Commodore Resort
$131
/ night
Avg. for September
Prices for Commodore Resort
Select dates to see prices and availability
$131
/ night
Avg. for September
Monthly average prices
Nightly prices at Commodore Resort average $90 in March, the cheapest month, and $194 in July, the most expensive, based on the last 12 months.
| Month | Average price |
|---|---|
| January | $96 |
| February | $98 |
| March | $90 |
| April | $92 |
| May | $130 |
| June | $145 |
| July | $194 |
| August | $186 |
| September | $131 |
| October | $113 |
| November | $92 |
| December | $93 |
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
Sep · $131
S
O
N
D
Most expensive: July (~$194)
Cheapest: March (~$90)
About this property
Take advantage of recreation opportunities including a nightclub and an outdoor pool. Additional amenities at this hotel include complimentary wireless internet access, a banquet hall, and a vending machine.
Amenities
Take advantage of recreation opportunities including a nightclub and an outdoor pool. Additional amenities at this hotel include complimentary wireless internet access, a banquet hall, and a vending machine.
Business amenities
Featured amenities include a 24-hour front desk, luggage storage, and ATM/banking services. Free self parking is available onsite.
Dining
Satisfy your appetite with American cuisine at Mr.Ed's Bar & Cameo Pizza, one of the hotel's 2 restaurants. Relax with a refreshing drink from the poolside bar or one of the 2 bars/lounges.
Rooms
Make yourself at home in one of the 74 air-conditioned rooms featuring refrigerators and microwaves. Complimentary wireless internet access is available to keep you connected.
Location
Commodore Resort is centrally located in Put-in-Bay, a 4-minute walk from Put-in-Bay Winery and 7 minutes by foot from Jet Express Dock. This hotel is 0.5 mi (0.8 km) from Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial and 0.8 mi (1.3 km) from Perry's Cave.
What's nearby
Oak Point State Park(0.1 miles)
Lake Erie Islands Historical Society(0.1 miles)
Kimberly's Carousel(0.2 miles)
Put-in-Bay Winery(0.2 miles)
Lake Erie(0.2 miles)
DeRivera Park(0.2 miles)
Aquatic Resource Center(0.3 miles)
Jet Express Dock(0.4 miles)
Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial(0.5 miles)
Heineman Winery(0.7 miles)
Perry's Cave(0.7 miles)
South Bass Island State Park(1.3 miles)
Scheeff East Point Nature Preserve(1.6 miles)
Island Paws Dog Park(2 miles)
South Bass Island Lighthouse(2.3 miles)
The preferred airport for Commodore Resort is Toledo Express Airport (TOL)(68.5 miles)
Restaurant
Swimming pool
Non-Smoking Rooms
Housekeeping
Banquet Facilities
ATM / Cash Machine
Location
272 Delaware Avenue, Put-in-Bay, Ohio, United States of America
Oak Point State Park (0.1 miles)
Lake Erie Islands Historical Society (0.1 miles)
Kimberly's Carousel (0.2 miles)
Put-in-Bay Winery (0.2 miles)
Lake Erie (0.2 miles)
DeRivera Park (0.2 miles)
Room options
1
Standard Double Room, 2 Double Beds (Exterior)
Room details
2 Full Beds
Sleeps 4
225 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
1
Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed, Jetted Tub
Room details
1 King Bed
Sleeps 2
275 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
2
Classic Double Room, 2 Double Beds
Room details
2 Full Beds
Sleeps 4
275 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
2
Classic Double Room, 2 Double Beds (Exterior)
Room details
2 Full Beds
Sleeps 4
225 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
1
Classic Room, 1 King Bed (Exterior)
Room details
1 King Bed
Sleeps 2
225 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
Guest reviews of Commodore Resort
6.3
Pleasant
Based on 538 verified reviews
Who stays here?
Couple
48%
Family
12%
Group
37%
Solo
1%
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
At Commodore Resort, guests praise the central, walkable location and lively pool scene, but many report inconsistent cleanliness, small dated rooms, and loud late-night noise, with limited parking and maintenance issues affecting comfort for some stays.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
At Commodore Resort, guests praise the central, walkable location and lively pool scene, but many report inconsistent cleanliness, small dated rooms, and loud late-night noise, with limited parking and maintenance issues affecting comfort for some stays.
Staff feedback is mixed: many find employees friendly and helpful, while others cite unresponsive front desks and check-in hassles. The pool area is social, sometimes crowded with non-guests; early closing is noted, and one review mentions a temporary closure during remodeling. Dining notes are limited, though multiple reviews mention a Subway in the lobby and pool bars serving drinks. Expect a party-focused crash pad suited to nightlife more than relaxation.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Lively pool scene with loud music; can be crowded with non-guests, with early closing noted and one report of a temporary closure. Parking is limited, with a few reports of elevator problems and the property being hard to find.
