**CASA AMARILLA** Old Town Cottage & Pool + Last Key White Glove Service...
From
$823
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
$823
/ night
About this property
FLEXIBLE, NO-FEE CANCELLATION INCLUDED: Rentals are 100% Refundable until 30 days prior to your arrival!The moment you arrive at CASA AMARILLA and see the dual rocking chairs beckoning you to the front porch, you’ll feel the weight of the ...
Location
Located by the sea, this vacation home is in Old Town Key West, a neighborhood in Key West. Southernmost Point and Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum are notable landmarks, and the area's natural beauty can be seen at Florida Keys Beaches and Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park. Ready for a night out? Consider The Key West Theater and Sloppy Joe's Bar. Jet skiing and scuba diving offer great chances to get out on the surrounding water, or you can seek out an adventure with ecotours and cycling nearby.
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Coffee / Tea Maker
Cable / Satellite TV
Microwave
Hair Dryer
Guest reviews of **CASA AMARILLA** Old Town Cottage & Pool + Last Key White Glove Service...
9.9
Exceptional
Based on 23 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Travellers consistently praise **CASA AMARILLA @ DUVAL** Old Town Cottage & Private Pool + LAST KEY SERVICES for its walkable, quiet-end-of-Duval location, clean and comfortable interiors, and responsive support from Last Key’s team.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Travellers consistently praise **CASA AMARILLA @ DUVAL** Old Town Cottage & Private Pool + LAST KEY SERVICES for its walkable, quiet-end-of-Duval location, clean and comfortable interiors, and responsive support from Last Key’s team.
Many find the layout well suited to families or groups and appreciate the home being well stocked with useful extras and beach gear. Notes of caution include a small pool, occasional front-bedroom or daytime construction noise, and in one review uneven A/C between rooms plus wear on the outdoor shower decking. Overall, it delivers a relaxed, low-stress stay for couples, friends, or families.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
The private plunge pool is a popular perk for cooling off (some note it is small and that heating helps). Off street parking and well stocked beach gear and essentials add convenience.
Related guest reviews
10
Jamie K.
Jun 24, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Perfect spot to explore Key West! Plenty of room for our family to each have a private room The cottage was spotless and beautifully decorated We loved having the little pool to take a dip in when we needed to cool off.
Perfect spot to explore Key West! Plenty of room for our family to each have a private room The cottage was spotless and beautifully decorated We loved having the little pool to take a dip in when we needed to cool off.
10
Sandra W.
Aug 25, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Fantastic location! Cozy living room for game nights! The pool is tiny, but we made it work. The concierge team was fantastic and extremely responsive! We’ll come back!
Fantastic location! Cozy living room for game nights! The pool is tiny, but we made it work. The concierge team was fantastic and extremely responsive! We’ll come back!
10
Karen T.
Mar 29, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
10
MARC D.
Jun 27, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
It was nice having the pool after being in the heat all day.
It was nice having the pool after being in the heat all day.
10
Tamra T.
Sep 24, 2024
·
Stayed 5 nights
This was a girls trip. Big enough and comfortable for five girls. I have never stayed in a place that was so clean. This place is well equipped in the kitchen and bathrooms. The pool is small but is deep enough to get in and cool off. Less than a half block off of Devaul Street.
This was a girls trip. Big enough and comfortable for five girls. I have never stayed in a place that was so clean. This place is well equipped in the kitchen and bathrooms. The pool is small but is deep enough to get in and cool off. Less than a half block off of Devaul Street.
10
Tim W.
Jul 27, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Property was just as advertised. The a/c was cold, the house was stocked with necessities and toiletries. Fantastic!
Property was just as advertised. The a/c was cold, the house was stocked with necessities and toiletries. Fantastic!
10
Amy D.
Aug 23, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
10
Cassie P.
Nov 6, 2025
·
Stayed 6 nights
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
10
Isabel D.
