Name: Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
Address: 290 Old Montauk Highway, New York, United States of America, Suffolk County, US
Price range: US$453–US$986 per night
Rating: 8.03

What guests think

At Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, travelers consistently praise the beachfront location and views, spa and bathhouse, and many friendly staff, while repeated critiques cite ongoing construction and closures, dated or noisy rooms with maintenance issues, and high prices.

Cleanliness and upkeep vary, with reports of dirty or musty items, bugs, and late or inconsistent housekeeping alongside spotless stays. Service is mixed: some guests note welcoming staff, helpful managers, upgrades, and early check-ins, while others encounter rude or disorganized teams, slow responses, and problems with valet or billing. Dining ranges from very good at Scarpetta to average, with options occasionally limited, and the spread out, stair heavy layout means long walks. Expect superb ocean frontage with amenities, but uneven execution.

Facilities

Cleanliness

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Facilities

Spa, bathhouse, pool, and direct beach access are highlights mentioned repeatedly. However, ongoing construction has closed or limited areas and created noise, and guests report valet or parking confusion plus long walks and many stairs across the property.

Related guest reviews

8

Kathryn

30 Mar 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Lots of construction!

8

Emily

12 May 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

I liked everything except the valet parking because the guys don't take care of the cars. They left the light on and my car ran out of battery. Plus, they hit the handbrake and moved the car like that and ruined my traction.

8

Irina

28 Apr 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The resort is well established and well known. We always came to spend time and eat at the hotel’s restaurant. This year we needed to get away from our regular routine and stress. Upon arrival we found out that the entire lobby, lounge area and the restaurant is apparently closed for renovation. It’s a huge disappointment not to mention the noise coming from construction at 7 am. Rude awakening so to say… I just think that this kind of situation can’t be hidden from guests . Yes, there is still a small restaurant and a spa, but it’s not the same . The price should reflect all changes mentioned above. And the entire project should be disclosed before arrival.

10

Darryl

29 Sept 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

wonderful place only criticism is how far away rooms are from lobby and the rest of the facilities

8

Anthony

14 Jul 2025

·

Stayed 5 nights

the property is beautiful however there was construction being done upon the premises and certain areas were closed off

2

Deanella

8 Sept 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Our experience was horrible our room had roaches . When I called to tell them I wasn’t staying in the room they gave us another room I asked to speak to management and they never showed face the front desk was very unprofessional . If you are handicapped or with special needs don’t stay here as the facility isn’t handicap friendly. Only area is the pool and that’s basically it the lift is full of bugs and webs . They have steps in all there designated areas . I was very disappointed and don’t recommend this place no management skills and they need to better train there employees when we asked security where a room was he said I don’t know it’s my first day how are you security and have no knowledge of the property this tells me someone didn’t train him. Very disappointing we had such high expectations of this place

6

paul

6 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 4 nights

Still under construction. Very pricey.

10

Matthew

8 Jul 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Bath house was a game changer that had a sauna and cold plunge

2

robin

28 Mar 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

nobody said it was under construction !!!! but expedia should have told me when i booked bec i would have NEVRT gone to gurneys the beautiful restaurant it’s known for was demolished along with the bar and coffee shop .. very disappointed ☹️

10

Stacy

16 Jun 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Gurney's is perfect for a short reset by the sea with wonderful spa and pool. Restaurant onsite is v. good.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Cleanliness

Reviews are split: some describe spotless rooms, while others report dirty towels or robes, odors, bugs, and late, inconsistent housekeeping, plus occasional unclean public bathrooms.

Related guest reviews

8

Kristopher

25 Aug 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

It was clean and staff is very nice

10

Rudy

7 Jan 2023

·

Stayed 19,362 nights

If you’re looking for a beach front hotel with all the bells and whistles this is your spot. Spotless clean room and incredible atmosphere.

8

Fedaa

11 Sept 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beautiful location on the beach. We had a great room with an amazing view but upon checking into the room we were greeting with an unflushed toilet full of urine and cigarette butts.

