The Manhattan Club

Only 2 elevators for 26 floors, be prepared to wait, especially during checkout & dinner time.

We’ve stayed at TMC several times. We selected a penthouse this time, which btw, does not have a private patio accessed from the room, however, a shared guest patio w/ a panoramic city view is located a floor above.

Clean,spacious room and very quiet for being in the city. Great gym also.

For the price of the Penthouse suite it most certainly should come with better perks. The penthouse suite rooftop access was "closed for the season" which should NOT be the case! You should allow your guests to make the decision whether or not it's too cold. The breakfast was absolutely not worth the amount it costs! They don't offer any eggs other than half frozen boiled and no protein??? Unacceptable to say the least! Other than the bathroom floors covered in hair the place was clean. The place itself could use a bit of TLC. I understand the place is old and "classic" but it definitely doesn't have to look like it on the inside of the suites.

Excellent stay at The Manhattan Club. Valet parking was a plus. We were on penthouse floor with 2 room suite. Living/dining/kitchen with fridge, microwave, coffee maker, dishes and dishwasher. Queen sleeper sofa and full bath and TV. Bedroom had king size bed with full bath and TV. 10-15 walk to Times Square. Lots of dining options nearby. Staff were great. Room cleaned each day. Would highly recommend.

I highly recommend and looking forward to returning. Great staff all around. Nice Queen suite with pullout couch. Has a really great area on 23rd floor used to allow guests to relax with bar and food available.

Great stay. The staff are all lovely and so friendly. The lifts were undergoing refurbishment so could take a little while to go up and down at times. We stayed in the penthouse and it was a lovely room. I would have preferred firmer pillows and better lighting in the room but really, they’re only minor issues. I’d still highly recommend staying at this hotel.

Excellent choice. Lots of space. Great staff. Good gym. Lots to do around the property. Near subway stations, Times Square, Central Park and Fifth Ave. Will stay here again. However, food options need significant improvement.

Elevators were poor. Out of four, it appeared only one was in operation. Sometimes had to wait up to 10 minutes to descend. A $500 deposit was applied to our credit card after booking which seemed a bit excessive.

Excellent location. The parking is pricey, but considering the area, it's probably the best option. The continental breakfast costs extra and doesn't offer many choices. I prepaid for it, so I was stuck with it. I'd suggest exploring nearby for better alternatives. Overall, the location is the standout feature, which is crucial when visiting Manhattan.

Window blinds stuck in down position - so room was dark like a cave. Hotel knew that the blinds needed repair because they had a note on the blinds apologizing that they didn’t work. However, they never fixed them over the three days I was there. Weirdly they have blank plates on the walls where you would normally have light switches. So you have to fish around in the dark to find the switch on the plugged-in lights. Also, room was not clean - many stains on the walls. Elevators very slow. Location is good, but price not justified due to condition and poor management.

Dirty carpet in room. Poor breakfast with dirty carpet - restaurant smelled.

Friendly staff, spacious one-bedroom suite, very clean. Definitely returning.

Very nice rooms, very clean. Our room was cleaned daily. We asked for an extra blanket and had it in less than 20 mins. Very walkable location. The only drawback was no streaming abilities on the tvs.

Shouldn’t be rated as a 4 star. Rooms are big but very dated and smelled of old furniture. Sofa in my room had stains so did the armchair which was also ripped. No ventilation. Staff are wonderful. Great that the room had a fridge.

Property and suite were generally very nice. We were quite disappointed to find the tub and shower water to be very brown. After a long day of travel and walking the city, we were unable to relax and get cleaned up. I brought pictures to front desk and was told it would be looked into. The second night, water seemed to be fine. A slight tinge in bath, so again we were unable to bathe. Hotel staff never relayed info to us. Asked about the water at checkout and if they could offer any remedy. No manager on duty? Staff said to expect a phone call shortly to discuss. There has been no communication.

Rooms are too dusty

Great stay! Warm and welcoming. Very clean.

The bathrooms could use a bit of up keeping. There’s was mold on the sink and a shower cap hanging on a door which was never removed. Check in and check out was fast and personnel in general was friendly. Great location.

Great location. Super staff. But the air conditioning didn't work and when we called, they offered to come open our windows for us. We found bugs in our first room that looked very much like bed bugs, but we were told were "beetle spiders". however, the giant cockroaches on the ceiling in the hallway were very much giant cockroaches.

Very spacious room for city standards. Clean and comfortable. Not the latest design but the cleanliness, space, kitchen and living room (!) made up for that and more.

While the hotel is starting to show its age and is due for a renovation, it still was just about perfect for a family stay in the city. Steps from Central Park, Times Square and everything in Midtown. Easily the largest hotel room available for the price in the city. Wallpaper is peeling a bit and the walls are a bit thin, but the room was clean, the staff friendly and helpful, and the location perfect.

