Maggie May Beach Cottage @ Cape May, NJ
From
$208
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
$208
/ night
About this property
Welcome to the Maggie May in Cape May! This newly renovated home is perfectly located with a short walk to the Bay beach and a 10 minute Uber or drive to the heart of Cape May! Spend your days on the beach and your nights walking to see the...
Location
Located by the sea, this vacation home is in North Cape May, a neighborhood in Cape May. Shoppers can check out Washington Street Mall, while everyone can enjoy the natural beauty of Cape May Beach and Sunset Beach. Looking to enjoy an event or a game while in town? See what's going on at Wildwood Crest Tennis Center, or consider a night out at Nauti Spirits Distillery. Looking to get your feet wet? Jet skiing, kayaking and water skiing adventures can be found near the property.
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Coffee / Tea Maker
TV
Hair Dryer
Garden
Guest reviews of Maggie May Beach Cottage @ Cape May, NJ
9.8
Exceptional
Based on 89 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Guests consistently praise Maggie May Beach Cottage @ Cape May, NJ for its very clean home in a quiet, safe neighborhood, a fully fenced yard ideal for dogs, and convenient access to the bay beach, sunsets, and the ferry.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Guests consistently praise Maggie May Beach Cottage @ Cape May, NJ for its very clean home in a quiet, safe neighborhood, a fully fenced yard ideal for dogs, and convenient access to the bay beach, sunsets, and the ferry.
Multiple reviews commend friendly, responsive hosts and straightforward check-in. Interiors are cozy and well equipped, with comfortable furnishings and a spacious back room that adds hangout or extra sleeping space. The setting suits families and pet owners seeking a relaxed base near Cape May.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
The fully fenced backyard is praised across many reviews and works well for dogs; a deck is also mentioned.
Related guest reviews
10
Joseph H.
Sep 13, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
10
Alys T.
Apr 26, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
We had a relaxing stress free stay. The house was clean and comfortable. It is about a half mile from the bay beach and also walking distance to restaurants and the ferry terminal. There is so much to do in the area from shopping to wineries, breweries the boardwalk... Our dog enjoyed the fenced in yard and relaxing on the deck with us. I would definitely recommend this property.
We had a relaxing stress free stay. The house was clean and comfortable. It is about a half mile from the bay beach and also walking distance to restaurants and the ferry terminal. There is so much to do in the area from shopping to wineries, breweries the boardwalk... Our dog enjoyed the fenced in yard and relaxing on the deck with us. I would definitely recommend this property.
10
Michael
Apr 8, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We will be back! This location is amazing and Anna is extremely communicative. Our dogs loved the yard and we appreciated the close proximity to the beach. An all around great experience.
We will be back! This location is amazing and Anna is extremely communicative. Our dogs loved the yard and we appreciated the close proximity to the beach. An all around great experience.
10
Andrea V.
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 9 nights
Our whole family had a wonderful, relaxing time during our vacation including our pets. The home was very comfortable in every ways, nice big fenced backyard to play with our dog. Safe, quiet neighborhood with friendly neighbors. Just a walk away is the beautiful beach where you can walk with your dogs many hours in the mornings and afternoons and can enjoy the most spectacular sunsets in NJ! Grocery store is close by and open late and there are many great pet friendly restaurants to choose from. We are definitely coming back again!
Our whole family had a wonderful, relaxing time during our vacation including our pets. The home was very comfortable in every ways, nice big fenced backyard to play with our dog. Safe, quiet neighborhood with friendly neighbors. Just a walk away is the beautiful beach where you can walk with your dogs many hours in the mornings and afternoons and can enjoy the most spectacular sunsets in NJ! Grocery store is close by and open late and there are many great pet friendly restaurants to choose from. We are definitely coming back again!
10
Patricia K.
Aug 3, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
10
Sherry K.
Nov 24, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
10
Gene l.
May 6, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Excellente communication. Calme des environs. Proximité de la plage. Logement très bien équipé. Le jardin cloturé est un réel plus pour nous qui voyageons avec notre chien. A recommander!
