Name: Beachcomber Resort at Montauk
Address: 727 Old Montauk, Montauk, New York, United States of America, Montauk, New York, US
Price range: $243–$1,058 per night
Rating: 9

What guests think

Beachcomber Resort at Montauk earns consistent praise for its prime spot across from the beach, walkable access to town, sweeping ocean views, friendly staff, and well-kept grounds with a heated pool and useful extras like tennis, gym, and sauna.

Units are individually owned, so quality varies: some updated and spacious with balconies and kitchens, others dated, with mixed mattress comfort, occasionally loud AC, and intermittent noise from neighboring rooms. Cleanliness is frequently noted, though a few guests reported issues such as musty smells, dirty grout or carpets, ants, or minor maintenance lapses; Wi-Fi can be slow. Expect a relaxed, beach-focused stay with great views and convenient access, but some variability between rooms.

Facilities

Cleanliness

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Facilities

Heated pool is popular, with additional amenities like a gym, sauna, and a tennis court; grounds are well maintained and beach access is directly across the street. Parking can be tight.

Related guest reviews

10

Anthony

Oct 14, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Room was clean and views were spectacular. Heated pool and walking distance from the beach.

10

kristina

Aug 18, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Property was great. Family of four and had a corner unit, plenty of room and great view of the ocean. Nice and clean. Staff super friendly and accommodating. Nice tennis court, made reservation's for the court with no problem

10

Kathryn

May 31, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Loved having a tennis court and a pool and we had an awesome view it was walkable to town like a nice walk, but not too close to anybody so it was nice and quiet and walking distance to the beach. I would definitely stay there again. I want the same room tho, best views!

10

jorge

Aug 17, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Room and view was amazing. All rooms on back of property have balcony ocean view as back building are up on a hill. Gym pool and sauna is a plus. Friendly staff. Some rooms are updated some arent. Not a deal breaker. Our room had a new tiled shower. Kitchen cabinets were of the old brown type. Prices in MTK have tripled in the last few years so we got this one slightly discounted last minute so took it. 3 day stay. 2min walk to beach. Bed was firm. Pillows were on the cheaper flimsy side. Would def stay there again. We usually stay at the Blue or MTK Manor. BC is 0.8 miles away from main street/711 so it is quieter which we liked. Overall 9/10.

10

Patrick

Jun 26, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Great location and very close to the beach. Also, great pool area with heated pool.

10

Ulrike

Sep 27, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Very relaxing property, beautiful views of the ocean, short walk to the beach, nice and very clean pool, friendly staff.

10

Lydia

May 26, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

We enjoyed our stay here, it was the second time we stayed. It is quiet, 15 min walk from the center (or 3 min by car, Uber), nice beach in front. Property has a pool and sauna. We didn’t use it, but will try next time.

10

Charles

Aug 20, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Parking is too limited

10

Jacqueline

Sep 29, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beachcomber is great! Beach is right across the street, and the pool is heated with fresh towels and plenty of room to sit or lounge! The staff is very friendly and helpful, and the grounds are well maintained! We love to stay here when we go to Montauk!

8

Elizabeth

Jun 27, 2024

·

Stayed 5 nights

Literally the only thing that could have made it better would be having a pool bar. Other than that, it is completely ideal.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Cleanliness

Reviews frequently highlight very clean rooms and well-kept property. A minority noted issues such as musty odors, dirty dishes or grout, stained carpets, ants, or worn linens.

Related guest reviews

8

Elisa

Jul 14, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

When we visit Greenport this is a great place to stay. Beautiful grounds and beach! Love it here. The unit we stayed in could have use some updating as the bathroom shower handle seemed loose and the grout was dirty. The refrigerator looked as if someone beat it up which didn’t help the aesthetic of the very blue room. With this being said we’d choose a different room next time!

4

Valerie

Aug 7, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

arrived late due to road closure. Unable to get key fob from the key code accessible unit. Very pricey for what you got. Was labeled as two beds, but was only one. Dishes were dirty.

6

John Ryan

Jul 21, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

As these units are individually owned you can get a nice brand new room or one that is older. Unfortunately our stay was in an older unit that could use some TLC. Also the carpet needs to be cleaned as my toddlers feet were black after about a half hour. Besides the room everything else was great.

10

Carol

Jun 5, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Located across from the ocean with a beautiful view, and the pool heated to 85 degrees made for a great early Summer getaway. Walk to town, great location. Pristine grounds, friendly staff, very clean room and comfortable bed.

10

Anjel

Oct 10, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Staff was accommodating, room was clean. The view was amazing and the location to stores was perfect. Will definitely come back..

10

Kimberly

Aug 16, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The staff was knowledgeable and courteous. The cleaning crew cleaned the room exceptionally well. The view of the ocean from the room was breathtaking. I will definitely go back.