2

Deanella

8 Sept 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Our experience was horrible our room had roaches . When I called to tell them I wasn’t staying in the room they gave us another room I asked to speak to management and they never showed face the front desk was very unprofessional . If you are handicapped or with special needs don’t stay here as the facility isn’t handicap friendly. Only area is the pool and that’s basically it the lift is full of bugs and webs . They have steps in all there designated areas . I was very disappointed and don’t recommend this place no management skills and they need to better train there employees when we asked security where a room was he said I don’t know it’s my first day how are you security and have no knowledge of the property this tells me someone didn’t train him. Very disappointing we had such high expectations of this place

4

Ana Maria

29 Jun 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

A/C was so incredibly loud we could not keep it on while in the room. Safe was out of battery and didn’t work. Bathroom door didn’t close. Room was not made up until we got back at 5 pm and called 3 times to request someone come replenish the shampoo and water and maybe make the bed. Other days was done around 4pm, sloppily. Food ordered often came without cutlery or cups or napkins. Sunday night there was a wedding in the oceanfront venue which was right above our room. Could not head ourselves tall until past 11; no notice about this. Tipped $20 to the man taking out our luggage for checkout to put it in the car: we started driving only to realize he just dumped it by the door, never actually loaded the car if we didn’t check it would have been left there

4

Kaye

5 Dec 2022

·

Stayed 1 night

Super overrated! Rooms were small and very motelish. We ended up leaving. Bathroom upon arrival in the lobby had not been cleaned during the day.

4

marcee

22 Sept 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

I was very disappointed. Not sure if it was because of the end of the season. We had a dirty robe that had makeup on it in the bathroom and a dirty towel that was folded back up and stuck in with the clean towels. Knew it was dirty by the sour smell compared to the other ones. It was extremely noisy and we weren’t warned about the noise that night. We know Montauk has a noise ordnance and this exceeded it. Very disappointing for the cost.

6

Cantrice

21 Jun 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

Rooms took over an hour to be ready upon check in once checked in bathrooms dirty. Previous guest used towels left in the bathroom.

6

Qiutong

29 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Valet parking process wasn’t clear and we had to retrieve our bags from the car after checking in. Room looks old and bathroom had bad smell.

4

Kerry

29 Oct 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Thebroom we were in was outdated. There were bugs in the room, NOT bed bugs. The shower has loose falling tiles. The bathroom was teeny tine

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Rooms

Many like the ocean views and some rooms are spacious and comfortable, but others find accommodations dated with uncomfortable beds, noise from neighbors or events, and HVAC problems. Several guests also felt ocean view categories were misleading.

Related guest reviews

2

Grigory

8 Jun 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Beautiful resort, one of the best in the area. Not the first time staying here, but this time the description of the room was absolutely misleading. Room 601 that suppose to have “partial ocean view”, turned out to have no view whatsoever, being on ground level and surrounded by bushes. For almost $900 a night, very disappointing!

8

Casey

18 May 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Great property but lots of trucks in the parking lot outside my “ocean view” which made it noisy

8

Deborah

15 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Gurney's is located directly on the beach in Montauk, NY. The setting is nice but the prices are high. Our one bedroom room had a nice view but the king bed was soft and saggy - very uncomfortable. The sofa bed was uncomfortable as well. The maid service was superior. The resort fees are high but the yoga was good. The restaurant, Scarpetta Beach, was very overpriced but the service was excellent. I would recommend the Short Rib & Bone Marrow Agnolotti but it costs $39 for pasta.

6

Jamie

19 May 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

We booked a room with an ocean view. Was great but the AC in our room wasn’t properly functioning. We informed the front desk who indicated it would be promptly services. It wasn’t. We waited for three hours to have someone check it out. We called again. Technician came. Room was hovering around 79 degrees. We later asked to move rooms. We moved (ourselves no offer to help us move). Same issue. We called again (third time), then were moved to the “renovated” side with working AC but to a lesser room. It’s a great place overall but we were disappointed with the service in terms of hearing our gripe and not doing much about it. On a short weekend getaway it ate a lot of our short window to deal with this multiple times and with very little attention from the staff. Otherwise everything else was very good. Perhaps the resort should install modern hvac units in the unrenovated rooms.

