Island City House
US$248
/ night
Avg. for October
Prices for Island City House
Select dates to see prices and availability
US$248
/ night
Avg. for October
Monthly average prices
Nightly prices at Island City House average US$195 in the cheapest month (September) and US$457 in the most expensive month (February), based on the last 12 months.
| Month | Average price |
|---|---|
| January | US$389 |
| February | US$457 |
| March | US$430 |
| April | US$377 |
| May | US$289 |
| June | US$218 |
| July | US$248 |
| August | US$198 |
| September | US$195 |
| October | US$248 |
| November | US$261 |
| December | US$302 |
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
Oct · US$248
O
N
D
Most expensive: February (~US$457)
Cheapest: September (~US$195)
About this property
Don't miss out on recreational opportunities including an outdoor pool and bicycles to rent. Additional amenities at this hotel include complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services.
Amenities
Don't miss out on recreational opportunities including an outdoor pool and bicycles to rent. Additional amenities at this hotel include complimentary wireless internet access and concierge services.
Business amenities
Featured amenities include complimentary newspapers in the lobby, dry cleaning/laundry services, and luggage storage. Limited parking is available onsite.
Rooms
Make yourself at home in one of the 24 individually furnished guestrooms, featuring kitchens with full-sized refrigerators/freezers and stovetops. Complimentary wireless internet access keeps you connected, and cable programming is available for your entertainment. Conveniences include phones, as well as microwaves and coffee/tea makers.
Location
A stay at Island City House Hotel places you in the heart of Key West, within a 15-minute walk of Duval Street and Florida Keys Beaches. This hotel is 0.6 mi (1 km) from Mallory Square and 0.8 mi (1.2 km) from Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.
What's nearby
The Kite House(0.2 Miles)
Donkey Milk House(0.2 Miles)
Key West Historic Seaport(0.2 Miles)
Schooner Western Union(0.2 Miles)
Sails To Rails Museum at Flagler Station(0.2 Miles)
The Key West Theater(0.3 Miles)
Key West Bight Marina(0.3 Miles)
Duval Street(0.3 Miles)
St. Paul's Episcopal Church(0.3 Miles)
Red Barn Theater(0.3 Miles)
Hellings House Museum(0.4 Miles)
Key West Cemetery(0.4 Miles)
San Carlos Institute - Casa Cuba(0.4 Miles)
Curry Mansion Museum(0.4 Miles)
Papa's Pilar Rum Distillery Hemingway Rum Company(0.4 Miles)
The preferred airport for Island City House Hotel is Key West Intl. Airport (EYW)(3.6 Miles)
Swimming pool
Non-smoking rooms
Tour desk
Housekeeping
Bicycle rental
Garden
Location
411 William Street, Historic Seaport, Key West, Florida, United States of America
The Kite House (0.2 Miles)
Donkey Milk House (0.2 Miles)
Key West Historic Seaport (0.2 Miles)
Schooner Western Union (0.2 Miles)
Sails To Rails Museum at Flagler Station (0.2 Miles)
The Key West Theater (0.3 Miles)
Room options
1
Island City House 2 Bedroom Suite with Porch
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
, 1 Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 5
550 ft²
Balcony or TerraceAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
3
Arch House Studio Suite Street
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
300 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
7
Cigar House Queen Suite with Poolside Balcony
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 4
480 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
5
Island City House King
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 4
385 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
7
Arch House 2 Bedroom Suite
Room details
2 Large Double Beds
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 5
496 ft²
Balcony or TerraceAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
6
Cigar House King Suite with Poolside Porch
Room details
1 Extra-Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 4
480 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
3
Island City House Queen Suite with Porch
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 2
385 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
4
Island City House Queen Suite
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
and 1 Sofa Bed
Sleeps 3
385 ft²
Air ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
4
Arch House Garden Viewith Studio with Balcony
Room details
1 Large Double Bed
Sleeps 2
350 ft²
BalconyAir ConditioningWi-Fi (Free)Kitchen
Guest reviews of Island City House
9.3
Superb
Based on 1,000 verified reviews
Who stays here?
Business
0%
Couple
59%
Family
19%
Group
14%
Solo
5%
What guests think
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Island City House draws consistent praise for its walkable, quiet-yet-central location and lush tropical grounds with a pleasant pool, while roomy, historic suites with kitchens and balconies create a laid-back vibe, though some spaces feel small or dated.
Read moreWas this helpful?
What guests think
Island City House draws consistent praise for its walkable, quiet-yet-central location and lush tropical grounds with a pleasant pool, while roomy, historic suites with kitchens and balconies create a laid-back vibe, though some spaces feel small or dated.
