Name: The Lightkeeper’s Inn
Address: 25 Simpsons Lane, Edgartown, Massachusetts, United States of America, Edgartown, Massachusetts, US
Price range: $236–$1,654 per night
Rating: 7.2

What guests think

At The Lightkeeper’s Inn, travellers highlight a very walkable, quiet Edgartown location and home-like suites with kitchens and some private entrances or decks, while noting a simple, unfussy setup that feels more like a self-serve inn than a full-service hotel.

Guests consistently praise convenient parking and overall cleanliness. Common drawbacks include dated furnishings and carpets, occasional maintenance issues, and uncomfortable or unreliable sofa beds; some also report limited or delayed service, no daily housekeeping, and minimal on-site staffing with communication mostly by text. Expect a clean, simple, well-located base rather than a luxury, full-service stay.

Facilities

Cleanliness

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Facilities

Parking is consistently appreciated, and many units include kitchens and some private or garden decks. On-site services are minimal with no concierge and no daily housekeeping; climate control can be basic (e.g., window AC, an isolated heat issue).

Related guest reviews

6

Luigi

Oct 15, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Heat only 1 day out of 3, shower has a big gap probably soaking foundation or framing, no one on premises

10

Yota

Jul 5, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

We loved the garden deck where we had dinner.

10

Tim

Jun 3, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great locstaion. One block walk to downtown Edgartown. Upstairs unit with private deck was beautiful.

6

Elise

Sep 21, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

More like an air bnb than a hotel. No concierge or check in. They just five you a door code to access the room. No maid service or fresh towels. We only stayed 2 nights so perhaps that’s the policy but still… the pull out bed in the suite had a terrible mattress - springs poking out. On the bright side, the location is wonderful. Walk to town and all of Edgartown. We don’t spend a lot of time in the room when we travel so overall if was just okay. If you’re looking for something with panache or luxury this isn’t it.

8

jennifer

Nov 2, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Great location just steps from the shops in Edgartown, yet very quiet and private. We had a very spacious room and parking was great.

8

Zarine

Jun 11, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Perfect location. Very close to the Main Street with all the shops. No need to drive a car. The staff working are very friendly. The room I had was older than the photos online. The fridge did not have a handle and was old. The carpet is also old with some stains. I had a second level room and the stairs are not wide. If you are a senior or have kids I won’t recommend the second floor room. I will recommend this Inn and will stay again when visiting Martha’s Vineyard. With parking and a convenient location I can’t ask for anything more.

10

Kerstin

Jul 19, 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Lovely spot . Great little kitchen.

10

sharon

Aug 15, 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

The property looks much better than its pictures. It’s in a very good location, walkable to the ferry or the bus stop not to mention all the shopping and dining varieties. Our rooms were very clean, but there is carpet in the main living space. If you are a coffee drinker, bring your own. They provided an old style coffee maker, (not a Keurig) and the coffee was horrible. So we still had to go out for coffee.

10

Mark

Oct 18, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Lovely room, separate bedroom, and a fully equipped kitchen for cooking those large lobsters from the local fisheries in Menemsha. Clise to everything in Edgartown. A big plus was a parking space for the car. Rooms have private entrances. Almost dont want to write a great review, there may not be a room for me once this gem is discovered.

4

Akl

Jul 4, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

The property is very dated. Doors are squeaky, floor is uneven, furniture is old, mattress is not comfortable. AC is a window unit. On the ground floor you can’t open the shades if you want privacy and room is very small.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Cleanliness

Most guests find the accommodations clean, with some praising the cleaning staff. Several note worn or stained carpets and a dated feel, plus small maintenance issues like squeaky doors.

Related guest reviews

8

Mary

Aug 26, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Very cute, comfortable beds, old fashioned, excellent cleaning staff, very friendly and nice.

10

Cameron

May 18, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

This property was perfect for what we needed. We were within walking distance to everything in Edgartown and the price was very reasonable. The rooms were clean and I wouldn’t hesitate to stay there again

8

Anthony

Oct 15, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great location. Very clean. We will be back

8

Michelle

Oct 10, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Very good location, especially for the price. Room was nice and cozy, except for outdated/old carpet but would not prevent me from staying here again.

10

Janice

Oct 14, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Would like to help by telling you that the bathroom door squeaks and could awaken people. A little adjustment would help.

8

Zarine

Jun 11, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Perfect location. Very close to the Main Street with all the shops. No need to drive a car. The staff working are very friendly. The room I had was older than the photos online. The fridge did not have a handle and was old. The carpet is also old with some stains. I had a second level room and the stairs are not wide. If you are a senior or have kids I won’t recommend the second floor room. I will recommend this Inn and will stay again when visiting Martha’s Vineyard. With parking and a convenient location I can’t ask for anything more.