8

ross

Sep 2, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Unit we had was clean but had a musty smell. Staff came to spray. It improved but still was there when no windows open.

10

ariel

Jun 2, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Super clean room. Excellent location. Amazing staff. Thank you!

10

Carol

Oct 6, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

This was a much needed short getaway!!!! It was exactly what my family needed. Everything was neat and clean all staff was excellent and friendly. I would highly recommend this place and we intend on going back for a week next year!

6

Armando

Jun 7, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Being so close to the beach was excellent, one street crossing away to the dunes. Going in with a relative expectation of what to expect, I was still surprised with some surprisingly blatant uncleanliness. In the closet of my room was a broken mirror, I ended up using my own beach towels to dry off after a shower as the supplied towels could not be described as anything other than rancid smelling (I left them outside) and I ended up having to use an inhaler, as there it was most certainly mold somewhere in the room. The room was enormous with plenty of amenities, the staff is extremely kind, and the beach access is ideal for the price point. But the lack of cleanliness will likely keep me from staying here again.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Rooms

Many rooms are spacious with ocean-view balconies and kitchens, but decor and fit-out vary by unit. Guests mention mixed mattress comfort, occasionally loud or dated AC, some footstep noise, and spotty or slow Wi-Fi.

Related guest reviews

10

MARIA HELENA

Jul 22, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

The room was impeccable. Gorgeous and well appointed. Clean. Amazing view. Big balcony to have a meal or coffee. Only nitpick was noisy old fashioned AC unit. Pool area beautiful. Close to town. Close to beaches and restaurants.

8

Danielle

Sep 23, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

The lower building is not as quiet.

10

jorge

Aug 17, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Room and view was amazing. All rooms on back of property have balcony ocean view as back building are up on a hill. Gym pool and sauna is a plus. Friendly staff. Some rooms are updated some arent. Not a deal breaker. Our room had a new tiled shower. Kitchen cabinets were of the old brown type. Prices in MTK have tripled in the last few years so we got this one slightly discounted last minute so took it. 3 day stay. 2min walk to beach. Bed was firm. Pillows were on the cheaper flimsy side. Would def stay there again. We usually stay at the Blue or MTK Manor. BC is 0.8 miles away from main street/711 so it is quieter which we liked. Overall 9/10.

4

Matthew

May 19, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Location and staff were both great, but that is where the compliments end. For the nightly rate we paid for an off season rental, we expected significantly more. The two primary issues were the terribly uncomfortable bed and the terribly loud neighbors above and to the side of us that literally kept us up both nights of our stay stomping around. My freshman year college dorm issued mattress seems like a Temperpedic compared to the bed in this rental. We could feel the springs in our back, and we woke up each morning very stiff and in pain. For context, we are 37 and 34 years old and have never had a single back issue. We are confident we would’ve been better off sleeping on a futon bought from Target. Then again, I’m sure our health was also negatively impacted by the stomping of the above neighbors that sounded like Thor’s hammer all night.

8

Lauren

Jun 4, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Resort was perfect, room was clean and updated. Only complaint was very spongy/uncomfortable Murphy Bed mattress.

10

Adliana

Jul 11, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Nice place, it's pretty quiet all around, and the beach is literally across the street. The studio apartment with balcony is perfect especially with the full kitchen, in case you want to stay in and cook a bit.

6

todd

Aug 19, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Was fine for a 2 night staycation. CONS: Room was dated and in poor condition: all lamps and TV in power cords; broken cabinets, lightbulbs out, AC so loud could not run at night. PROS: lovely view even from lower level, nice pool And gym, walkable

8

Jesus

Sep 8, 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

This was my first stay at this property. The staff here are delightful, very attentive and friendly! The room was clean and well-appointed, and they delivered on the ocean view and no carpet room I requested. Room for improvement: The AC we had was terribly loud, since it was cooler at night we just switched to fan. Very low water pressure, I ended up not using the shower and filling a small bucket to pour over my body repeatedly. Also, the 3rd person to shower gets only cold water and the wifi is slow. Still, it's close to town and a GREAT deal for families. Very clean and we felt safe! Verdict, we would absolutely go back!

4

Minseok

Aug 4, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Bad WiFi connection!

10

Sherrie

Oct 7, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Spacious, beautiful view of ocean

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Service

Staff are widely described as friendly, accommodating, and responsive, with some early check-ins. A few guests reported unfriendly or aggressive interactions.

