The Menhaden Hotel
From
US$392
/ night
Select dates to see prices and availability
From
US$392
/ night
About this property
Take in the views from a rooftop terrace and make use of amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services. This hotel also features shopping on site, wedding services, and a reception hall.
Amenities
Take in the views from a rooftop terrace and make use of amenities such as complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services. This hotel also features shopping on site, wedding services, and a reception hall.
Business amenities
Featured amenities include dry cleaning/laundry services, a 24-hour front desk, and luggage storage. This hotel has 2 meeting rooms available for events. Limited parking is available onsite.
Dining
Enjoy a meal at the restaurant or snacks in the hotel's coffee shop/cafe. Quench your thirst with your favorite drink at the bar/lounge. A complimentary self-serve breakfast is served daily from 8:00 AM to 11:00 AM.
Rooms
Stay in one of 16 guestrooms featuring Smart televisions. Your memory foam bed comes with down comforters and premium bedding. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Private bathrooms with bathtubs or showers feature rainfall showerheads and designer toiletries.
Location
When you stay at The Menhaden in Greenport, you'll be near the beach, just steps from Camera Obscura and East End Seaport Maritime Museum. This hotel is 6.1 mi (9.8 km) from The Hamptons Beaches and 0.1 mi (0.1 km) from Greenport Carousel.
What's nearby
Camera Obscura(0.1 Miles)
East End Seaport Maritime Museum(0.1 Miles)
Greenport Carousel(0.1 Miles)
Greenport Farmers' Market(0.2 Miles)
Railroad Museum of Long Island(0.2 Miles)
Greenport Harbor Brewing Company(0.3 Miles)
Eastern Long Island Hospital(0.8 Miles)
Stony Brook Eastern Long Island Hospital(0.9 Miles)
Kontokosta Winery(1.2 Miles)
Safe Harbor Stirling(1.3 Miles)
67 Steps Beach(1.4 Miles)
Norman E. Klipp Marine Park(1.8 Miles)
Island's End Golf and Country Club(1.9 Miles)
Shelter Island Country Club(2 Miles)
Sunset Beach(2.6 Miles)
East Hampton, NY (HTO)(13.9 Miles)
Fishers Island, NY (FID-Elizabeth Field)(36.1 Miles)
New London, CT (GON-Groton - New London)(34 Miles)
John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK)(95.2 Miles)
LaGuardia Airport (LGA)(97.5 Miles)
Parking
Housekeeping
Safe-deposit box
Bicycle rental
Golf course (nearby)
Beach (nearby)
Location
207 Front Street, Greenport, New York, United States of America
Camera Obscura (0.1 Miles)
East End Seaport Maritime Museum (0.1 Miles)
Greenport Carousel (0.1 Miles)
Greenport Farmers' Market (0.2 Miles)
Railroad Museum of Long Island (0.2 Miles)
Greenport Harbor Brewing Company (0.3 Miles)
Room options
16
Studio Suite, 1 King Bed
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
360 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
14
Premium Room, 1 King Bed
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
330 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
9
Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds
Room details
2 Large Double Beds
Sleeps 4
350 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
17
Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
279 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
10
Premium Room, 1 Queen Bed
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
275 ft²
Air ConditioningHeatingWi-Fi (Free)
Guest reviews
9.5
Exceptional
Based on 191 verified reviews
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
At The Menhaden Hotel, travelers highlight exceptionally warm, proactive service, spotless modern rooms, and a walkable in-town Greenport setting that makes getting to shops, restaurants, and ferries easy, creating an inviting boutique stay that feels both polished and relaxed.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
At The Menhaden Hotel, travelers highlight exceptionally warm, proactive service, spotless modern rooms, and a walkable in-town Greenport setting that makes getting to shops, restaurants, and ferries easy, creating an inviting boutique stay that feels both polished and relaxed.
Guests repeatedly enjoy the rooftop terrace with fire pits, a comfortable bar/lounge with games and vinyl, and floor galleys stocked with complimentary drinks, croissants, and evening cookies. Feedback is largely positive, though a few mention a mandatory amenity fee, occasional downtown street noise, and isolated hiccups like small rooms or an unavailable advertised amenity. Expect a stylish, centrally located boutique hotel with standout service and thoughtful perks.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Popular features include the rooftop terrace with fire pits, a cozy bar/lounge with games and vinyl, and floor galleys offering complimentary drinks, croissants, and evening cookies. A few guests disliked the mandatory amenity fee, and one noted certain amenities were unavailable during their stay.