10

sharon

Aug 15, 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

The property looks much better than its pictures. It’s in a very good location, walkable to the ferry or the bus stop not to mention all the shopping and dining varieties. Our rooms were very clean, but there is carpet in the main living space. If you are a coffee drinker, bring your own. They provided an old style coffee maker, (not a Keurig) and the coffee was horrible. So we still had to go out for coffee.

8

christina

Dec 5, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Darling, cozy property in a great location with a convenient kitchen but could use some new carpet or flooring and beds. A little worn out. The staff was very helpful and location couldn’t be beat but definitely could use some renovations.

10

Richard

Oct 6, 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Clean, quiet apartment close to the Edgartown waterfront

4

Akl

Jul 4, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

The property is very dated. Doors are squeaky, floor is uneven, furniture is old, mattress is not comfortable. AC is a window unit. On the ground floor you can’t open the shades if you want privacy and room is very small.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Rooms

Suites often provide separate bedrooms, kitchens, and occasional private decks, and many guests find beds comfortable and the setting quiet. Some units feel small or dated, and several report uncomfortable or unreliable sofa beds.

Related guest reviews

10

David

Jun 3, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Very good overall and super comfortable bed. Nice and helpful host. The only minor negative is the couch was uncomfortable with cushions that had no support. Needs replacing. Overall B plus.

10

Scott

Oct 2, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Very nice property. They let us have our room early and store our luggage when we left. It’s not as big as it looks in the pictures but still very nice

8

PATRICIA

Aug 6, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

A great option if you are looking for a stay with a kitchen, living room area. New England charm. We had a few bumps with our stay. We were four people and had requested two extra pillows which took a few days to acquire. And unfortunately, the pullout sofa bed is an air mattress which sprung a lake and completely deflated the last night. That was a terrible situation for the two that slept out there. The difficulty is communicating with staff as they ask you to text. Customer service for a hotel really needs to be if not available in person certainly by phone. I’ve stayed here before and would I stay here again… Yes, I would. I’m sure they will make an accommodation for the situation. They’ve been helpful if not delayed so far.

6

Ronald

Jul 27, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

The property is close to attractions. We found it to be quiet and peaceful. The staff was accommodating and friendly. The cons were that the unit we stayed it was a tight fit for a family of two adult and two small children. No way 4 adults could fit there. Also it was a bit pricey for what it was. Would recommend to a couple.

10

joan

Aug 21, 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Stayed in room 5, really enjoyed it. Beautiful 4 poster bed. Picture perfect.

10

Tim

Jun 3, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great locstaion. One block walk to downtown Edgartown. Upstairs unit with private deck was beautiful.

6

Elise

Sep 21, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

More like an air bnb than a hotel. No concierge or check in. They just five you a door code to access the room. No maid service or fresh towels. We only stayed 2 nights so perhaps that’s the policy but still… the pull out bed in the suite had a terrible mattress - springs poking out. On the bright side, the location is wonderful. Walk to town and all of Edgartown. We don’t spend a lot of time in the room when we travel so overall if was just okay. If you’re looking for something with panache or luxury this isn’t it.

8

jennifer

Nov 2, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Great location just steps from the shops in Edgartown, yet very quiet and private. We had a very spacious room and parking was great.

10

Mark

Oct 18, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Lovely room, separate bedroom, and a fully equipped kitchen for cooking those large lobsters from the local fisheries in Menemsha. Clise to everything in Edgartown. A big plus was a parking space for the car. Rooms have private entrances. Almost dont want to write a great review, there may not be a room for me once this gem is discovered.

4

Akl

Jul 4, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

The property is very dated. Doors are squeaky, floor is uneven, furniture is old, mattress is not comfortable. AC is a window unit. On the ground floor you can’t open the shades if you want privacy and room is very small.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Service

Staff are frequently described as friendly, accommodating, and responsive by text. Downsides include limited on-site presence, occasional delays, and reports of no daily housekeeping.

Related guest reviews

6

Luigi

Oct 15, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Heat only 1 day out of 3, shower has a big gap probably soaking foundation or framing, no one on premises

8

Mary

Aug 26, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Very cute, comfortable beds, old fashioned, excellent cleaning staff, very friendly and nice.

10

Scott

Oct 2, 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Very nice property. They let us have our room early and store our luggage when we left. It’s not as big as it looks in the pictures but still very nice

8

PATRICIA

Aug 6, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

A great option if you are looking for a stay with a kitchen, living room area. New England charm. We had a few bumps with our stay. We were four people and had requested two extra pillows which took a few days to acquire. And unfortunately, the pullout sofa bed is an air mattress which sprung a lake and completely deflated the last night. That was a terrible situation for the two that slept out there. The difficulty is communicating with staff as they ask you to text. Customer service for a hotel really needs to be if not available in person certainly by phone. I’ve stayed here before and would I stay here again… Yes, I would. I’m sure they will make an accommodation for the situation. They’ve been helpful if not delayed so far.