Oct 16, 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
There were 5 of us on a girls trip , the house was plenty big & could have fit one more person. Clean, well furnished & charmingly appointed. There was space in the driveway for a Suburban AND a golf cart. Which on the island is essential, lol , both for parking & the golf cart, well , that’s just fun ! Worth it to get the pool heated….it felt great ! Also, this property comes with concierge service, and a perfectly wonderful house manager, Alice ! Easy to communicate with, responds instantly, & friendly ! No issues at all with the house , Another plus is the location !!! Within walking distance to Duval Street…Couldn’t have asked for a better home away from home. I would most certainly rent this property again ! !!
There were 5 of us on a girls trip , the house was plenty big & could have fit one more person. Clean, well furnished & charmingly appointed. There was space in the driveway for a Suburban AND a golf cart. Which on the island is essential, lol , both for parking & the golf cart, well , that’s just fun ! Worth it to get the pool heated….it felt great ! Also, this property comes with concierge service, and a perfectly wonderful house manager, Alice ! Easy to communicate with, responds instantly, & friendly ! No issues at all with the house , Another plus is the location !!! Within walking distance to Duval Street…Couldn’t have asked for a better home away from home. I would most certainly rent this property again ! !!
10
Nora K.
Mar 8, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Beautifully appointed home away from home. Fantastic location, walk everywhere or hop on free shuttle a block away for the Duvall Loop. We wanted a car for day trips, groceries, etc., and there was off street parking. We wanted for nothing! Good communication with host. Highly recommend!
Beautifully appointed home away from home. Fantastic location, walk everywhere or hop on free shuttle a block away for the Duvall Loop. We wanted a car for day trips, groceries, etc., and there was off street parking. We wanted for nothing! Good communication with host. Highly recommend!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Reviews repeatedly describe the house as very clean, spotless, and well kept. One review mentions worn decking at the outdoor shower, but overall standards read strong.
Related guest reviews
10
Jeron L.
Aug 14, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Very nice place, clean, and check in process was seamless
Very nice place, clean, and check in process was seamless
10
Diane M.
Mar 17, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Clean, comfortable and great location. Property manager was accessible and helpful.
Clean, comfortable and great location. Property manager was accessible and helpful.
10
Karen T.
Mar 29, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
10
Moriah H.
Mar 1, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
My family and I had a wonderful stay at Casa Amarilla. When we arrived, the house was clean and welcoming. All furniture was comfortable and clean. We never needed to go buy supplies as everything was right there ready for use. The location was great. It was close to Duval but was tucked away on a one way street. This gave my family and I plenty of quiet time. We loved Casa Amarilla and will be back.
My family and I had a wonderful stay at Casa Amarilla. When we arrived, the house was clean and welcoming. All furniture was comfortable and clean. We never needed to go buy supplies as everything was right there ready for use. The location was great. It was close to Duval but was tucked away on a one way street. This gave my family and I plenty of quiet time. We loved Casa Amarilla and will be back.
10
sue m.
Jan 23, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
The property was exactly as advertised. Perfect for our group of six adults. The location was convenient, and the house was clean.
The property was exactly as advertised. Perfect for our group of six adults. The location was convenient, and the house was clean.
10
Cassie P.
Nov 6, 2025
·
Stayed 6 nights
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
10
Robert K.
Aug 28, 2023
·
Stayed 8 nights
Nice clean place with everything you need in the perfect location. Everything was great!!
Nice clean place with everything you need in the perfect location. Everything was great!!
10
Alexandre P.
Sep 10, 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Clean, well situated, well stocked and beautifully decorated, the Casa Amarilla really met all our standards. Travelling with 4 children’s can be exhausting but when we got in the house, the professional service and good care of our host helped us making ourselves at « home ». We enjoyed our stay and would recommend warmly booking with the same team.
Clean, well situated, well stocked and beautifully decorated, the Casa Amarilla really met all our standards. Travelling with 4 children’s can be exhausting but when we got in the house, the professional service and good care of our host helped us making ourselves at « home ». We enjoyed our stay and would recommend warmly booking with the same team.
10
Lesley S.
Jun 29, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Was clean and up to date decor. Perfect for our weekend adult trip.
Was clean and up to date decor. Perfect for our weekend adult trip.
