The Silliman House - New renovation, Farmhouse Chic, close to baseball parks
From
US$332
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
US$332
/ night
About this property
This Property Books on Cooperstown Dreams Park calendar only!
The Silliman House - A spectacular property that has just been entirely renovated, featuring vintage wood and beams from over 100 yrs ago. Style, comfort, technology, - nothing ...
Location
Located in Maryland, this vacation home is in a rural area. Bear Pond Winery and Cooperstown Brewing Company are worth checking out if an activity is on the agenda, while those looking for area attractions can visit Rail Explorers Cooperstown and Foothills Performing Arts Center. Traveling with kids? Consider Anderson Center for the Arts and Bowl Winkles. Discover the area's water adventures with kayaking and motor boating nearby, or enjoy the great outdoors with cycling and hiking.
Refrigerator
Cable/Satellite TV
Microwave
Hair dryer
Garden
Fishing
Guest reviews of The Silliman House - New renovation, Farmhouse Chic, close to baseball parks
10
Exceptional
Based on 15 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Across reviews, The Silliman House - New renovation, Farmhouse Chic, close to baseball parks stands out for spotless interiors, thoughtful family-friendly amenities, and exceptionally attentive hosts, with a convenient drive to local ballfields and easy access to Goodyear Lake.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Across reviews, The Silliman House - New renovation, Farmhouse Chic, close to baseball parks stands out for spotless interiors, thoughtful family-friendly amenities, and exceptionally attentive hosts, with a convenient drive to local ballfields and easy access to Goodyear Lake.
Guests praise the modern, well-stocked home features like a coffee bar, multiple entertainment options, and a basement game room that keeps families entertained. Hosts earn consistent praise for warm welcomes, proactive communication, and thoughtful extras that make stays hassle free. Expect a comfortable, well-equipped base ideal for tournament weeks and relaxed downtime.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Reviews frequently highlight the basement game room with arcade, foosball and air hockey, a handy coffee bar, and outdoor spaces including the deck and fire pit.
Related guest reviews
10
Skip M.
8 Jul 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
10
Greg G.
9 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
This was a fun and modern place to stay. The owners were very attentive and welcomed us very well. We loved the fire pit and the ample televisions, they made for a very relaxing weekend. 10/10
This was a fun and modern place to stay. The owners were very attentive and welcomed us very well. We loved the fire pit and the ample televisions, they made for a very relaxing weekend. 10/10
10
Jolene V.
20 Jun 2024
·
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
10
Jenna S.
24 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,287 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
10
Nicole R.
27 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
10
Maryjean S.
23 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Home owners Phil and Kelly were awesome and very welcoming. House was super clean with a well stocked kitchen. Location was great for visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. Even though it rained all weekend, the home was well stocked with fun board games and the game room downstairs provided great family time! Thank you Phil and Kelly!
Home owners Phil and Kelly were awesome and very welcoming. House was super clean with a well stocked kitchen. Location was great for visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. Even though it rained all weekend, the home was well stocked with fun board games and the game room downstairs provided great family time! Thank you Phil and Kelly!
10
Rebecca H.
15 Jul 2024
·
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
10
Charles L.
28 Jun 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Absolutely first class property and hosts. My family (wife, 15 year old daughter and in-laws) were in town for a tournament at Dreams Park for our son. To say this was the best VRBO property we've ever stayed at wouldn't be doing it justice. Phil and Kelly have thought of everything when it comes to making your stay as enjoyable and comfortable as possible. From the integrated sound system allowing you to fill the property with your favorite tunes to the arcade like experience on the lower level keeping the kids (and adults) entertained, the house provides everything you would ever want or need for your stay. Place is immaculate and if we ever travel back to Cooperstown, the Silliman house is where we'll be staying! Thank you, Phil and Kelly. You two are the best!