Friendly, helpful staff and smooth check-ins earn frequent compliments, and maintenance issues are resolved promptly. Cleanliness is widely appreciated, but a handful of reviews mention musty odors or housekeeping misses. Recurring drawbacks include construction or street noise in some units, limited or off-site parking, no on-site dining or breakfast, and occasional AC, water pressure, or Wi-Fi issues. Expect a charming, garden-style stay near everything, best for travelers who value character over full-service amenities.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Facilities
Lush gardens and a pleasant heated pool stand out; on-site bike rentals and a water dispenser are appreciated. There’s no elevator, no on-site restaurant or bar, and parking is limited to nearby paid options.
Related guest reviews
10
Scott
1 Sept 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Property was centrally located which was a plus. There is no on-site parking and one spot that is supposed to be for loading and unloading only, though it seemed to be constantly taken. We had to take a couple trips to where we parked to unload, just keep that in mind when visiting. Overall we had a great stay!
Property was centrally located which was a plus. There is no on-site parking and one spot that is supposed to be for loading and unloading only, though it seemed to be constantly taken. We had to take a couple trips to where we parked to unload, just keep that in mind when visiting. Overall we had a great stay!
6
Stefano
12 May 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Old decor
Old decor
10
Autumn
30 May 2025
·
Stayed 7 nights
This was absolutely the most amazing hotel I have ever stayed in. Our room was secluded and clean. The hotel garden area was stunning and teeming with life. I so appreciated the cold, purified water dispenser out in the garden, probably my favorite amenity. Our room also had a hammock on the balcony. This was the perfect place to spend our honeymoon.
This was absolutely the most amazing hotel I have ever stayed in. Our room was secluded and clean. The hotel garden area was stunning and teeming with life. I so appreciated the cold, purified water dispenser out in the garden, probably my favorite amenity. Our room also had a hammock on the balcony. This was the perfect place to spend our honeymoon.
10
nancy
28 Aug 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
This is in a quiet area of Key West. But very walkable to everything. No elevators though.
This is in a quiet area of Key West. But very walkable to everything. No elevators though.
10
ofelia
8 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Very beautiful close to Duvall Parking garage available for reasonable price within walking distance
Very beautiful close to Duvall Parking garage available for reasonable price within walking distance
10
Adora
28 May 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
10
Randall
9 Sept 2023
·
Stayed 2 nights
A beautiful property with lush gardens and a nice quiet pool area. Beautiful pathways through tropical foliage. Bike rentals on property. Super convenient to the marina and to Mallory Square and Duvall Street. My interactions with the staff were all very favorable. This is our new go to place when we visit Key West.
A beautiful property with lush gardens and a nice quiet pool area. Beautiful pathways through tropical foliage. Bike rentals on property. Super convenient to the marina and to Mallory Square and Duvall Street. My interactions with the staff were all very favorable. This is our new go to place when we visit Key West.
10
Craig
18 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Parking can be a bit “tricky “… but great location n staff
Parking can be a bit “tricky “… but great location n staff
10
Keith
9 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Wonderful trip. Great hotel but not for those who have issues with stairs unless they ask for one of the first floor rooms or bungalows. Would stay there again. Wish they served food though.
Wonderful trip. Great hotel but not for those who have issues with stairs unless they ask for one of the first floor rooms or bungalows. Would stay there again. Wish they served food though.
10
Cheryl
30 Mar 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Location was perfect for walking around KWest. Parking is limited, but they offer great options at $15/day.
Location was perfect for walking around KWest. Parking is limited, but they offer great options at $15/day.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Cleanliness
Many guests found rooms and grounds very clean with attentive housekeeping. A few reported musty odors or lapses such as used sheets or a dirty sofa.
Related guest reviews
4
Zlata
12 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great location, nice lush garden and spacious swimming pool. However, the basics of hospitality services - the cleanness of the room was below expectations. We booked for three people and the sofa bed still had used sheets from previous visit. We found an old box of takeaway food next on the side table, there were only two towels for three people prepared. It left not a good impression.
Great location, nice lush garden and spacious swimming pool. However, the basics of hospitality services - the cleanness of the room was below expectations. We booked for three people and the sofa bed still had used sheets from previous visit. We found an old box of takeaway food next on the side table, there were only two towels for three people prepared. It left not a good impression.
8
Kellianne
31 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great place to stay in Key West! Enjoyed the historic aspect of the property. Very clean , friendly staff. My only complaint is the water pressure. Would definitely stay again.
Great place to stay in Key West! Enjoyed the historic aspect of the property. Very clean , friendly staff. My only complaint is the water pressure. Would definitely stay again.
10
Kathi
12 Nov 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Very clean and location is perfect to walk to most of the things to see.
Very clean and location is perfect to walk to most of the things to see.