8

Eugene

24 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

I booked an ocean view which is across the parking and maybe if u look just right you will see a the ocean so we had to pay an additional $100 for an actual ocean view otherwise the property is great

10

Kenny

2 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Excellent location on the beach. Spacious accommodations. Excellent service.

4

Hiu

6 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Room was noisy due to footsteps above and was only given a choice to downgrade our room

10

Roxanna

29 Mar 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

The hotel rooms are beautiful and comfortable. We booked the double room for 6 of us and it was comfortable and spacious.

6

Anthony

19 Feb 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

No heat in my room. Absolutely one of the worst responses to a legitimate complaint of being in a cold room late at night with no where to go. Still haven’t heard back from Expedia or the resort. Paid a lot of money to be sitting and waiting in my coat for the resort to do something.

6

Dean

2 Nov 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Expensive for what it is - rooms are tired and have poor polyester sheets and pillow - super uncomfortable

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Service

Service feedback is mixed: numerous mentions of friendly, accommodating staff, upgrades, and helpful managers contrast with reports of rudeness or disorganization, slow issue resolution, long check-ins, valet mishaps, and billing errors.

Related guest reviews

10

Cecilia

5 Nov 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

The staff was very friendly and the receptionist upgraded our room since the hotel was not as busy and it was wonderful.

10

Jason

13 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

Gurneys Inn was a beautiful place to stay. The staff extremely attentive and friendly!

4

Lenilson S. Caeiro

30 Jul 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

It took us 40minutes to check in, for an already late check in at 4pm.

2

Naiem

14 Sept 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Rude disorganized staff. Check in process was absolutely hideous. They put us in three different rooms and couldn’t manage to figure out which room is the proper one. They told us the air conditioning and one is broken. They did not offer any discounts. The bartending staff at the outside fire pit facility is absolutely rude and unfriendly.

8

Emily

12 May 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

I liked everything except the valet parking because the guys don't take care of the cars. They left the light on and my car ran out of battery. Plus, they hit the handbrake and moved the car like that and ruined my traction.

6

Anthony

19 Feb 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

No heat in my room. Absolutely one of the worst responses to a legitimate complaint of being in a cold room late at night with no where to go. Still haven’t heard back from Expedia or the resort. Paid a lot of money to be sitting and waiting in my coat for the resort to do something.

4

Ana Maria

29 Jun 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

A/C was so incredibly loud we could not keep it on while in the room. Safe was out of battery and didn’t work. Bathroom door didn’t close. Room was not made up until we got back at 5 pm and called 3 times to request someone come replenish the shampoo and water and maybe make the bed. Other days was done around 4pm, sloppily. Food ordered often came without cutlery or cups or napkins. Sunday night there was a wedding in the oceanfront venue which was right above our room. Could not head ourselves tall until past 11; no notice about this. Tipped $20 to the man taking out our luggage for checkout to put it in the car: we started driving only to realize he just dumped it by the door, never actually loaded the car if we didn’t check it would have been left there

8

Jennifer

22 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

Although there were some initial hiccups, overall we had a pleasant stay. This was definitely due to Jennifer, the assistant front desk manager, who took our complaint seriously and did everything in her power to rectify it. So even in spite of the initial challenges I would stay here again. Thank you for making our stay pleasant Jennifer

10

Stuart Philip

22 Nov 2023

·

Stayed 4 nights

The Staff are what make this place the breakfast staff amazing and the reception. I travel all over the world and it’s so refreshing to stay outside of the Marriot and Hilton groups. I enjoyed my 4 days there it was fantastic and relaxing well done keep up the work

10

richard

27 Apr 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

front desk staff irritating as can be

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Location

Beachfront setting with beautiful ocean views and a relaxed, quiet atmosphere at certain times of year. The property involves many stairs and distances that some found challenging.