Absolutely first class property and hosts. My family (wife, 15 year old daughter and in-laws) were in town for a tournament at Dreams Park for our son. To say this was the best VRBO property we've ever stayed at wouldn't be doing it justice. Phil and Kelly have thought of everything when it comes to making your stay as enjoyable and comfortable as possible. From the integrated sound system allowing you to fill the property with your favorite tunes to the arcade like experience on the lower level keeping the kids (and adults) entertained, the house provides everything you would ever want or need for your stay. Place is immaculate and if we ever travel back to Cooperstown, the Silliman house is where we'll be staying! Thank you, Phil and Kelly. You two are the best!
10
Jennifer P.
14 Jun 2024
·
Beautiful home and property for our stay while our son played at Cooperstown. Very clean and has everything you will need for your visit. My family enjoyed the game room downstairs and watching deer from the deck. Would highly recommend for families coming to the Cooperstown area!
Beautiful home and property for our stay while our son played at Cooperstown. Very clean and has everything you will need for your visit. My family enjoyed the game room downstairs and watching deer from the deck. Would highly recommend for families coming to the Cooperstown area!
10
Denis G.
9 Aug 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Cleanliness is a standout theme, with many reviews calling the home spotless or immaculately maintained.
Related guest reviews
10
Michael A.
24 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,317 nights
This was our first time incoming to All Star Village and staying at the Silliman House. Kelly and Phil were amazing hosts! The house is unbelievably clean and has everything you can need. Even things I did not think of to bring were provided in the house. We would give this house 10 stars if we could! We are coming back for my younger son next year and this will be the ONLY place we will stay! Highly recommend!
This was our first time incoming to All Star Village and staying at the Silliman House. Kelly and Phil were amazing hosts! The house is unbelievably clean and has everything you can need. Even things I did not think of to bring were provided in the house. We would give this house 10 stars if we could! We are coming back for my younger son next year and this will be the ONLY place we will stay! Highly recommend!
10
Christine C.
17 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,311 nights
If I could give this review 10 stars, I would! If you are looking for a clean, warm, and inviting space to really make Cooperstown the best trip ever, rent this house! The owners were so responsive and have literally thought of everything to make this house perfect! We knew our boys were going to have the best week of their life playing at Dreamspark, and this beautiful house helped the moms have ours! We couldn’t have asked for anything more!
If I could give this review 10 stars, I would! If you are looking for a clean, warm, and inviting space to really make Cooperstown the best trip ever, rent this house! The owners were so responsive and have literally thought of everything to make this house perfect! We knew our boys were going to have the best week of their life playing at Dreamspark, and this beautiful house helped the moms have ours! We couldn’t have asked for anything more!
10
Teresa G.
14 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
It could not have been nicer. Beautiful decorations, up-to-date technology, comfortable furnishings, clean as a whistle, everything in perfect working order and condition. Would highly recommend!
It could not have been nicer. Beautiful decorations, up-to-date technology, comfortable furnishings, clean as a whistle, everything in perfect working order and condition. Would highly recommend!
10
Tonilyn P.
16 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,281 nights
We had a wonderful experience staying at this rental house during our son’s 12U Cooperstown trip. The home was exceptionally clean, beautifully organized, and had everything we could have possibly needed—and then some! The hosts went above and beyond, greeting us warmly upon arrival, giving us a tour, and making sure we felt completely at home. They were kind, thoughtful, and incredibly accommodating. This house was the perfect home base for such a special week—we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay!
We had a wonderful experience staying at this rental house during our son’s 12U Cooperstown trip. The home was exceptionally clean, beautifully organized, and had everything we could have possibly needed—and then some! The hosts went above and beyond, greeting us warmly upon arrival, giving us a tour, and making sure we felt completely at home. They were kind, thoughtful, and incredibly accommodating. This house was the perfect home base for such a special week—we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay!
10
Kate M.
23 Jun 2025
·
Stayed -20,251 nights
We loved it! It’s our second time staying in this home and we plan to stay again in a few years! Super clean, well stocked, convenient and an awesome basement.
We loved it! It’s our second time staying in this home and we plan to stay again in a few years! Super clean, well stocked, convenient and an awesome basement.
10
Jenna S.
24 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,287 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
10
Nicole R.