10
John
25 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
This hotel is the most enchanting and beautiful property we have ever stayed at. It’s so serene and peaceful! The staff was pleasant and lovely as well as the cleanliness of the room was impeccable. I highly recommend this hotel! :)
This hotel is the most enchanting and beautiful property we have ever stayed at. It’s so serene and peaceful! The staff was pleasant and lovely as well as the cleanliness of the room was impeccable. I highly recommend this hotel! :)
6
Lorraine
17 Jan 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The location was excellent, safe with easy walking to many sights and restaurants. Our unit (Arch House number 1) was on a busy street so noisy. The place was very clean but had a musty, moldy smell and only the bathroom window opened so it was hard to fix. The two queen bedrooms were small but beds were comfy. No hooks for coats. Couch was so dirty we didn’t want to sit on it. Not comfortable to sleep on. Bathroom was tiny but functional. Staff was so friendly and professional. Pool was warm and amazing.
The location was excellent, safe with easy walking to many sights and restaurants. Our unit (Arch House number 1) was on a busy street so noisy. The place was very clean but had a musty, moldy smell and only the bathroom window opened so it was hard to fix. The two queen bedrooms were small but beds were comfy. No hooks for coats. Couch was so dirty we didn’t want to sit on it. Not comfortable to sleep on. Bathroom was tiny but functional. Staff was so friendly and professional. Pool was warm and amazing.
10
Patricia
30 Apr 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Our unit was clean, quiet. Check in person was very kind, helpful. Would highly recommend. We had unit 4, garden unit.
Our unit was clean, quiet. Check in person was very kind, helpful. Would highly recommend. We had unit 4, garden unit.
10
Zlatka
1 Mar 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Absolutely gorgeous property! Clean rooms! Anything you need for your stay!
Absolutely gorgeous property! Clean rooms! Anything you need for your stay!
10
Jerry
4 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Beautiful grounds, good clean room, cold A/C, centrally located.
Beautiful grounds, good clean room, cold A/C, centrally located.
10
Stacey
18 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Unique property. Not extremely clean but okay. Great proximity to area attractions
Unique property. Not extremely clean but okay. Great proximity to area attractions
10
Karen
12 Jan 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
We stayed 5 nights and had a wonderful time. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this property. The grounds were beautiful. The room had such Key West charm and the porch was where we spent most of our free time. The room was cleaned daily and bottles of water and granola bars were left for us each day. It’s those nice little touches that put it over the top. Easy to rent bikes on site. Perfect location. Highly recommend. My only recommendation is a step stool to get up in the main bed as it was a bit high to climb up on.
We stayed 5 nights and had a wonderful time. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this property. The grounds were beautiful. The room had such Key West charm and the porch was where we spent most of our free time. The room was cleaned daily and bottles of water and granola bars were left for us each day. It’s those nice little touches that put it over the top. Easy to rent bikes on site. Perfect location. Highly recommend. My only recommendation is a step stool to get up in the main bed as it was a bit high to climb up on.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Rooms
Spacious, apartment-style suites with kitchens and porches/balconies (often with hammocks) are praised for comfort and historic charm. Some units are small or dated, with AC noise/limits, weak water pressure, occasional Wi-Fi issues, and street or construction noise.
Related guest reviews
8
Kellianne
31 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great place to stay in Key West! Enjoyed the historic aspect of the property. Very clean , friendly staff. My only complaint is the water pressure. Would definitely stay again.
Great place to stay in Key West! Enjoyed the historic aspect of the property. Very clean , friendly staff. My only complaint is the water pressure. Would definitely stay again.
4
Kaitlin
3 Jun 2024
·
We are extremely upset because this hotel was not cheap at all and no notice was given about loud construction right next to our room. It wasn’t expressed anywhere and was not told upon check in. Plus they gave us the room right next to it. Construction starts very early in the morning so we never got to sleep properly on our vacation and to add, the cleaning crew was very loud even earlier. The front desk said they are not allowed to start before 8:30 but we heard lots of banging around at 6am not exaggerating at all and then promptly at 8am was vacuuming and then leaf blower for 30 min straight. Everyone woke up. So no one got sleep and we couldn’t even enjoy the hammock and porch because the construction was so loud. For over $500 we are very upset and will now be warning anyone we know. The front lady said she would refund me but couldn’t since I booked with Expedia. What a vacation
We are extremely upset because this hotel was not cheap at all and no notice was given about loud construction right next to our room. It wasn’t expressed anywhere and was not told upon check in. Plus they gave us the room right next to it. Construction starts very early in the morning so we never got to sleep properly on our vacation and to add, the cleaning crew was very loud even earlier. The front desk said they are not allowed to start before 8:30 but we heard lots of banging around at 6am not exaggerating at all and then promptly at 8am was vacuuming and then leaf blower for 30 min straight. Everyone woke up. So no one got sleep and we couldn’t even enjoy the hammock and porch because the construction was so loud. For over $500 we are very upset and will now be warning anyone we know. The front lady said she would refund me but couldn’t since I booked with Expedia. What a vacation
10
Justin
6 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 6 nights
We stayed in the Cigar House and really enjoyed the hammocks and being pool-front. The space was large enough for our family of four - the fold-out couch was comfortable for the kids. The property overall was charming and the location was great - a short walk to both Duval St and the harbor but far enough away to be quiet at night.