Related guest reviews

8

John

15 Oct 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Last minute trip from the city for a relaxing getaway. We know the location is perfect and it was, remote relaxed and easy. The best part was the Spa, recently renovated and it was truly nice. 90 min massage was perfect and gym was useful also, nice pool. The room was less than expected, maybe because we had a pet the room was less nice but at Ritz Carlton prices you expect more. Heat was not working, room was just adequate and towels were not good quality. Staff everywhere was very nice and responsive. Due to rain eating venue was limited to one and not able to accommodate all guests with little places to have a drink to wait. Maybe next time we come without our pet and see how it goes.

10

Andrew

3 Sept 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

After Labor Day it’s very quiet and it feels like you have the resort all to yourself.

8

Deborah

15 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Gurney's is located directly on the beach in Montauk, NY. The setting is nice but the prices are high. Our one bedroom room had a nice view but the king bed was soft and saggy - very uncomfortable. The sofa bed was uncomfortable as well. The maid service was superior. The resort fees are high but the yoga was good. The restaurant, Scarpetta Beach, was very overpriced but the service was excellent. I would recommend the Short Rib & Bone Marrow Agnolotti but it costs $39 for pasta.

10

Ranvir

28 Nov 2024

·

Stayed 3 nights

Beautiful views. Great staff and amenities.

8

ROBIN

2 Oct 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

October 2nd 2024 safe and quiet thru the week 187 resort fee extra to charge on expeedia Lots of stairs Bike to montauk pretty reasonable

8

Eugene

24 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

I booked an ocean view which is across the parking and maybe if u look just right you will see a the ocean so we had to pay an additional $100 for an actual ocean view otherwise the property is great

10

Kenny

2 Jun 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

Excellent location on the beach. Spacious accommodations. Excellent service.

10

lisa

13 Nov 2023

·

Stayed 5 nights

location, location, location !!!! outstanding views!!! only downside ??? stairs, and alot of them !!! but they do keep you in shape !!

6

Lisbeth Ann

5 Sept 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

Eh, the greatest thing about Gurney’s is the location. After being a guest after 10 years, I’m not feeling it anymore. It’s a nice enough resort however, the food at Scarpetta’s is average. There’s no selection and the menu hasn’t changed in forever. The spa is way overpriced and I am a New Yorker. The rooms are beaten up, even though they had a recent renovation. Try it if you want to however, I’ll be finding a new resort to go to in Montauk.

8

Darlene

26 Nov 2023

·

Stayed 3 nights

Gorgeous location!

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Dining

Scarpetta is often praised, but food and drinks are expensive and alternatives can feel limited at times. Some guests noted closures reducing options and occasional lapses like charged orders not delivered.

Related guest reviews

8

John

15 Oct 2023

·

Stayed 2 nights

Last minute trip from the city for a relaxing getaway. We know the location is perfect and it was, remote relaxed and easy. The best part was the Spa, recently renovated and it was truly nice. 90 min massage was perfect and gym was useful also, nice pool. The room was less than expected, maybe because we had a pet the room was less nice but at Ritz Carlton prices you expect more. Heat was not working, room was just adequate and towels were not good quality. Staff everywhere was very nice and responsive. Due to rain eating venue was limited to one and not able to accommodate all guests with little places to have a drink to wait. Maybe next time we come without our pet and see how it goes.

2

Leonard

30 Jul 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

This is probable the worst resort ever ! I booked online a room for 2 adults and 2 kids and they give me a room with 1 bed and 1 couch and they dont even provide you with blankets and on top of that they charge you 20% more of what you paid online. I get it its the hamptons but you do not get what you pay for and if you want to use the cabbanas at the beach they want $800 for it and you order drinks at the beach they charge you but you never get the drinks and on top of EVERYTHING the place is under construction there is huge noise dust the whole area smells like paint but what you gonna do. This was my second time here and my last. For the money that you gonna spend here for 2 days you can go to a 5 star resort anywhere in the world and get the best service for at least 10 days. So youre just paying for the name and get nothing in return. If you want to have the worst time of your life you should stay at this resort

8

Deborah

15 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

Gurney's is located directly on the beach in Montauk, NY. The setting is nice but the prices are high. Our one bedroom room had a nice view but the king bed was soft and saggy - very uncomfortable. The sofa bed was uncomfortable as well. The maid service was superior. The resort fees are high but the yoga was good. The restaurant, Scarpetta Beach, was very overpriced but the service was excellent. I would recommend the Short Rib & Bone Marrow Agnolotti but it costs $39 for pasta.