Related guest reviews
8
Paul
17 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The hotel was lovely but a few things were amiss during our stay: (1) The Moke was not working despite the ads saying we would have access to it; the bikes, touted as "first-come-first-serve", were actually reserved for another party so not available for our use on our first day there; and the lounge that is supposed to be open was off limits due to a conference. Given the promises about all these things and the price, we should certainly have been informed prior to our stay and/or compensated.
The hotel was lovely but a few things were amiss during our stay: (1) The Moke was not working despite the ads saying we would have access to it; the bikes, touted as "first-come-first-serve", were actually reserved for another party so not available for our use on our first day there; and the lounge that is supposed to be open was off limits due to a conference. Given the promises about all these things and the price, we should certainly have been informed prior to our stay and/or compensated.
6
David
1 Jan 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
I rarely post reviews but this is warranted. Menhaden very nice upscale place but they need to address customer service, specifically the issue of a $35 amenity fee. We noticed on our invoice and inquired what it consists of. We were told it covers parking (parking lot was full- parked in street), WiFi (this is free in every hotel I’ve ever stayed in), and access to the galley (we were told at checkin this was complimentary). When we raised these issues we received a surprising amount of push back. Overall it’s a deceptive practice and the hotel should consider how it treats its guests. They eventually offered a $75 gift card in lieu of a credit, do not think we’ll return based on how they treated us.
I rarely post reviews but this is warranted. Menhaden very nice upscale place but they need to address customer service, specifically the issue of a $35 amenity fee. We noticed on our invoice and inquired what it consists of. We were told it covers parking (parking lot was full- parked in street), WiFi (this is free in every hotel I’ve ever stayed in), and access to the galley (we were told at checkin this was complimentary). When we raised these issues we received a surprising amount of push back. Overall it’s a deceptive practice and the hotel should consider how it treats its guests. They eventually offered a $75 gift card in lieu of a credit, do not think we’ll return based on how they treated us.
10
Nancy
18 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
We truly enjoyed our stay. The Staff was wonderful, the roof terrace was a lovely spot for a cocktail, and the galley is a nice touch. Those chocolate chip cookies in the evening were the best. Will definitely be returning.
We truly enjoyed our stay. The Staff was wonderful, the roof terrace was a lovely spot for a cocktail, and the galley is a nice touch. Those chocolate chip cookies in the evening were the best. Will definitely be returning.
10
sean
17 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
8
Richard
11 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful hotel, with a B & B vibe. Good privacy. They impose a destination/ amenity fee scam, that is supposed to cover stuff that traditionally would be included in a hotel's advertised price, which makes the hotel very pricey. Our room had no water view, but instead over looked a busy downtown street that was an early morning access road to the ferry. Each floor has a snack station in a hallway alcove, loaded with "complementary" snacks, coffee/tea, yogurt, fruit, candy, and fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Eat your fill: you pay for it in spades with the silly fees.
Beautiful hotel, with a B & B vibe. Good privacy. They impose a destination/ amenity fee scam, that is supposed to cover stuff that traditionally would be included in a hotel's advertised price, which makes the hotel very pricey. Our room had no water view, but instead over looked a busy downtown street that was an early morning access road to the ferry. Each floor has a snack station in a hallway alcove, loaded with "complementary" snacks, coffee/tea, yogurt, fruit, candy, and fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Eat your fill: you pay for it in spades with the silly fees.
10
Judeen
1 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
10
Jesper
17 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Skønt lille hotel i søde Greenport. Meget enkel men fin morgenmad og adgang til snacks, soft drinks og the/kaffe. Hyggelig lounge hvor vi spillede spil og lyttede til gamle LP plader. Feriestemning.
Skønt lille hotel i søde Greenport. Meget enkel men fin morgenmad og adgang til snacks, soft drinks og the/kaffe. Hyggelig lounge hvor vi spillede spil og lyttede til gamle LP plader. Feriestemning.