We stayed in the Cigar House and really enjoyed the hammocks and being pool-front. The space was large enough for our family of four - the fold-out couch was comfortable for the kids. The property overall was charming and the location was great - a short walk to both Duval St and the harbor but far enough away to be quiet at night.
8
Bryce
4 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Great location and atmosphere. The bed was uncomfortable and the AC couldn’t keep up with the heat. Overall could not sleep well. But the property itself is awesome.
Great location and atmosphere. The bed was uncomfortable and the AC couldn’t keep up with the heat. Overall could not sleep well. But the property itself is awesome.
6
Daniel
2 Apr 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had an apartment in the oldest part of the building. Directly facing Eaton Street. Very noisy at times. The furniture is getting on in years. It smells old in the rooms. The bathroom is very small. The garden and pool are very nice. The whole complex has flair. The staff are all very friendly.
We had an apartment in the oldest part of the building. Directly facing Eaton Street. Very noisy at times. The furniture is getting on in years. It smells old in the rooms. The bathroom is very small. The garden and pool are very nice. The whole complex has flair. The staff are all very friendly.
10
Erin
24 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great location. Appreciated having access to a pool and liked the separate living area with kitchen amenities.
Great location. Appreciated having access to a pool and liked the separate living area with kitchen amenities.
8
Tom
14 Jul 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Was great place , but the A/c ran all night very noisy and the ceiling fan in the bed room did not have a chain to adjust the speed and it was on low
Was great place , but the A/c ran all night very noisy and the ceiling fan in the bed room did not have a chain to adjust the speed and it was on low
10
Beverly
16 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
6
Elizabeth
17 Nov 2025
·
Stayed 5 nights
The bedrooms were very small with little dresser space. We stayed in the Arch House and were woken up early every day by the landscaping crew. We have stayed here a few times before but this is the first time we have had these problems. Please consider rearranging the bedrooms so there can be more space to move around.
The bedrooms were very small with little dresser space. We stayed in the Arch House and were woken up early every day by the landscaping crew. We have stayed here a few times before but this is the first time we have had these problems. Please consider rearranging the bedrooms so there can be more space to move around.
10
Bernice
21 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Gardens beautiful, pool area very nice, suite comfortable with nice balcony, Wi Fi didn’t work is only complaint
Gardens beautiful, pool area very nice, suite comfortable with nice balcony, Wi Fi didn’t work is only complaint
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Service
Friendly, welcoming staff and smooth check-ins are frequently praised, and maintenance requests are handled promptly. Guests also appreciate helpful touches like luggage holds and local bakery coupons.
Related guest reviews
10
Peter
30 May 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Awesome staff! They were very accommodating for our early arrival and late departure. Room was spacious and clean. we especially enjoyed an evening on our balcony
Awesome staff! They were very accommodating for our early arrival and late departure. Room was spacious and clean. we especially enjoyed an evening on our balcony
10
Mary
1 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 2 nights
The lovely agent from Poland who did my check-in was exceptional. Room was spacious and very clean. Lots of snacks, coffee pods etc. included. I had a problem with coffee maker on the first morning. it was quickly resolved.
The lovely agent from Poland who did my check-in was exceptional. Room was spacious and very clean. Lots of snacks, coffee pods etc. included. I had a problem with coffee maker on the first morning. it was quickly resolved.
10
William
14 May 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had a wonderful stay at the Island City House. Accommodations were wonderful and staff friendly. Daily cleaning was nice. Highly recommend
We had a wonderful stay at the Island City House. Accommodations were wonderful and staff friendly. Daily cleaning was nice. Highly recommend
10
Jackie
29 Sept 2023
·
Stayed 3 nights
We stay at Island City House every March with my whole family and this year we got w great deal for September so we could not miss the chance to come back for a visit. The staff is beyond outstanding and always so professional and accommodating. We normally request the same room on the first floor and it was unavailable for this visit so we were on the 2nd floor which was just as nice. We love the neighborhood because everything is in walking distance yet we don't have the noise of the busier areas. Island City house had made some lovely improvements in the pool and garden area and everything is so well taken care of. We highly recommend Island City House and in the 7 years we have been going there with our family, we have never been disappointed.
We stay at Island City House every March with my whole family and this year we got w great deal for September so we could not miss the chance to come back for a visit. The staff is beyond outstanding and always so professional and accommodating. We normally request the same room on the first floor and it was unavailable for this visit so we were on the 2nd floor which was just as nice. We love the neighborhood because everything is in walking distance yet we don't have the noise of the busier areas. Island City house had made some lovely improvements in the pool and garden area and everything is so well taken care of. We highly recommend Island City House and in the 7 years we have been going there with our family, we have never been disappointed.