8

Irina

28 Apr 2025

·

Stayed 2 nights

The resort is well established and well known. We always came to spend time and eat at the hotel’s restaurant. This year we needed to get away from our regular routine and stress. Upon arrival we found out that the entire lobby, lounge area and the restaurant is apparently closed for renovation. It’s a huge disappointment not to mention the noise coming from construction at 7 am. Rude awakening so to say… I just think that this kind of situation can’t be hidden from guests . Yes, there is still a small restaurant and a spa, but it’s not the same . The price should reflect all changes mentioned above. And the entire project should be disclosed before arrival.

8

Hedieh

11 Apr 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

The lobby and restaurant and bar area were beautiful. staff both at reception and at the spa were not very friendly, particularly at the Spa. Drinks are way too expensive and wish the outdoor furniture wasn't all wrapped up and was more inviting since it's so beautiful out there.

8

Robert

24 Mar 2024

·

Stayed 2 nights

a little overpriced. food outside of scapetta is average at best

6

Marc

16 Nov 2025

·

Stayed 3 nights

What you are paying for is the ocean view. The rest is sub standard. Not very well maintained. The restaurant was very good.

10

Sophia

15 Jun 2023

·

Stayed 1 night

This resort was excellent. The staff was exceptional. Dining was exceptional. The beach was just beautiful. We enjoyed our getaway to the max, romantic, peaceful nature walk trails were especially beautiful. People were kind, smiling. It’s a place to relax and get away from it all whether it’s a girls spa day out or a couples getaway, it’s a place to be.

2

robin

28 Mar 2025

·

Stayed 1 night

nobody said it was under construction !!!! but expedia should have told me when i booked bec i would have NEVRT gone to gurneys the beautiful restaurant it’s known for was demolished along with the bar and coffee shop .. very disappointed ☹️

10

Stacy

16 Jun 2024

·

Stayed 1 night

Gurney's is perfect for a short reset by the sea with wonderful spa and pool. Restaurant onsite is v. good.

Was this helpful?

AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews

Month	Average price
January	US$397
February	US$433
March	US$413
April	US$540
May	US$628
June	US$961
July	US$1,161
August	US$1,028
September	US$702
October	US$516
November	US$412
December	US$398

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16 $913	17 $743	18 $986	19 $910
20 $628	21 $628	22 $629	23 $834	24 $842	25 $843	26 $841
27 $535	28 $853	29 $533	30 $510

Su	Mo	Tu	We	Th	Fr	Sa
				1 $779	2	3
4 $472	5 $509	6 $518	7 $559	8 $593	9 $907	10
11 $912	12 $457	13 $574	14 $520	15 $756	16	17
18 $495	19 $472	20 $456	21 $628	22 $911	23	24
25 $501	26 $462	27 $461	28 $453	29 $527	30	31

Select dates to see prices and availability

Monthly average prices

About this property

Location

Room options

Partial Ocean View Two Bedroom Suite

Ocean View Three Bedroom Cottage

Partial Ocean View King

Partial Ocean View Junior Suite

Oceanfront One Bedroom Cottage

Ocean View King

Oceanfront Two Bedroom Plus Den Residence

Oceanfront Two Bedroom Cottage

Ocean View One Bedroom Suite

Oceanfront King

Garden Partial Ocean View King

Ocean View One Bedroom Residence

Oceanfront Two Queens

Oceanfront One Bedroom Suite

Partial Ocean View One Bedroom Suite

Ocean View Junior Suite

Ocean View Two Bedroom Residence

Oceanfront King Accessible

Oceanfront Three Bedroom Cottage

Oceanfront Two Bedroom Suite

Garden Partial Ocean View Junior Suite

Guest reviews

Very good

Who stays here?

What guests think

Property policies

Check-in instructions

Good to know

Optional extras

FAQs about Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

Have a question?

Prices for upcoming dates