10
Nick D.
Dec 31, 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
Our family of 5 stayed here for 4 nights between Christmas and New Years. We enjoyed this location near the quieter end of Duval Street. The pool was not big, but our 3 kids (10, 8, and 5) really had fun swimming--the pool is heated which helped because our first 2 days were in the 60s. Highlights include walking to some great restaurants for dinner and a half-day sailing trip/eco-tour. The property was clean and kitchen had what we needed to make breakfast and lunch. One bedroom at the front of the house had some noise from the street, not unexpected and not enough to keep someone up all night. The back 2 bedrooms were perfectly quiet. We would stay here again.
Our family of 5 stayed here for 4 nights between Christmas and New Years. We enjoyed this location near the quieter end of Duval Street. The pool was not big, but our 3 kids (10, 8, and 5) really had fun swimming--the pool is heated which helped because our first 2 days were in the 60s. Highlights include walking to some great restaurants for dinner and a half-day sailing trip/eco-tour. The property was clean and kitchen had what we needed to make breakfast and lunch. One bedroom at the front of the house had some noise from the street, not unexpected and not enough to keep someone up all night. The back 2 bedrooms were perfectly quiet. We would stay here again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Guests find the cottage comfortable, well appointed, and suitable for groups, with layouts that work for multiple couples or families. A few note minor issues like uneven A/C between rooms and some front bedroom or daytime construction noise.
Related guest reviews
10
Anne B.
Jan 15, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This well-appointed property is just off Duval Street, yet street noise was never a problem! We walked to everything that we wanted to see in Key West, and loved having excellent Cuban coffee and breakfast just steps away. The property was very comfortable for 6 adults, with a charming back garden, a comfortable living room, and a larger than expected living room. Highly recommended!
This well-appointed property is just off Duval Street, yet street noise was never a problem! We walked to everything that we wanted to see in Key West, and loved having excellent Cuban coffee and breakfast just steps away. The property was very comfortable for 6 adults, with a charming back garden, a comfortable living room, and a larger than expected living room. Highly recommended!
10
Jamie K.
Jun 24, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Perfect spot to explore Key West! Plenty of room for our family to each have a private room The cottage was spotless and beautifully decorated We loved having the little pool to take a dip in when we needed to cool off.
Perfect spot to explore Key West! Plenty of room for our family to each have a private room The cottage was spotless and beautifully decorated We loved having the little pool to take a dip in when we needed to cool off.
10
Mark F.
Oct 12, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
10
Aida R.
Oct 21, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Loved the whole house. It was cute and quaint but very spacious for 6 people. The amenities were nice and the location was OUTSTANDING!! Walked almost everywhere.
Loved the whole house. It was cute and quaint but very spacious for 6 people. The amenities were nice and the location was OUTSTANDING!! Walked almost everywhere.
10
Edith D.
May 5, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Very nice house and close to activities. Air conditioning a little cold in some rooms while too warm in others was our only disappointment. We liked that it was one level. The pool was great for relaxing after a morning and early afternoon of touring.
Very nice house and close to activities. Air conditioning a little cold in some rooms while too warm in others was our only disappointment. We liked that it was one level. The pool was great for relaxing after a morning and early afternoon of touring.
10
Kaitlyn S.
May 26, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a group of 3 couple stay at Casa Amarillo and it was top notch. The house was perfect for what we needed. Great location to walk to the Southernmost points lots of coffee and breakfast options and obviously Duval street. Rooms were great, pool was beautiful and relaxing- a great little hidden oasis. Christian and his team were amazing hosts- very responsive, checked in daily, and left a lovely unexpected treat. We’ll definitely be back!
We had a group of 3 couple stay at Casa Amarillo and it was top notch. The house was perfect for what we needed. Great location to walk to the Southernmost points lots of coffee and breakfast options and obviously Duval street. Rooms were great, pool was beautiful and relaxing- a great little hidden oasis. Christian and his team were amazing hosts- very responsive, checked in daily, and left a lovely unexpected treat. We’ll definitely be back!
10
sue m.