Related guest reviews
4
bradley
Jun 27, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We were on 3rd floor elevator did not work going down. Hallways always had something spelled in them you had to walk around. Rooms blank slate but holes in wall. None of vending machines worked on floor. One young man was nice but no one knew where things were around town. Entrance in alley behind stinky dumpsters. Signs for “resort” were poor locations. Pool was very nice but open to all made very crowded. Bed were clean but pillows hard and bed looked like tool always. Not what we expected.
We were on 3rd floor elevator did not work going down. Hallways always had something spelled in them you had to walk around. Rooms blank slate but holes in wall. None of vending machines worked on floor. One young man was nice but no one knew where things were around town. Entrance in alley behind stinky dumpsters. Signs for “resort” were poor locations. Pool was very nice but open to all made very crowded. Bed were clean but pillows hard and bed looked like tool always. Not what we expected.
8
Rebecca
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
A little crowded in the pool on Saturday.
A little crowded in the pool on Saturday.
2
Bonnie
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
This place was awful no parking had to park in the alley...room had mold in it said no ice paid $4 for a bag of ice! Never would I recommend this place
This place was awful no parking had to park in the alley...room had mold in it said no ice paid $4 for a bag of ice! Never would I recommend this place
8
Natalie and Frank
Aug 10, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
3 night birthday stay. Beds were extremely uncomfortable which made sight seeing a bit tiresome due to lack of sleep. The maintenance men were awesome and fixed things brought to their attention immediately. However, it took several hours, phone calls and personal visits to the front desk to have the tub unplugged because it wouldn't drain. The front desk person kept saying that they gave information to management but nothing came of it until finally at 11:30 at night my final personal visit to front desk, the maintenance man was there and said that he wasn't aware of anything. He came immediately and snaked the tub drain and fixed it so we could shower without having water to our knees. Housekeeping did a nice job. Rooms were cleaned daily if you put the sign on door knob. Pool is only open until 7pm that kinda was kind of a bummer. We preferred the pool across the parking lot with pirate ship and bigger bar area because service is faster. Overall, this hotel is perfect for people on budget, young couples, college kids, etc. We would not stay again due to the beds. But this was only hotel with availability for weekend we wanted due to huge volleyball tournament on island.
3 night birthday stay. Beds were extremely uncomfortable which made sight seeing a bit tiresome due to lack of sleep. The maintenance men were awesome and fixed things brought to their attention immediately. However, it took several hours, phone calls and personal visits to the front desk to have the tub unplugged because it wouldn't drain. The front desk person kept saying that they gave information to management but nothing came of it until finally at 11:30 at night my final personal visit to front desk, the maintenance man was there and said that he wasn't aware of anything. He came immediately and snaked the tub drain and fixed it so we could shower without having water to our knees. Housekeeping did a nice job. Rooms were cleaned daily if you put the sign on door knob. Pool is only open until 7pm that kinda was kind of a bummer. We preferred the pool across the parking lot with pirate ship and bigger bar area because service is faster. Overall, this hotel is perfect for people on budget, young couples, college kids, etc. We would not stay again due to the beds. But this was only hotel with availability for weekend we wanted due to huge volleyball tournament on island.
2
Debra
Aug 10, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
They allowed non guests to use the facilities and therefore people who paired nearly $280 a night for a very low grade hotel couldn’t even park there or use the amenities.very noisy but it was the fights in the pool and property & the managers negative reaction to our plea for help that turned us from returning there to that resort ever!
They allowed non guests to use the facilities and therefore people who paired nearly $280 a night for a very low grade hotel couldn’t even park there or use the amenities.very noisy but it was the fights in the pool and property & the managers negative reaction to our plea for help that turned us from returning there to that resort ever!
8
Kristen
Sep 8, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great pool.... and had a subway in the lobby
Great pool.... and had a subway in the lobby
10
Scott
Aug 18, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Everything was great room staffing location pool only downfall trash compactor smelling really bad and leaking making a mess in the parking lot maybe get a street sweeper and hit it once in awhile
Everything was great room staffing location pool only downfall trash compactor smelling really bad and leaking making a mess in the parking lot maybe get a street sweeper and hit it once in awhile
4
David
Jun 20, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Worst mattress ever Pool water very cold Pool music WAY TO LOUD
Worst mattress ever Pool water very cold Pool music WAY TO LOUD
8
Trent
Aug 4, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Ok place tostay. If you have younger kids under 21 don't stay here. They will not let them in pool area.