27 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
10
Jennifer T.
10 Jul 2023
·
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
10
Christine D.
21 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
10
kimberly e.
11 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,305 nights
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Guests describe modern, comfortable spaces with tech touches like labeled remotes and bedside wireless chargers, a spacious living area, and comfy beds; several also mention a quiet, cozy environment.
Related guest reviews
10
Skip M.
8 Jul 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
10
Christine Y.
19 Aug 2024
·
We had a great week at the Silliman House! Kelly and Phil met us at the house to check in, at 9pm! Gave us all the info we needed. All of the extra touches in the house were appreciated. Light switches and remotes all labeled to know what controlled what. Wireless charging stands on all of the nightstands. And a lovely welcome basket including a custom travel coffee mug! Would highly recommend to anyone going to Cooperstown ASV or Dreams Park!
We had a great week at the Silliman House! Kelly and Phil met us at the house to check in, at 9pm! Gave us all the info we needed. All of the extra touches in the house were appreciated. Light switches and remotes all labeled to know what controlled what. Wireless charging stands on all of the nightstands. And a lovely welcome basket including a custom travel coffee mug! Would highly recommend to anyone going to Cooperstown ASV or Dreams Park!
10
Denis G.
9 Aug 2023
·
House couldn’t have been more comfortable and well equipped. Updated throughout, with the owners attention to detail top notch! Highly recommend.
House couldn’t have been more comfortable and well equipped. Updated throughout, with the owners attention to detail top notch! Highly recommend.
10
Greg G.
9 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
This was a fun and modern place to stay. The owners were very attentive and welcomed us very well. We loved the fire pit and the ample televisions, they made for a very relaxing weekend. 10/10
This was a fun and modern place to stay. The owners were very attentive and welcomed us very well. We loved the fire pit and the ample televisions, they made for a very relaxing weekend. 10/10
10
Sarah M.
11 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
We are a group of 6 woman that take an annual girls trip. This year we drove to the Silliman House and it was perfect for our needs. Perfect number of beds and plenty of space for us to sit around the table to eat/play games. The game room downstairs and wireless charging options through the house were great bonuses. Not to mention the owners met us at the home for a quick tour and they were nothing but nice and charming. Great proximity to local wineries and restaurants too. Would definitely stay here again if we ever find ourselves out that way again!
We are a group of 6 woman that take an annual girls trip. This year we drove to the Silliman House and it was perfect for our needs. Perfect number of beds and plenty of space for us to sit around the table to eat/play games. The game room downstairs and wireless charging options through the house were great bonuses. Not to mention the owners met us at the home for a quick tour and they were nothing but nice and charming. Great proximity to local wineries and restaurants too. Would definitely stay here again if we ever find ourselves out that way again!
10
Teresa G.
14 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
It could not have been nicer. Beautiful decorations, up-to-date technology, comfortable furnishings, clean as a whistle, everything in perfect working order and condition. Would highly recommend!
It could not have been nicer. Beautiful decorations, up-to-date technology, comfortable furnishings, clean as a whistle, everything in perfect working order and condition. Would highly recommend!
10
Jennifer T.
10 Jul 2023
·
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
10
Corinne G.
8 Jul 2023
·
We just stayed at the Silliman house for a week while our son played at All-star village. The house is absolutely perfect- they ah e thought of everything you could need for your trip, and are helpful and responsive to their guests during their stay. The game room was perfect for younger siblings, beds were comfortable, and the house was quiet and cozy. We were about 15 minutes from all-star, making it easy for us to get to games. We plan to stay again when our younger son goes to Cooperstown on a few years!
We just stayed at the Silliman house for a week while our son played at All-star village. The house is absolutely perfect- they ah e thought of everything you could need for your trip, and are helpful and responsive to their guests during their stay. The game room was perfect for younger siblings, beds were comfortable, and the house was quiet and cozy. We were about 15 minutes from all-star, making it easy for us to get to games. We plan to stay again when our younger son goes to Cooperstown on a few years!
10
kimberly e.
