Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
From
US$316
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
US$316
/ night
About this property
Make use of convenient amenities, which include complimentary wireless internet access and barbecue grills.
Amenities
Make use of convenient amenities, which include complimentary wireless internet access and barbecue grills.
Business amenities
Free self parking is available onsite.
Rooms
Make yourself comfortable in this air-conditioned cottage, which features a fireplace. A kitchen is outfitted with an oven, a stovetop, and a microwave. Conveniences include a washing machine and a ceiling fan.
Location
Located in Monticello, this cottage is a 4-minute drive from Lake Shafer and 9 minutes from Tippecanoe Country Club. This cottage is 4.6 mi (7.4 km) from High Speed Naskart Gokart Racing and 5 mi (8 km) from Indiana Beach Amusement Resort.
What's nearby
Lake Shafer(1.1 Miles)
Tippecanoe Country Club(3.7 Miles)
High Speed Naskart Gokart Racing(4.6 Miles)
Indiana Beach Amusement Resort(5 Miles)
Pine View Golf Course(5.7 Miles)
Monon Family Health Clinic(7.4 Miles)
MASE Clinic Monticello(8.1 Miles)
Terre Vin Monticello WineShop(8.3 Miles)
IU Health White Memorial Hospital(8.6 Miles)
White County Memorial Hospital(8.6 Miles)
Altherr Nature Park(9.2 Miles)
Monticello City Park(9.4 Miles)
Monon Connection Museum(9.8 Miles)
Whyte Horse Winery(11.5 Miles)
Hollow Acres Golf Center(14.3 Miles)
Lafayette, IN (LAF-Purdue University)(36.1 Miles)
Indianapolis Intl. Airport (IND)(102 Miles)
Parking
Free wi-fi
Non-smoking rooms
Express check-in/check-out
Free parking
Parking Onsite
Location
5899 W 5.3
Lake Shafer (1.1 Miles)
Tippecanoe Country Club (3.7 Miles)
High Speed Naskart Gokart Racing (4.6 Miles)
Indiana Beach Amusement Resort (5 Miles)
Pine View Golf Course (5.7 Miles)
Monon Family Health Clinic (7.4 Miles)
Room options
22
Cottage (2 Bedrooms)
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
and 2 Single Beds
Sleeps 4
968 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)Fireplace
Guest reviews of Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
9.8
Exceptional
Based on 44 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Across recent reviews, Lakefront Cottage with Deck Near Indiana Beach! is praised for its peaceful lakeside setting and over-water deck, spotless interiors with thoughtful decor, and warm, attentive hosts who make stays easy, comfortable, and welcoming.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Across recent reviews, Lakefront Cottage with Deck Near Indiana Beach! is praised for its peaceful lakeside setting and over-water deck, spotless interiors with thoughtful decor, and warm, attentive hosts who make stays easy, comfortable, and welcoming.
Guests also note well-equipped kitchens, screened or all-season rooms, and comfortable beds, with many saying the cottage matches its listing. The location is convenient to Indiana Beach, Monticello shops, and outings like cruises and wineries, yet remains quiet. Overall, expect a calm, well-kept stay with personable support.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Repeated praise for the over-water deck and lake access, plus screened/sunrooms for bad weather. Many mention a well-equipped kitchen and useful outdoor touches like a fire pit.
Related guest reviews
10
Jim
26 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
We booked "Cozy Cottage" for the 5 days over the 4th of July holiday. We had stayed here before and wanted to return. The accommodations were great, the view of the river fabulous and the deck actually sits on the river. 100% great.
We booked "Cozy Cottage" for the 5 days over the 4th of July holiday. We had stayed here before and wanted to return. The accommodations were great, the view of the river fabulous and the deck actually sits on the river. 100% great.
10
Scott
30 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Very nice place to stay! Loved the wooden deck over the river.
Very nice place to stay! Loved the wooden deck over the river.
10
Debra P.
3 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
10
Lori
12 Jul 2023
·
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
10
Ken W.
24 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
10
Donna R.
27 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
10
Terry O.
10 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Enjoyed cool fall weather on the deck overlooking Lake Shafer
Enjoyed cool fall weather on the deck overlooking Lake Shafer
10
us@jerrodcarter.com u.
26 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
10
Debra K.
8 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
10
Anna S.