10
Dolores
31 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 7 nights
The staff were all very friendly and very helpful. They took care of us immediately when we had an incident in our room. Despite the oppressive heat, the accommodations were excellently cool and comfortable. Rooms could use a little more lighting...bedroom & living room both had 1 small lamp. Lights in the ceiling fans would be a good improvement. The pool, gardens and water dispenser were a welcome respite. So was Bert the cat...as we were missing our cat back at home. We definitely recommend Island City House and would stay there again if we ever return to Key West.
The staff were all very friendly and very helpful. They took care of us immediately when we had an incident in our room. Despite the oppressive heat, the accommodations were excellently cool and comfortable. Rooms could use a little more lighting...bedroom & living room both had 1 small lamp. Lights in the ceiling fans would be a good improvement. The pool, gardens and water dispenser were a welcome respite. So was Bert the cat...as we were missing our cat back at home. We definitely recommend Island City House and would stay there again if we ever return to Key West.
10
Lauren
17 May 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
This hotel was amazing. We had a slight check in snafu that was dealt with quickly, and the woman at the front desk was incredibly gracious and helpful the whole time we were there. We loved the ambiance of the hotel and our awesome suite felt like a Victorian apartment. Housekeeping was wonderful too. Great pool surrounded by lush garden, rental bikes, private porch for sitting. The amenities and grounds were incredible. Everything in Key West is expensive so we thought this was a great value compared to other rentals/hotels available. Walkable, safe area close to everything, and close to a (paid) parking lot that was easy for us to leave our rental car and not worry about it. We would come back here in a heartbeat.
This hotel was amazing. We had a slight check in snafu that was dealt with quickly, and the woman at the front desk was incredibly gracious and helpful the whole time we were there. We loved the ambiance of the hotel and our awesome suite felt like a Victorian apartment. Housekeeping was wonderful too. Great pool surrounded by lush garden, rental bikes, private porch for sitting. The amenities and grounds were incredible. Everything in Key West is expensive so we thought this was a great value compared to other rentals/hotels available. Walkable, safe area close to everything, and close to a (paid) parking lot that was easy for us to leave our rental car and not worry about it. We would come back here in a heartbeat.
10
Beverly
16 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
10
Adora
28 May 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
10
Angelia
12 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
The desk staff were very courteous, polite and helpful. Housekeeping did an excellent job of taking care of our room daily. Bicycle rental for the week was convenient and easy to do through our hotel and the bikes were only a few steps away from our door, waiting on us daily. The pool was very nice, clean, and conveniently only a couple steps away from our room! The courtyard was beautiful and peaceful. Would definitely recommend Island City House to anyone, and will stay there again myself when visiting Key West!
The desk staff were very courteous, polite and helpful. Housekeeping did an excellent job of taking care of our room daily. Bicycle rental for the week was convenient and easy to do through our hotel and the bikes were only a few steps away from our door, waiting on us daily. The pool was very nice, clean, and conveniently only a couple steps away from our room! The courtyard was beautiful and peaceful. Would definitely recommend Island City House to anyone, and will stay there again myself when visiting Key West!
10
Neysa
19 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff were incredibly helpful. Easy location for walking.
Staff were incredibly helpful. Easy location for walking.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Location
Central Old Town spot within easy walking distance of Duval Street, the marina, and major sights, yet generally quiet and safe. A few street-facing Arch House rooms reported traffic noise.
Related guest reviews
10
DENISE
10 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Relaxing property. Quiet but close to attractions
Relaxing property. Quiet but close to attractions
10
Kathi
12 Nov 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Very clean and location is perfect to walk to most of the things to see.
Very clean and location is perfect to walk to most of the things to see.
10
Chris
29 Apr 2025
·
Stayed 1 night
Great place to stay in Key West. Restaurants and shops all walkable.
Great place to stay in Key West. Restaurants and shops all walkable.
10
Rachel
5 Jul 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
This was our first time to Key West. The location was perfect. Lots to do in walking distance but far enough away from Duval that it was quiet and safe.
This was our first time to Key West. The location was perfect. Lots to do in walking distance but far enough away from Duval that it was quiet and safe.
6
Daniel
2 Apr 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
We had an apartment in the oldest part of the building. Directly facing Eaton Street. Very noisy at times. The furniture is getting on in years. It smells old in the rooms. The bathroom is very small. The garden and pool are very nice. The whole complex has flair. The staff are all very friendly.
We had an apartment in the oldest part of the building. Directly facing Eaton Street. Very noisy at times. The furniture is getting on in years. It smells old in the rooms. The bathroom is very small. The garden and pool are very nice. The whole complex has flair. The staff are all very friendly.
