Theater Motel

Beautiful, peaceful property with very nice owners. Cant wait to go back

Love the motel setup. Was very quiet. Had a family emergency and had to leave in the night, but check-in was great and loved the room and what was available in it.

Very nice property.

Very enjoyable stay for 3 nights. Everything clean, friendly helpful staff. Room a little dated but in good condition. Love the outdoor space. Would definitely stay again.

What a gem! I typically stick with one of the big hotel chains but decided to give this a try based on reviews. Sooo glad I did. Charming place, fantastic rooms (dining table and a desk in addition to the two beds!), no stairs, parking right outside your room, clean and overall a win!

The Theater Motel is family-owned and operated. Staying here feels like a nostalgic mid-century experience from decor to the warm hospitality. The rooms are always clean, tidy, and comfortable. The grounds are well maintained and offer a cute gazebo for gathering with friends, a small child-friendly playground, BBQ, and plenty of parking. It is quaint, quiet, and very affordable. It is my 'go-to' motel when visiting SUNY Fredonia, which is only a 20 minute drive. No frills, no fuss, but always satisfied.

Owners are very friendly. Property is very nice. Very relaxing stay.

Quiet and safe location. Owners were very friendly and helpful. Room was clean, had a fridge, microwave sink and TV worked just fine. Bed was clean and comfy. Best value and owner operated so you can see they care about running a good business.

Great room, staff very helpful and nice, lots of outdoor lighting.

This was a quick one-night stop on a road trip to Maine. We arrived late, but the manager was ready and expecting us. His friendly smile made us feel very welcome. The property is interesting, if not a little bit quirky. But everything was clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. The room is a delightful mixture of retro styling (bathroom tiles colors are very 60s-70s) and modern comfort (new bed with memory foam mattress topper). And it's a quick drive to the downtown of Westfield, NY, which is quaint and has a great little coffee shop, not to mention that it's a 5-minute drive to the Lake Erie shore. We'd stay here again if our itinerary called for it. Thanks!

The owner was always delightful to talk with and never without a smile. Everyone made sure we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The room was spotless and was the perfect fit for what we were looking for.

Very nice for price. Very clean and spacious. Perfect place to stop for a night. The only complaint was the very musty/mildewy smell. The carpets looked clean, but smelled old. Used my own Febreze, but it was only a temporary fix.

Clean, comfortable overnight stay !!

Spotless, friendly staff, comfortable bed, great price for the area and weekend. Conveniently near a Tim Horton’s ;-)

The room was spotless at arrival. The staff was helpful every step of the way. They made us feel very welcome. The motel is beautiful and has a perfect spot to watch the sunset.

The room was clean, however we had mosquitos and other bugs flying around in our room. We had a window AC unit, so I am assuming it wasn't sealed properly and that's how the bugs were getting in. Also, the AC unit was so loud that we were unable to get good sleep, but if you turned it off, then the room became very warm and muggy. We ended up getting up earlier than planned and left because we were unable to get any sleep

Older place but very clean

Clean and yes, basic - but clean!

Very clean and well cared for. Owners are super nice and friendly. Whenever we come to Westfield this is the only place we stay

Very friendly welcome. Property and room are very clean and well-maintained. This is a solid no-frills, perfectly functional place to stay. Would 100% stay again if I am in the area.

Owner is friendly and accommodating. Room was spotless and had a fridge microwave and sink. Shower pressure and water temp is great. Only downside is wifi wouldn’t connect and unable to get regular cell service. Highly recommend!

Nice motel, but VERY noisy A/C units.

The only negative that I have is that the a/c unit for our room ( number 25) seemed a bit overwhelmed later in the day if the temperature got in the upper 80s. Great stay other than that.

What a gem! I typically stick with one of the big hotel chains but decided to give this a try based on reviews. Sooo glad I did. Charming place, fantastic rooms (dining table and a desk in addition to the two beds!), no stairs, parking right outside your room, clean and overall a win!

There is a train track really close to the motel. And freight trains come every 10-15 minutes (I am not exaggerating). If you are a light sleeper, this may be a problem. The owner was super nice to give me a room as far away from the tracks as possible but it is still very loud. I solved the problem with ear plugs, a pillow over my head, and white noise. So, in the end it was not a problem :)

Room is old and could use a decor upgrade BUT the bed was comfortable, AC was cold and water pressure was excellent. It isn’t pretty but it does the job.