2 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a great time here MDW. The deck was perfect for lounging while we did crosswords and played cards, and we had many meals out there. On rainy days, the couch was comfy for lounging and watching our favorite shows. The cottage has a very well equipped kitchen - I usually bring a few kitchen things of my own because I never know what to expect, and they had everything we needed including good knives, basic oil and spices, and plenty of pots and pans. We would absolutely stay here again!
We had a great time here MDW. The deck was perfect for lounging while we did crosswords and played cards, and we had many meals out there. On rainy days, the couch was comfy for lounging and watching our favorite shows. The cottage has a very well equipped kitchen - I usually bring a few kitchen things of my own because I never know what to expect, and they had everything we needed including good knives, basic oil and spices, and plenty of pots and pans. We would absolutely stay here again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Reviews consistently describe the cottage as very clean, with spotless kitchens and bathrooms and tidy interiors.
Related guest reviews
10
Debra P.
3 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
10
Lori
12 Jul 2023
·
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
10
Donna R.
27 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
10
Kate
14 Aug 2023
·
We absolutely loved the cottage! It was clean, well stocked with dishes, appliances, blankets, towels, etc. We loved sitting on the back porch and drinking our morning coffee. The deck was nice too! Definitely would stay here again!
We absolutely loved the cottage! It was clean, well stocked with dishes, appliances, blankets, towels, etc. We loved sitting on the back porch and drinking our morning coffee. The deck was nice too! Definitely would stay here again!
10
Julie
15 Nov 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
We were pleasantly surprised to find such a nice place to stay while visiting family at Shafer Lake. We have been coming to this area for the past 10+ years for a family reunion and struggle to find a good place to stay. The home was clean and had every amenity you could want during a stay. The Host was extremely friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be staying here for future visits.
We were pleasantly surprised to find such a nice place to stay while visiting family at Shafer Lake. We have been coming to this area for the past 10+ years for a family reunion and struggle to find a good place to stay. The home was clean and had every amenity you could want during a stay. The Host was extremely friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be staying here for future visits.
10
Diana H.
22 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
10
Heather R.
19 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
Clean and exactly as described.
Clean and exactly as described.
10
Debra K.
8 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
10
Ronald
26 Aug 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
The cottage is adorable! Well stocked with every amenity. Super clean and the grounds are beautiful...very peaceful. The owners Bob & Jayne are very nice. We will be back again!
The cottage is adorable! Well stocked with every amenity. Super clean and the grounds are beautiful...very peaceful. The owners Bob & Jayne are very nice. We will be back again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Guests describe interiors as cozy, nicely decorated, and comfortable, with good beds and relaxing screened or all-season rooms. Many appreciated the lake views from inside and felt the cottage matched its description.
Related guest reviews
10
Debra P.
3 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
10
Lori
12 Jul 2023
·
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
This cottage is updated and nicely decorated. We spent a lot of time reading, playing games, and relaxing on the screened in porch. The beds were all very comfortable, and we had plenty of extra blankets. Cupboards were very well stocked with dishes and cookware, and the air conditioning worked great in spite of some very hot days. Most of all, this place is CLEAN! Not a speck of dust or cobweb to be found. The kitchen & appliances were immaculate, as was the entire bathroom. Our family thoroughly enjoyed our time here!
8
Connie H.
20 Jun 2022
·
Stayed 5 nights
We had a great time. Our daughter was disappointed that there were not bunk beds, but everything else was great.
We had a great time. Our daughter was disappointed that there were not bunk beds, but everything else was great.
10
Donna R.
27 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
8
Jessica H.
9 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
The property manager was easy to communicate with! Always great in my book! The cottage was cozy, very well decorated, and perfect size! It had everything we needed! We enjoyed the lake view from the screened in porch and played games. We did travel with a dog and toddler, so the grounds wasn’t great. No area really to walk our dog or to let the toddler run around. To swim, you need a life jacket and our dog/toddler couldn’t swim because it is deep. We spent the day at Indiana Beach and it is close to some good restaurants. We would be back for an adult only getaway!
The property manager was easy to communicate with! Always great in my book! The cottage was cozy, very well decorated, and perfect size! It had everything we needed! We enjoyed the lake view from the screened in porch and played games. We did travel with a dog and toddler, so the grounds wasn’t great. No area really to walk our dog or to let the toddler run around. To swim, you need a life jacket and our dog/toddler couldn’t swim because it is deep. We spent the day at Indiana Beach and it is close to some good restaurants. We would be back for an adult only getaway!