Jan 23, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
The property was exactly as advertised. Perfect for our group of six adults. The location was convenient, and the house was clean.
The property was exactly as advertised. Perfect for our group of six adults. The location was convenient, and the house was clean.
10
Lesley S.
Jun 29, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Was clean and up to date decor. Perfect for our weekend adult trip.
Was clean and up to date decor. Perfect for our weekend adult trip.
10
Kathy B.
Dec 5, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Casa Amarilla was in a perfect location, less than a block from Duval St. on the quiet end. Central to everything we needed. Good layout for 2 couples.
Casa Amarilla was in a perfect location, less than a block from Duval St. on the quiet end. Central to everything we needed. Good layout for 2 couples.
10
Nick D.
Dec 31, 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
Our family of 5 stayed here for 4 nights between Christmas and New Years. We enjoyed this location near the quieter end of Duval Street. The pool was not big, but our 3 kids (10, 8, and 5) really had fun swimming--the pool is heated which helped because our first 2 days were in the 60s. Highlights include walking to some great restaurants for dinner and a half-day sailing trip/eco-tour. The property was clean and kitchen had what we needed to make breakfast and lunch. One bedroom at the front of the house had some noise from the street, not unexpected and not enough to keep someone up all night. The back 2 bedrooms were perfectly quiet. We would stay here again.
Our family of 5 stayed here for 4 nights between Christmas and New Years. We enjoyed this location near the quieter end of Duval Street. The pool was not big, but our 3 kids (10, 8, and 5) really had fun swimming--the pool is heated which helped because our first 2 days were in the 60s. Highlights include walking to some great restaurants for dinner and a half-day sailing trip/eco-tour. The property was clean and kitchen had what we needed to make breakfast and lunch. One bedroom at the front of the house had some noise from the street, not unexpected and not enough to keep someone up all night. The back 2 bedrooms were perfectly quiet. We would stay here again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Service from Last Key is praised as proactive and responsive, with smooth check in/out, regular check ins, concierge help, luggage storage, and useful recommendations. Hosts are frequently complimented.
Related guest reviews
10
Diane M.
Mar 17, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Clean, comfortable and great location. Property manager was accessible and helpful.
Clean, comfortable and great location. Property manager was accessible and helpful.
10
Carrie P.
May 7, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Casa Aramilla was the perfect location for our first family Key West trip. We easily walked to the southern most point and beach. We walked Duvall each evening. Also nice to relax by the pool. Great experience. Christian was on top of everything and very responsive. Would absolutely stay again.
Casa Aramilla was the perfect location for our first family Key West trip. We easily walked to the southern most point and beach. We walked Duvall each evening. Also nice to relax by the pool. Great experience. Christian was on top of everything and very responsive. Would absolutely stay again.
10
Mark F.
Oct 12, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
10
Amy D.
Aug 23, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
10
Kaitlyn S.
May 26, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a group of 3 couple stay at Casa Amarillo and it was top notch. The house was perfect for what we needed. Great location to walk to the Southernmost points lots of coffee and breakfast options and obviously Duval street. Rooms were great, pool was beautiful and relaxing- a great little hidden oasis. Christian and his team were amazing hosts- very responsive, checked in daily, and left a lovely unexpected treat. We’ll definitely be back!
We had a group of 3 couple stay at Casa Amarillo and it was top notch. The house was perfect for what we needed. Great location to walk to the Southernmost points lots of coffee and breakfast options and obviously Duval street. Rooms were great, pool was beautiful and relaxing- a great little hidden oasis. Christian and his team were amazing hosts- very responsive, checked in daily, and left a lovely unexpected treat. We’ll definitely be back!
10
Jeffery B.
Feb 20, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Christian with Last Key kept us informed before, during and after the rental period. The property was clean, modern and located just off Duval. No issues during the stay. Last Key provided convenient luggage storage prior to access to the property and then on departure. Would definitely recommend and will be returning !!!
Christian with Last Key kept us informed before, during and after the rental period. The property was clean, modern and located just off Duval. No issues during the stay. Last Key provided convenient luggage storage prior to access to the property and then on departure. Would definitely recommend and will be returning !!!