Ok place tostay. If you have younger kids under 21 don't stay here. They will not let them in pool area.
8
Autumn
Sep 24, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Staff was really great! Location was awesome. I wouldn’t exactly say rooms were resort style - more like super 8. Booked with intentions of hanging out poolside. It appeared they were in the process of remodeling the pool because it was closed. Right next door is the Islander which offers a public pool. Neither the Commodore’s pool or the Islander’s pool was open
Staff was really great! Location was awesome. I wouldn’t exactly say rooms were resort style - more like super 8. Booked with intentions of hanging out poolside. It appeared they were in the process of remodeling the pool because it was closed. Right next door is the Islander which offers a public pool. Neither the Commodore’s pool or the Islander’s pool was open
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Feedback is inconsistent: many report dirty rooms and bathrooms, musty or moldy odors, stained linens, and even bed bugs, while some say their rooms were clean.
Related guest reviews
4
John
Jul 28, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
It’s a great location but man it was dirty. Lots of hair on the floor from previous guests, smears of some questionable origin all across the tv, stains on sheets and blankets, bathroom sink was clogged. WAY too expensive for this level of filth.
It’s a great location but man it was dirty. Lots of hair on the floor from previous guests, smears of some questionable origin all across the tv, stains on sheets and blankets, bathroom sink was clogged. WAY too expensive for this level of filth.
2
Lauren
Jul 27, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Extremely filthy.
Extremely filthy.
10
Desarae
Aug 17, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Clean
Clean
4
Brittany
Jul 3, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
If i could send pics that would be great the room was dirty
If i could send pics that would be great the room was dirty
4
Susan
Sep 21, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We stayed in a king bed room. As soon as we walked in there was a weird, kind of musty/moldy smell that was present during our entire stay. The bathroom looked like it hadn't been deep cleaned in a very long time. There was a water leak coming from under the toilet tank and moldy grime caked into the caulk. Every time you sat on the toilet seat, the entire toilet moved and made a noise. There was a very annoying water drip coming from somewhere the entire night. (We presumed it was from the air conditioning unit but couldn't pin point it for sure)
We stayed in a king bed room. As soon as we walked in there was a weird, kind of musty/moldy smell that was present during our entire stay. The bathroom looked like it hadn't been deep cleaned in a very long time. There was a water leak coming from under the toilet tank and moldy grime caked into the caulk. Every time you sat on the toilet seat, the entire toilet moved and made a noise. There was a very annoying water drip coming from somewhere the entire night. (We presumed it was from the air conditioning unit but couldn't pin point it for sure)
10
Carrie
Jun 30, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Clean room
Clean room
4
Stevanie
Aug 1, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
They had bed bug in the room and we literally had to go back and forth with the lady in charge just to get another room because she didn’t think it was a bed big on the cover too I showed her 5 of them in the headboard then she gave us a room after she said she was all booked
They had bed bug in the room and we literally had to go back and forth with the lady in charge just to get another room because she didn’t think it was a bed big on the cover too I showed her 5 of them in the headboard then she gave us a room after she said she was all booked
2
Kimberly
Sep 14, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
So gross, the mattresses were stained and everything was dirty. Very load at night.
So gross, the mattresses were stained and everything was dirty. Very load at night.
6
Lesley
Sep 26, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
It really wasn’t that great. Limited parking. Rooms weren’t very clean, very weird area lol but the places around weren’t too bad.
It really wasn’t that great. Limited parking. Rooms weren’t very clean, very weird area lol but the places around weren’t too bad.
6
Jennifer
Aug 25, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Great location. The hotel is not very clean.
Great location. The hotel is not very clean.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Rooms are small and dated with uncomfortable beds and various maintenance problems (e.g., nonworking TVs or fridges, weak showers, awkward bathroom layouts). Noise from nightlife or the pool is common.
Related guest reviews
4
Paul
Aug 13, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
8
Jesse
Jul 25, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
8
Edgar
Aug 12, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Need better beds! Mattress was not good!! Other than that! It was great! And the cleaning lady was very nice and helpful!
Need better beds! Mattress was not good!! Other than that! It was great! And the cleaning lady was very nice and helpful!