8
Tyler
23 Jul 2024
·
Stayed 3 nights
Overall a nice stay. Good pool area that is covered by large trees. Center area has wonderful greenery and landscaping making it pleseant. The balcony doors were unlocked when we checked in and only caught it after we had left which meant someone could have entered even though we locked the front door. Parking was a 10 min walk away for $12/day or so which was much cheaper than the $40/day in the same garage. I would recommend this place. Great location/walking distance to Duval and the harbor.
Overall a nice stay. Good pool area that is covered by large trees. Center area has wonderful greenery and landscaping making it pleseant. The balcony doors were unlocked when we checked in and only caught it after we had left which meant someone could have entered even though we locked the front door. Parking was a 10 min walk away for $12/day or so which was much cheaper than the $40/day in the same garage. I would recommend this place. Great location/walking distance to Duval and the harbor.
6
Lorraine
17 Jan 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
The location was excellent, safe with easy walking to many sights and restaurants. Our unit (Arch House number 1) was on a busy street so noisy. The place was very clean but had a musty, moldy smell and only the bathroom window opened so it was hard to fix. The two queen bedrooms were small but beds were comfy. No hooks for coats. Couch was so dirty we didn’t want to sit on it. Not comfortable to sleep on. Bathroom was tiny but functional. Staff was so friendly and professional. Pool was warm and amazing.
The location was excellent, safe with easy walking to many sights and restaurants. Our unit (Arch House number 1) was on a busy street so noisy. The place was very clean but had a musty, moldy smell and only the bathroom window opened so it was hard to fix. The two queen bedrooms were small but beds were comfy. No hooks for coats. Couch was so dirty we didn’t want to sit on it. Not comfortable to sleep on. Bathroom was tiny but functional. Staff was so friendly and professional. Pool was warm and amazing.
10
SHAILESH
9 Mar 2023
·
Stayed 1 night
Excellent hotel. Only 5 minute walk to Duval Street, Marina and Mallory square. Highly recommended. Staff was very nice.
Excellent hotel. Only 5 minute walk to Duval Street, Marina and Mallory square. Highly recommended. Staff was very nice.
10
keith
2 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Wonderful property in a great location. Peaceful and quiet yet close to the marina and Duval Street. No need for a car if you are staying on the island, just rent a bike.
Wonderful property in a great location. Peaceful and quiet yet close to the marina and Duval Street. No need for a car if you are staying on the island, just rent a bike.
10
Patrick
11 Aug 2025
·
Stayed 3 nights
We loved our time at this property. It’s beautiful with lush gardens and common areas, and the location is perfect. It’s less than a 10 minute walk to Duval Street, and it’s quiet and secluded. We used the pool every day of our stay. Definitely check out the bakery they give you coupons for. It’s great! We will definitely try to return here on future trips to Key West.
We loved our time at this property. It’s beautiful with lush gardens and common areas, and the location is perfect. It’s less than a 10 minute walk to Duval Street, and it’s quiet and secluded. We used the pool every day of our stay. Definitely check out the bakery they give you coupons for. It’s great! We will definitely try to return here on future trips to Key West.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
Dining
There's no on-site restaurant, bar, or true breakfast; guests use in-room kitchens or nearby eateries, sometimes with bakery coupons. Many dining options are within a short walk.
Related guest reviews
10
Rhonda
1 Jun 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Nice quaint place. Walking distance to Duval St, local restaurants and shopping. I would recommend and stay again.
Nice quaint place. Walking distance to Duval St, local restaurants and shopping. I would recommend and stay again.
10
Robert
2 Oct 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
An old historic site who architecture was quidacential Key West. Very convient location within walking distance to the marina, and some great ocal establishments. We will definitely stay here again.Thank you for making another Key West memory for our family!
An old historic site who architecture was quidacential Key West. Very convient location within walking distance to the marina, and some great ocal establishments. We will definitely stay here again.Thank you for making another Key West memory for our family!
10
Christine
15 Jan 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
We had a great stay at the Island City House Hotel! Check in was a breeze and the coupons to the bakery down the street were great especially as my boyfriend was obsessed with their breakfast sandwiches. It was a spacious room with a large balcony and porch swing. Great location as well, super close to everything we did!
We had a great stay at the Island City House Hotel! Check in was a breeze and the coupons to the bakery down the street were great especially as my boyfriend was obsessed with their breakfast sandwiches. It was a spacious room with a large balcony and porch swing. Great location as well, super close to everything we did!
6
Stefano
12 May 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
Old decor
Old decor
8
Sandy
24 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 1 night
It was very charming. Staff was nice and room was clean and nicely decorated. The parking is on the street and very limited. Once you park and get into your room there is a ton of walkable places to go. Very fun!