10
Terry F.
Jun 7, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this property. The staff of Last Key Realty did a great job from beginning to end.
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this property. The staff of Last Key Realty did a great job from beginning to end.
10
Joe T.
Mar 11, 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great place. Highly recommend. Last Key was very proactive and responsive.
Great place. Highly recommend. Last Key was very proactive and responsive.
10
David R.
Dec 30, 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
Brought my adult children for a Christmas weekend. Very nice, well provisioned house. Awesome location. Clean and as advertised. The Last Key folks were great. Have us some great restaurant recommendations.
Brought my adult children for a Christmas weekend. Very nice, well provisioned house. Awesome location. Clean and as advertised. The Last Key folks were great. Have us some great restaurant recommendations.
10
Jodi J.
Jul 16, 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
The house was just as described. Last Key was great to work with and they checked in during our stay to see if we needed anything. The a/c was perfect and much needed during our July stay. We used the included concierge service and they were very helpful.
The house was just as described. Last Key was great to work with and they checked in during our stay to see if we needed anything. The a/c was perfect and much needed during our July stay. We used the included concierge service and they were very helpful.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Excellent walkable spot just off the quieter end of Duval Street, close to Southernmost Point and many attractions, while generally remaining peaceful. A couple of reviews note some street noise in a front bedroom.
Related guest reviews
10
Anne B.
Jan 15, 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This well-appointed property is just off Duval Street, yet street noise was never a problem! We walked to everything that we wanted to see in Key West, and loved having excellent Cuban coffee and breakfast just steps away. The property was very comfortable for 6 adults, with a charming back garden, a comfortable living room, and a larger than expected living room. Highly recommended!
This well-appointed property is just off Duval Street, yet street noise was never a problem! We walked to everything that we wanted to see in Key West, and loved having excellent Cuban coffee and breakfast just steps away. The property was very comfortable for 6 adults, with a charming back garden, a comfortable living room, and a larger than expected living room. Highly recommended!
10
Randy E.
Dec 17, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
We spent a wonderful Thanksgiving weekend in Key West at the charming Casa Amarilla. The home is in a fantastic location and close to the action just off of Duval Street. The home was comfortable and convenient for our family of six. Last Key was professional, responsive and very helpful throughout our time in Key West. Highly recommend booking a home through them, including Casa Armailla. Every day should be a Key West day!
We spent a wonderful Thanksgiving weekend in Key West at the charming Casa Amarilla. The home is in a fantastic location and close to the action just off of Duval Street. The home was comfortable and convenient for our family of six. Last Key was professional, responsive and very helpful throughout our time in Key West. Highly recommend booking a home through them, including Casa Armailla. Every day should be a Key West day!
10
Karen T.
Mar 29, 2023
·
Stayed 5 nights
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
The property was just as listed. It was immaculate and well furnished. The beds were comfortable. The deck on the back was like a tropical hideaway. We were smart to get the small pool heated. The quieter end of Duval Street was about 100 yards away. We were able to walk everywhere. We were also glad to have a small driveway to park one car. The house came with five beach chairs. Would definitely stay there again.
10
Mark F.
Oct 12, 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
Exactly as advertised. This house was perfect for our family trip to Key West. Close to Duval St. but not so close that you could hear the noise. The house is well appointed and very, very comfortable. Really appreciated the seamless checkin and checkout process and the daily text communication. Highly recommend it!
10
Aida R.
Oct 21, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Loved the whole house. It was cute and quaint but very spacious for 6 people. The amenities were nice and the location was OUTSTANDING!! Walked almost everywhere.
Loved the whole house. It was cute and quaint but very spacious for 6 people. The amenities were nice and the location was OUTSTANDING!! Walked almost everywhere.
10
Amy D.
Aug 23, 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
We loved Casa Amarilla. The location was close to everything. The house was well appointed, nicely renovated, and the staff left everything we needed for a great vacation. The plunge pool was great for a hot summer day. Great service from Last Key too. Highly recommend!