10
Lisa
26 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Hotel manager was great! Loved the firepits outside
Hotel manager was great! Loved the firepits outside
10
Frances
30 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
We had a wonderful stay in this ultra clean and ultra chic hotel. We had an emergency that required lots of printing, scanning, and notarizing which Mario the manager helped us with all day. He also arranged a great "oyster experience " with Founders Oyster Farm and a last minute late dinner reservation. The hotel is conveniently located for walking around Greenport. They have hot croissants, yogurt, coffee, juice early each morning on each floor. Then later, there are snacks and delicious hot cookies. Tea, coffee, cold drinks also. There is a large bar/hang out area where one can order a drink, or go across the street to the various delis and being a meal in. Also, a lovely coffee shop with all barista choices and charcuterie, cheese, snack.
We had a wonderful stay in this ultra clean and ultra chic hotel. We had an emergency that required lots of printing, scanning, and notarizing which Mario the manager helped us with all day. He also arranged a great "oyster experience " with Founders Oyster Farm and a last minute late dinner reservation. The hotel is conveniently located for walking around Greenport. They have hot croissants, yogurt, coffee, juice early each morning on each floor. Then later, there are snacks and delicious hot cookies. Tea, coffee, cold drinks also. There is a large bar/hang out area where one can order a drink, or go across the street to the various delis and being a meal in. Also, a lovely coffee shop with all barista choices and charcuterie, cheese, snack.
10
Barney
6 Jan 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Reviews consistently describe the property and rooms as very clean, with many calling them spotless or immaculate.
Related guest reviews
10
Vijay
14 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Perfect hotel with friendly staff, immaculate condition and very desirable neighborhood close to water views/restaurants.
Perfect hotel with friendly staff, immaculate condition and very desirable neighborhood close to water views/restaurants.
10
Leah
8 Nov 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful hotel! We really loved all the staff and cleanliness of it. The Galley was the best part!!! We will definitely come back.
Beautiful hotel! We really loved all the staff and cleanliness of it. The Galley was the best part!!! We will definitely come back.
10
Lauren
19 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Very clean, friendly staff, beautiful decor. Gallery in hallway with drinks and snacks, nice touch!
Very clean, friendly staff, beautiful decor. Gallery in hallway with drinks and snacks, nice touch!
10
Jess
21 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great location , clean and really modern rooms. Staff was really friendly and helpful. Will definately recommend and visit again.
Great location , clean and really modern rooms. Staff was really friendly and helpful. Will definately recommend and visit again.
10
Kimberly
1 May 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
This hotel is clean, trendy and very welcoming
This hotel is clean, trendy and very welcoming
10
Matthew
26 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
First class. Clean, extremely helpful, great location.
First class. Clean, extremely helpful, great location.
10
sean
17 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
10
Brian
31 Dec 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
10
John
9 Jan 2023
·
Stayed 19,364 nights
Immaculate hotel with kind staff
Immaculate hotel with kind staff
10
Andrew
14 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
My boyfriend and I stayed at The Menhaden for my birthday, and it was truly an incredible experience! From the moment we arrived, everything exceeded our expectations. The staff incredible. The entire property was spotless — especially our room, which was beautifully maintained and so comfortable. I had one of the best nights of sleep I’ve had in a long time. The location is perfect too, just a short walk to everything in town. I couldn’t recommend The Menhaden more. 10/10 experience. Thank you for making my birthday so special!
My boyfriend and I stayed at The Menhaden for my birthday, and it was truly an incredible experience! From the moment we arrived, everything exceeded our expectations. The staff incredible. The entire property was spotless — especially our room, which was beautifully maintained and so comfortable. I had one of the best nights of sleep I’ve had in a long time. The location is perfect too, just a short walk to everything in town. I couldn’t recommend The Menhaden more. 10/10 experience. Thank you for making my birthday so special!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Rooms are modern and comfortable, with some noted as spacious, but a few guests mention small layouts, occasional street noise, and isolated issues like lack of a tub or temperature control.
Related guest reviews
6
keri m
7 Sept 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
I ordered the most expensive room, the king deluxe suite expecting there to be a small living area with a couch. It said slept three that’s why I booked a room. It was very expensive almost 700 and something dollars and basically it was just a king size bed after asking Felicia was extremely nice. She brought up a rollaway, but my son was already asleep in the closet with pillows that we had to put down and blankets.
I ordered the most expensive room, the king deluxe suite expecting there to be a small living area with a couch. It said slept three that’s why I booked a room. It was very expensive almost 700 and something dollars and basically it was just a king size bed after asking Felicia was extremely nice. She brought up a rollaway, but my son was already asleep in the closet with pillows that we had to put down and blankets.