Related guest reviews

4

James

Sep 8, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Upon arriving after 6 hours of travel with my 8 lbs hypoallergenic service dog I wasn’t even greeted with a hello before an angry old woman at the front desk went on a monologue for berating me about the dog. She falsely claimed their listing on hotels.com claimed service dogs must be pre registered when dogs aren’t even mentioned in the rules or regs. Hotels.com claims to have talked to them, but they didn’t reach out at all let alone apologize. I left early as felt extremely unwelcome and the property is very much early 90s 3 star vibe despite being across from the ocean. Mean and awful experience especially to someone with PTSD.

10

Derek

Jun 22, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

This was our first time to Montauk! We came for Memorial Day weekend. The prices were very reasonable and we lucked out with great weather! The location is perfect - an easy walk to down town and right across from our own private beach! The hotel staff were very friendly and anytime we walked by anyone, they would ask us how we are and how our stay is. Very attentive!!

4

Callie

Sep 12, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Don't let the landscaping and pictures on the internet fool you - we were duped. We booked 2 rooms; both were very outdated. One room had water stains on the wallpaper and the other felt like you were in a trailer when you went into the bathroom. Both had full sized beds. We asked for a nicer room or larger bed, staff was not friendly and dismissed us. Would never stay here again.

10

JUNWOO

Oct 26, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Very Clean, Nice view, Nice Staff and Service

10

Meaghan

Aug 18, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Easy walk to the beach, close to town. Staff went above and beyond - rooms could be updated a bit but overall 10/10 stay!

10

Eleanor

Jun 23, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

We had a view of the water and the staff was very welcoming and the place was very clean when we arrived and even though check in was 4 we received an email at 12:30 that our room was ready even though the weather was rainy and cloudy for the whole weekend we still made the best of it.

10

Anjel

Oct 10, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Staff was accommodating, room was clean. The view was amazing and the location to stores was perfect. Will definitely come back..

4

Brittany Van

Aug 26, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Staff was unprofessional and aggressive. Pushed me out to leave before check out and still charged me a late check out fee.

10

Jacqueline

Sep 29, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beachcomber is great! Beach is right across the street, and the pool is heated with fresh towels and plenty of room to sit or lounge! The staff is very friendly and helpful, and the grounds are well maintained! We love to stay here when we go to Montauk!

10

Kendall

Jun 16, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The ladies at the front desk were so nice!

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Location

Across the street from the beach and within walking distance of town; many appreciate the ocean views and quieter setting just outside the center.

Related guest reviews

10

Srini

Aug 20, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Walkable to the beach. Have to cross a highway which was not as wide or busy, so it was easy.

10

Walter

Dec 8, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Great location right on the ocean -

10

Peter

Jun 21, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Clean, easy access to beach and Montauk with a little distance so out of the summer scrum.

10

Brian

May 22, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

It is the perfect location...across street from ocean and walkable to town.

10

Noreen

Aug 3, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Great hotel across from the beach. Walking/biking distance to town. Great spot.

10

Carol

Jun 5, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Located across from the ocean with a beautiful view, and the pool heated to 85 degrees made for a great early Summer getaway. Walk to town, great location. Pristine grounds, friendly staff, very clean room and comfortable bed.

10

Ardeshir

May 30, 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

This is a great property that’s walking distance to the west end of downtown Montauk. Clean, quiet and great heated pool. Rooms have lovely views of the ocean. Had my morning coffee and evening cocktail on the taking taking in the ocean!

10

Ana

Sep 2, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great location, good amenities.

10

David

Aug 25, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Close to main area of Montauk

10

Kaitlyn

Sep 23, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Perfect location fir a weekend getaway. The beach access was right across the road. You coul walk into town easily or if you wanted to d6ive everything was a close location to here.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Dining

Not enough information in reviews.

Related guest reviews

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
				1 $274	2	3
4 $275	5 $275	6 $275	7 $275	8 $275	9	10
11 $373	12 $243	13 $243	14 $244	15 $243	16	17
18 $243	19 $243	20 $1,057	21 $1,057	22 $1,057	23 $1,058	24 $1,057
25 $1,057	26 $1,057	27 $1,058	28 $1,057	29 $1,057	30 $1,057	31 $1,057

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17 $340	18	19
20 $289	21 $275	22 $274	23 $275	24 $279	25	26
27 $273	28 $274	29 $274	30 $275

Select dates to see prices and availability

About this property

Location

Room options

Studio

Studio (Lower Level Corner)

Studio Lower

Studio (Upper Level Corner)

Suite, 1 Bedroom, Fireplace

Suite, 2 Bedrooms

Suite, 1 Bedroom (Upper Ocean View)

Studio Upper

Suite, 1 Bedroom (Lower Level)

Guest reviews

Superb

Who stays here?

What guests think

Property Policies

Check-in instructions

Good to know

Optional extras

FAQs about Beachcomber Resort at Montauk

Have a question?

Prices for upcoming dates