10
Aaron
Jun 15, 2023
·
This place was great! It was 2 blocks from the southernmost point and we could walk or easily get transportation to anywhere. We would definitely stay here again! The pool was perfect after a day or walking around.
This place was great! It was 2 blocks from the southernmost point and we could walk or easily get transportation to anywhere. We would definitely stay here again! The pool was perfect after a day or walking around.
10
Eric B.
Aug 26, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
House was as described and in a good location 1/2 a block off of Duval street. Would stay at again.
House was as described and in a good location 1/2 a block off of Duval street. Would stay at again.
10
Cassie P.
Nov 6, 2025
·
Stayed 6 nights
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
Beautiful place to stay, the location is perfect, the house is clean and was perfect for our family. The pool was amazing and we loved it!
10
Kathy B.
Dec 5, 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Casa Amarilla was in a perfect location, less than a block from Duval St. on the quiet end. Central to everything we needed. Good layout for 2 couples.
Casa Amarilla was in a perfect location, less than a block from Duval St. on the quiet end. Central to everything we needed. Good layout for 2 couples.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Not enough information in reviews.
Related guest reviews
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Sean C.
Jun 6, 2026
·
Stayed 4 nights
Our family had an awesome stay at Casa Amarilla!! The house was very clean and perfectly located on the island (close enough to all the entertainment on Duval but not too close). Christian was a great help and checked in regularly to make sure we had all we need. No need to rent a car if you are just staying inKW. We Ubered or walked everywhere we went without issue. We can’t wait to come back and would definitely stay at Casa Amarilla again.
Our family had an awesome stay at Casa Amarilla!! The house was very clean and perfectly located on the island (close enough to all the entertainment on Duval but not too close). Christian was a great help and checked in regularly to make sure we had all we need. No need to rent a car if you are just staying inKW. We Ubered or walked everywhere we went without issue. We can’t wait to come back and would definitely stay at Casa Amarilla again.
10
candace b.
May 30, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
The host was super responsive, even late at night when we could not find the apartment. Everything was clean and as it should have been, I would rent this property again.
The host was super responsive, even late at night when we could not find the apartment. Everything was clean and as it should have been, I would rent this property again.
10
Dawn A.
Apr 26, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
Beautiful house just off of Duval street. Easy walking to shopping and restaurants. House was perfectly clean, plenty of linens. The property managers contacted us daily to make sure everything was going well. We added a late check out which was great for a later flight out of Key West. Our party was 5 adults and we were extremely comfortable. Pool was lovely with a great outdoor area and shower. We would definitely consider staying here again in the future versus a hotel room.
Beautiful house just off of Duval street. Easy walking to shopping and restaurants. House was perfectly clean, plenty of linens. The property managers contacted us daily to make sure everything was going well. We added a late check out which was great for a later flight out of Key West. Our party was 5 adults and we were extremely comfortable. Pool was lovely with a great outdoor area and shower. We would definitely consider staying here again in the future versus a hotel room.
10
Nelson V.
Apr 10, 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
Host was outstanding, wonderful backyard with pool and one block from Duval St. The six of us enjoyed our stay
Host was outstanding, wonderful backyard with pool and one block from Duval St. The six of us enjoyed our stay
10
Lauren G.
Mar 5, 2026
·
Stayed 5 nights
Everything was smooth and easy. The Last Key team was attentive and the house was well taken care of. Would definitely book again.
Everything was smooth and easy. The Last Key team was attentive and the house was well taken care of. Would definitely book again.
Property Policies
Check-in
Check-out
Check-in from 16:00
Before 10:00
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 25 years old.
Popular amenities
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Coffee / Tea Maker
Cable / Satellite TV
Microwave
Hair Dryer
General
Pet Friendly
Refrigerator
Cable / Satellite TV
Coffee / Tea Maker
Microwave
Hair Dryer
Desk
Towels
Shared Bathroom
Ice Machine
Smoke-Free Property
Activities
Scuba Diving
Fishing
Ecotours on Site
Outdoor heated pool
Tennis Courts (on site)
Services
Laundry Facilities
Internet
Free Wi-Fi