It was very charming. Staff was nice and room was clean and nicely decorated. The parking is on the street and very limited. Once you park and get into your room there is a ton of walkable places to go. Very fun!
10
Beverly
16 Oct 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
This was a charming hotel set among peaceful gardens. Check-in was seamless, he gave us two $5 discounts to a wonderful bakery/coffee shop nearby, and he walked us around the property to show us where everything is. The location is very convenient to lots of Key West sites, so we walked most everywhere. LOVED the hammock on the balcony overlooking the gardens. Just exactly what we needed for a rejuvenating, relaxing getaway.
10
Adora
28 May 2025
·
Stayed 4 nights
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
Great experience. Hotel is in an ideal location. Easy to walk to so much! Food, convenience store, bakery, Italian restaurant, the marina, coffee shops etc. The garden is lush. The koi pond is such a lovely tropical touch. There is a great patio area with shade and beautiful plants. We checked in late, after the desk closed, and it was still seamless. Housekeeping services were timely and attentive. I loved our suite. It was on the third floor (no elevator). The private patio was so nice to enjoy our morning coffee on. Good seating. The AC in our suite worked great, but was pretty loud. Fans in the bedroom was really nice. Overall great stay. Would recommend. Would stay again
10
Lori
11 Jun 2025
·
Stayed 2 nights
Only downside to this property is no restaurant or bar or access to any food. Rooms have full kitchens but it’s a hike to get any beverages or food. Next time I will know to stock an extra suitcase with drinks and snacks to enjoy while on property.
Only downside to this property is no restaurant or bar or access to any food. Rooms have full kitchens but it’s a hike to get any beverages or food. Next time I will know to stock an extra suitcase with drinks and snacks to enjoy while on property.
10
Marcie
10 Apr 2023
·
Stayed 4 nights
Beautiful property with lovely garden courtyard and close to everything. Nice sized suite with comfortable bed and handy kitchenette. On-site bike rental. Old Town Bakery and Eaton Street Seafood steps away were wonderful. We really enjoyed our stay.
Beautiful property with lovely garden courtyard and close to everything. Nice sized suite with comfortable bed and handy kitchenette. On-site bike rental. Old Town Bakery and Eaton Street Seafood steps away were wonderful. We really enjoyed our stay.
10
Keith
9 Dec 2024
·
Stayed 4 nights
Wonderful trip. Great hotel but not for those who have issues with stairs unless they ask for one of the first floor rooms or bungalows. Would stay there again. Wish they served food though.
Wonderful trip. Great hotel but not for those who have issues with stairs unless they ask for one of the first floor rooms or bungalows. Would stay there again. Wish they served food though.
Was this helpful?
AI-generated summary based on recent guest reviews
10
Maria-Monica
2 weeks ago
·
Stayed 3 nights
Great stay. Love the area
Great stay. Love the area
10
John
4 weeks ago
·
Stayed 1 night
Key West Paradise in Old Town.
Key West Paradise in Old Town.
10
Heidi
4 weeks ago
·
Stayed 1 night
Absolutely stellar property - gorgeous in all respects. Our rooms, the spacious private porch, the grounds, pool, everything. Beds were comfy, staff was helpful, and we all enjoyed Bert's visits to our porch as well. As a former Key West resident, I loved the Old Town location and atmosphere of the Island City House Hotel. The staff were also friendly and helpful. We have every intention of staying here again in the future!
Absolutely stellar property - gorgeous in all respects. Our rooms, the spacious private porch, the grounds, pool, everything. Beds were comfy, staff was helpful, and we all enjoyed Bert's visits to our porch as well. As a former Key West resident, I loved the Old Town location and atmosphere of the Island City House Hotel. The staff were also friendly and helpful. We have every intention of staying here again in the future!
10
Melissa
23 Sept 2026
·
Stayed 1 night
Staff was amazing Took us to our room and showed us around Place was amazing Great location
Staff was amazing Took us to our room and showed us around Place was amazing Great location
10
PETER
13 Sept 2026
·
Stayed 6 nights
Everything was great. Loved the iguanas.
Everything was great. Loved the iguanas.
FAQs about Island City House
Is parking available at the property?
Limited parking is available onsite.
What are the check-in and check-out times?
Check-in is from 3:00 PM until 7:00 PM, and check-out is at 11:00 AM. Early or late check-in/check-out may be available upon request.
Where is the hotel located in relation to key landmarks?
The hotel is located in the heart of Key West, within a 15-minute walk of Duval Street and Florida Keys Beaches. It is 0.7 mi from Mallory Square and 0.8 mi from the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.
Does the hotel have a swimming pool?
Yes, the property features an outdoor heated pool. The pool is seasonal and operational hours are not specified.
Have a question?
Instant AI responses are based on hotel information
Prices for upcoming dates
October 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
November 2026
Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cheaper
Pricier
Average nightly price across deals, with taxes & fees.