11 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,305 nights
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
10
Denis G.
9 Aug 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Hosts Kelly and Phil earn repeated praise for warm welcomes, detailed orientations, quick, proactive communication, and thoughtful help—even during a power outage or with small requests.
Related guest reviews
10
Michael A.
24 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,317 nights
This was our first time incoming to All Star Village and staying at the Silliman House. Kelly and Phil were amazing hosts! The house is unbelievably clean and has everything you can need. Even things I did not think of to bring were provided in the house. We would give this house 10 stars if we could! We are coming back for my younger son next year and this will be the ONLY place we will stay! Highly recommend!
This was our first time incoming to All Star Village and staying at the Silliman House. Kelly and Phil were amazing hosts! The house is unbelievably clean and has everything you can need. Even things I did not think of to bring were provided in the house. We would give this house 10 stars if we could! We are coming back for my younger son next year and this will be the ONLY place we will stay! Highly recommend!
10
Dave A.
25 Nov 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
When we arrived, power was out due to heavy snow on powerlines. The hosts Kelly and Phill Scrambled to Get the house on a generator, which was absolutely sufficient enough to make us comfortable. Everything in the house worked beautifully as it should and we enjoyed our stay to the fullest with great communication from the house.
When we arrived, power was out due to heavy snow on powerlines. The hosts Kelly and Phill Scrambled to Get the house on a generator, which was absolutely sufficient enough to make us comfortable. Everything in the house worked beautifully as it should and we enjoyed our stay to the fullest with great communication from the house.
10
Christine Y.
19 Aug 2024
·
We had a great week at the Silliman House! Kelly and Phil met us at the house to check in, at 9pm! Gave us all the info we needed. All of the extra touches in the house were appreciated. Light switches and remotes all labeled to know what controlled what. Wireless charging stands on all of the nightstands. And a lovely welcome basket including a custom travel coffee mug! Would highly recommend to anyone going to Cooperstown ASV or Dreams Park!
We had a great week at the Silliman House! Kelly and Phil met us at the house to check in, at 9pm! Gave us all the info we needed. All of the extra touches in the house were appreciated. Light switches and remotes all labeled to know what controlled what. Wireless charging stands on all of the nightstands. And a lovely welcome basket including a custom travel coffee mug! Would highly recommend to anyone going to Cooperstown ASV or Dreams Park!
10
Romonia F.
9 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Superior customer service. Very helpful and quick response with answering questions. The house is beautiful. Really enjoyed the Christmas decor through out the home. Arcade was great for game night. 10/10
Superior customer service. Very helpful and quick response with answering questions. The house is beautiful. Really enjoyed the Christmas decor through out the home. Arcade was great for game night. 10/10
10
shannon c.
5 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful home filled with everything you need and more! The hosts were super friendly and helpful. 10/10. We will definitely be back!
Beautiful home filled with everything you need and more! The hosts were super friendly and helpful. 10/10. We will definitely be back!
10
Christine C.
17 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,311 nights
If I could give this review 10 stars, I would! If you are looking for a clean, warm, and inviting space to really make Cooperstown the best trip ever, rent this house! The owners were so responsive and have literally thought of everything to make this house perfect! We knew our boys were going to have the best week of their life playing at Dreamspark, and this beautiful house helped the moms have ours! We couldn’t have asked for anything more!
If I could give this review 10 stars, I would! If you are looking for a clean, warm, and inviting space to really make Cooperstown the best trip ever, rent this house! The owners were so responsive and have literally thought of everything to make this house perfect! We knew our boys were going to have the best week of their life playing at Dreamspark, and this beautiful house helped the moms have ours! We couldn’t have asked for anything more!
10
Tonilyn P.
16 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,281 nights
We had a wonderful experience staying at this rental house during our son’s 12U Cooperstown trip. The home was exceptionally clean, beautifully organized, and had everything we could have possibly needed—and then some! The hosts went above and beyond, greeting us warmly upon arrival, giving us a tour, and making sure we felt completely at home. They were kind, thoughtful, and incredibly accommodating. This house was the perfect home base for such a special week—we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay!