Excellente communication. Calme des environs. Proximité de la plage. Logement très bien équipé. Le jardin cloturé est un réel plus pour nous qui voyageons avec notre chien. A recommander!
10
Julie B.
Dec 27, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We had an amazing time for the 2 nights we stayed here. The house was clean and kid- and dog-friendly. The yard was the perfect size for our dog to run around. It was a nice walk to the beach as well. Thank you for hosting us. We will be back!
We had an amazing time for the 2 nights we stayed here. The house was clean and kid- and dog-friendly. The yard was the perfect size for our dog to run around. It was a nice walk to the beach as well. Thank you for hosting us. We will be back!
10
giovanna m.
Jul 23, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
10
Jessica L.
Aug 21, 2024
·
Stayed 7 nights
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Reviews repeatedly describe the cottage as very clean and well maintained, with consistent upkeep.
Related guest reviews
10
Morgan E.
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
very clean, orderly and attractively decorated house in a quiet neighborhood
very clean, orderly and attractively decorated house in a quiet neighborhood
10
John W.
Nov 15, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Property was appropriately located in a quiet neighborhood. Clean, organized, and furnished with everything we needed. Host was responsive, and the check out list of responsibilities was not over the top. Great stay, the perfect respite during a cold November week.
Property was appropriately located in a quiet neighborhood. Clean, organized, and furnished with everything we needed. Host was responsive, and the check out list of responsibilities was not over the top. Great stay, the perfect respite during a cold November week.
10
Walter D.
May 25, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Everything was as advertised. Pleasant, clean and comfortable.
Everything was as advertised. Pleasant, clean and comfortable.
10
Susan P.
Sep 30, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We recently had the pleasure of staying at Maggie May in Cape May, and it exceeded all our expectations. The property was incredibly well-appointed, with everything we needed already in place, making it feel like a home away from home. From kitchen essentials to comfortable furnishings, every detail was thoughtfully taken care of. The home was well-maintained and spotless, showing how much care the owners put into it. One of the biggest highlights for us was that it was pet-friendly. We were so grateful that our dog was welcome, which is always a big plus when traveling. The pictures were completely accurate, and there were no surprises—just a charming, cozy atmosphere. Plus, the location was perfect! We were close to everything Cape May has to offer, from the beach to restaurants and shops. The communication with the owners was excellent as well. They were responsive and helpful, making sure we had all the information we needed before and during our stay. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and look forward to staying at Maggie May again! Highly recommend!
We recently had the pleasure of staying at Maggie May in Cape May, and it exceeded all our expectations. The property was incredibly well-appointed, with everything we needed already in place, making it feel like a home away from home. From kitchen essentials to comfortable furnishings, every detail was thoughtfully taken care of. The home was well-maintained and spotless, showing how much care the owners put into it. One of the biggest highlights for us was that it was pet-friendly. We were so grateful that our dog was welcome, which is always a big plus when traveling. The pictures were completely accurate, and there were no surprises—just a charming, cozy atmosphere. Plus, the location was perfect! We were close to everything Cape May has to offer, from the beach to restaurants and shops. The communication with the owners was excellent as well. They were responsive and helpful, making sure we had all the information we needed before and during our stay. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and look forward to staying at Maggie May again! Highly recommend!
10
Amanda H.
Aug 15, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Our family (my husband and I, and our daughters age 11 + age 14) stayed at the Maggie May beach cottage in August. We enjoyed our stay. It is a beautiful cottage in a quiet neighborhood. Cozy, clean, and cute. Thanks!
Our family (my husband and I, and our daughters age 11 + age 14) stayed at the Maggie May beach cottage in August. We enjoyed our stay. It is a beautiful cottage in a quiet neighborhood. Cozy, clean, and cute. Thanks!
10
Sherry K.
Nov 24, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
10
frank d.
Jul 24, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Maggie May was a comfortable, clean, 2 bedroom cottage located in a safe and friendly neighborhood
Maggie May was a comfortable, clean, 2 bedroom cottage located in a safe and friendly neighborhood
10
Christin S.