8
Natalie and Frank
Aug 10, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
3 night birthday stay. Beds were extremely uncomfortable which made sight seeing a bit tiresome due to lack of sleep. The maintenance men were awesome and fixed things brought to their attention immediately. However, it took several hours, phone calls and personal visits to the front desk to have the tub unplugged because it wouldn't drain. The front desk person kept saying that they gave information to management but nothing came of it until finally at 11:30 at night my final personal visit to front desk, the maintenance man was there and said that he wasn't aware of anything. He came immediately and snaked the tub drain and fixed it so we could shower without having water to our knees. Housekeeping did a nice job. Rooms were cleaned daily if you put the sign on door knob. Pool is only open until 7pm that kinda was kind of a bummer. We preferred the pool across the parking lot with pirate ship and bigger bar area because service is faster. Overall, this hotel is perfect for people on budget, young couples, college kids, etc. We would not stay again due to the beds. But this was only hotel with availability for weekend we wanted due to huge volleyball tournament on island.
3 night birthday stay. Beds were extremely uncomfortable which made sight seeing a bit tiresome due to lack of sleep. The maintenance men were awesome and fixed things brought to their attention immediately. However, it took several hours, phone calls and personal visits to the front desk to have the tub unplugged because it wouldn't drain. The front desk person kept saying that they gave information to management but nothing came of it until finally at 11:30 at night my final personal visit to front desk, the maintenance man was there and said that he wasn't aware of anything. He came immediately and snaked the tub drain and fixed it so we could shower without having water to our knees. Housekeeping did a nice job. Rooms were cleaned daily if you put the sign on door knob. Pool is only open until 7pm that kinda was kind of a bummer. We preferred the pool across the parking lot with pirate ship and bigger bar area because service is faster. Overall, this hotel is perfect for people on budget, young couples, college kids, etc. We would not stay again due to the beds. But this was only hotel with availability for weekend we wanted due to huge volleyball tournament on island.
2
Holly
Apr 13, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Check in was stated for 5:00 PM. I received a call about 4:45 PM asking if I was still coming because they close the lobby at 5:30 and there wouldn’t be anyone to check me in. I arrived, got to my room and it was freezing. The heat would not work. The refrigerator did not work. There were no ice machines. My shower had no water pressure and no hot water. The hotel was pretty much empty except for myself and one other person, who they placed in the room above mine and I had to deal with them stomping around. Every time I tried to call the front desk, I never got an answer. I still don’t. The room was not clean. The bed wasn’t even made correctly.
Check in was stated for 5:00 PM. I received a call about 4:45 PM asking if I was still coming because they close the lobby at 5:30 and there wouldn’t be anyone to check me in. I arrived, got to my room and it was freezing. The heat would not work. The refrigerator did not work. There were no ice machines. My shower had no water pressure and no hot water. The hotel was pretty much empty except for myself and one other person, who they placed in the room above mine and I had to deal with them stomping around. Every time I tried to call the front desk, I never got an answer. I still don’t. The room was not clean. The bed wasn’t even made correctly.
4
Jeffrey Forest
Sep 24, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Given a room which had a bathroom commode so large that the door could not be closed. Remote TV wouldn’t work only to find wiring in back of TV had to be ‘jiggled’ and remote batteries replaced.
Given a room which had a bathroom commode so large that the door could not be closed. Remote TV wouldn’t work only to find wiring in back of TV had to be ‘jiggled’ and remote batteries replaced.
6
Alana
Jul 30, 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
I like the location of this hotel. Staff was very friendly. Night time was a bit load, but I also had the first room on the main floor next to the lobby. The bed wasn't very comfy.
I like the location of this hotel. Staff was very friendly. Night time was a bit load, but I also had the first room on the main floor next to the lobby. The bed wasn't very comfy.
2
Tabitha
Jul 4, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
There was a main hotel building and then there were buildings outside of the main building and they were terrible. Dirty, small, bathroom door couldn’t shut without hitting the toilet. Shower pressure was terrible. TV didn’t work. No phone to call front desk. Asked for more towels from housekeeping and never got them. Only drunk college could would be able to tolerate this room. Only positive is the air conditioner worked great.
There was a main hotel building and then there were buildings outside of the main building and they were terrible. Dirty, small, bathroom door couldn’t shut without hitting the toilet. Shower pressure was terrible. TV didn’t work. No phone to call front desk. Asked for more towels from housekeeping and never got them. Only drunk college could would be able to tolerate this room. Only positive is the air conditioner worked great.
4
Stefanie
Jun 27, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Terrible beds, dirty room, tv broke, no phone to call for help, fridge wasn’t on. Extremely noisy. BUT coming here we knew kind of what to expect, it’s a party place and kept as so.
Terrible beds, dirty room, tv broke, no phone to call for help, fridge wasn’t on. Extremely noisy. BUT coming here we knew kind of what to expect, it’s a party place and kept as so.