10
Diana H.
22 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
10
us@jerrodcarter.com u.
26 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
10
brooke b.
3 Aug 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful little cottage. Decor is very well done. Owners are in the next cottage over. Bob and Jayne are extremely welcoming and friendly.
Beautiful little cottage. Decor is very well done. Owners are in the next cottage over. Bob and Jayne are extremely welcoming and friendly.
10
Chris F.
21 Apr 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Cozy cottage with all the furnishings to make you feel right at home!
Cozy cottage with all the furnishings to make you feel right at home!
10
Anna S.
2 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a great time here MDW. The deck was perfect for lounging while we did crosswords and played cards, and we had many meals out there. On rainy days, the couch was comfy for lounging and watching our favorite shows. The cottage has a very well equipped kitchen - I usually bring a few kitchen things of my own because I never know what to expect, and they had everything we needed including good knives, basic oil and spices, and plenty of pots and pans. We would absolutely stay here again!
We had a great time here MDW. The deck was perfect for lounging while we did crosswords and played cards, and we had many meals out there. On rainy days, the couch was comfy for lounging and watching our favorite shows. The cottage has a very well equipped kitchen - I usually bring a few kitchen things of my own because I never know what to expect, and they had everything we needed including good knives, basic oil and spices, and plenty of pots and pans. We would absolutely stay here again!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Service earns repeated praise for warm, welcoming hosts who are responsive, accommodating, and available on site, with proactive communication before arrival.
Related guest reviews
10
Hollie
6 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The cabin was quiet and relaxing. I had my coffee on the dock each morning and it was beautiful. Owners go above and beyond to be very friendly and accommodating - fantastic people.
The cabin was quiet and relaxing. I had my coffee on the dock each morning and it was beautiful. Owners go above and beyond to be very friendly and accommodating - fantastic people.
10
Ken W.
24 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
10
Megan and Nate
26 Aug 2022
·
Very nice/relaxing stay!! The owners even let us pick some tomatoes and were so very friendly! Nice, cozy place with all you need and nice views!
Very nice/relaxing stay!! The owners even let us pick some tomatoes and were so very friendly! Nice, cozy place with all you need and nice views!
10
Donna R.
27 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 4 nights
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
The owner contacted me beforehand with helpful information and a pleasant welcome. The cottage was nicely decorated, very clean and fully equipped. I especially loved the deck overlooking the water and the all seasons room. I had a wonderful stay and highly recommend this property.
8
Jessica H.
9 Aug 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
The property manager was easy to communicate with! Always great in my book! The cottage was cozy, very well decorated, and perfect size! It had everything we needed! We enjoyed the lake view from the screened in porch and played games. We did travel with a dog and toddler, so the grounds wasn’t great. No area really to walk our dog or to let the toddler run around. To swim, you need a life jacket and our dog/toddler couldn’t swim because it is deep. We spent the day at Indiana Beach and it is close to some good restaurants. We would be back for an adult only getaway!
The property manager was easy to communicate with! Always great in my book! The cottage was cozy, very well decorated, and perfect size! It had everything we needed! We enjoyed the lake view from the screened in porch and played games. We did travel with a dog and toddler, so the grounds wasn’t great. No area really to walk our dog or to let the toddler run around. To swim, you need a life jacket and our dog/toddler couldn’t swim because it is deep. We spent the day at Indiana Beach and it is close to some good restaurants. We would be back for an adult only getaway!
10
Alan
6 Jul 2023
·
We had a great time at Cozy Cottage. This place was exactly as advertised, in excellent condition, and we especially enjoyed the deck right on the lake. Hope to stay there again sometime. We met the owners who were very friendly and helpful also
We had a great time at Cozy Cottage. This place was exactly as advertised, in excellent condition, and we especially enjoyed the deck right on the lake. Hope to stay there again sometime. We met the owners who were very friendly and helpful also
10
Julie
15 Nov 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
We were pleasantly surprised to find such a nice place to stay while visiting family at Shafer Lake. We have been coming to this area for the past 10+ years for a family reunion and struggle to find a good place to stay. The home was clean and had every amenity you could want during a stay. The Host was extremely friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be staying here for future visits.
We were pleasantly surprised to find such a nice place to stay while visiting family at Shafer Lake. We have been coming to this area for the past 10+ years for a family reunion and struggle to find a good place to stay. The home was clean and had every amenity you could want during a stay. The Host was extremely friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be staying here for future visits.