We had a wonderful experience staying at this rental house during our son’s 12U Cooperstown trip. The home was exceptionally clean, beautifully organized, and had everything we could have possibly needed—and then some! The hosts went above and beyond, greeting us warmly upon arrival, giving us a tour, and making sure we felt completely at home. They were kind, thoughtful, and incredibly accommodating. This house was the perfect home base for such a special week—we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay!
10
Joshua K.
8 Jul 2023
·
The Silliman House was amazing from beginning to end. The comfort and amenities offered fulfilled all our needs and then some. Philip and Kelley were amazing hosts. They checked in on us regularly and were available any time of day to address any concerns and also offered insider suggestion for day activities and food options. They genuinely cared for our family’s experience at Cooperstown and we are looking for to the next time we can stay!
The Silliman House was amazing from beginning to end. The comfort and amenities offered fulfilled all our needs and then some. Philip and Kelley were amazing hosts. They checked in on us regularly and were available any time of day to address any concerns and also offered insider suggestion for day activities and food options. They genuinely cared for our family’s experience at Cooperstown and we are looking for to the next time we can stay!
10
Jenna S.
24 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,287 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
10
Nicole R.
27 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Convenient for baseball trips, with a short, scenic drive (about 15 minutes) to Dreams Park and All-Star Village, plus easy access to Oneonta and the Baseball Hall of Fame; Goodyear Lake is walkable for some.
Related guest reviews
10
Skip M.
8 Jul 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
The Silliman House was perfect! Phil and Kelly were great hosts and their home was more than accommodating. The spacious living room allowed all 7 of us to relax comfortably. The cleanliness and modern upgrades made the stay even better. There was no need for us to pull out our numerous phone chargers as they provided those in just about every room. The property is beautiful, peaceful and well maintained. We even had deer visit us while outside enjoying the fire and eating s’mores. Bonus was the laundry room in the basement and play room that the kids enjoyed playing foosball, air hockey and arcade games. The area allows for a beautiful drive to Cooperstown Dreams Park. We were very happy with stay and could not have thanked Phil and Kelly more for their quick response time and checking in to make sure our stay was pleasant.
10
Jolene V.
20 Jun 2024
·
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
10
Kate M.
23 Jun 2025
·
Stayed -20,251 nights
We loved it! It’s our second time staying in this home and we plan to stay again in a few years! Super clean, well stocked, convenient and an awesome basement.
We loved it! It’s our second time staying in this home and we plan to stay again in a few years! Super clean, well stocked, convenient and an awesome basement.
10
Jenna S.
24 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,287 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
10
Maryjean S.
23 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Home owners Phil and Kelly were awesome and very welcoming. House was super clean with a well stocked kitchen. Location was great for visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. Even though it rained all weekend, the home was well stocked with fun board games and the game room downstairs provided great family time! Thank you Phil and Kelly!
Home owners Phil and Kelly were awesome and very welcoming. House was super clean with a well stocked kitchen. Location was great for visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. Even though it rained all weekend, the home was well stocked with fun board games and the game room downstairs provided great family time! Thank you Phil and Kelly!
10
Rebecca H.
15 Jul 2024
·
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
10
Jennifer T.
10 Jul 2023
·
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
10
Corinne G.
8 Jul 2023
·
We just stayed at the Silliman house for a week while our son played at All-star village. The house is absolutely perfect- they ah e thought of everything you could need for your trip, and are helpful and responsive to their guests during their stay. The game room was perfect for younger siblings, beds were comfortable, and the house was quiet and cozy. We were about 15 minutes from all-star, making it easy for us to get to games. We plan to stay again when our younger son goes to Cooperstown on a few years!
We just stayed at the Silliman house for a week while our son played at All-star village. The house is absolutely perfect- they ah e thought of everything you could need for your trip, and are helpful and responsive to their guests during their stay. The game room was perfect for younger siblings, beds were comfortable, and the house was quiet and cozy. We were about 15 minutes from all-star, making it easy for us to get to games. We plan to stay again when our younger son goes to Cooperstown on a few years!