6
Cindy
Aug 15, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
There was plenty of food. The beds are hard. Had people screaming outside our room at 4am one night. Another night a man was blasting music at 3am. Maybe it was better in the newer section, but I won't be staying there again.
There was plenty of food. The beds are hard. Had people screaming outside our room at 4am one night. Another night a man was blasting music at 3am. Maybe it was better in the newer section, but I won't be staying there again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Many guests praise friendly, helpful staff, but others experienced rude or unresponsive front desks, limited lobby hours, and slow resolution of problems.
Related guest reviews
10
Kenneth
Jul 17, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
The staff was excellent!! Only downside to the property was the limited parking. I would suggest not brining a car, but instead renting a golf cart.
The staff was excellent!! Only downside to the property was the limited parking. I would suggest not brining a car, but instead renting a golf cart.
2
Jennifer
Sep 17, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Property was insanely dirty and a dark alley with no lights. Did not seem safe at night. Ran out of toilet paper and the front desk person didn’t even know where it was kept. Do not stay here!!!
Property was insanely dirty and a dark alley with no lights. Did not seem safe at night. Ran out of toilet paper and the front desk person didn’t even know where it was kept. Do not stay here!!!
10
Marco
Sep 16, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Room was clean and staff was friendly on hand and prepared to meet my needs
Room was clean and staff was friendly on hand and prepared to meet my needs
6
Amy
Jul 30, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The maintenance & cleaning staff were super friendly and attentive to our needs. The front desk staff do not smile and barely speak to you. And, I was charged more than Expedia indicated with no explanation. They didn’t even give me a receipt. The pool bar staff were great.
The maintenance & cleaning staff were super friendly and attentive to our needs. The front desk staff do not smile and barely speak to you. And, I was charged more than Expedia indicated with no explanation. They didn’t even give me a receipt. The pool bar staff were great.
10
Joseph
Jun 13, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
The staff was friendly and helpful. They were very friendly and polite.
The staff was friendly and helpful. They were very friendly and polite.
2
Debra
Aug 10, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
They allowed non guests to use the facilities and therefore people who paired nearly $280 a night for a very low grade hotel couldn’t even park there or use the amenities.very noisy but it was the fights in the pool and property & the managers negative reaction to our plea for help that turned us from returning there to that resort ever!
They allowed non guests to use the facilities and therefore people who paired nearly $280 a night for a very low grade hotel couldn’t even park there or use the amenities.very noisy but it was the fights in the pool and property & the managers negative reaction to our plea for help that turned us from returning there to that resort ever!
6
john
Aug 28, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
This hotel has an exceptional front desk staff….kind, attentive and friendly. Very warm welcome
This hotel has an exceptional front desk staff….kind, attentive and friendly. Very warm welcome
2
Holly
Apr 13, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Check in was stated for 5:00 PM. I received a call about 4:45 PM asking if I was still coming because they close the lobby at 5:30 and there wouldn’t be anyone to check me in. I arrived, got to my room and it was freezing. The heat would not work. The refrigerator did not work. There were no ice machines. My shower had no water pressure and no hot water. The hotel was pretty much empty except for myself and one other person, who they placed in the room above mine and I had to deal with them stomping around. Every time I tried to call the front desk, I never got an answer. I still don’t. The room was not clean. The bed wasn’t even made correctly.
Check in was stated for 5:00 PM. I received a call about 4:45 PM asking if I was still coming because they close the lobby at 5:30 and there wouldn’t be anyone to check me in. I arrived, got to my room and it was freezing. The heat would not work. The refrigerator did not work. There were no ice machines. My shower had no water pressure and no hot water. The hotel was pretty much empty except for myself and one other person, who they placed in the room above mine and I had to deal with them stomping around. Every time I tried to call the front desk, I never got an answer. I still don’t. The room was not clean. The bed wasn’t even made correctly.
10
Jennifer
Sep 7, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Staff was very friendly! Excellent location too!
Staff was very friendly! Excellent location too!
2
Scott
Sep 27, 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
I did NOT check in. They were CLOSED. They did not respond to the phone number on the door and it did not allow me to leave a message.
I did NOT check in. They were CLOSED. They did not respond to the phone number on the door and it did not allow me to leave a message.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Very central and walkable to restaurants and entertainment; however, late-night noise is common and some found the entrance hard to find or near dumpsters.
Related guest reviews
4
bradley
Jun 27, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
We were on 3rd floor elevator did not work going down. Hallways always had something spelled in them you had to walk around. Rooms blank slate but holes in wall. None of vending machines worked on floor. One young man was nice but no one knew where things were around town. Entrance in alley behind stinky dumpsters. Signs for “resort” were poor locations. Pool was very nice but open to all made very crowded. Bed were clean but pillows hard and bed looked like tool always. Not what we expected.
