Why results appear this way

Accommodation Choices with Parking in Shelter Island Heights

The Pridwin Hotel

Shelter Island Heights, NY
9.2

Superb

104 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$710
/ night

West Neck Guesthouse

Shelter Island Heights, NY
8

Good

37 reviews

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

Family Room

from
$249
/ night

Shelter Island House

Shelter Island Heights, NY
9.2

Superb

58 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$229
/ night

The Cliffside Resort Condominiums

Greenport West, NY
9

Superb

253 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$299
/ night

The Menhaden Hotel

Greenport, NY
9.5

Exceptional

183 reviews

Top rated

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from
$524
/ night

The Shoals Suites & Slips

Southold, NY
9.3

Superb

274 reviews

Experience luxury with individually decorated rooms, outdoor spaces, and a coffee shop at this Southold hotel near the bay.

Top rated

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from
$331
/ night

Hotel Moraine

Greenport West, NY
9.8

Exceptional

22 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$488
/ night

Cliffside Resort Poolside Condo A204

Greenport West, NY
9.9

Exceptional

17 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

from
$755
/ night

ZEY HOTEL

Greenport, NY
8.1

Very good

4 reviews

Top rated

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from
$276
/ night

Two Bed Condo with Garden Views

Greenport West, NY
10

Exceptional

4 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

from
$758
/ night

North Fork Resort

Greenport West, NY
9.6

Exceptional

1 review

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$318
/ night

Bright, Newer Home Close to Beach & Greenport Town

East Marion, NY
9.9

Exceptional

26 reviews

Top rated

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

Kitchen/kitchenette

from
$710
/ night

Waterfront Southold Retreat < 3 Mi to Wineries!

Southold, NY

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

Free Parking

Beach on property

from
$462
/ night

Sag Harbor Inn

Sag Harbor, NY
8.7

Fabulous

620 reviews

Enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool and complimentary breakfast near The Hamptons Beaches in Sag Harbor.

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$357
/ night

Faraway Sag Harbor

Sag Harbor, NY
9

Superb

292 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$971
/ night

Bay Front-View of the Bay-Unit-Bathroom

Northwest Harbor, NY
9.6

Exceptional

39 reviews

Top rated

Free Parking

from
$298
/ night

Large Contemporary for Your Enjoyment

Noyack, NY
8.8

Fabulous

17 reviews

Top rated

Pool

Free WiFi

Air Conditioned

from
$2,205
/ night

Cowgirl Palace

Sag Harbor, NY

5-star

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

from
$442
/ night

Hamptons 9BD MEGA Compound w POOL TENNIS BBALL NIGHTCLUB

Sag Harbor, NY

Pool

Parking

Free WiFi

Free Parking

from
$3,446
/ night

LoveCedarPt

Northwest Harbor, NY

Parking

Free Parking

Non-Smoking Rooms

Beach (Nearby)

from
$300
/ night

Product

  • Affiliate program
  • Cookie preferences
  • Cookie policy
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use

Social

© 2026 Vio