10
Celeste
5 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
This hotel is right out of a movie set! Fancy snacks, drinks and warm chocolate chip cookies during the day. Spacious room, awesome rooftop with gas fireplaces. Great location. Aidan could not have been more accommodating. He is the epitome of fine customer service and should manage his own hotel one day.
This hotel is right out of a movie set! Fancy snacks, drinks and warm chocolate chip cookies during the day. Spacious room, awesome rooftop with gas fireplaces. Great location. Aidan could not have been more accommodating. He is the epitome of fine customer service and should manage his own hotel one day.
10
Jess
21 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great location , clean and really modern rooms. Staff was really friendly and helpful. Will definately recommend and visit again.
Great location , clean and really modern rooms. Staff was really friendly and helpful. Will definately recommend and visit again.
10
sean
17 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
10
Brian
31 Dec 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
8
Richard
11 Oct 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Beautiful hotel, with a B & B vibe. Good privacy. They impose a destination/ amenity fee scam, that is supposed to cover stuff that traditionally would be included in a hotel's advertised price, which makes the hotel very pricey. Our room had no water view, but instead over looked a busy downtown street that was an early morning access road to the ferry. Each floor has a snack station in a hallway alcove, loaded with "complementary" snacks, coffee/tea, yogurt, fruit, candy, and fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Eat your fill: you pay for it in spades with the silly fees.
Beautiful hotel, with a B & B vibe. Good privacy. They impose a destination/ amenity fee scam, that is supposed to cover stuff that traditionally would be included in a hotel's advertised price, which makes the hotel very pricey. Our room had no water view, but instead over looked a busy downtown street that was an early morning access road to the ferry. Each floor has a snack station in a hallway alcove, loaded with "complementary" snacks, coffee/tea, yogurt, fruit, candy, and fresh baked chocolate chip cookies. Eat your fill: you pay for it in spades with the silly fees.
8
Kimberly
15 May 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
Cute property, good location, cozy rooms…but the rooms are rather small for the price.
Cute property, good location, cozy rooms…but the rooms are rather small for the price.
10
Matthew
13 Nov 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Very nice property and in a good location. Great amenities and extras like complimentary snacks and teas and coffees on each floor. There was a bit of street noise that was loud at times, but otherwise a great stay.
Very nice property and in a good location. Great amenities and extras like complimentary snacks and teas and coffees on each floor. There was a bit of street noise that was loud at times, but otherwise a great stay.
10
Barney
6 Jan 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
10
Jane
30 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great hotel in the middle of everything! Staff was very accomodating and welcoming. Was great to have refreshments available. Very comfortable rooms. Highly recommend.
Great hotel in the middle of everything! Staff was very accomodating and welcoming. Was great to have refreshments available. Very comfortable rooms. Highly recommend.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Service stands out for its friendliness and proactive help, with staff frequently going above and beyond for recommendations, special requests, and flexible arrangements.
Related guest reviews
10
Melissa
4 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
One of my top 5 most enjoyable stays at a hotel. Mario connected us with Steve from Founders Oysters for an amazing charter experience. Mario was so knowledgeable and took ownership of his job like it was his business. John was so great too - he kept us laughing as we changed our check out multiple times he was able to accommodate our work schedule with ease.
One of my top 5 most enjoyable stays at a hotel. Mario connected us with Steve from Founders Oysters for an amazing charter experience. Mario was so knowledgeable and took ownership of his job like it was his business. John was so great too - he kept us laughing as we changed our check out multiple times he was able to accommodate our work schedule with ease.
8
David
26 Jan 2026
·
Stayed 3 nights
Excellent reception staff - very attentive and responsive.
Excellent reception staff - very attentive and responsive.
10
sean
17 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
10
Brian
31 Dec 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
10
Anthony
2 Jan 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
The best hotel experience ever. Mario, John and crew took amazing personal care of every detail. Champagne on arrival. Reservations for dinner. I even forgot my wallet and Mario offered to lend me cash. UNHEARD OF! Thank you guys for a fabulous stay!
The best hotel experience ever. Mario, John and crew took amazing personal care of every detail. Champagne on arrival. Reservations for dinner. I even forgot my wallet and Mario offered to lend me cash. UNHEARD OF! Thank you guys for a fabulous stay!
10
Darisabel
11 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
One of the best hotels we have ever stay in terms of service. The staff, including one of the managers and Aedan make every thing they can to make your stay comfortable. Highly recommended!
