vintage Victorian hotel with period style rooms. Very spacious and comfortable. Our first room didn't have any electrical outlets or nightstands so Garrett the manager upgraded us to a nicer, bigger room with a semi- private balcony. The grounds are amazing. the hotel was closed for season during our stay so there wasn't any activities or amenities. We kept busy by strolling the immense property and just relaxing and taking in the views. The breakfast was nice and simple. Coffee and tea were available in the lobby 24 hrs. Parking was very far away and I wish they could figure out a more convenient location after season. Definatley worth the visit if you are in the area.
Best night sleep in a long time. Quaint vintage Victorian hotel with period style rooms. Very spacious and comfortable. Our first room didn't have any electrical outlets or nightstands so Garrett the manager upgraded us to a nicer, bigger room with a semi- private balcony. The grounds are amazing. the hotel was closed for season during our stay so there wasn't any activities or amenities. We kept busy by strolling the immense property and just relaxing and taking in the views. The breakfast was nice and simple. Coffee and tea were available in the lobby 24 hrs. Parking was very far away and I wish they could figure out a more convenient location after season. Definatley worth the visit if you are in the area.
10
michael
Sep 8, 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
everything was excellent and beautiful from the grounds and. building to our room, food and staff. we plan on visiting again.
everything was excellent and beautiful from the grounds and. building to our room, food and staff. we plan on visiting again.
8
Caren
Sep 6, 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
A charming building in a historically interesting location. Restaurant was closed during my visit, though, and parking was inconvenient. Ended up with a very expensive dinner elsewhere. Probably a better choice for a long-term stay. Not particularly convenient for a stop-over on a road trip.
A charming building in a historically interesting location. Restaurant was closed during my visit, though, and parking was inconvenient. Ended up with a very expensive dinner elsewhere. Probably a better choice for a long-term stay. Not particularly convenient for a stop-over on a road trip.
10
Mike
Jul 15, 2026
·
Stayed 2 nights
very nice people, hotel was old but well kept and interesting. great stay!
very nice people, hotel was old but well kept and interesting. great stay!
10
Charles
Jun 17, 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Wow. A time capsule of the 19th century.
Wow. A time capsule of the 19th century.
FAQs about Athenaeum Hotel
Is parking available at the property?
Yes, free self parking is available on-site.
Is breakfast offered at the hotel?
Breakfast is available at the hotel, served at the Heirloom restaurant.
Does the hotel allow pets?
Yes, pets are allowed with a fee of USD 35.00 per accommodation, per night. Service animals are exempt from fees.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 15:00, and check-out is by 10:00. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request and could incur additional charges.
What accessibility features does the hotel offer?
The property features step-free entrances and wheelchair-accessible facilities in public areas and rooms.
Where is the hotel located in relation to nearby attractions?
The hotel is located in Mayville, just steps from Chautauqua Amphitheater and 3 minutes by foot from Chautauqua Lake. It is 0.4 mi from Chautauqua Golf Club and 1.1 mi from Chautauqua Institution.
Are children allowed to stay at the hotel?
Yes, children are allowed to stay at the hotel. The minimum age for children to stay for free is not specified.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Front desk staff will greet guests on arrival at the property. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 18 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Safety features at this property include a carbon monoxide detector, a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, a security system, and a first aid kit
- Contactless check-out is available.
- Pet fee: USD 35.00 per accommodation, per night
- Service animals are exempt from fees
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
Popular amenities
Parking
Restaurant
Non-Smoking Rooms
Valet Parking
Tennis Courts
ATM / Cash Machine
Services
ATM / Cash Machine
Luggage Storage
Designated Smoking Area
Self Laundry
24-Hour Front Desk
Concierge Services
Parking
Parking
Valet Parking
Electric Car charging station
Internet
Free Wi-Fi
Activities
Tennis Courts
Garden
Golf Course (nearby)
Beach (Nearby)
Live Music
Outdoor Furniture
General
Restaurant
Non-Smoking Rooms
Family Room