We were on 3rd floor elevator did not work going down. Hallways always had something spelled in them you had to walk around. Rooms blank slate but holes in wall. None of vending machines worked on floor. One young man was nice but no one knew where things were around town. Entrance in alley behind stinky dumpsters. Signs for “resort” were poor locations. Pool was very nice but open to all made very crowded. Bed were clean but pillows hard and bed looked like tool always. Not what we expected.
4
Paul
Aug 13, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
8
Jesse
Jul 25, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
6
Mike
Sep 3, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Got to say I was surprised about this hotel. It's definitely one of the budget friendly hotels on island. Don't expect too much from it. The location was outstanding. Right on the middle of all the fun. Located next to two pool bars. A subway open late located in the lobby. The hotel is old and run down in parts, however, we did feel it was clean and never thought negatively about it. Just understand it's a budget place. If your comfortable with the minimum and looking for primarily a crash pad. I recommend it.
Got to say I was surprised about this hotel. It's definitely one of the budget friendly hotels on island. Don't expect too much from it. The location was outstanding. Right on the middle of all the fun. Located next to two pool bars. A subway open late located in the lobby. The hotel is old and run down in parts, however, we did feel it was clean and never thought negatively about it. Just understand it's a budget place. If your comfortable with the minimum and looking for primarily a crash pad. I recommend it.
10
Stephannie
Sep 3, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Right in the center of it all
Right in the center of it all
8
Diane
Jun 16, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
It was located within walking distance to everything.
It was located within walking distance to everything.
10
Anthony
Aug 22, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Close to restaurant and entertainment
Close to restaurant and entertainment
10
Scott
Aug 20, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
It was centrally located and friendly staff.
It was centrally located and friendly staff.
4
Rob
Jun 22, 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Hard to find, loud, not very clean, missing light bulbs in room, door locks did not function, gaps between door and frame, located on alley, to much partying going on.
Hard to find, loud, not very clean, missing light bulbs in room, door locks did not function, gaps between door and frame, located on alley, to much partying going on.
6
Beth
Jun 29, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
If you’re young and you’re looking for a fun but very loud place to stay much like a spring break hotel, and this is the place for you. We found someone else’s pill bottle in the drawer and on the last day we found a bag with a half eaten cookie in it behind the nightstand. In spite of all of that, the location was excellent and we did have fun in the town.
If you’re young and you’re looking for a fun but very loud place to stay much like a spring break hotel, and this is the place for you. We found someone else’s pill bottle in the drawer and on the last day we found a bag with a half eaten cookie in it behind the nightstand. In spite of all of that, the location was excellent and we did have fun in the town.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Mentions include a Subway in the lobby and drinks from the pool bar. Broader on-site dining quality or variety isn’t well covered in reviews.
Related guest reviews
4
Paul
Aug 13, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
10
Tiffany
Jun 13, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Absolutely love how close the walking distance everything was, having the pool right outside The front door was amazing when the weather was good. Room service was so great and was the front desk.
Absolutely love how close the walking distance everything was, having the pool right outside The front door was amazing when the weather was good. Room service was so great and was the front desk.
8
Jesse
Jul 25, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
This hotel is in the heart of Put in Bay. My wife and I stayed for two nights and were able to walk everywhere we wanted to go. The room was a bit small, especially the bathroom, but in decent shape. The main room was in better condition than the bathroom. The bathroom was so small that the door bumped up against the toilet every time you open and closed the door. The pool was great. Beware...you cannot take your own alcohol and sit by the pool. You must buy their alcohol from their bars at the pool, so if you want to sit at the pool and have some drinks, you'll need to budget for that. Regardless, the pool was a fun spot to hang out! Be prepared for some noise as this is in a busy area, but noise did not prevent us from getting a good night's sleep. I would return to this hotel in the future as I think it's a great value.
10
Christopher
Jul 15, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Very good vibes Pool very clean bar staff excellent. Party by the pool with the MC was fun.
Very good vibes Pool very clean bar staff excellent. Party by the pool with the MC was fun.
6
Amy
Jul 30, 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The maintenance & cleaning staff were super friendly and attentive to our needs. The front desk staff do not smile and barely speak to you. And, I was charged more than Expedia indicated with no explanation. They didn’t even give me a receipt. The pool bar staff were great.