One of the best hotels we have ever stay in terms of service. The staff, including one of the managers and Aedan make every thing they can to make your stay comfortable. Highly recommended!
10
Judeen
1 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
10
Chris
10 Aug 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
We loved everything about our stay - the staff is unbelievably courteous, helpful and friendly, from the GM Mario who is hands on with an effortless 5-star service mentality all the way down. Every detail of the hotel is thoughtful and elevated in a warm and inviting way - the place is unbelievably charming and welcoming. From the lobby, bar, galleys, room, and rooftop deck - even the stairwell with plush deep blue carpet and skylight is a nice touch that didn’t go unnoticed. Being right in the heart of town, but an easy walk to the dock, was fantastic as Greenport has really grown into its own with nice shops and great restaurants. We can’t wait to return next year!
We loved everything about our stay - the staff is unbelievably courteous, helpful and friendly, from the GM Mario who is hands on with an effortless 5-star service mentality all the way down. Every detail of the hotel is thoughtful and elevated in a warm and inviting way - the place is unbelievably charming and welcoming. From the lobby, bar, galleys, room, and rooftop deck - even the stairwell with plush deep blue carpet and skylight is a nice touch that didn’t go unnoticed. Being right in the heart of town, but an easy walk to the dock, was fantastic as Greenport has really grown into its own with nice shops and great restaurants. We can’t wait to return next year!
10
Barney
6 Jan 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
10
Kerri
5 Apr 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Fabulous hotel in a great location. Employees were so helpful, Nachi at the front desk was just wonderful. Looking forward to next visit!
Fabulous hotel in a great location. Employees were so helpful, Nachi at the front desk was just wonderful. Looking forward to next visit!
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Central, walkable location close to shops, restaurants, the ferry, and the train. A couple of reviews note some street noise due to the downtown setting.
Related guest reviews
10
Vijay
14 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Perfect hotel with friendly staff, immaculate condition and very desirable neighborhood close to water views/restaurants.
Perfect hotel with friendly staff, immaculate condition and very desirable neighborhood close to water views/restaurants.
10
Gary
30 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Loved the vineyards that a were a couple of miles away
Loved the vineyards that a were a couple of miles away
10
Sonali
30 Jun 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
A nice place to stay in Greenport. Very convenient to nearby shops and restaurants. The staff is very friendly and helpful too
A nice place to stay in Greenport. Very convenient to nearby shops and restaurants. The staff is very friendly and helpful too
10
Lisa
17 Feb 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
The staff were very accommodating, the room was fresh and modern, it was very close to shopping and restaurants and also a short walk to the train.
The staff were very accommodating, the room was fresh and modern, it was very close to shopping and restaurants and also a short walk to the train.
10
Brian
31 Dec 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
Front desk staff was outstanding. So helpful with all types of suggestions from dining to wineries and general property amenities. Room as beautiful and spotless. Bed was quite comfortable. Lounge/ bar was so convenient. Great location in town too.
10
Matthew
13 Nov 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
Very nice property and in a good location. Great amenities and extras like complimentary snacks and teas and coffees on each floor. There was a bit of street noise that was loud at times, but otherwise a great stay.
Very nice property and in a good location. Great amenities and extras like complimentary snacks and teas and coffees on each floor. There was a bit of street noise that was loud at times, but otherwise a great stay.
10
Judeen
1 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
10
Chris
10 Aug 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
We loved everything about our stay - the staff is unbelievably courteous, helpful and friendly, from the GM Mario who is hands on with an effortless 5-star service mentality all the way down. Every detail of the hotel is thoughtful and elevated in a warm and inviting way - the place is unbelievably charming and welcoming. From the lobby, bar, galleys, room, and rooftop deck - even the stairwell with plush deep blue carpet and skylight is a nice touch that didn’t go unnoticed. Being right in the heart of town, but an easy walk to the dock, was fantastic as Greenport has really grown into its own with nice shops and great restaurants. We can’t wait to return next year!
We loved everything about our stay - the staff is unbelievably courteous, helpful and friendly, from the GM Mario who is hands on with an effortless 5-star service mentality all the way down. Every detail of the hotel is thoughtful and elevated in a warm and inviting way - the place is unbelievably charming and welcoming. From the lobby, bar, galleys, room, and rooftop deck - even the stairwell with plush deep blue carpet and skylight is a nice touch that didn’t go unnoticed. Being right in the heart of town, but an easy walk to the dock, was fantastic as Greenport has really grown into its own with nice shops and great restaurants. We can’t wait to return next year!