Our stay at The Manhattan Club was pleasant. We had a one bedroom suite which was very spacious. Our daughter had a comfortable sofa bed in the lounge room and there was a bonus 2nd bathroom for her. The rooms are quite dated though and furnishings are starting to look a little shabby. A couple of the dining chairs were actually threadbare and the glass table lent to one side. They advertise these suites as having a kitchenette but there is no kettle and no toaster. When we enquired about these items they said toasters aren't provided due to th being a fire risk and no kettles because there is a coffee machine provided. If you want a cup of tea, you have to boil water in the microwave, which is not ideal. Other than that, we had a good 7 night stay.

The staff was wonderful- the room was roomy but dates and had a strange musty smell. The heat was not a thermostat but simply on or off. But luckily we were able to crack a window for air. Oh and GREAT CENTRAL location!!

Location was great - loved the lounge on the 26th floor where we could work and have breakfast and lunch. Only negative about the hotel was the WiFi wasn’t strong everywhere - but we could have got the uopgraded option but chose to use our hotspot instead. Wasn’t a huge inconvenience at all. We will definitely be back.

Great for the price. The room was SO HOT! We tried to cool the room, but only hot air came out. When I called about the temperature, I was told the building is only set to heat. In order to cool the room,you had to turn everything off. Our room never dropped below 77 the entire stay. We were in the 25th floor. Maybe the lower floors were cooler. Staff was exceptional. The suite was spacious and well equipped. It could use some updating.

Clean,spacious room and very quiet for being in the city. Great gym also.

We stayed in the Penthouse suite (2901) The rooms are huge with so much space. We travelled with our 19 and 16 year olds and there was so much room, the main bedroom has an ensuite and the Lounge area has a huge comfortable sofa bed and we had a roll away bed in there as well. Their is a dining table large entrance and another bathroom for the kids to use. Please not the bathroom only has a bath with a shower handle to use whilst in the bath not a true shower. But the main bedrooms shower is amazing pressure. The main bedrooms ensuite also has a separate toilet with a door which is great. The rooms are dated but clean, the old style in the window airconditioners are interesting but we didn't need to use them as the airconditioning in the room worked fine, these were additional. Room 2901 is soooo quiet and for NY this is not normal! The sirens and car nose can make it hard to sleep but not in this room it was so quiet and we really enjoyed it. The beds are so comfortable and sheets nice and clean and crisp. If you are looking for a modern hotel this is not for you! but if you are not worried about it being dated but clean and quiet, you won't be disappointed. I would say the staff at the check in desk were ok, but very cut and dry about things not helpful (especially James quite condescending) But the bell staff were amazing, especially Faisal, he was so helpful and nothing was an issue! Room staff also amazing. I would definitely stay again.

The 1BR suite was the largest room we’ve stayed in by far in NYC. Perfect for our family of 4. Bonus points for 2 bathrooms, a refrigerator and a microwave. Lots of dining options close by. Much quieter than Midtown and Times Square. This is one of my new favorites for a NYC stay!

We had a great time at The Manhattan Club this past week. We spent 5 nights in one of the penthouse suites and we were not disappointed in the space. Two bathrooms, so much room for our kids and ourselves, nice views, we loved it! A few downsides were the sound of the elevator that made thumping sounds all night long, but eventually got use to it, and some of the furniture was a bit worn down (ie.the chairs lost a few screws). Otherwise, everything was great! Staff was helpful and nice, we felt safe and the location was everything. We’ll definitely stay there again when we go back to NYC!

My wife and I had a great time staying at The Manhattan Club. The staff was very friendly, especially Adam and Joel. The hotel had everything that we needed, Central Park is maybe 7 minutes away. Close to everything, highly recommended.

The room was spacious for NY. The beds comfortable. The reception that received us late at night didn't even say "Welcome" and their way of talking was very short towards tired travelers. But the process was quick. The only person that gave us excellent service was Faisal who retrieved our luggage after we left it in storage for a few hours. He should do reception instead of the lady that received us.

Beware of the completely unjustfied hudden USD 500 holding charge which is sprung upon you at check in when it is too late to cancel. Absolutely outrageous for a hotel which offers no additional services. And cleaning staff who walk straight into the room without knocking at 9am.

Overall the stay was above parr. My only issue was that it took over 90 minutes to have a housekeeping request for robes and extra pillows satisfied.

We have stayed here before and loved it, but this time was less appealing. Our room had some wear and tear. Couch was shabby and in need of replacement, and bathroom door handle kept falling off. But my biggest complaint was that we ordered food from the lounge and it was horrible. We paid almost $70 for a small burnt pizza and soggy wings. I complained to the hotel hoping they would make it right, but they simply thanked me for my feedback. Location is great but I may look into other options next visit.

Greeted at the curb with efficiency which continued at the front desk and throughout our stat with the bell men and housekeeping. Could not ask for better service.