10
Christine D.
21 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
10
kimberly e.
11 Aug 2025
·
Stayed -20,305 nights
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
The Silliman House was the perfect home away from home for our family while our son played at Dreams Park. The owners have thought of everything and the home was impeccably clean and comfortable! Walking distance to Goodyear Lake and a short ride to the ballfields - couldn’t ask for anything more!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
No on-site dining is mentioned, but guests repeatedly appreciate the well-stocked coffee bar and handy to-go cups.
Related guest reviews
10
Jolene V.
20 Jun 2024
·
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
We had an amazing experience staying here. Perfect place to come back from ASV (short drive) and recharge in between games and unwind after games. Everything is super clean, organized, stocked and cozy and inviting. The hosts are super on top of everything and welcoming. Beautiful deck and backyard to BBQ and 5 minute walk to Goodyear Lake siblings to swim or fish. There’s also a fun game room too for kids and Dads to hangout. 5 minutes away from post office, grocery stores & gas stations. Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful place with us!
10
Jenna S.
24 Jul 2025
·
Stayed -20,287 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
We had a wonderful stay at the Silliman House and would highly recommend it to anyone staying in the area. It was the perfect place to come home to each night while our son played at the Cooperstown Dream Park, which was a short, scenic 15 minute drive away. The house was beautifully renovated, clean, comfortable, and had absolutely everything we needed. We enjoyed Goodyear Lake, just around the corner, as well as the foosball table, air hockey, and arcade games at the house (the kids even got to be the first players on the new system in the kids’ bedroom!). The coffee bar was wonderful and we appreciated the to-go cups for early morning ball games! Phil and Kelly were the perfect hosts; welcoming and hospitable right from the start of our trip and had great communication throughout. If our younger sons are able to play at Cooperstown Dream Park in the future, we will be sure to book the Sillimon House again!!
10
Nicole R.
27 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 6 nights
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
Hands down this was one of the best homes I have stayed in! Kelly and Philip were amazing hosts! We were greeted with a "goodie basket" and they were so incredibly kind. They checked in with us to make sure our stay was going well and they even ran over ketchup because we forgot to buy it at the store! The house was beautiful! So clean and organized. We loved the coffee bar! They even had "to-go cups" for those of us who were running off to baseball games! The basement was simply perfect for our kids! They all loved the arcade games! The family room was my favorite place to hang! Overall, absolutely beautiful home and it was only 15 min from Dreams Park. My friend who stayed with us is planning to stay Summer of '25 when her other son comes to play! Thank you Kelly and Philip for such a wonderful stay!
10
Rebecca H.
15 Jul 2024
·
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
We had the pleasure of spending a wonderful week at the Silliman House in July 2024. The home is beautiful and looks just like the pictures. The hosts are amazing and very responsive to any questions or concerns. The amenities for kids are amazing, from the game room in the basement to plenty of games in the bunk room. They really thought of everything in the home, even providing to-go coffee cups and skewers to roast marshmallows over the fire pit! The home is very centrally located, being a quick 15 minute drive to Dreams Park and a 10 minute drive to Oneonta. We highly recommend this home to future visitors to the area!
10
Jennifer T.
10 Jul 2023
·
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
My family and I stayed at Silliman House while our boys were competing at Cooperstown Dreams Park. The house was perfectly appointed with all you need to relax for the little time you are off the fields! It was immaculately clean, better than I could've wished for. It was stocked with coffee, paper towel and other products you'd need. The beds were comfy, and the hosts were superb in communication and recommendations. They live next door and were very kind to every need (we had none - the house was amazing). The house is a short 15 min drive to the fields, and its a lovely drive to take. We wish we could experience Cooperstown again - and would love to stay here again!
10
Denis G.
9 Aug 2023
·
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
The Silliman House was perfect! The hosts thought of every detail to make our stay wonderful. The house is very spacious and nicely decorated. We loved the coffee bar in the kitchen and the fun video games in the basement. The outdoor deck and firepit area were also wonderful. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and would rent this house again.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Lillie P.