The room was clean, however we had mosquitos and other bugs flying around in our room. We had a window AC unit, so I am assuming it wasn't sealed properly and that's how the bugs were getting in. Also, the AC unit was so loud that we were unable to get good sleep, but if you turned it off, then the room became very warm and muggy. We ended up getting up earlier than planned and left because we were unable to get any sleep

Simple, a step back in time. But clean, large room, with kitchenette, fridge microwave and dining table and comfortable bed. Would stop here again!

Dated, clean room with comfortable bed and all necessary amenities(coffee pot, ice fridge, microwave, shampoo.

The owner was very friendly and welcoming. Our room with 1 queen bed was a good size and very clean. The carpet looked new, bed, bedding, and pillows were clean and comfortable. Towels were average, bathroom sink had no place to put any of our travel items. Shower had good pressure and hot water. Simple, clean, just what we expected. Good location for the Erie Wine Trail, and a couple of good restaurants in Westfield. Our only complaints was the sound of trains coming by several times during the night!

The owner was always delightful to talk with and never without a smile. Everyone made sure we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The room was spotless and was the perfect fit for what we were looking for.

Excellent customer service. My flight was delayed 2 hours from Buffalo airport and I arrived at the motel at 3am. I called in advance to let them know and they had my room ready and unlocked for me when I got there. Thank you.

Fine, good value for the price. Didn’t stay long and struggled to contact the owners when we arrived very late due to bad traffic but eventually got hold of them and were able to access the property.

The room was spotless at arrival. The staff was helpful every step of the way. They made us feel very welcome. The motel is beautiful and has a perfect spot to watch the sunset.

Buyer beware. The pictures shown have to be at least 20 years old. The entire place is very rundown. My room flooring is broken in places. Cabinet doors don’t have hinges. Walls are stained. Bathroom door looks to have been punched. They advertise a daily continental breakfast. That’s what I put in the search parameters on Travelocity. The first morning I went to get something (around 7am) and there was nothing out. I asked the man at the desk when are they putting it out. He said they stopped when Covid started. He offered me a protein bar. I passed on that. At check in I asked if there was daily housekeeping. Normally not but they could schedule that for me so I asked them to do so. On second day I returned in the evening and the room had not been cleaned. I went to the check in area and asked why the room was not cleaned. The same woman that checked me in said she just got there and wasn’t responsible for that day’s schedule. So I asked to please have the room cleaned the next day (today). I went to the desk this morning and that same woman was there and showed me my room was on the schedule to be cleaned. I went out for the day and just returned this evening at 8pm and the room was not cleaned. I went to the desk and got towels. I’m leaving tomorrow morning early and I’m relieved to go. The only saving grace was the bed which was surprisingly comfortable. It was relatively cheap to stay but not worth the aggravation.

The front desk worker was very friendly, and check-in was pleasant. The room, however, was extremely musty.. The heat did not work, and we were cold all night. The linens were sneezy. The shower was dripping throughout the night. When I went to take a shower in the morning, brown water and chunks came out of the bath faucet, and the shower aspect would not turn on. We called the front deak, and they came over with tools and fixed it within twenty minutes, which was nice, but then there was not enough hot water for even one of our paety of five to take a shower. We were told we would get a credit, but that did not happen. Very bizarre experience.

Owner is very nice and remembered me from a previous stay over a year ago. Got to my room, but the wifi was really weak. Owner was very understanding and switched me to a different room with a much stronger signal. Great service! Room is simple but exactly what I needed for just an overnight to break up a long drive.

The owners were such lovely people and very accommodating. I am from out of town and they made my stay in New York a wonderful experience.

Very clean and well cared for. Owners are super nice and friendly. Whenever we come to Westfield this is the only place we stay

Very friendly welcome. Property and room are very clean and well-maintained. This is a solid no-frills, perfectly functional place to stay. Would 100% stay again if I am in the area.

It was a decent motel for the money. Convenient to the town and nearby wineries. The rooms a bit outdated but clean

Nice, clean, quiet classic motel near a town with good restaurants.

We enjoyed our stay at The Theater Motel, it is an incredible value, it is very clean, in a nice quiet surrounding.

The Theater Motel is family-owned and operated. Staying here feels like a nostalgic mid-century experience from decor to the warm hospitality. The rooms are always clean, tidy, and comfortable. The grounds are well maintained and offer a cute gazebo for gathering with friends, a small child-friendly playground, BBQ, and plenty of parking. It is quaint, quiet, and very affordable. It is my 'go-to' motel when visiting SUNY Fredonia, which is only a 20 minute drive. No frills, no fuss, but always satisfied.