The service was great. James at the front desk and Anthony out front were super helpful.

Great stay. The staff are all lovely and so friendly. The lifts were undergoing refurbishment so could take a little while to go up and down at times. We stayed in the penthouse and it was a lovely room. I would have preferred firmer pillows and better lighting in the room but really, they’re only minor issues. I’d still highly recommend staying at this hotel.

Jerry, who checked me in, went out of his way to accommodate all of our needs....

We had a great time at The Manhattan Club this past week. We spent 5 nights in one of the penthouse suites and we were not disappointed in the space. Two bathrooms, so much room for our kids and ourselves, nice views, we loved it! A few downsides were the sound of the elevator that made thumping sounds all night long, but eventually got use to it, and some of the furniture was a bit worn down (ie.the chairs lost a few screws). Otherwise, everything was great! Staff was helpful and nice, we felt safe and the location was everything. We’ll definitely stay there again when we go back to NYC!

My wife and I had a great time staying at The Manhattan Club. The staff was very friendly, especially Adam and Joel. The hotel had everything that we needed, Central Park is maybe 7 minutes away. Close to everything, highly recommended.

Great location! Very comfortable and convenient to all. Easy access to subway. Excellent staff!

It was an excellent location

WONDERFUL staff, friendly, engaging & helpful!!! Beautiful room, clean, good layout. And we were able to walk to our Broadway plays, comedy club, restaurants, shopping, Time Square... EXCELLENT LOCATION!

The one bedroom two bathroom suite is spacious, comfortable and easily accommodates 4 people. Staff is friendly and very attentive. Location is easily accessible to Central Park, Carnegie Hall, Times Square and restaurants. Highly recommend.

Great Midtown Hotel: CLEAN room and VERY friendly staff. You can to the food amenities and subway station. We will return.

Friendly and helpful staff. Spacious suites. Great location.

Superb location, excellent service, great value for money.

The Manhattan Club is a perfect location for walking to Carnegie Hall, Times Square, Cental Park, Radio City, MOMA.

The staff are incredible! Location is amazing! Walking distance to Central Park, Times Square and Empire State Building. Having two bathrooms with the one bedroom suite was fantastic. Super comfortable bed. Highly recommend! Will definitely stay again.

My only issue is that they did not have any decent coffee offered. They would not even let me get a free cup in the beautiful dining area. Who doesn't have coffee????

The hotel was in a great location. Rooms were large and very clean. We had an iron but no ironing board so we made a makeshift ironing board. We had a hair dyer but the electrical prong was broken. Called front desk to get a replacement. Went up to the bar for a late night drink (bar open until 11pm) but was told they always close 15 before closing time!?!?!?

Great staff and clean, comfortable rooms. The area around the hotel is a little noisy at night but that’s expected given the location. The only inconvenience was the elevators, they are very small and slow and we often had to wait 5 minutes for one. The continental breakfast is also pricey given the limited options available.

We have stayed here before and loved it, but this time was less appealing. Our room had some wear and tear. Couch was shabby and in need of replacement, and bathroom door handle kept falling off. But my biggest complaint was that we ordered food from the lounge and it was horrible. We paid almost $70 for a small burnt pizza and soggy wings. I complained to the hotel hoping they would make it right, but they simply thanked me for my feedback. Location is great but I may look into other options next visit.

We really enjoyed our stay here. Michael in the lounge is very accommodating in the morning for breakfast. He’s very friendly, helpful and eager to assist. Housekeeping staff were delightful. Our Room condition was excellent. The mattress and bedding were very comfortable. Bathrooms were breathtaking and beautiful. The Manhattan Club is well maintained, efficiently run and located in the right place. If we had any complaints it would be slow elevators, rooms need a few more outlets along with usb outlets and the people in the next room were animals who let their children play with their entry door & it slammed every 10 seconds starting at 7am.

Good: location, easy walking distance to broadway, Central Park, Rock center, subways easy, lots of space in the room, 2 bathrooms, small kitchen if you need that. Quiet rooms, Not great: expensive breakfast so go somewhere else, slightly dated but in good condition,

Overall it is a nice place to stay. I like the convience. Walkable to lots of attactions. One thing that can be improved is the breakfast. It is relatively expensive ($30 plus tip for adult) considering the options that are offered.

Michael and his team at breakfast were outstanding. Went above and beyond every day...old school customer service.

I loved this property. The only drawback was the expensive breakfast and the fact that I couldn’t get a free cup of coffee in the morning! Free coffee in the afternoon was a nice perk.

Excellent location. The parking is pricey, but considering the area, it's probably the best option. The continental breakfast costs extra and doesn't offer many choices. I prepaid for it, so I was stuck with it. I'd suggest exploring nearby for better alternatives. Overall, the location is the standout feature, which is crucial when visiting Manhattan.