The maintenance & cleaning staff were super friendly and attentive to our needs. The front desk staff do not smile and barely speak to you. And, I was charged more than Expedia indicated with no explanation. They didn’t even give me a receipt. The pool bar staff were great.
6
Mike
Sep 3, 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Got to say I was surprised about this hotel. It's definitely one of the budget friendly hotels on island. Don't expect too much from it. The location was outstanding. Right on the middle of all the fun. Located next to two pool bars. A subway open late located in the lobby. The hotel is old and run down in parts, however, we did feel it was clean and never thought negatively about it. Just understand it's a budget place. If your comfortable with the minimum and looking for primarily a crash pad. I recommend it.
Got to say I was surprised about this hotel. It's definitely one of the budget friendly hotels on island. Don't expect too much from it. The location was outstanding. Right on the middle of all the fun. Located next to two pool bars. A subway open late located in the lobby. The hotel is old and run down in parts, however, we did feel it was clean and never thought negatively about it. Just understand it's a budget place. If your comfortable with the minimum and looking for primarily a crash pad. I recommend it.
8
Kristen
Sep 8, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great pool.... and had a subway in the lobby
Great pool.... and had a subway in the lobby
2
Heather
Nov 10, 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
This was the worse place I’ve ever stayed it was completely dirty it smelled so bad!! There is no where to eat on site. And the men who checked us in was so scary I made my husband check us in there were wearing hoodies and mask just felt off!! And then they were doing work in the room next to us until 1 am using drills moving furniture we didn’t any sleep I would rather slept in my car!! Never come here!!
This was the worse place I’ve ever stayed it was completely dirty it smelled so bad!! There is no where to eat on site. And the men who checked us in was so scary I made my husband check us in there were wearing hoodies and mask just felt off!! And then they were doing work in the room next to us until 1 am using drills moving furniture we didn’t any sleep I would rather slept in my car!! Never come here!!
6
Cindy
Aug 15, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
There was plenty of food. The beds are hard. Had people screaming outside our room at 4am one night. Another night a man was blasting music at 3am. Maybe it was better in the newer section, but I won't be staying there again.
There was plenty of food. The beds are hard. Had people screaming outside our room at 4am one night. Another night a man was blasting music at 3am. Maybe it was better in the newer section, but I won't be staying there again.
4
Teresa
Jun 20, 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
We arrived early and the staff was very polite and got us into our room. Upon arriving the music at the pool/bar was very loud almost too loud to talk. The resort has a Subway located in the lobby and that is all you smell so if you don’t like Subway don’t stay, the Subway light was right outside our window and even with the blind closed it flashed all night long lighting up our room, our room was next to Subway so getting to sleep until after 3AM (when they close) was impossible due to the fact the head of the bed is on the other side of the wall of Subway. Overall experience would never stay here again.
We arrived early and the staff was very polite and got us into our room. Upon arriving the music at the pool/bar was very loud almost too loud to talk. The resort has a Subway located in the lobby and that is all you smell so if you don’t like Subway don’t stay, the Subway light was right outside our window and even with the blind closed it flashed all night long lighting up our room, our room was next to Subway so getting to sleep until after 3AM (when they close) was impossible due to the fact the head of the bed is on the other side of the wall of Subway. Overall experience would never stay here again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
2
Kevin
4 weeks ago
·
Stayed 3 nights
The rooms were awful terrible guest in other rooms people blasting music late hours you wake up with trash all over the ground outside people working there are rude, the property is disgusting had mold in our bathroom dust and dirt on walls spider webs wasn’t a fun place.
The rooms were awful terrible guest in other rooms people blasting music late hours you wake up with trash all over the ground outside people working there are rude, the property is disgusting had mold in our bathroom dust and dirt on walls spider webs wasn’t a fun place.
2
Ryan
Aug 16, 2026
·
Stayed 2 nights
Room was absolutely disgusting. Shower and bathroom were nasty. I’d never stay there again. Room service never came and they wouldn’t give us new towels
Room was absolutely disgusting. Shower and bathroom were nasty. I’d never stay there again. Room service never came and they wouldn’t give us new towels
8
Pam
Aug 8, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
We enjoyed our stay. It was a bit loud some days. The room was sparse but we had cats with us, so I understand the minimalist due to animals. The bed & pillows could use an upgrade. Staff were great from check in to check out. Great pool & bars. We will definitely be returning. Great location. Love the all adults only !! Thank you.
We enjoyed our stay. It was a bit loud some days. The room was sparse but we had cats with us, so I understand the minimalist due to animals. The bed & pillows could use an upgrade. Staff were great from check in to check out. Great pool & bars. We will definitely be returning. Great location. Love the all adults only !! Thank you.