Prices in USD for 2 guests, updated daily.
- 2026-10-25: NO DATA
- 2026-10-26: 192.05331080267334USD
- 2026-10-27: 192.68924140753174USD
- 2026-10-28: 190.40579179290773USD
- 2026-10-29: 256.7974926569214USD
- 2026-10-30: 316.4974265675049USD
- 2026-10-31: 359.40123774291993USD
- 2026-11-01: 201.15784519793704USD
- 2026-11-02: 201.6086925404053USD
- 2026-11-03: 205.83622413659668USD
- 2026-11-04: 245.24120617614747USD
- 2026-11-05: 348.34651615942386USD
- 2026-11-06: NO DATA
- 2026-11-07: NO DATA
- 2026-11-08: 352.34051507385254USD
- 2026-11-09: 274.30560527551273USD
- 2026-11-10: 263.98659520245366USD
- 2026-11-11: 288.74847780700685USD
- 2026-11-12: 432.65836287731935USD
- 2026-11-13: 456.6662183514405USD
- 2026-11-14: 532.4370173741455USD
- 2026-11-15: 279.4034016798706USD
- 2026-11-16: 296.96843938183594USD
- 2026-11-17: 296.53022879394535USD
- 2026-11-18: 267.6589111187744USD
- 2026-11-19: 308.380810111084USD
- 2026-11-20: 330.2548446948242USD
- 2026-11-21: 333.4371239812012USD
- 2026-11-22: 338.6912170869141USD
- 2026-11-23: 346.79681688549806USD
- 2026-11-24: 306.6322652792969USD
- 2026-11-25: 317.225446881836USD
- 2026-11-26: 362.95293319348144USD
- 2026-11-27: 389.66532700561527USD
- 2026-11-28: 366.66895761450195USD
- 2026-11-29: 310.9159374909668USD
- 2026-11-30: 263.8439243673706USD
- 2026-12-01: 335.79717859118654USD
- 2026-12-02: 316.6146192496338USD
- 2026-12-03: 397.05071706152347USD
- 2026-12-04: 418.9982528763428USD
- 2026-12-05: 585.9894004069824USD
- 2026-12-06: 430.9696081420899USD
- 2026-12-07: 396.4247798955078USD
- 2026-12-08: 378.5637078848877USD
- 2026-12-09: 392.5702457299805USD
- 2026-12-10: NO DATA
- 2026-12-11: NO DATA
- 2026-12-12: NO DATA
- 2026-12-13: 347.87870043530273USD
- 2026-12-14: 353.89072595727544USD
- 2026-12-15: 327.2093697879639USD
- 2026-12-16: 347.87870043530273USD
- 2026-12-17: 361.9390937067871USD
- 2026-12-18: 469.8765894971924USD
- 2026-12-19: 551.4579763292237USD
- 2026-12-20: 498.9770400124512USD
- 2026-12-21: 498.2552954412842USD
- 2026-12-22: 498.2552954412842USD
- 2026-12-23: 458.90283864343263USD
- 2026-12-24: 514.1791069302978USD
- 2026-12-25: 518.8295690440674USD
The front desk is open daily from 8:00 AM - 7:00 PM. To make arrangements for check-in please contact the property ahead of time using the information on the booking confirmation. If you are planning to arrive after 8:00 PM please contact the property in advance using the information on the booking confirmation. Guests must contact the property in advance for check-in instructions. The front desk is staffed during limited hours. For any questions, please contact the property using the information on the booking confirmation. Information provided by the property may be translated using automated translation tools. Guests are asked to contact the property at least 24 hours in advance for after hours check-in instructions.
Check-in must be done by someone who is at least 21 years old.
- Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy
- Government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges
- Special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed
- The name on the credit card used at check-in to pay for incidentals must be the primary name on the guestroom reservation
- This property accepts credit cards; cash is not accepted
- Safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a smoke detector, and a first aid kit
- This property has outdoor spaces, such as balconies, patios, terraces which may not be suitable for children; if you have concerns, we recommend contacting the property prior to your arrival to confirm they can accommodate you in a suitable room
- Please note that cultural norms and guest policies may differ by country and by property; the policies listed are provided by the property
- Nearby parking fee: USD 48 per day
The above list may not be comprehensive. Fees and deposits may not include tax and are subject to change.
Popular amenities
Swimming pool
Non-smoking rooms
Tour desk
Housekeeping
Bicycle rental
Garden
Services
Tour desk
Housekeeping
Bicycle rental
Luggage storage
Designated smoking area
Self laundry
Concierge Services
General
Non-smoking rooms
Family room
Fence Around Pool
Activities
Swimming pool
Garden
Pool outdoor
Outdoor heated pool
Outdoor Furniture
Pool (Seasonal Outdoor)
Terrace
Internet
Free wi-fi