10

Sapna

Aug 4, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

This is a road trip to Ed town. I must say lightkeepers in was a delight. They were super responsive. The accommodation was lovely and close to everything.

10

Tresa

Sep 8, 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Perfect location- very walkable to shopping and dining. Staff was always available via text and extremely accommodating. I’ll be back!

10

Taryn

Jul 31, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great stay! Incredible budget friendly option. Clean & convenient! Heidi is so helpful if you have any questions!

6

Elise

Sep 21, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

More like an air bnb than a hotel. No concierge or check in. They just five you a door code to access the room. No maid service or fresh towels. We only stayed 2 nights so perhaps that’s the policy but still… the pull out bed in the suite had a terrible mattress - springs poking out. On the bright side, the location is wonderful. Walk to town and all of Edgartown. We don’t spend a lot of time in the room when we travel so overall if was just okay. If you’re looking for something with panache or luxury this isn’t it.

10

John

Jul 22, 2024

·

Stayed 4 nights

Staff was very flexible and friendly. Room was exceptional, great location within walking distance to shopping, dining, and tours. Easy to catch public transportation to other towns on the island

10

Lalit

Apr 9, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

great staff, cozy, simple, convenient

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Location

Consistently praised for being a short, quiet walk to downtown Edgartown, shops, restaurants, the waterfront, and ferry or bus stops. Many appreciate the peaceful residential feel despite the central access.

Related guest reviews

10

Sarah

Jul 8, 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great stay and wonderful location close to stores and restaurants.

8

Robert

Sep 24, 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Location and neighborhood were quiet residential area outside of main tourist street.

10

Peter

Jul 21, 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Walking distance to coffee shops, restaurants, lighthouse beach; we were very happy with our stay. Look forward to visiting again next year.

10

Kasey

Jul 27, 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great location!

10

Tim

Jun 3, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Great locstaion. One block walk to downtown Edgartown. Upstairs unit with private deck was beautiful.

10

James

Oct 23, 2024

·

Stayed 5 nights

A lovely spot near the downtown, shopping, restaurants and the wharf. It had everything we needed.

6

William J

Sep 18, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Not fancy but cozy. Great location. Convenient Quiet.

8

jennifer

Nov 2, 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Great location just steps from the shops in Edgartown, yet very quiet and private. We had a very spacious room and parking was great.

10

Mark

Oct 18, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Lovely room, separate bedroom, and a fully equipped kitchen for cooking those large lobsters from the local fisheries in Menemsha. Clise to everything in Edgartown. A big plus was a parking space for the car. Rooms have private entrances. Almost dont want to write a great review, there may not be a room for me once this gem is discovered.

10

James

Jun 17, 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

Excellent place close to everything in Edgartown

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Dining

Not enough information in reviews.

Related guest reviews

10

Yota

Jul 5, 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

We loved the garden deck where we had dinner.

10

sharon

Aug 15, 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

The property looks much better than its pictures. It’s in a very good location, walkable to the ferry or the bus stop not to mention all the shopping and dining varieties. Our rooms were very clean, but there is carpet in the main living space. If you are a coffee drinker, bring your own. They provided an old style coffee maker, (not a Keurig) and the coffee was horrible. So we still had to go out for coffee.

10

Mark

Oct 18, 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

Lovely room, separate bedroom, and a fully equipped kitchen for cooking those large lobsters from the local fisheries in Menemsha. Clise to everything in Edgartown. A big plus was a parking space for the car. Rooms have private entrances. Almost dont want to write a great review, there may not be a room for me once this gem is discovered.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	19 $1,654
20 $427	21 $418	22 $418	23 $418	24 $384	25 $562	26 $755
27 $427	28 $478	29 $350	30 $350

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
				1 $350	2 $835	3 $834
4 $454	5 $454	6 $454	7 $339	8 $339	9 $790	10 $791
11 $293	12 $293	13 $249	14 $249	15 $249	16 $395	17 $395
18 $281	19 $281	20 $282	21 $281	22 $405	23 $454	24 $455
25 $351	26 $236	27 $236	28 $236	29 $236	30 $283	31 $282

The Lightkeeper’s Inn

About this property

Location

Room options

Deluxe Suite, 1 Queen Bed with Sofa Bed

Deluxe Suite, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed

Cottage, 1 King Bed with Sofa Bed

Guest reviews of The Lightkeeper’s Inn

Who stays here?

What guests think

Property Policies

Check-in instructions

Good to know

Optional extras

FAQs about The Lightkeeper’s Inn

Prices for upcoming dates