14 Jun 2026
·
Stayed -20,610 nights
The Silliman House had everything you could possibly think of for the entire family. The House was very clean, well kept and equipped with everything you needed. The Owners met us at check in to show us everything the house had to offer and was willing to help with any questions we had during our stay. With a Busy schedule during a Cooperstown Tournament this house was conveniently located, and easy to find and helped make our days back and forth to the ball field manageable! Cooperstown is a beautiful area, and we wouldn't mind visiting again, even without a Baseball tournament on our schedule!
The Silliman House had everything you could possibly think of for the entire family. The House was very clean, well kept and equipped with everything you needed. The Owners met us at check in to show us everything the house had to offer and was willing to help with any questions we had during our stay. With a Busy schedule during a Cooperstown Tournament this house was conveniently located, and easy to find and helped make our days back and forth to the ball field manageable! Cooperstown is a beautiful area, and we wouldn't mind visiting again, even without a Baseball tournament on our schedule!
10
Jesica F.
4 Jun 2026
·
Stayed -20,603 nights
Staying at the Silliman House was absolutely perfect! When I tell you they thought of everything you may need, they truly did!! It was cozy, comfortable, spacious and gorgeous as ever. Not to mention, the location was perfectly centered to everything around town. We would 1,000% recommend to any family or friends. We will be back in the near future!
Staying at the Silliman House was absolutely perfect! When I tell you they thought of everything you may need, they truly did!! It was cozy, comfortable, spacious and gorgeous as ever. Not to mention, the location was perfectly centered to everything around town. We would 1,000% recommend to any family or friends. We will be back in the near future!
10
Dave P.
21 Dec 2025
·
Stayed -20,441 nights
We had an exceptional, albeit, short weekend at the Silliman House! Weekend before Christmas and the home was decorated to the tee! Kelly, was very attentive to our needs and walked us through the house and all of its features. The weather was perfectly cold and snowy which created the perfect environment in the home with the tree and fireplace. This was a trip we will truly remember…highly recommended!
We had an exceptional, albeit, short weekend at the Silliman House! Weekend before Christmas and the home was decorated to the tee! Kelly, was very attentive to our needs and walked us through the house and all of its features. The weather was perfectly cold and snowy which created the perfect environment in the home with the tree and fireplace. This was a trip we will truly remember…highly recommended!
10
shannon c.
5 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful home filled with everything you need and more! The hosts were super friendly and helpful. 10/10. We will definitely be back!
Beautiful home filled with everything you need and more! The hosts were super friendly and helpful. 10/10. We will definitely be back!
10
Christine D.
21 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
The house was beautiful, spotless, and in a great location. Will definitely stay there again in the future.
Property policies
Check-in
Check-out
Check-in from 16:00
Before 09:00
FAQs about The Silliman House - New renovation, Farmhouse Chic, close to baseball parks
Are pets allowed at the property?
No pets are allowed, including service animals, due to severe allergies of the hosts.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is at 16:00 and check-out is at 09:00. Early or late check-in/check-out availability is not specified.
What is the location of the property in relation to key landmarks?
The property is located in Maryland, New York, approximately 15 minutes from Cooperstown and Oneonta. Nearby attractions include Bear Pond Winery, Cooperstown Brewing Company, and outdoor activities such as kayaking and hiking.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are allowed at the property, and there is no charge for children aged 0-17.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 25 years old.
Popular amenities
Refrigerator
Cable/Satellite TV
Microwave
Hair dryer
Garden
Fishing
Activities
Garden
Fishing
Playground
Kayaking
Ecotours on site
Fitness facilities
Arcade/Game Room
Firepit
Games
Hiking/Biking (nearby)
Mountain Bike (nearby)
General
Refrigerator
Cable/Satellite TV
Microwave
Hair dryer
Towels
Children's Games
Smoke-Free Property
Parking
Electric car charging station
Services
Laundry Facilities
Stereo
Internet
Free wi-fi