Apr 17, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We enjoyed our stay. The home was clean, cozy and comfortable. Everything we needed! Would love to come back again!
We enjoyed our stay. The home was clean, cozy and comfortable. Everything we needed! Would love to come back again!
10
Jessica R.
Jun 10, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
This place was perfect for our little weekend away. It was nice and clean, and the location was excellent for an event I was participating in. Three of us had plenty of space and had a very comfortable stay.
This place was perfect for our little weekend away. It was nice and clean, and the location was excellent for an event I was participating in. Three of us had plenty of space and had a very comfortable stay.
10
Jess A.
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Our family enjoyed staying here so much! It was very nice and clean!
Our family enjoyed staying here so much! It was very nice and clean!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Guests find the interiors cozy, comfortable, and well equipped; several note a spacious back room that provides extra hangout or sleeping space.
Related guest reviews
10
Alexis H.
Jun 4, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
My husband & I had a wonderful stay at Maggie May Beach Cottage! The host was super friendly and very easy to communicate with. The cottage itself was perfect for us and our furry friend. The fenced in yard gave him space to stretch his legs without us having to worry. The place was super clean and gave the perfect beachy vibe! Also a great location - Beach, food, and different shore pointa all within a 5-15 min drive. Highly recommend!
My husband & I had a wonderful stay at Maggie May Beach Cottage! The host was super friendly and very easy to communicate with. The cottage itself was perfect for us and our furry friend. The fenced in yard gave him space to stretch his legs without us having to worry. The place was super clean and gave the perfect beachy vibe! Also a great location - Beach, food, and different shore pointa all within a 5-15 min drive. Highly recommend!
10
Cory B.
Jul 2, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Nice, newly renovated home, perfect size and location for what we were looking for (4 adults and a dog). Thanks for hosting us!
Nice, newly renovated home, perfect size and location for what we were looking for (4 adults and a dog). Thanks for hosting us!
10
Jacqueline D.
Aug 20, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
10
Patricia K.
Aug 3, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
10
Christin S.
Apr 17, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We enjoyed our stay. The home was clean, cozy and comfortable. Everything we needed! Would love to come back again!
We enjoyed our stay. The home was clean, cozy and comfortable. Everything we needed! Would love to come back again!
10
giovanna m.
Jul 23, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
10
Alissa B.
Jul 1, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
This was my family's second stay here and we look forward to returning again in the future. We particularly enjoy having a more spacious room in the back where we can all hang out together -- and it also works as an additional sleeping area. The house offered more than enough space for our family of four (with two teens) and our dog - and provided quick and easy access to the bay and a short drive to the Washington Street Mall area of Cape May to explore the restaurants and shops. Looking forward to planning our next visit already!
This was my family's second stay here and we look forward to returning again in the future. We particularly enjoy having a more spacious room in the back where we can all hang out together -- and it also works as an additional sleeping area. The house offered more than enough space for our family of four (with two teens) and our dog - and provided quick and easy access to the bay and a short drive to the Washington Street Mall area of Cape May to explore the restaurants and shops. Looking forward to planning our next visit already!
10
Robert J
Feb 25, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
This is the perfect spot for a getaway! We know the area and have local friends, and this cozy, well equipped house gave us the freedom to explore, host, and relax. And our puppy enjoyed his first vacation. We would recommend Maggie May Beach Cottage to anyone, and we hope to return.⭐️
This is the perfect spot for a getaway! We know the area and have local friends, and this cozy, well equipped house gave us the freedom to explore, host, and relax. And our puppy enjoyed his first vacation. We would recommend Maggie May Beach Cottage to anyone, and we hope to return.⭐️
10
Jessica L.
Aug 21, 2024
·
Stayed 7 nights
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
8
Mark V.
Apr 8, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
Comfortable, well appointed stay
Comfortable, well appointed stay
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Hosts are friendly and highly responsive, with clear communication and easy check in.
Related guest reviews
10
Joseph H.