10
Diana H.
22 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
10
Pam P.
21 Jul 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
We SO enjoyed our few days at Shafer Lake. Our little cottage was perfect and we rarely left the beautiful deck! Jane and Bob were fantastic hosts…friendly and helpful with all our questions. We hope to go back some time!
We SO enjoyed our few days at Shafer Lake. Our little cottage was perfect and we rarely left the beautiful deck! Jane and Bob were fantastic hosts…friendly and helpful with all our questions. We hope to go back some time!
10
us@jerrodcarter.com u.
26 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
The cabin was super cute and had everything we could possibly need! The hosts thought of everything. Cabin was very nicely decorated. We were there for the Fourth of July and could see fireworks all around us as we sat on the deck over the river.We would definitely recommend this rental. Host were on property and were there anytime we needed anything. They were very hospitable.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Waterfront on Lake Shafer with an over-water deck, yet convenient to Indiana Beach and Monticello amenities like shops and restaurants. Several guests valued the quiet, country feel while remaining within a short drive of attractions.
Related guest reviews
10
Jessica E.
2 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
My family and I really enjoyed our stay here! We enjoyed the house, it was really like a home away from home. Most definitely enjoyed the private deck over the water. We were fortunate enough to see some of the neighbors doing beautiful fireworks. We were able to bring our dogs, which is a huge plus. We went to Indiana beach one day and the house is so close we were able to come back and cool off a few times! I would definitely recommend staying at this property! It truly met all of our needs.
My family and I really enjoyed our stay here! We enjoyed the house, it was really like a home away from home. Most definitely enjoyed the private deck over the water. We were fortunate enough to see some of the neighbors doing beautiful fireworks. We were able to bring our dogs, which is a huge plus. We went to Indiana beach one day and the house is so close we were able to come back and cool off a few times! I would definitely recommend staying at this property! It truly met all of our needs.
10
Jim
26 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
We booked "Cozy Cottage" for the 5 days over the 4th of July holiday. We had stayed here before and wanted to return. The accommodations were great, the view of the river fabulous and the deck actually sits on the river. 100% great.
We booked "Cozy Cottage" for the 5 days over the 4th of July holiday. We had stayed here before and wanted to return. The accommodations were great, the view of the river fabulous and the deck actually sits on the river. 100% great.
10
Debra P.
3 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
Came to the area to visit family and decided to try this cabin in lieu of a hotel room. Best choice ever! This cabin far exceeds any hotel in the Monticello area. It was just as described. Clean, well furnished and perfectly comfortable. Location was great; 10 minutes from the Kroger and Walmart. Lake view was nice and the deck was perfect for early mornings and evening for relaxing. Very quiet area of the lake. The sunroom was also perfect for when the weather was not suited for being outside. Overall… it was perfect for us and we will be back when we are in the area again.
10
Ken W.
24 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍
10
Wendy K
23 Jun 2022
·
We very much enjoyed our stay at the Cozy Cabin. Cabin was close to the wineries and to the Madam Carroll dinner boat cruise we went on. We enjoyed our day on the deck playing cards and catching some rays! Cabin is stocked with most everything you need.
We very much enjoyed our stay at the Cozy Cabin. Cabin was close to the wineries and to the Madam Carroll dinner boat cruise we went on. We enjoyed our day on the deck playing cards and catching some rays! Cabin is stocked with most everything you need.
10
Terry O.
10 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Enjoyed cool fall weather on the deck overlooking Lake Shafer
Enjoyed cool fall weather on the deck overlooking Lake Shafer
10
Tracy S.
31 May 2022
·
Stayed 2 nights
The owner lives next to the property and there are a few decks to enjoy the water views. It is about 5 miles from Indiana Beach.
The owner lives next to the property and there are a few decks to enjoy the water views. It is about 5 miles from Indiana Beach.
10
Pam P.
21 Jul 2022
·
Stayed 3 nights
We SO enjoyed our few days at Shafer Lake. Our little cottage was perfect and we rarely left the beautiful deck! Jane and Bob were fantastic hosts…friendly and helpful with all our questions. We hope to go back some time!
We SO enjoyed our few days at Shafer Lake. Our little cottage was perfect and we rarely left the beautiful deck! Jane and Bob were fantastic hosts…friendly and helpful with all our questions. We hope to go back some time!
10
Debra K.