10
Susan
Aug 3, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
I was pleasantly surprised in how clean the room was, staff were nice
I was pleasantly surprised in how clean the room was, staff were nice
8
Cami
Aug 1, 2026
·
Stayed 2 nights
It’s was ok clean room view was horrible
It’s was ok clean room view was horrible
FAQs about Commodore Resort
Is parking available at the property?
Free self parking is available on-site.
Does the hotel allow pets?
Pets are allowed in specific rooms only, with a pet fee of USD 35 per accommodation, per stay. Service animals are exempt from fees.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 5:00 PM, and check-out is until 11:00 AM. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request.
What accessibility features does the hotel offer?
The property has limited wheelchair accessibility, including step-free entrances and accessible public areas.
What is the hotel's location in relation to nearby attractions?
The hotel is centrally located in Put-in-Bay, within a 5-minute walk of Lake Erie and Lake Erie Islands Historical Society, and is close to several attractions including Oak Point State Park (0.1 mi) and Kimberly's Carousel (0.2 mi).
Does the hotel have a swimming pool?
Yes, the hotel features a seasonal outdoor pool, open from May to September, with access available from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
What are the hotel's policies for guests staying with children?
Guests under 21 years old are not permitted at this adults-only property.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Prices for upcoming dates
September 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
October 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cheaper
Pricier
Average nightly price across deals, with taxes & fees.
Prices in USD for 2 guests, updated daily.
- 2026-09-19: 197.5854578170776USD
- 2026-09-20: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-21: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-22: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-23: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-24: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-25: NO DATA
- 2026-09-26: NO DATA
- 2026-09-27: 140.53664418106078USD
- 2026-09-28: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-29: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-09-30: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-01: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-02: NO DATA
- 2026-10-03: NO DATA
- 2026-10-04: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-05: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-06: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-07: 140.729359173584USD
- 2026-10-08: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-09: NO DATA
- 2026-10-10: NO DATA
- 2026-10-11: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-12: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-13: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-10-14: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-15: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-16: 211.78697198638915USD
- 2026-10-17: 211.77267928619383USD
- 2026-10-18: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-10-19: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-20: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-10-21: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-22: 140.68999294357297USD
- 2026-10-23: NO DATA
- 2026-10-24: NO DATA
- 2026-10-25: NO DATA
- 2026-10-26: 126.49926836166381USD
- 2026-10-27: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-10-28: NO DATA
- 2026-10-29: NO DATA
- 2026-10-30: NO DATA
- 2026-10-31: NO DATA
- 2026-11-01: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-02: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-03: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-04: NO DATA
- 2026-11-05: NO DATA
- 2026-11-06: NO DATA
- 2026-11-07: NO DATA
- 2026-11-08: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-09: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-10: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-11: NO DATA
- 2026-11-12: NO DATA
- 2026-11-13: NO DATA
- 2026-11-14: NO DATA
- 2026-11-15: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-16: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-17: 126.50640595397948USD
- 2026-11-18: NO DATA
- 2026-11-19: NO DATA
Front desk staff will greet guests on arrival at the property. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 21 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Cashless transactions are available
- Parties and events are allowed on site
- Long-term renters welcome
- Noise-free guestrooms cannot be guaranteed
- Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, and a first aid kit
- The seasonal pool will be open from May to September.
- Pool access available from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
- Guests under 21 years old are not permitted at this adults-only property.
- Only registered guests are allowed in the guestrooms.
- The property allows pets in specific rooms only and has other pet restrictions (surcharges apply and can be found in the Fees section). Guests can arrange to bring pets by contacting the property directly, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.
- Cashless payment methods are available for all transactions.
- Contactless check-out is available.
- Pet deposit: USD 35.00 per stay
- Pet fee: USD 35 per accommodation, per stay
- Service animals are exempt from fees
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
Popular amenities
Restaurant
Swimming pool
Non-Smoking Rooms
Housekeeping
Banquet Facilities
ATM / Cash Machine
General
Restaurant
Non-Smoking Rooms
Poolside Bar
Picnic Area/Tables
Vending Machines
Adults Only
Beach Sun Loungers
Fence Around Pool
Wheelchair Accessible (Limited)
Services
Housekeeping
Banquet Facilities
ATM / Cash Machine
Luggage Storage
Designated Smoking Area
24-Hour Front Desk
Lockers Available
Activities
Swimming pool
Golf Course (nearby)
Fishing
Pool Outdoor
Live Music
Evening Entertainment
Outdoor Furniture
Pool (Seasonal Outdoor)
Terrace
Internet
Free Wi-Fi