Sep 13, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
10
Alexis H.
Jun 4, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
My husband & I had a wonderful stay at Maggie May Beach Cottage! The host was super friendly and very easy to communicate with. The cottage itself was perfect for us and our furry friend. The fenced in yard gave him space to stretch his legs without us having to worry. The place was super clean and gave the perfect beachy vibe! Also a great location - Beach, food, and different shore pointa all within a 5-15 min drive. Highly recommend!
My husband & I had a wonderful stay at Maggie May Beach Cottage! The host was super friendly and very easy to communicate with. The cottage itself was perfect for us and our furry friend. The fenced in yard gave him space to stretch his legs without us having to worry. The place was super clean and gave the perfect beachy vibe! Also a great location - Beach, food, and different shore pointa all within a 5-15 min drive. Highly recommend!
10
John W.
Nov 15, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Property was appropriately located in a quiet neighborhood. Clean, organized, and furnished with everything we needed. Host was responsive, and the check out list of responsibilities was not over the top. Great stay, the perfect respite during a cold November week.
Property was appropriately located in a quiet neighborhood. Clean, organized, and furnished with everything we needed. Host was responsive, and the check out list of responsibilities was not over the top. Great stay, the perfect respite during a cold November week.
10
Michael
Apr 8, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We will be back! This location is amazing and Anna is extremely communicative. Our dogs loved the yard and we appreciated the close proximity to the beach. An all around great experience.
We will be back! This location is amazing and Anna is extremely communicative. Our dogs loved the yard and we appreciated the close proximity to the beach. An all around great experience.
10
Aleisha K.
Dec 16, 2024
·
Stayed 7 nights
Our stay here was awesome! The host made the check in process super easy and communicated everything to us! Neighbourhood was quiet and was close to Cape May and surrounding area! Great price for a great place!
Our stay here was awesome! The host made the check in process super easy and communicated everything to us! Neighbourhood was quiet and was close to Cape May and surrounding area! Great price for a great place!
10
Jacqueline D.
Aug 20, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
10
Susan P.
Sep 30, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We recently had the pleasure of staying at Maggie May in Cape May, and it exceeded all our expectations. The property was incredibly well-appointed, with everything we needed already in place, making it feel like a home away from home. From kitchen essentials to comfortable furnishings, every detail was thoughtfully taken care of. The home was well-maintained and spotless, showing how much care the owners put into it. One of the biggest highlights for us was that it was pet-friendly. We were so grateful that our dog was welcome, which is always a big plus when traveling. The pictures were completely accurate, and there were no surprises—just a charming, cozy atmosphere. Plus, the location was perfect! We were close to everything Cape May has to offer, from the beach to restaurants and shops. The communication with the owners was excellent as well. They were responsive and helpful, making sure we had all the information we needed before and during our stay. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and look forward to staying at Maggie May again! Highly recommend!
We recently had the pleasure of staying at Maggie May in Cape May, and it exceeded all our expectations. The property was incredibly well-appointed, with everything we needed already in place, making it feel like a home away from home. From kitchen essentials to comfortable furnishings, every detail was thoughtfully taken care of. The home was well-maintained and spotless, showing how much care the owners put into it. One of the biggest highlights for us was that it was pet-friendly. We were so grateful that our dog was welcome, which is always a big plus when traveling. The pictures were completely accurate, and there were no surprises—just a charming, cozy atmosphere. Plus, the location was perfect! We were close to everything Cape May has to offer, from the beach to restaurants and shops. The communication with the owners was excellent as well. They were responsive and helpful, making sure we had all the information we needed before and during our stay. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience and look forward to staying at Maggie May again! Highly recommend!
10
Sherry K.
Nov 24, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
10
Robert V.
May 5, 2024
·
Stayed 5 nights
Property was lovely and centrally located. We were able to get to places easily. Anna took care of everything
Property was lovely and centrally located. We were able to get to places easily. Anna took care of everything
10
Jessica L.