10
Jane
30 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great hotel in the middle of everything! Staff was very accomodating and welcoming. Was great to have refreshments available. Very comfortable rooms. Highly recommend.
Great hotel in the middle of everything! Staff was very accomodating and welcoming. Was great to have refreshments available. Very comfortable rooms. Highly recommend.
10
Tracy
18 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Great spot. Everything was perfect.
Great spot. Everything was perfect.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
Guests appreciate the complimentary galley offerings (coffee, soft drinks, croissants, and evening cookies) and enjoy the on-site bar/lounge for drinks and socializing. Breakfast is simple but well-liked.
Related guest reviews
10
Lauren
19 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Very clean, friendly staff, beautiful decor. Gallery in hallway with drinks and snacks, nice touch!
Very clean, friendly staff, beautiful decor. Gallery in hallway with drinks and snacks, nice touch!
10
Monica
21 Sept 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
This was one of the best hotels that we have ever stayed at. The area is great & we can’t wait to return. The chocolate chip cookies were amazing and the gallery in each floor was so convenient and such a treat! Thank you!
This was one of the best hotels that we have ever stayed at. The area is great & we can’t wait to return. The chocolate chip cookies were amazing and the gallery in each floor was so convenient and such a treat! Thank you!
10
Nancy
18 Aug 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
We truly enjoyed our stay. The Staff was wonderful, the roof terrace was a lovely spot for a cocktail, and the galley is a nice touch. Those chocolate chip cookies in the evening were the best. Will definitely be returning.
We truly enjoyed our stay. The Staff was wonderful, the roof terrace was a lovely spot for a cocktail, and the galley is a nice touch. Those chocolate chip cookies in the evening were the best. Will definitely be returning.
10
sean
17 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
From the friendly check in with Mario to the check out everything was top class .The private bar is a really special touch and Dan was a great bar tender. The roof top is very nice to relax on with a glass of wine and the fire pit lit. Rooms are comfortable and spotless. There is a galley on each floor where they have coffee water and soda free all day plus fresh croissants in the morning .Highly recommend this hotel
10
Alyssa
8 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great overall experience - super accommodating staff and their complimentary snack and drink galley throughout the day is a lovely value added amenity
Great overall experience - super accommodating staff and their complimentary snack and drink galley throughout the day is a lovely value added amenity
10
Joe
15 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Wonderful stay. Kitchen was awesome, chocolate chip cookies were amazing!
Wonderful stay. Kitchen was awesome, chocolate chip cookies were amazing!
10
Judeen
1 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
Our stay was AMAZING!! The Front Desk staff could not have been more helpful and friendly - they acted like their #1 priority was making sure we had everything we needed. There was a wonderful bar/community area where we could play table games, play vinyl records that were provided, have a drink - so comfortable and fun! It was also within walking distance of shops, restaurants, and not far from the Ferry to Shelter Island. We highly recommend this hotel!!
10
Jesper
17 Mar 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Skønt lille hotel i søde Greenport. Meget enkel men fin morgenmad og adgang til snacks, soft drinks og the/kaffe. Hyggelig lounge hvor vi spillede spil og lyttede til gamle LP plader. Feriestemning.
Skønt lille hotel i søde Greenport. Meget enkel men fin morgenmad og adgang til snacks, soft drinks og the/kaffe. Hyggelig lounge hvor vi spillede spil og lyttede til gamle LP plader. Feriestemning.
10
Frances
30 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
We had a wonderful stay in this ultra clean and ultra chic hotel. We had an emergency that required lots of printing, scanning, and notarizing which Mario the manager helped us with all day. He also arranged a great "oyster experience " with Founders Oyster Farm and a last minute late dinner reservation. The hotel is conveniently located for walking around Greenport. They have hot croissants, yogurt, coffee, juice early each morning on each floor. Then later, there are snacks and delicious hot cookies. Tea, coffee, cold drinks also. There is a large bar/hang out area where one can order a drink, or go across the street to the various delis and being a meal in. Also, a lovely coffee shop with all barista choices and charcuterie, cheese, snack.