8 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
Such a great time. Only 10 minutes from Indiana Beach. Loved having morning coffee on the deck every morning. Place was clean and so adorable. We will be back if coming to Indiana again.
10
Al B.
12 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
What a great place. Perfect for a small family that wants to vacation in Monticello. The place itself is very nice, but i especially like it's location right outside the edge of town, and right on the lake. Close to Indiana beach and anything you need in town, yet with a country feel to it - cornfields and meadows just North of the property. This was our second time here, and we really like the place.
What a great place. Perfect for a small family that wants to vacation in Monticello. The place itself is very nice, but i especially like it's location right outside the edge of town, and right on the lake. Close to Indiana beach and anything you need in town, yet with a country feel to it - cornfields and meadows just North of the property. This was our second time here, and we really like the place.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Not enough information in reviews.
Related guest reviews
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
ICS P.
30 Jun 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
I give it 10 STARS my wife and I now have our hang out we’ve been everywhere and this property is AWESOME Bob& Jayne perfect hosts
I give it 10 STARS my wife and I now have our hang out we’ve been everywhere and this property is AWESOME Bob& Jayne perfect hosts
10
Marcia A.
11 Jun 2026
·
Stayed 5 nights
Wonderful property, very peaceful and the host was very friendly and knowledgeable about the area. House is small but cozy and has everything you need for the stay. We would definitely stay here again this one is probably one of my favorites so far since we have been coming up here the past few years. I would highly recommend!
Wonderful property, very peaceful and the host was very friendly and knowledgeable about the area. House is small but cozy and has everything you need for the stay. We would definitely stay here again this one is probably one of my favorites so far since we have been coming up here the past few years. I would highly recommend!
10
Freddie B.
25 May 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
The room’s was cleaned and the host was very nice and friendly I enjoyed the lake view
The room’s was cleaned and the host was very nice and friendly I enjoyed the lake view
10
Diana H.
22 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
The Cozy Cottage was a perfect place to stay for a short getaway to find some peace, quiet, and rest, which I needed very much. Everything was meticulously clean, well organized, and decorated tastefully. The hosts were so kind and helpful, making me feel very welcomed and safe since I was visiting on my own. I highly recommend this property.
10
Al B.
12 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
What a great place. Perfect for a small family that wants to vacation in Monticello. The place itself is very nice, but i especially like it's location right outside the edge of town, and right on the lake. Close to Indiana beach and anything you need in town, yet with a country feel to it - cornfields and meadows just North of the property. This was our second time here, and we really like the place.
What a great place. Perfect for a small family that wants to vacation in Monticello. The place itself is very nice, but i especially like it's location right outside the edge of town, and right on the lake. Close to Indiana beach and anything you need in town, yet with a country feel to it - cornfields and meadows just North of the property. This was our second time here, and we really like the place.
FAQs about Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!
Is parking available at the property?
Yes, free self-parking is available on-site.
Does the property allow pets?
Yes, pets are allowed with a maximum of 1 pet permitted. A pet fee of USD 342.52 per accommodation, per stay applies, but service animals are exempt from fees.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in time is at 16:00 and check-out time is at 11:00. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request, and guests should contact the property at least 48 hours before arrival to make arrangements.
What is the location of the property in relation to key landmarks?
The property is located in Monticello, within a 15-minute drive of Indiana Beach Amusement Resort and Lake Shafer. It is approximately 1.1 miles from Lake Shafer, 3.7 miles from Tippecanoe Country Club, and 5 miles from Indiana Beach Amusement Resort.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are permitted at the property, and kids aged 0-17 can stay for free.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
The check-in location differs from the property location. Check-in location: [apartment]. To make arrangements for check-in please contact the property at least 48 hours before arrival using the information on the booking confirmation. Guests must contact the property for check-in instructions. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 18 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Host has indicated there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property
- Host has indicated there is a smoke detector on the property
- This property has outdoor spaces, such as balconies, patios, terraces which may not be suitable for children; if you have concerns, we recommend contacting the property prior to your arrival to confirm they can accommodate you in a suitable room
- Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.
- Pet fee: USD 342.52 per accommodation, per stay
- Service animals are exempt from fees
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
Popular amenities
Parking
Free wi-fi
Non-smoking rooms
Express check-in/check-out
Free parking
Parking Onsite
Parking
Parking
Free parking
Parking Onsite
Services
Express check-in/check-out
General
Non-smoking rooms
Internet
Free wi-fi