Aug 21, 2024
·
Stayed 7 nights
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
We loved our time at the beach house. It is close to the ferry and in a quiet neighborhood. We liked how the house had a larger back room than most other houses around the area for rent. The backyard is also enclosed. The owner was very responsive and friendly. :)
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Quiet, safe neighborhood within a short walk to the bay beach and an easy drive to Cape May sights; close to the ferry, restaurants, and shops.
Related guest reviews
10
Joseph H.
Sep 13, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
Quaint property with lots of relaxing Space and a HUGE back yard. Easy to get around and very close to the Ferry Dock. Host was very attentive to email messages and VERY HELPFUL.
10
Alys T.
Apr 26, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
We had a relaxing stress free stay. The house was clean and comfortable. It is about a half mile from the bay beach and also walking distance to restaurants and the ferry terminal. There is so much to do in the area from shopping to wineries, breweries the boardwalk... Our dog enjoyed the fenced in yard and relaxing on the deck with us. I would definitely recommend this property.
We had a relaxing stress free stay. The house was clean and comfortable. It is about a half mile from the bay beach and also walking distance to restaurants and the ferry terminal. There is so much to do in the area from shopping to wineries, breweries the boardwalk... Our dog enjoyed the fenced in yard and relaxing on the deck with us. I would definitely recommend this property.
10
Lynne R.
May 30, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
House was perfect for my husband and I, and our dog. Short walk to fabulous and NOT CROWDED beach, even on Memorial Day weekend. Could also walk to two very good restaurants, if you’d like to stay out of the car for a day or two! Short drive to town and Cape May attractions. Just one bathroom but otherwise plenty of room for more guests and would be perfect for a family with children/grandchildren. Very comfortable, we will be back!
House was perfect for my husband and I, and our dog. Short walk to fabulous and NOT CROWDED beach, even on Memorial Day weekend. Could also walk to two very good restaurants, if you’d like to stay out of the car for a day or two! Short drive to town and Cape May attractions. Just one bathroom but otherwise plenty of room for more guests and would be perfect for a family with children/grandchildren. Very comfortable, we will be back!
10
Aleisha K.
Dec 16, 2024
·
Stayed 7 nights
Our stay here was awesome! The host made the check in process super easy and communicated everything to us! Neighbourhood was quiet and was close to Cape May and surrounding area! Great price for a great place!
Our stay here was awesome! The host made the check in process super easy and communicated everything to us! Neighbourhood was quiet and was close to Cape May and surrounding area! Great price for a great place!
10
Andrea V.
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 9 nights
Our whole family had a wonderful, relaxing time during our vacation including our pets. The home was very comfortable in every ways, nice big fenced backyard to play with our dog. Safe, quiet neighborhood with friendly neighbors. Just a walk away is the beautiful beach where you can walk with your dogs many hours in the mornings and afternoons and can enjoy the most spectacular sunsets in NJ! Grocery store is close by and open late and there are many great pet friendly restaurants to choose from. We are definitely coming back again!
Our whole family had a wonderful, relaxing time during our vacation including our pets. The home was very comfortable in every ways, nice big fenced backyard to play with our dog. Safe, quiet neighborhood with friendly neighbors. Just a walk away is the beautiful beach where you can walk with your dogs many hours in the mornings and afternoons and can enjoy the most spectacular sunsets in NJ! Grocery store is close by and open late and there are many great pet friendly restaurants to choose from. We are definitely coming back again!
10
Jacqueline D.
Aug 20, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
Property was in perfect walking proximity to the bay and a short drive to anywhere we wanted to go. The owner was very quick to respond to any questions we had and our stay was very comfortable. We would definitely want to come back in the future!
10
Patricia K.
Aug 3, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
Comfortable CottageClose to the beach and other places we wanted to go. Nice bathroom. Kitchen had everything we needed. Our dog enjoyed the back yard. We all enjoyed the sunset on the bay! Nicely furnished and equipped. Great Location.
10
Sherry K.