We had a wonderful stay in this ultra clean and ultra chic hotel. We had an emergency that required lots of printing, scanning, and notarizing which Mario the manager helped us with all day. He also arranged a great "oyster experience " with Founders Oyster Farm and a last minute late dinner reservation. The hotel is conveniently located for walking around Greenport. They have hot croissants, yogurt, coffee, juice early each morning on each floor. Then later, there are snacks and delicious hot cookies. Tea, coffee, cold drinks also. There is a large bar/hang out area where one can order a drink, or go across the street to the various delis and being a meal in. Also, a lovely coffee shop with all barista choices and charcuterie, cheese, snack.
10
Barney
6 Jan 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Loved our stay at the Menhaden! Everything was great especially the staff who went beyond our expectations...from offering us champagne and my husband a great mocktail to cleaning the snow off our car! The place is so pretty and the bar has all fun games & all albums you can play. The king room was large, no bath though :( and it was a bit cold in there, they did try and fix it though. Breakfast and goodies available all day on our floor with sodas, water, coffee and cappuccinos :).
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Jerrold
25 May 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Has become our gat away home away from home. From the staff, to property itself, top level. Staff is professional and friendly, it just goes unmatched. Can’t wait for June when we return again for a long weekend.
Has become our gat away home away from home. From the staff, to property itself, top level. Staff is professional and friendly, it just goes unmatched. Can’t wait for June when we return again for a long weekend.
10
Lisa
20 May 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff was very accommodating and extremely nice, Great stay!
Staff was very accommodating and extremely nice, Great stay!
10
Jennifer
3 May 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
The property was gorgeous…brand new. Great location to the center of town including the carousel, Aldo’s coffee shop, and great bars/restaurants. The staff went above and beyond beyond! The bar was great…excellent cocktails, prestigious service, and FUN games to play too. A must stay for anyone going to Greenport!
The property was gorgeous…brand new. Great location to the center of town including the carousel, Aldo’s coffee shop, and great bars/restaurants. The staff went above and beyond beyond! The bar was great…excellent cocktails, prestigious service, and FUN games to play too. A must stay for anyone going to Greenport!
10
Gary
28 Apr 2026
·
Stayed 4 nights
Everything exceeded all expectations. Excellence is a not strong enough description.
Everything exceeded all expectations. Excellence is a not strong enough description.
10
Mary
8 Apr 2026
·
Stayed 2 nights
Kaylee, John and the rest of the staff were helpful and patient. We felt like we were home. My daughter and I will definitely be back here to stay. We took many pictures and videos and will tell everyone about our stay here. Having a Galley on each floor was helpful as we had everything we needed within reach. Two suggestions, maybe get a peep hole for the room doors and have a microwave in each Galley so we don’t have to ask staff to microwave anything. Other than that, we felt relaxed and staying here made our trip just perfect. Little touches such as warm breakfast croissants, the candy bar (we seriously ate so many jellybeans and m&m’s this trip lol), the game room/bar area, macaroons upon checkout….we never felt rushed or like we were a bother. Can’t say enough about our experience here. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!
Kaylee, John and the rest of the staff were helpful and patient. We felt like we were home. My daughter and I will definitely be back here to stay. We took many pictures and videos and will tell everyone about our stay here. Having a Galley on each floor was helpful as we had everything we needed within reach. Two suggestions, maybe get a peep hole for the room doors and have a microwave in each Galley so we don’t have to ask staff to microwave anything. Other than that, we felt relaxed and staying here made our trip just perfect. Little touches such as warm breakfast croissants, the candy bar (we seriously ate so many jellybeans and m&m’s this trip lol), the game room/bar area, macaroons upon checkout….we never felt rushed or like we were a bother. Can’t say enough about our experience here. Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!
FAQs about The Menhaden Hotel
Is parking available at the property?
Limited on-site parking is available at no additional cost. Reservations are not required.
What type of breakfast is offered and what are the serving hours?
A complimentary self-serve breakfast is served daily from 8:00 AM to 11:00 AM.
Does the property allow pets?
Pets are allowed in specific rooms only, with a fee of USD 75 per pet, per stay. Service animals are exempt from fees.
What are the standard check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 3:00 PM to 11:30 PM, and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request and may incur additional charges.
What accessibility features does the property offer for guests with disabilities?
The property features limited wheelchair accessibility, including step-free entrances and accessible public areas. However, specific details about accessible rooms and bathrooms are not provided.
Where is the property located in relation to key landmarks?
The property is situated near the beach, just steps from Camera Obscura and East End Seaport Maritime Museum. It is 6.1 miles from The Hamptons Beaches and 0.1 miles from Greenport Carousel.