The room was very clean and the bed was ok, just a bit firmer than I like. It was very quiet even though my room was next to the highway. Westfield is a really pretty town with several restaurants and a Welch's grape factory tour nearby. It's also fairly close to Lake Chautauqua & Jamestown

There is a train track really close to the motel. And freight trains come every 10-15 minutes (I am not exaggerating). If you are a light sleeper, this may be a problem. The owner was super nice to give me a room as far away from the tracks as possible but it is still very loud. I solved the problem with ear plugs, a pillow over my head, and white noise. So, in the end it was not a problem :)

close to fishing will stay there again

It was just average and kind of out of the way. Basic room nothing special. Very close to train tracks. Several trains came through during the night The owner was very nice but seemed surprised that we had booked his motel the same day.

This was a quick one-night stop on a road trip to Maine. We arrived late, but the manager was ready and expecting us. His friendly smile made us feel very welcome. The property is interesting, if not a little bit quirky. But everything was clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. The room is a delightful mixture of retro styling (bathroom tiles colors are very 60s-70s) and modern comfort (new bed with memory foam mattress topper). And it's a quick drive to the downtown of Westfield, NY, which is quaint and has a great little coffee shop, not to mention that it's a 5-minute drive to the Lake Erie shore. We'd stay here again if our itinerary called for it. Thanks!

Quiet, relaxed, friendly staff, close to dining options in town and an excellent shower

Very clean carpeted room with very comfy beds and very good TV service. Lots of land to walk around the property. Good shower, bar fridge and microwave. Coffee maker in the room was basic and lots of ice was available. No breakfast but for the price in the vineyards of Western NY we would definitely stay here again.

Nice, clean, quiet classic motel near a town with good restaurants.

Nice, basic vintage motel with good prices and a safe area. Local restaurants are usually closed, though, leaving McDonalds as the only choice.

The room was very clean and the bed was ok, just a bit firmer than I like. It was very quiet even though my room was next to the highway. Westfield is a really pretty town with several restaurants and a Welch's grape factory tour nearby. It's also fairly close to Lake Chautauqua & Jamestown

Buyer beware. The pictures shown have to be at least 20 years old. The entire place is very rundown. My room flooring is broken in places. Cabinet doors don’t have hinges. Walls are stained. Bathroom door looks to have been punched. They advertise a daily continental breakfast. That’s what I put in the search parameters on Travelocity. The first morning I went to get something (around 7am) and there was nothing out. I asked the man at the desk when are they putting it out. He said they stopped when Covid started. He offered me a protein bar. I passed on that. At check in I asked if there was daily housekeeping. Normally not but they could schedule that for me so I asked them to do so. On second day I returned in the evening and the room had not been cleaned. I went to the check in area and asked why the room was not cleaned. The same woman that checked me in said she just got there and wasn’t responsible for that day’s schedule. So I asked to please have the room cleaned the next day (today). I went to the desk this morning and that same woman was there and showed me my room was on the schedule to be cleaned. I went out for the day and just returned this evening at 8pm and the room was not cleaned. I went to the desk and got towels. I’m leaving tomorrow morning early and I’m relieved to go. The only saving grace was the bed which was surprisingly comfortable. It was relatively cheap to stay but not worth the aggravation.

The owner was so nice and the room was perfect! It had everything I needed and was close to several restaurants and stores. Highly recommend!

it was close to everything

This was a quick one-night stop on a road trip to Maine. We arrived late, but the manager was ready and expecting us. His friendly smile made us feel very welcome. The property is interesting, if not a little bit quirky. But everything was clean, comfortable, and well-maintained. The room is a delightful mixture of retro styling (bathroom tiles colors are very 60s-70s) and modern comfort (new bed with memory foam mattress topper). And it's a quick drive to the downtown of Westfield, NY, which is quaint and has a great little coffee shop, not to mention that it's a 5-minute drive to the Lake Erie shore. We'd stay here again if our itinerary called for it. Thanks!

The owner was very friendly and welcoming. Our room with 1 queen bed was a good size and very clean. The carpet looked new, bed, bedding, and pillows were clean and comfortable. Towels were average, bathroom sink had no place to put any of our travel items. Shower had good pressure and hot water. Simple, clean, just what we expected. Good location for the Erie Wine Trail, and a couple of good restaurants in Westfield. Our only complaints was the sound of trains coming by several times during the night!

Quiet, relaxed, friendly staff, close to dining options in town and an excellent shower