Nov 24, 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
We had a wonderful week at the Maggie May cottage! Anna was easy to communicate with and quickly responded when we had questions. The cottage was cutely decorated, very clean, had many amenities, was in a great location & had a big fenced backyard for our dogs. Would highly recommend this property and look forward to renting again! Thank you!
10
giovanna m.
Jul 23, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
Beds and couches very comfy!!! Very well supplied. Had everything needed. PERFECT location. Great fenced in yard for my pup!! Wonderful get away. Thank you!!!
10
Alissa B.
Jul 1, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
This was my family's second stay here and we look forward to returning again in the future. We particularly enjoy having a more spacious room in the back where we can all hang out together -- and it also works as an additional sleeping area. The house offered more than enough space for our family of four (with two teens) and our dog - and provided quick and easy access to the bay and a short drive to the Washington Street Mall area of Cape May to explore the restaurants and shops. Looking forward to planning our next visit already!
This was my family's second stay here and we look forward to returning again in the future. We particularly enjoy having a more spacious room in the back where we can all hang out together -- and it also works as an additional sleeping area. The house offered more than enough space for our family of four (with two teens) and our dog - and provided quick and easy access to the bay and a short drive to the Washington Street Mall area of Cape May to explore the restaurants and shops. Looking forward to planning our next visit already!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Not enough information in reviews.
Related guest reviews
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
cathy v.
May 29, 2026
·
Stayed 4 nights
Had a great time at the cottage. Was perfect size for the two of us. Location was great. This was 2nd time staying here.
Had a great time at the cottage. Was perfect size for the two of us. Location was great. This was 2nd time staying here.
6
BRIDGET T.
Apr 22, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
The home was okay for what we needed. There is some obvious visible upkeep that could be improved just with overall wear of the home and materials inside.
The home was okay for what we needed. There is some obvious visible upkeep that could be improved just with overall wear of the home and materials inside.
10
Christine S.
Apr 19, 2026
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great pet friendly dind!
Great pet friendly dind!
10
Kayla B.
Mar 23, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had the pleasure of staying here and it was absolutely amazing. The house was clean, nearby many places to eat, and a short drive to many shops and the zoo. We look forward to staying here again in the future!
We had the pleasure of staying here and it was absolutely amazing. The house was clean, nearby many places to eat, and a short drive to many shops and the zoo. We look forward to staying here again in the future!
10
Honor F.
Dec 29, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Thank you so much! Your cottage was so cute - I really enjoyed my stay. I like that it was so close to the ferry. I had alot of personal issues that took up much of my stay but now that I know where you are I look forward to coming back again. The only issue that I know of was the pipe burst in the backyard shower, but Matt took care of that right away. Thanks so much!
Thank you so much! Your cottage was so cute - I really enjoyed my stay. I like that it was so close to the ferry. I had alot of personal issues that took up much of my stay but now that I know where you are I look forward to coming back again. The only issue that I know of was the pipe burst in the backyard shower, but Matt took care of that right away. Thanks so much!
Property Policies
Check-in
Check-out
Check-in from 16:00
Before 10:00
FAQs about Maggie May Beach Cottage @ Cape May, NJ
Are pets allowed at the property?
Yes, pets are allowed with a limit of 2 total. Service animals are exempt from this restriction.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is at 16:00 and check-out is at 10:00. Early or late check-in/check-out availability and costs are not specified.
What is the location of the property in relation to key landmarks?
The property is located by the sea in North Cape May, a neighborhood in Cape May. It is a short walk to the Bay beach and a 10-minute drive to the heart of Cape May. Nearby attractions include Washington Street Mall, Cape May Beach, and Sunset Beach.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are permitted at the property, and ages 0-17 can stay for free.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 22 years old.
Popular amenities
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Coffee / Tea Maker
TV
Hair Dryer
Garden
General
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Coffee / Tea Maker
Hair Dryer
TV
Towels
Shower
Beach Sun Loungers
Smoke-Free Property
Internet
Free Wi-Fi
Activities
Garden
Windsurfing
Playground
Bird Watching
Water-skiing
Games
Outdoor Furniture
Public Winery Tours
Services
Laundry Facilities