What are the policies for guests staying with children?
Children are allowed at the property, and the minimum age for children to stay for free is not specified.
What are the policies regarding extra beds and cribs?
The property offers rollaway beds for a fee of USD 68.55 per day. Advance request or confirmation is required for rollaway beds.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Prices for upcoming dates
September 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
October 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cheaper
Pricier
Average nightly price across deals, with taxes & fees.
Prices in USD for 2 guests, updated daily.
- 2026-09-16: 469.06254350616456USD
- 2026-09-17: 396.42377264160154USD
- 2026-09-18: 968.454132545166USD
- 2026-09-19: NO DATA
- 2026-09-20: 613.9595391290283USD
- 2026-09-21: 468.77194911254884USD
- 2026-09-22: 468.77194911254884USD
- 2026-09-23: 468.77194911254884USD
- 2026-09-24: 632.4998041815186USD
- 2026-09-25: NO DATA
- 2026-09-26: NO DATA
- 2026-09-27: 496.302069465332USD
- 2026-09-28: 496.302069465332USD
- 2026-09-29: 450.9028595333862USD
- 2026-09-30: 450.9028595333862USD
- 2026-10-01: 559.8609983435058USD
- 2026-10-02: 1132.795421921997USD
- 2026-10-03: NO DATA
- 2026-10-04: 441.82298257354734USD
- 2026-10-05: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-06: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-07: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-08: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-09: 1131.8914281939697USD
- 2026-10-10: 1131.8914281939697USD
- 2026-10-11: 814.0967138562012USD
- 2026-10-12: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-13: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-14: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-15: 423.66329860076905USD
- 2026-10-16: NO DATA
- 2026-10-17: NO DATA
- 2026-10-18: 428.14360734893796USD
- 2026-10-19: 428.14360734893796USD
- 2026-10-20: 428.14360734893796USD
- 2026-10-21: 505.3223166934204USD
- 2026-10-22: 486.030122472229USD
- 2026-10-23: NO DATA
- 2026-10-24: NO DATA
- 2026-10-25: 487.4352157876587USD
- 2026-10-26: 447.4358015701294USD
- 2026-10-27: 447.4358015701294USD
- 2026-10-28: 428.14360734893796USD
- 2026-10-29: 428.14360734893796USD
- 2026-10-30: NO DATA
- 2026-10-31: NO DATA
- 2026-11-01: 412.88469124176027USD
- 2026-11-02: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-03: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-04: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-05: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-06: 654.7364830804444USD
- 2026-11-07: 654.7364830804444USD
- 2026-11-08: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-09: 392.6686383731079USD
- 2026-11-10: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-11: 392.6686383731079USD
- 2026-11-12: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-13: 544.3537357699585USD
- 2026-11-14: 543.6489508114624USD
- 2026-11-15: 392.1633769451904USD
- 2026-11-16: 392.1633769451904USD
Front desk staff will greet guests on arrival at the property. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 21 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Noise-free guestrooms cannot be guaranteed
- Safety features at this property include a carbon monoxide detector, a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, a security system, a first aid kit, and window guards
- Only registered guests are allowed in the guestrooms.
- The property has connecting/adjoining rooms, which are subject to availability and can be requested by contacting the property using the number on the booking confirmation.
- This property allows pets in specific rooms only (surcharges apply and can be found in the Fees section). Guests can request one of these rooms by contacting the property directly, using the contact information on the booking confirmation.
- Contactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.
- Pet fee: USD 75 per pet, per stay
- Service animals are exempt from fees
- Rollaway bed fee: USD 68.55 per day
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
Popular amenities
Parking
Housekeeping
Safe-deposit box
Bicycle rental
Golf course (nearby)
Beach (nearby)
General
Packed lunches
Allergy-free room available
Family room
Beach Sun Loungers
Snack Bar/Deli
Wheelchair Accessible (Limited)
Activities
Golf course (nearby)
Beach (nearby)
Windsurfing
Fishing
Golf (miniature)
Hiking
Outdoor Fireplace
Outdoor Furniture
Terrace
Services
Housekeeping
Safe-deposit box
Bicycle rental
Luggage storage
Express check-in/check-out
24-Hour Front Desk
Concierge Services
Parking
Parking
Free parking
Parking (Limited)
Parking Onsite
Internet
Free wi-fi